Why we believe.

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pete_1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Pete_1

Guest
I know some of what we believe as Catholics, but I do not understand why we believe. I do believe, but I do not know why. What is this faith of ours based on and why is it rational?

I believe that faith in itself is rational due to the limitations of the human mind: faith is required to know God’s will.

My problem arises out of my belief that many people are deluded by false faiths, how do we know our faith is the truth and that we are not being decieved?

I know this is a hard question but perhaps someone could help me out.
 
Our faith is based on a realist epistemology, it asserts objective truth and it thoroughly makes sense. It embraces and works in conjunction with human nature, so that when you are living a fully Catholic life, you are as happy as you can be in this world, and you have great confidence in meeting God in the next.

👍
 
I know some of what we believe as Catholics, but I do not understand why we believe. I do believe, but I do not know why. What is this faith of ours based on and why is it rational?

I believe that faith in itself is rational due to the limitations of the human mind: faith is required to know God’s will.

My problem arises out of my belief that many people are deluded by false faiths, how do we know our faith is the truth and that we are not being decieved?

I know this is a hard question but perhaps someone could help me out.
One knows if one is wrongly believing something if some contradiction arises from the application of that belief.

If I believe that I can fly, and the pavement beneath my ladder contradicts my belief that I can fly, some options are presented to me:
  • *) I can redefine “flying” to something less “pavement impact inducing” and continue to believe that I can fly.
  • *) I can give up the belief that I can fly.
Now, it would SEEM that item #2 is the obvious choice, but I’d choose item #1, and redefine “flying” as being airborne in some “flying machine” type thingy.

The question is what “adjustments” need to be made to reconcile one’s beliefs with reality.

So, what is the “internal non-contradiction” of a set of beliefs (which is what a religion is)? And, are there any contradictions between said set-of-beliefs (religion) and reality?

Since I’m lazy, I chose Catholicism to believe in because of it’s apparent internal non-contradiction and it’s non-interference (non-contradiction in application) with physical/human-nature reality.

I also chose it because of it’s “confidence” in making some very BOLD claims seemingly not threatened in the least by the apparent ease of it’s being contradicted by non-Catholics!

I figured I’d either do some more extensive research and it’s self-contradictions would show up rather quickly, or that research would reinforce it’s validity.

Taking the axioms of Catholicism as a basis to build on, and “judging” the axioms themselves as to whether they are “obviously obnoxious” (which is admittedly rather subjective) or not, I have yet to find any reason to not believe in Catholicism, and have found an incredibly powerful basis for finding the self-contradictions in EVERY other religion whose adherents pose the validity of their religion to me to evaluate.

The reason that I believe in the Church is because it functions as it says it functions as “the one fullness of truth”, while no other religion actually does function as it says it functions unless it is self-admittedly NOT “the one fullness of truth”.
 
Anyone else?
I’ll try to answer without turning it into a book. But, speaking of books, I would strongly suggest you get the book “Mere Christianity” by C.S.Lewis. That will give you the rationale for believing in God and believing that Jesus Christ is God. (Once you believe Jesus is God, Christianity (vs any of the non Christian religions) becomes the only path. Lewis was not Catholic (very close tho!!!) so the book does not go into why Catholicism rather than other Christian faiths.

So, I’ll start where he leaves off - giving you my rationale for being Catholic. First, I was born Catholic. But, from the time I could understand the gospels (eg Mt. 16:18-19), I could never understand how someone could believe Jesus was God and not be a Catholic. It seemed obvious to me even as a young girl that the Church with the successor of Peter as its visible head had to be the one Jesus founded. As I grew older and learned the history of the other Christian religions, it became even more obvious to me that the Catholic Church was/is the true Church. It is the ONLY Church that claims the successor of Peter as it’s head, the only Church that claims the power of infallibility (that what is bound here is bound in heaven, …)

As to why I believe the various doctrines - once papal infallibility really registered with me, where I really believed it (thanks to Scripture and God’s grace), then accepting the infallible teachings of the Church on faith and morals was no problem at all. Infallibility is God using His Church to proclaim His truth – and I want His truth way more than any faulty reasoning of mine. If the Church declares something is true but my reasoning says it isn’t – I KNOW who’s right, and it isn’t me! I’ll accept the Church’s teaching every time and seek God’s grace to help me understand it and to show me where my reasoning took a wrong turn.

God help you as you continue to grow in your faith. Catholicism is such a rich, marvelous gift from God.

Nita
 
I know some of what we believe as Catholics, but I do not understand why we believe. I do believe, but I do not know why. What is this faith of ours based on and why is it rational?

I believe that faith in itself is rational due to the limitations of the human mind: faith is required to know God’s will.

My problem arises out of my belief that many people are deluded by false faiths, how do we know our faith is the truth and that we are not being decieved?

I know this is a hard question but perhaps someone could help me out.
The resource you need to start with is: The Catechism of the Catholic Church which starts out defending the existence of God and goes on from there. It is easy to search online.

Also, I highly recommend G. K. Chesterton’s Orthodoxy and The Catholic Church and Conversion. C. S. Lewis is fine but he wasn’t a Catholic so he wrote only from a traditional point of view which he wasn’t as able to defend as Chesterton who converted to the Catholic faith and was a genius of brilliant wit.
 
I’ll try to answer without turning it into a book. But, speaking of books, I would strongly suggest you get the book “Mere Christianity” by C.S.Lewis. That will give you the rationale for believing in God and believing that Jesus Christ is God. (Once you believe Jesus is God, Christianity (vs any of the non Christian religions) becomes the only path. Lewis was not Catholic (very close tho!!!) so the book does not go into why Catholicism rather than other Christian faiths.

So, I’ll start where he leaves off - giving you my rationale for being Catholic. First, I was born Catholic. But, from the time I could understand the gospels (eg Mt. 16:18-19), I could never understand how someone could believe Jesus was God and not be a Catholic. It seemed obvious to me even as a young girl that the Church with the successor of Peter as its visible head had to be the one Jesus founded. As I grew older and learned the history of the other Christian religions, it became even more obvious to me that the Catholic Church was/is the true Church. It is the ONLY Church that claims the successor of Peter as it’s head, the only Church that claims the power of infallibility (that what is bound here is bound in heaven, …)

As to why I believe the various doctrines - once papal infallibility really registered with me, where I really believed it (thanks to Scripture and God’s grace), then accepting the infallible teachings of the Church on faith and morals was no problem at all. Infallibility is God using His Church to proclaim His truth – and I want His truth way more than any faulty reasoning of mine. If the Church declares something is true but my reasoning says it isn’t – I KNOW who’s right, and it isn’t me! I’ll accept the Church’s teaching every time and seek God’s grace to help me understand it and to show me where my reasoning took a wrong turn.

God help you as you continue to grow in your faith. Catholicism is such a rich, marvelous gift from God.

Nita
Thanks for the reccomendation. 😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top