Why would God let demons and the devil haunt some locations?

  • Thread starter Thread starter CatholicZ09
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

CatholicZ09

Guest
Okay, so people have claimed to have had their house haunted by demons or infact the devil, (keyword here is “claimed”) and I have been wondering…why would God let the demons or devil haunt a house or specific location? Wouldn’t God dislike it?

The same goes for demonic possessions. Why would God allow this?
 
Why does God allow drunk driving, cliffs, potholes, influenza…?

There’s always a reason… 🙂 We don’t always get to know it.

Generally, though, if a demon is haunting a place it’s because something particularly offensive to God happened there. Occultism, false worship, witchcraft, something particularly abominable…

That or, there’s a lot of work to be done there. 🙂
 
If you’re asking why people project their fears and internal conflicts onto a personification that they can blame instead of working on the actual issue, it’s because they’re human. Seriously, even if the devil exists I think people give him far too much credit.

In case you’re interested, a documentary on the history of the devil: wimp.com/thedevil/
 
And I would say people give him far too little.

But that’s what happens when you claim that everyone with experience with the spiritual is a unreliable, kooky or compensating, rather than realizing there’s a ton of reliable testimony from people who are truly honest and genuine witnesses to something that, after all, is spiritual.

People who in fact would rather die than lie because they are that concerned about loving God and not sinning with false testimony – which is a lot more reliable than a witness who doesn’t care. 🙂

Some people are too insecure and invested in denying the existence of the spiritual to admit that it exists and could even have had an influence on them – because then they would have to change their own lives. 🙂
 
One book that helped me become aware of the nature of the devil (and to defend against him) was the Vatican Exorcist’s book An Exorcist Tells His Story (by Gabrielle Amorth). He talks about his experiences of possession, hauntings, etc. It’s pretty crazy.
If you’re asking why people project their fears and internal conflicts onto a personification that they can blame instead of working on the actual issue, it’s because they’re human. Seriously, even if the devil exists I think people give him far too much credit.

In case you’re interested, a documentary on the history of the devil: wimp.com/thedevil/
I watched the documentary. It was terrible.😛

A lot of Catholic Church bashing. But it really didn’t say anything. I guess it was trying to imply some stuff. Its subtle arguments could be summed up as follows:
  • Since the writers of the Old and New Testament used ideas about the devil similar to those in the culture of the time (which the Church has always acknowledged because the Bible is also a human work in addition to being a divine work), thus Christianity is false and the devil doesn’t exist (huh?)
  • Since people are accused of and persecuted for being witches and worshipping the devil, thus witches don’t exist and the devil doesn’t exist either (huh?)
  • Since the Catholic Church accused its enemies of being in league with the devil, the devil doesn’t exist and the Catholic Church is wrong (huh?)
  • Because some people have used the idea of the devil to scare people into doing what you want them to do, the devil doesn’t exist (huh?)
  • Because there are different versions of how the devil is understood or depicted, the devil doesn’t exist (huh?)
All very logically sound arguments, no?

I loved it when they were interviewing the Satanists in the end, and one of them nonchalantly said that none of this was a big deal and that “There is no good or evil” (which is one of Voldemort’s famous lines … classic … you can’t make that stuff up).

They also got some history just plain wrong, especially about Zoroaster introducing the idea of an evil god and a good god. That already existed in the Sumerian civilization. They also indicated that the Spanish Inquisitors were solely doing things for religious reasons, whereas it was primarily to find Muslim spies who were plotting against the government because the Muslims had wrongly invaded Spain for no reason, and the Christians were finally fighting back. A similar situation existed with the crusade against the Cathars. It made some creative exegetical assertions about the devil in the OT that kind of came out of nowhere. And I think there was some other stuff.

A good quote from Chesterton: “The cleverest thing the Devil did was to make us believe
that he doesn’t exist.”

Thank you, Liquidpele, though, for sharing.🙂
 
Okay, so people have claimed to have had their house haunted by demons or infact the devil, (keyword here is “claimed”) and I have been wondering…why would God let the demons or devil haunt a house or specific location? Wouldn’t God dislike it?

The same goes for demonic possessions. Why would God allow this?
So that good might come out of it.
 
Seriously, even if the devil exists I think people give him far too much credit.
Which is why the Church has very strict guidelines as to who is actually considered possessed. I have no doubt whatsoever that possession is very real, don’t get me wrong. It’s just a very rigorous process of discernment b/c many other things that are not possession can be blamed on this and it’s not something to be taken lightly.
 
Try reading Timothy Gallagher’s Discernment of Spirits. All based on St. Ignatius’ rules. Takes Satan very seriously, just gives God a lot more credit :). It also takes the drama out of the subject that Hollywood likes to put into it.
 
As bookgirl says, the Catholic Church regards possession and real hauntings (infestations) as rare. The Church also recognises the influence of human psychology, including projection of anxieties and fears, on people’s reports of their experiences. Acknowledging that some ‘possessions’ and ‘hauntings’ are the result of human misinterpretation for many reasons is not the same as saying that this *is always *the case.

Church teachings are more nuanced and subtle than many understand! Often what atheists and opponents of the Church present is a nothing more than caricature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top