Will Christianity in USA die in short time?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Timi_Celcer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think it will, but I don’t get much joy from that. Christianity at least has a firm moral code, but the religion of secularism has no such thing. It’s only a matter of time before people are locked up for saying that homosexuality is wrong.
 
I believe in the very near future in the US, practicing any form of christianity will be outlawed, you can see hints of this now, the mainstream media refusing to even mention certain things when it has to do with christianity, christians being persecuted and killed in other countries for their beliefs, and this is not reported by western media…??? LOL Yet on the other hand media favors islam and muslim people.

I truly believe it will start out as the govt ‘encouraging’ people to NOT talk about christianity anywhere in public, we are almost at this point, in that all references to it in public places have been banned and these bans held up by the courts, would not take much to take it to the next step.

The it will go from a ‘suggested’ thing to a legal thing and they will outlaw it, close down the churches and make it a crime. This will be the time when people will be persecuted and put to death for their beliefs, its already happening in other countries, it will eventually make it here. This is also the time when God said relatives and neighbors will be turning each other in. It wont be a pretty sight!

Im just curious at how many true christians will actually accept this new law and obey it though. I have a feeling 90% or more will suddenly change their beliefs or keep it secret to protect themselves and their families, jobs, incomes, etc, even if they know it means eternal damnation upon death…this is the truly sad part…imo anyway.
 
When people cite governmental persecution of the Church, I am encouraged by the history of the early Church. Growth in the faith, percentage wise, was the greatest during the period of the worst Roman persecution. “If God is for us, who can be against?”
 
Grace & Peace!
I believe in the very near future in the US, practicing any form of christianity will be outlawed, you can see hints of this now, the mainstream media refusing to even mention certain things when it has to do with christianity, christians being persecuted and killed in other countries for their beliefs, and this is not reported by western media…???
Mikekle, has it ever been the case that mainstream media consistently and regularly reported on Christian persecution throughout the world? I don’t know that it has. I can’t remember a time when the persecution of Christians was regularly reported. As such, I find it hard to believe that such reporting has actually declined or has been actively discouraged or refused.
LOL Yet on the other hand media favors islam and muslim people.
I see no real evidence for this assertion.
I truly believe it will start out as the govt ‘encouraging’ people to NOT talk about christianity anywhere in public, we are almost at this point, in that all references to it in public places have been banned and these bans held up by the courts, would not take much to take it to the next step.

The it will go from a ‘suggested’ thing to a legal thing and they will outlaw it, close down the churches and make it a crime. …]
What you describe here is a bit fantastical. The government is not against Christians or churches. The problem with American government/civic culture is much deeper but also much more nuanced than that.

The problem with American government and culture is that its narrative is flawed. Liberal democracy tells a particular story about itself in order to empower as many people as possible (who may not share the same values) to participate in the civic culture–and the story that American political life tells is, “the only story you have is the story you make up for yourself.” Or, to paraphrase Hauerwas, “The only story you have is the story you had when you had no story.” This narrative is fundamentally anti-historical (denying the value of the past or of tradition to shape and condition us), anti-family (denying the value of familial relationships and ties to actually shape and condition us), anti-community (denying the value of broader human relationships to shape and condition us), anti-environment (denying the value of our environment and our relationship to it to shape and condition us) and pro-individual. Subsequently, this narrative finds it very difficult to actually affirm any value as universal: nothing, according to this narrative, can be affirmed as bindingly or universally true.

The consequences of this? Our civic identity has a legal quality to it–only the laws of the land can be said to bind us together as a people. Nothing else. Not tradition. Not family. Not community. Not religion. Not environment. Government is not interested in truth claims. It’s not interested in saying that anything is or isn’t true. It’s only interest is in upholding the law. That’s why, from a government perspective, same-sex marriage or abortion, for instance, are not moral issues–they’re questions of how to interpret and apply the law. What is moral or immoral is a question of actually affirming one value over another–and that simply will not happen.

How does this relate to the idea that Christianity will be persecuted in America? The fact is, it won’t be. Because the government simply cannot (by its very nature) affirm or deny Christianity and the claims it makes as either valuable or truthful. It cannot do it. The same goes for Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Wicca, Atheism–it cannot affirm or deny any of them, but must (because it is liberal/Enlightenment democracy) create a space for all of them. Some folks may feel oppressed by that, feeling that their inner conviction regarding the truth is not particularly or especially respected by the public discourse or those who moderate it. But that’s the point: the public discourse in a liberal democracy will never be able to definitively and publicly affirm any value as universally true. Those who believe one thing and those believe the opposite are both right. The law doesn’t care–it’ll step in if someone gets hurt or can demonstrate that their “rights” have been abused or denied.

Christianity will never be illegal, but in the eyes of the government, it will never be special–it’s just one religion among many. It’s interests and claims need to be balanced, from the government perspective, against the interests and claims of a lot of other people. That’s a difficult tension, as a Christian, to live into. But no one said being a Christian would be easy.

This tension is exacerbated, though, when we believe or suspect that the government is or should be for us in some fundamental or explicit way. The truth is: it isn’t. It hasn’t been. It never will be. But the more we believe that it is or should be, the more we’ll be beholden to it; the more our Christianity will look more like it; the more we will speak of the importance of religious liberty as opposed to the liberty of the Gospel and the Royal Law of Love; the more we will choose legal recourse to defend or express our views as opposed to martyrdom and patterning our lives after the witness of the saints.
Im just curious at how many true christians will actually accept this new law and obey it though. I have a feeling 90% or more will suddenly change their beliefs or keep it secret to protect themselves and their families, jobs, incomes, etc, even if they know it means eternal damnation upon death…this is the truly sad part…imo anyway.
This is idle speculation.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
 
Grace & Peace!

Mikekle, has it ever been the case that mainstream media consistently and regularly reported on Christian persecution throughout the world? I don’t know that it has. I can’t remember a time when the persecution of Christians was regularly reported. As such, I find it hard to believe that such reporting has actually declined or has been actively discouraged or refused.

I see no real evidence for this assertion.

What you describe here is a bit fantastical. The government is not against Christians or churches. The problem with American government/civic culture is much deeper but also much more nuanced than that.

The problem with American government and culture is that its narrative is flawed. Liberal democracy tells a particular story about itself in order to empower as many people as possible (who may not share the same values) to participate in the civic culture–and the story that American political life tells is, “the only story you have is the story you make up for yourself.” Or, to paraphrase Hauerwas, “The only story you have is the story you had when you had no story.” This narrative is fundamentally anti-historical (denying the value of the past or of tradition to shape and condition us), anti-family (denying the value of familial relationships and ties to actually shape and condition us), anti-community (denying the value of broader human relationships to shape and condition us), anti-environment (denying the value of our environment and our relationship to it to shape and condition us) and pro-individual. Subsequently, this narrative finds it very difficult to actually affirm any value as universal: nothing, according to this narrative, can be affirmed as bindingly or universally true.

The consequences of this? Our civic identity has a legal quality to it–only the laws of the land can be said to bind us together as a people. Nothing else. Not tradition. Not family. Not community. Not religion. Not environment. Government is not interested in truth claims. It’s not interested in saying that anything is or isn’t true. It’s only interest is in upholding the law. That’s why, from a government perspective, same-sex marriage or abortion, for instance, are not moral issues–they’re questions of how to interpret and apply the law. What is moral or immoral is a question of actually affirming one value over another–and that simply will not happen.

How does this relate to the idea that Christianity will be persecuted in America? The fact is, it won’t be. Because the government simply cannot (by its very nature) affirm or deny Christianity and the claims it makes as either valuable or truthful. It cannot do it. The same goes for Judaism, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Wicca, Atheism–it cannot affirm or deny any of them, but must (because it is liberal/Enlightenment democracy) create a space for all of them. Some folks may feel oppressed by that, feeling that their inner conviction regarding the truth is not particularly or especially respected by the public discourse or those who moderate it. But that’s the point: the public discourse in a liberal democracy will never be able to definitively and publicly affirm any value as universally true. Those who believe one thing and those believe the opposite are both right. The law doesn’t care–it’ll step in if someone gets hurt or can demonstrate that their “rights” have been abused or denied.

Christianity will never be illegal, but in the eyes of the government, it will never be special–it’s just one religion among many. It’s interests and claims need to be balanced, from the government perspective, against the interests and claims of a lot of other people. That’s a difficult tension, as a Christian, to live into. But no one said being a Christian would be easy.

This tension is exacerbated, though, when we believe or suspect that the government is or should be for us in some fundamental or explicit way. The truth is: it isn’t. It hasn’t been. It never will be. But the more we believe that it is or should be, the more we’ll be beholden to it; the more our Christianity will look more like it; the more we will speak of the importance of religious liberty as opposed to the liberty of the Gospel and the Royal Law of Love; the more we will choose legal recourse to defend or express our views as opposed to martyrdom and patterning our lives after the witness of the saints.

This is idle speculation.

Under the Mercy,
Mark

All is Grace and Mercy! Deo Gratias!
Govt also relies on control of the public, they have to maintain control over the people. and when this clashes with religion/Gods law, that is when Govt will bet more involved. They want people obeying THEIR laws, even if it conflicts with Gods laws, clear case is abortion, to christians, it is murder…PERIOD, but for govt, it is just a medical procedure. yet when christians try to fight back on this issue, they get arrested and labeled by the media, as crazy, right wing christians.

I believe the Govt has a real fear of christianity and religion in general, because they know people that have incredible faith in it (any religion), they know they cannot have total control over that person, even when it means using law enforcement, those people feel they are doing what God wants and are not concerned with mans laws, nor should they be, Gods laws ARE more important…but not to the Govt. Control is the reason why religion will face the persecution that is to come. Thats what I believe anyway.
 
yet when christians try to fight back on this issue, they get arrested and labeled by the media, as crazy, right wing christians.
Isn’t that dependent on how one fights back? There have been a range of protesting activities from media campaigns to peaceful demonstrations to fatal attacks. Some of the actions people do in protest result in arrest, some don’t.
 
Isn’t that dependent on how one fights back? There have been a range of protesting activities from media campaigns to peaceful demonstrations to fatal attacks. Some of the actions people do in protest result in arrest, some don’t.
True, but its been a long time since Ive seen any kind of media campaign concerning anything ‘pro’christian’.

IMO, the problem is, we as citizens have no comparable way to fight back, as law enforcement/govt is legally allowed to come out in force, and allowed to take it to any level deemed necessary with no fear of being labeled or arrested, so they will always win. I just wonder if the odds were more level, who would come out on top.

Look at history, how many times have peaceful protesting and demonstrations resulted in the people achieving what they set out to do. I cannot think of any, 98% of the time, it results in the police coming out to break it up and send people on their way, or it ends with police getting violent, by use of tear gas, rubber bullets, swat teams in riot gear, etc. Yet the group of people protesting have NO comparable way to fight back, nor are they even permitted to do so!!! With these odds, the ‘house’ will always win. The playing field should be more level imo, as this would allow the group who fought the hardest in what they believed in, to win in the end.
 
lubbockonline.com/interact/blog-post/may/2013-05-02/obama-determined-united-states-will-not-be-christian-nation#.UmkTszCQZYc

USA is becoming more and more secular and i think that at one point the nation will be almost completely atheistic. Obama is a supposed Christian and he strongly opposes Christianity. The millitary no longer has the right to preach the gospel or they can end up in prison. What’s next, you won’t be allowed to teach about Jesus to your own child? I don’t live in America but as i can see USA has incredible influence on Europe, mo homeland. The sexual revolution expanded from USA to Europe. When homosexuality was made legal in USA, European countries started to debate over legalizing homosexuality. And i think homosexuality will become legal in most European countries soon. What do you think on the subject?
As the Hispanic population in the US will increase from 16% to 30% of total population by 2050 its hard to see how Christianity will decline. Non-Catholic Christians may but with the increase in the Hispanic population I can see Catholicism being the biggest religion in the US one day.
 
lubbockonline.com/interact/blog-post/may/2013-05-02/obama-determined-united-states-will-not-be-christian-nation#.UmkTszCQZYc

The sexual revolution expanded from USA to Europe. When homosexuality was made legal in USA, European countries started to debate over legalizing homosexuality. And i think homosexuality will become legal in most European countries soon. What do you think on the subject?
I think you’ll find that many European countries legalized homosexual acts before the USA.
 
lubbockonline.com/interact/blog-post/may/2013-05-02/obama-determined-united-states-will-not-be-christian-nation#.UmkTszCQZYc

USA is becoming more and more secular and i think that at one point the nation will be almost completely atheistic. The millitary no longer has the right to preach the gospel or they can end up in prison. What’s next, you won’t be allowed to teach about Jesus to your own child? I don’t live in America but as i can see USA has incredible influence on Europe, mo homeland. The sexual revolution expanded from USA to Europe. When homosexuality was made legal in USA, European countries started to debate over legalizing homosexuality. And i think homosexuality will become legal in most European countries soon. What do you think on the subject?
I strongly dissagree. We have no state church and never will unless the Constitution is amended.

BTW I live only 80 miles from Lubbock and am very aware of the ultra-right position of the Avalanche Journal. If Lubbock has it’s way and a state church is instituted it will be Southern Baptist and not Catholic by a very long way. It has only been about 20 years or so that it has even been legal to buy liquor in Lubbock County. That is how fundamentalist/Baptist they truly are. You could fit 5 of the Catholic cathedral inside the First Baptist church in Lubbock.
 
True, but its been a long time since Ive seen any kind of media campaign concerning anything ‘pro’christian’.
I’m not sure I follow you. I recall a few.
There was Rick Parry’s Prayer Rally, the Catholics Come Home campaign, the
Mormon Ad Campaign, Christian billboards that advertise churches, and phone numbers for phone request for prayer, so on…
IMO, the problem is, we as citizens have no comparable way to fight back, as law enforcement/govt is legally allowed to come out in force, and allowed to take it to any level deemed necessary with no fear of being labeled or arrested, so they will always win.
What type of fight are you thinking about? Gun fight, fist fight, legal fight?
Look at history, how many times have peaceful protesting and demonstrations resulted in the people achieving what they set out to do.
Demonstrations tend to play a role in communicating a message. I don’t know how often demonstrations alone have been helpful, as the one’s I’ve been most familiar use some combination of appealing to one’s emotions and possibly peacefully hitting some one where it hurts (ex: boycott, organized walkouts, …). There’s also been civil disobedience.
I cannot think of any, 98% of the time, it results in the police coming out to break it up and send people on their way, or it ends with police getting violent, by use of tear gas, rubber bullets, swat teams in riot gear, etc.
Would you mind sharing which region or time period you are referring to here? I could see this being descriptive of civil rights protest decades ago in the USA, or the Arab Spring. I’m assuming the “98%” figure here also is not meant to be taken as factual, but figurative.
 
As the Hispanic population in the US will increase from 16% to 30% of total population by 2050 its hard to see how Christianity will decline. Non-Catholic Christians may but with the increase in the Hispanic population I can see Catholicism being the biggest religion in the US one day.
Something like a third of Americans raised Catholic no longer consider themselves to be Catholic. The Hispanic population is propping the Church up numerically. But many, many Latino Catholics are leaving the Church and many are becoming Protestants. Moreover, many Hispanic Catholics, like non-Hispanic ones, have only a marginal connection to their faith. There is an implosion of religious commitment in America that is hard to miss, and it affects those of all ethnicities. The Church may be growing qualitatively here, but not numerically.
 
Sorry when i said that homosexuality was firt legalized in America i meant homosexual marriage.
 
lubbockonline.com/interact/blog-post/may/2013-05-02/obama-determined-united-states-will-not-be-christian-nation#.UmkTszCQZYc

USA is becoming more and more secular and i think that at one point the nation will be almost completely atheistic. The millitary no longer has the right to preach the gospel or they can end up in prison. What’s next, you won’t be allowed to teach about Jesus to your own child? I don’t live in America but as i can see USA has incredible influence on Europe, mo homeland. The sexual revolution expanded from USA to Europe. When homosexuality was made legal in USA, European countries started to debate over legalizing homosexuality. And i think homosexuality will become legal in most European countries soon. What do you think on the subject?
If by “Will Christianity die in the USA…” means will Xianity disappear? No…fi will “Xiantiy die…” meaning will if loose it’s political and moral authority to influence legislation and define civil rights issues in terms of moraltiy and religious belief…most likely…I sure hope so any way…at least “conservative” Xianity.
 
. . . . This narrative is fundamentally anti-historical (denying the value of the past or of tradition to shape and condition us), anti-family (denying the value of familial relationships and ties to actually shape and condition us), anti-community (denying the value of broader human relationships to shape and condition us), anti-environment (denying the value of our environment and our relationship to it to shape and condition us) and pro-individual. Subsequently, this narrative finds it very difficult to actually affirm any value as universal: nothing, according to this narrative, can be affirmed as bindingly or universally true. !
If this is accurate, then we are in worse shape than even I thought—and I anticipate the fall of Western civilization.

A society which does not value family, community, history, environment, or even truth, cannot long endure. It is built on nothing.

Will Christianity die? No. Christianity will rebuild civilization after it falls.

Will Christianity be outlawed. Probably not, although embracing Christian morals may be. One might find it a thoughtcrime to accept Christian morals when it comes to homosexuality, abortion, euthanasia.

Cardinal George famously said in the course of a talk that he expected to die in his bed, his successor to die in prison, and his successor to die a martyr in the public square. We shall see. The secular culture is in any case, increasingly hostile to Christianity.
 
lubbockonline.com/interact/blog-post/may/2013-05-02/obama-determined-united-states-will-not-be-christian-nation#.UmkTszCQZYc

USA is becoming more and more secular and i think that at one point the nation will be almost completely atheistic. The millitary no longer has the right to preach the gospel or they can end up in prison. What’s next, you won’t be allowed to teach about Jesus to your own child? I don’t live in America but as i can see USA has incredible influence on Europe, mo homeland. The sexual revolution expanded from USA to Europe. When homosexuality was made legal in USA, European countries started to debate over legalizing homosexuality. And i think homosexuality will become legal in most European countries soon. What do you think on the subject?
The view from here is that America is a corpse currently undergoing the embalming process. Barring re-infusion of Life-giving Water, we’ll be ready for burial soon.

“If we ever forget we’re one nation under God, then we will be a nation gone under.” - Ronald Reagan
 
I suspect so, or at least lose its majority status. The US is already something of an outlier- most educated countries have ditched religion to a much larger extent. But the trend is still there and I don’t see any reason why it would turn around. Immigrants from more religious countries might prop up Chistiabity for awhile, but their children and grandchildren will assimilate and adopt secularism just as they adopt English.
 
No, I don’t think once Christianity fully permeates a society that it will die out. It might rise and it might decline, but it doesn’t just snuff out.

There’s a very easy, material reason for why this isn’t going to happen: the West is setting. America does not have the influence today that it did 10 years ago, and 10 years ago, America did not have the influence that it did 20 years ago. There is no anticipation of this country returning to the economic boom of the 20th century. Ditto for Europe and Japan. Our fertility rates have plummeted. Governments are sunk in entitlement programs. Student debt is soaring. The reason is quite simply because it is impossible to defy some basic tenets of the moral law and expect for you to magically go in prosperity indefinitely, as if a high standard of living were something that came naturally and without discipline. We can say whatever we want about the many shortcomings within developing countries, but they have adopted much of what made the West great in the first place, while the West, in turn, has become afflicted with amnesia.

This means at least two major things. 1) Peoples of developing countries aren’t going to look at post-Christian nations with Bambi-eyed admiration and imitate everything we do. As our influence weakens, so will our ability to project our values. 2) It has been a long understood reality - written about in the Old Testament and throughout history - that material convenience threatens a person’s devotion to their faith. When hard times fall on a country, that means people are going to sober up.

What I do anticipate is that the USA will not be able to hold on to its Christian identity as being a default religion for people. If you thought we would, then you were bound for disappointment. That time has already come and passed, and in my opinion, we were never a “Christian nation” to begin with.

Even if we were to theorize a dramatic case in the US similar to the Soviet takeover, where the flame of Christianity is brought down to a meager flicker, it simply means that Christianity is going to soar elsewhere. The CC is experiencing never before seen inroads of growth in Africa and Asia. It is already the case that some people from those countries of growing influence are going into neighborhoods in the West and performing various mission work.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top