Will Mormons Go to Hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter christian2112
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

christian2112

Guest
If Joseph Smith was a false prophet, as we Christians believe, do Mormons go to hell for believing in this false prophet (despite overwhelming evidence that he was a fraud) and especially for proselytizing others to the LDS Church? I want to know this because I have a friend who is a Mormon and I discuss faith with him often.
 
If Joseph Smith was a false prophet, as we Christians believe, do Mormons go to hell for believing in this false prophet (despite overwhelming evidence that he was a fraud) and especially for proselytizing others to the LDS Church? I want to know this because I have a friend who is a Mormon and I discuss faith with him often.
Not necessarily.Most Mormons are very sincere in their beliefs and are oblivious to the reality that they are deceived.
 
If Joseph Smith was a false prophet, as we Christians believe, do Mormons go to hell for believing in this false prophet (despite overwhelming evidence that he was a fraud) and especially for proselytizing others to the LDS Church? I want to know this because I have a friend who is a Mormon and I discuss faith with him often.
Only God can send someone to hell. God looks at the heart.
 
I guess I will slightly revise my question: Is earnestly believing in false doctrine from a false prophet something that will result in damnation?
 
I guess I will slightly revise my question: Is earnestly believing in false doctrine from a false prophet something that will result in damnation?
How can we really know? Christ says that it is only through Him that men can be saved. Catholics believe salvation comes only through the Catholic Church (which is His body and is the Church Christ Himself founded), but to many these days, that seems only to mean that every person in Heaven is a Catholic, not that every Catholic goes to Heaven, or that only Catholics in life go to Heaven.

I certainly hope others can go to Heaven, but I wouldn’t bet my eternity on it. I would just stick with the Church that Christ founded and not take chances.
 
I’m not God, therefore, I can’t say whether they do or don’t.
 
To your latter question: yes, if 1) it is not repented of 2) it does not come from a state of “invincible ignorance.”

Note: “invincible ignorance” is something only known to God. Therefore, since we are not God, we must go with “yes, if not repented of.”
 
I guess I will slightly revise my question: Is earnestly believing in false doctrine from a false prophet something that will result in damnation?
Not if the person is invincibly ignorant of the truth. You posted that they know their beliefs are a fraud. That’s not the case or they wouldn’t cling to their beliefs. No one who sincerely believes something believes it a fraud. Only deceivers know they are deceiving if they are doing it deliberately.

The Catholic Church teaches that due to Christ’s redemptive sacrificial death, the grace of God has been poured out on all mankind–not just on those who have heard of and believe in Jesus–or who truly understand who he was. All will be saved who respond to God’s grace as they know how. The thing we have to remember, though is that since we are all born with original sin, no one can do anything good without God’s grace. We need all the help from God we can get. That’s why Jesus gave us the Church, the seven sacraments, and all the helps he has seen fit to give us–so we can be saved. This is not easy for Christians, let alone for those who do not have access to Christian benefits. But God is not bound by anything except his mercy, his justice and his love.
 
I guess I will slightly revise my question: Is earnestly believing in false doctrine from a false prophet something that will result in damnation?
Well…see…consider this: Do those devout Mormons believe Joseph Smith to be a false prophet and Mormonism false?

If they believed otherwise…and found out Joseph Smith is a false prophet…would they remain Mormon? Yes or no?
 
It’s a polytheistic 19th century religion primarily centered in Utah surrounded by an ocean of a traditionally Christian nation in a high-tech, highly-connected society with easy access to information with the freedom to practice whatever religion you choose.

As much as I want not to, I have a bleak outlook towards their future. It says something if a person goes through decade after decade of their entire life without stopping and considering if the faith of their birth is true. Maybe they’re naive, or maybe they just don’t care, and their faith amounts to an accessory item.
 
God only knows but if they continue to persist in their beliefs…
 
The Church doesn’t assign anyone to hell. We don’t know. 🤷 We know the Mornons state they believe other than us, we are in agreement here. Do Mormons claim Catholic’s are going to hell? :confused.
 
I guess I will slightly revise my question: Is earnestly believing in false doctrine from a false prophet something that will result in damnation?
Mortal sin, the sin that condems, requires full knowledge and consent. A sincere member of the LDS or other Mormon sect does not necessarily know their church is false, thus may may lack the “full knowledge”. As a result, there is hope for their salvation in spite of their false beliefs.
 
Saying that Mormons will go to hell is like saying Jehovah’s Witnesses, Anglicans, Lutherans, etc., will go to hell. The short answer is: We don’t know. Only God can send someone to hell.
 
It’s a polytheistic 19th century religion primarily centered in Utah surrounded by an ocean of a traditionally Christian nation in a high-tech, highly-connected society with easy access to information with the freedom to practice whatever religion you choose.

As much as I want not to, I have a bleak outlook towards their future. It says something if a person goes through decade after decade of their entire life without stopping and considering if the faith of their birth is true. Maybe they’re naive, or maybe they just don’t care, and their faith amounts to an accessory item.
Most people live and believe what they have been taught by their elders is true. Why should they explore outside their beliefs if they are happy where they are and believe all they’ve told? Catholics are not in the business of proselytizing people away from their beliefs. We are expected to share what we know in love and pray. The rest is up to the Holy Spirit and the other person’s ability to hear the truth.
DaddyGirl:
People have earnestly believed in a large variety of ever-changing false Gods, false prophets, and false doctrines for tens of thousands of years–if not longer, much longer.
Certainly ever since the descendants of Noah broke into various family groups and separated from one another. This separation is what caused the words God had spoken to Adam and Noah to become fragmented and confused, but most containing germs of the truth in them, hence the commonality in myths and legends.
If there is a God, and if this God is all-knowing and compassionate as the religious experts claim…this God is not going to set up various religions around the world over thousands of years and allow people to believe in them…only, then, to send those billions of people to hell.
It makes no sense.
I agree that God is not eager to send anyone to hell. But he did not set up various religions around the world. People distorted the message they had heard when mankind was still one people. God chose not to interact and correct such errors until he chose Abram to make of him a nation dedicated to the true God. Men have the capacity to create all sorts of ideas based solely on what was known to the first descendants of Noah. Since Christ has died to redeem all mankind, though, all may be saved through him, even if they have never heard of him. This is cited in the Catechism.
Of course…I guess it’s possible we could have a God who could make no sense?
No, it’s we who often make no sense. 😉
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top