Women Priests?

  • Thread starter Thread starter The_Catholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I would print out the letter and show it to him in private and see how he reacts. If he was truly ignorant of it (which I find hard to believe) and accepts it, then everything may be ok. If he starts making excuses like,“that’s not binding” or “I don’t believe it” or “it will change some day” then these are little bells and whistles. Tell him that you are leaving because he is violating his vows among other things. Does he deviate from Church teaching in other things? One last thing, your decision, I would notify the bishop of this. Some would just walk away or put up with it. That is turning a blind eye to a problem. We have a duty as Catholics to report such abuses or they will just keep getting worst.
This is true. If, after you do your best to point out his error, and he still does not comply with Church teaching, I would definitely inform the Bishop.

But, pray first, and then approach him with charity on the subject. There may be something at work here that none of us can see but will be exposed if you just approached him first.

If your efforts fail however, do inform the Bishop. It will do no good for others to hear his views and think they are truly Catholic if they are not, and it could potentially send others down the wrong path.

Trust in God to lead you where He wants you. Who’s to say He didn’t send you to that parish for the priest’s benefit? 😉

God Bless,
Snert
 
I would print out the letter and show it to him in private and see how he reacts. If he was truly ignorant of it (which I find hard to believe) and accepts it, then everything may be ok. If he starts making excuses like,“that’s not binding” or “I don’t believe it” or “it will change some day” then these are little bells and whistles. Tell him that you are leaving because he is violating his vows among other things. Does he deviate from Church teaching in other things? One last thing, your decision, I would notify the bishop of this. Some would just walk away or put up with it. That is turning a blind eye to a problem. We have a duty as Catholics to report such abuses or they will just keep getting worst.
Wait hold on, the conversation I had, and the man I’m talking about is the pianoist, I’m sorry, I should of been more clear. I suspect the preist shares the same train of thought, because the Homily was about the scandal Jesus caused in the temple because of abuses in greed, a den of robbers, and he said: “a **good **scandal, like which Jesus caused, would be married preists, and women preists.” So I gathered he thinks this way too.

And thanks for your advice brother. 🙂
 
Wait hold on, the conversation I had, and the man I’m talking about is the pianoist, I’m sorry, I should of been more clear. I suspect the preist shares the same train of thought, because the Homily was about the scandal Jesus caused in the temple because of abuses in greed, a den of robbers, and he said: “a **good **scandal, like which Jesus caused, would be married preists, and women preists.” So I gathered he thinks this way too.

And thanks for your advice brother. 🙂
Oops, sorry. I misunderstood as well. I thought you were talking about the priest too.
😊
 
Well I just wrote the letter to him, I’ll await his response. I quoted the CCC, Pope John Paul II, the Church Fathers, gave some links, and quotes from the Magisterium. I just have this feleing he’s going to try and refute it all, and I’m not good in debates, so I’ll share with you guys what he says so you could help me, if that’s ok. 🙂
 
Well I just wrote the letter to him, I’ll await his response. I quoted the CCC, Pope John Paul II, the Church Fathers, gave some links, and quotes from the Magisterium. I just have this feleing he’s going to try and refute it all, and I’m not good in debates, so I’ll share with you guys what he says so you could help me, if that’s ok. 🙂
Oops, thought it was the priest also. But if he shares this view then we got big trouble in River City brother. And there is no debating this. This is infallible teaching, required belief for everyone, especially priests. Good luck and God Bless.
 
Oops, thought it was the priest also. But if he shares this view then we got big trouble in River City brother. And there is no debating this. This is infallible teaching, required belief for everyone, especially priests. Good luck and God Bless.
Thanks, I see he just emailed me back, I’m going to take a look and see what he says. I’ll get back to you guys.
 
Ok, he is claiming the Pope never spoke in Ex Cathedra. Here are his words:

**"When the Pope John Paul II made that statement there was a big move on with alot of pressure for women’s ordination and he really wanted to take it off the table - hence his emphatic language. Remember they were having a big meeting with all the bishops around that time in Rome back then.
Of course, I would have to agree with the holy father, who would know better than me about these things.
However he did stop short of formally defining it ‘Ex Cathedra’ as an Infallible Teaching (See article below at the bottom from Our Sunday Visitor and EWTN).

For my opinion, No matter what any priest may think, there can be no further change to this policy unless an ecumenical council directed otherwise. It would be alot of wasted energy to argue about it, and there are places in the world where this simply would not work, and I think the people know this as well as the fact that it would hamper any further union with our Orthodox brethren, with whom John Paul had worked so hard to come to an understanding.
I think the crux of the issue is here: we have a real responsibility to get some kind of healing going on with the Eastern Churches, anything to hamper that would be a mistake. The protestants are another matter, official union is unlikely to occur any time soon though there are many spiritual efforts that truly bring us to a catholic level together.

On the issue of married clergy we have a whole other matter. That can change, and probably is likely to in our lifetimes. And the Eastern Churches are certainly with us on an understanding of priesthood and ministry and have apostolic succession.

Note that women deacons were not mentioned. We know they existed in the early church. But deacons did not preside as celebrant at the Eucharist, only the bishop did. (later authority this was also shared with the presbyters). The issue of women deacons is under study. That may be another century."**

He also gave me a letter written by someone else stating:

cont…
 
**"By declaring that the doctrine barring women’s ordination as priests has been taught infallibly, the Vatican Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith cited the infallibility of the “ordinary and universal magisterium.” Quite apart from the women’s ordination issue, that was an unusual, important and widely misunderstood step.

Many people seem to have thought the Nov. 18 statement was referring to ****papal infallibility. That was the case, for example, with The New Republic, in an editorial criticizing the Vatican. Even Catholic News Service moved a story reporting that the doctrinal congregation said the doctrine on women’s ordination “has been taught ‘infallibly,’ by Pope John Paul II.”

That isn’t exactly what the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith said. The congregation did not speak of papal infallibility. It said the teaching on women’s ordination “has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal magisterium.”

The distinction – between papal infallibility and the infallibility of the “ordinary and universal magisterium” – is important. But because relatively little has been said about the latter – even the Vatican has been mum about it up to now – the distinction isn’t widely understood."**

There’s more to the letter but this is the important part. So there you have it, he’s claiming that it is still open for possibility. What should I say?

Personally I feel that since the Bible forbids it, along with the Tradition of the Church, it should never come about. What about you guys?
 
I’m going to post the rest of the letter in 2 parts:

**"What it means

Most people have some idea of what papal infallibility means. That dogma, defined
by the First Vatican Council and Pope Pius IX in 1870, affirms that God preserves the
pope from error when he definitively teaches a doctrine of faith or morals.

The dogma of papal infallibility was reaffirmed by the Second Vatican Council (1962-
1965) in (the Dogmatic Constitution on the Church). Here, the
council also made several other crucial points.

One is that infallibility is essentially a gift of God to the Church. When the pope
teaches infallibly, one might say, he is exercising this divine gift on the Church’s behalf.
The same thing is true, the council remarks, when the pope and bishops convened in an
ecumenical council join in a solemn teaching act.

Another important point made by Vatican II concerns the infallibility of the “ordinary
magisterium” – that is, the teaching authority of bishops in union with the pope,
exercised in “ordinary” acts of teaching outside an ecumenical council.

Not everything taught by bishops in union with the pope is infallibly taught, but some
things are. Section 25 of explains when.

“Taken individually,” it says, bishops “do not enjoy the privilege of infallibility.” Yet,
under certain circumstances, they do “proclaim infallibly the doctrine of Christ.”

As written in , that is so “when, even though dispersed throughout
the world but preserving for all that amongst themselves and with Peter’s successor
[the pope] the bond of communion, in their authoritative teaching concerning matters
of faith and morals, they [the bishops] are in agreement that a particular teaching is to
be held definitively and absolutely.”

The Second Vatican Council teaching states that four conditions must be met for an
infallible exercise of the ordinary magisterium of bishops around the world. These are:
  1. That the bishops be in communion with one another and with the pope.
  2. That they teach authoritatively on a matter of faith or morals.
  3. That they agree in one judgment.
  4. That they propose this as something to be held definitively by the faithful.
Conditions met

In appealing to the infallibility of “the ordinary and universal magisterium,” in its
Nov. 18 statement, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith implicitly was saying
these conditions are met in the case of the teaching that women cannot be ordained as
priests. The statement cited .

The doctrinal congregation did not develop this argument. Presumably, though, it was
making the point that, whenever in the history of the Church the question of ordaining
women as priests has come up, bishops with virtual – though not necessarily absolute -
  • unanimity have taken the position that it simply cannot be done because it is contrary
    to the will of Christ."
    **
cont…
 
**"Not much has been said about the infallibility of the ordinary magisterium since
Vatican II adopted and Pope Paul VI approved in 1964. For
obvious reasons, this is not a doctrine dissenting theologians call attention to. Even the
Vatican has said very little about it, and the Catechism of the Catholic Church barely
alludes to it (see no. 891).

In 1978, however, two American moral theologians – Jesuit Father John Ford and
Germain Grisez – published what is probably the most important theological article to
date analyzing and applying Vatican II’s doctrine.

The article, in the journal Theological Studies, argued at length that the teaching that
every act of contraception is intrinsically wrong has been proposed infallibly by the
ordinary magisterium.

In reaching this conclusion, Father Ford and Grisez traced the history of the teaching
on contraception over many centuries and examined the manner in which it was
proposed by countless bishops in their individual exercise of teaching authority.

Even if a substantial number of bishops now or at some time in the future were to be
doubtful about the teaching or not accept it, that would have no bearing on the fact
that the conditions for infallible teaching already have been met, they argued.

The Father Ford-Grisez thesis has not been widely embraced by theologians, and the
Vatican officially has not said anything about it. But their argument, though
challenged or ignored by dissenters, has never been refuted. And, as they pointed out
at the time, the same argument, if correct, applies not only to contraception but also to
many other matters taught by the ordinary magisterium.

In a Nov. 24 address to members of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith,
Pope John Paul expressed regret that many Catholics apparently think they are at
liberty to dismiss doctrines they don’t agree with unless it is formally stated that they
are infallibly proposed.

Different teachings do have different degrees of authority, he said. But he added,
“That does not authorize people to think that pronouncements and doctrinal decisions
of the magisterium require irrevocable assent only when it presents them with a
solemn judgment or definitive act.”

The Pope’s regret was well-founded. Apparently, the Vatican concluded that nothing
less than invoking infallibility would put an end to pressure for women’s ordination –
and it remains to be seen whether even that will work.

In basing its case against ordaining women on the infallibility of the ordinary
magisterium, however, the Vatican has made use of a tool with many other applications
besides this one. When, whether and in what context it will use the tool again are
weighty questions.

Shaw is Our Sunday Visitor’s Washington correspondent and director of public
information for the Knights of Columbus

This article was taken from the December 17, 1995 issue of Our Sunday Visitor. To
subscribe write Our Sunday Visitor, Inc, Huntington, In 46750."**
 
**
That isn’t exactly what the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith said. The congregation did not speak of papal infallibility. It said the teaching on women’s ordination “has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal magisterium.”

The distinction – between papal infallibility and the infallibility of the “ordinary and universal magisterium” – is important. But because relatively little has been said about the latter – even the Vatican has been mum about it up to now – the distinction isn’t widely understood."**

There’s more to the letter but this is the important part. So there you have it, he’s claiming that it is still open for possibility. What should I say?

Personally I feel that since the Bible forbids it, along with the Tradition of the Church, it should never come about. What about you guys?
That is a distinction w/o a difference. The ordinary and universal magisterium is every bit as infallible as the Pope speaking ex Cathedra. In fact the Pope has only formally invoked Infallibility twice. 99.9% of the deposit of Faith is held through the infallibility of the ordinary and univeral magisterium.

You are correct. He is wrong. Talk to the pastor. If he agrees with this fellow. find another parish and contact the bishop.

God Bless
 
That is a distinction w/o a difference.** The ordinary and universal magisterium is every bit as infallible as the Pope speaking ex Cathedra. In fact the Pope has only formally invoked Infallibility twice. 99.9% of the deposit of Faith is held through the infallibility of the ordinary and univeral magisterium.**

You are correct. He is wrong. Talk to the pastor. If he agrees with this fellow. find another parish and contact the bishop.

God Bless
Could you elaborate a little more on the section I highlighted please?
 
In 1994, Pope John Paul II declared, “Although the teaching that priestly ordination is to be reserved to men alone has been preserved by the constant and universal Tradition of the Church and firmly taught by the Magisterium in its more recent documents, at the present time in some places it is nonetheless considered still open to debate, or the Church’s judgment that women are not to be admitted to ordination is considered to have a merely disciplinary force. Wherefore, in order that all doubt may be removed regarding a matter of great importance, a matter which pertains to the Church’s divine constitution itself, in virtue of my ministry of confirming the brethren (cf. Luke 22:32), I declare that the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women and that this judgment is to be definitively held by all the Church’s faithful” (Ordinatio Sacerdotalis 4).

One year after this was written, the Church ruled that this teaching “requires definitive assent, since, founded on the written Word of God, and from the beginning constantly preserved and applied in the Tradition of the Church, it has been set forth infallibly by the ordinary and universal Magisterium (cf. Second Vatican Council, Dogmatic Constitution on the Church, Lumen Gentium 25:2)” (Response of Oct. 25, 1995). For more on this, see cin.org/users/james/files/inter.htm and cin.org/users/james/files/w-ordination.htm

What doesn’t he understand about “infallibly by the ordinary and universal Magisterium”?

The Pope issued the letter to put an end to the idea that women can be priests. They just won’t let go.
 
Here are some more articles and links. This is an infallible teaching.

vatican.va/holy_father/john_paul_ii/apost_letters/documents/hf_jp-ii_apl_22051994_ordinatio-sacerdotalis_en.html

The Only Good Catholic Is a Bad Catholic Department: According to Call to Action, one hundred members of CTA, FutureChurch, Pax Christi, and the Catholic Worker staged an Ash Wednesday protest on the steps of St. Matthew’s Cathedral in Washington, D.C. “Three young women in stoles led the service and marked the foreheads of passersby with ashes from a burned copy of the Vatican decree calling the ban on women priests infallible.”

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=26160
 
The ordinary and universal magisterium is every bit as infallible as the Pope speaking ex Cathedra. In fact the Pope has only formally invoked Infallibility twice. 99.9% of the deposit of Faith is held through the infallibility of the ordinary and univeral magisterium.
Could you elaborate a little more on the section I highlighted please?
Sure. I believe the only times the Pope has actually said “I am declaring this dogma by speaking ex cathedra” are the Immaculate Conception and the Assumption of Mary.

All other dogma/doctrines are either declarations of Ecumenical Councils or the universal ordinary magisterium (i.e. they have been taught always and everywhere by the Pope and bishops of the Church). Even all the declarations of the Councils were universal ordinary magisterial teachings until challenged by some heresy; at which point they were formally declared.

For example, the Canon of the Bible and Transubstantiation were first formally decreed at Trent (mid-1500’s). However, these things had been consistently taught throughout the history of the Church. They were universal ordinary magisterial teachings before Trent, and just as infallible.

Basically, any truth on Faith and Morals that has always been taught by the Pope and bishops is infallible.

Hope that helps.

God Bless
 
There is serious debate among canonists and theologians on whether or not this teaching meets the criteria of infallibility. You can find solid arguments on both sides of the question.

The Bible does not teach women can’t be ordained.
 
There is serious debate among canonists and theologians on whether or not this teaching meets the criteria of infallibility. You can find solid arguments on both sides of the question.

The Bible does not teach women can’t be ordained.
Gee, who do you think would know if the teaching is infallible? Maybe the POPE?!
 
My point is that many who disagree that this teaching has been taught infallibly point out that if John Paul II had wanted to teach it infallibly…why didn’t he clearly say so? Why did the CDF feel the need to later to come out and claim the teaching was taught infallibly? Canon Law (749) states “No doctrine is understood as defined infallibly unless this is manifestly evident.” Some would contend that the criterion of “manifestly evident” was not made by John Paul II.

My point is that sincere, faithful, educated people disagree on that point.

And yes, of course the Pope’s opinion on the matter is important. But there are plenty of theologians and canonists who have more extensive training and education in specific areas than a given Pope might have, and their voices shouldn’t be discounted. Infallibility is a gift or charism of the Church, not an individual.

Cheers
 
Given the area you live in, you would be hard pressed to find a parish that was not dissenting. This spirit extends past the Rochester diocese. As a matter of fact, you live in one of the most liberal dioceses of the country, according to a priest I know. Dissent is not only tolerated, it is favored and nurtured.

I think this pianist is selling you a line of goods. The priest is talking double talk, and in circles, to confuse you. In any case, if you have children in formation, hearing a priest talk like this is dangerous to their faith.

In Rochester, we had to look quite a bit to find an orthodox parish, and, after we moved from there, I am told it was removed from the priest who had it and taken over by the type you just mentioned.

I believe God removed us from there because I would literally be in despair, spiritually speaking. Orthodox Catholics are barely tolerated, loud ones are downright suppressed. I am told that in your diocese it is far worse. Why this is allowed and tolerated, I’ll never know, because it is very wearing on those of us who know better.

I would keep looking, in spite of living in such a rural area. You will be infected by this spirit of error, dissent, and new age childish silliness, if you stay. It is hard to remain spiritually fed, having to wade through the manure. I feel for you, believe me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top