cute2904:
So you believe in koran only?
no, i take my beliefs from the Quran and the authentic hadeeths. you spoke of “verses” and no verses have been quoted here with the expection of your last post, in which you quoted two. perhaps you are ignorant of that fact that hadeeths and other narrations are not considered “verses”. they are considered narrations, and only prophetic hadeeths are considered - along with the Quran - to be holy scripture. other narrations, such as quotes from scholars of islam and especially israelite traditions - such as the first one you quoted to start this thread, are not considered scripture at all, and in cases where they contradict islamic beliefs (as is the case with the narration you quoted from at-tabaree), they are rejected outright.
cute2904:
The point is, beside you say women are stupid.
i have never said such a thing. and no where in islam’s legislative texts does it say this either. and to accuse me, or islam of saying such is slander and an outright lie based on your corrupt interpretations of what’s been mentioned thus far.
cute2904:
You also say women are hell’s most residents.
read the other narrations of that authentic hadeeth. they say, “most of the fire’s people are women
who disbelieve” - and as is mentioned in fath al-baaree, the explanation of saheeh al-bukhaaree, this refers to those women who disbelieve in Allah as well as those women who are ungrateful to their husbands and the good that is done for them - whether that ungratefulness is out of outright denial or out of hiding the truth. you probably won’t, but perhaps you may benefit from reading this article,
women and the inhabitants of hellfire.
cute2904:
Are you trying to deny that Islam has put women at lower level than men?
you began the thread was trying to show that islam says that Allah made stupid. and you were wrong. if your intent was to show how islam “put women at a lower level than men” then perhaps you should have stated that at the beginning instead of beating around the bush, so to speak.
however, now that you bring it up, yes - as is a known fact of nature, that
in general men have a degree over women.
generally they are physically stronger than women.
generally they think more rationally than women do and are less emotional than them.
generally they possess better overall leadership qualities than women, which is why Allah mentions in the Quran, “
the men are maintainers over the women due to Allah giving preference to some of them over others, and due to what they spend from their wealth.” (4:34). as for in the eyes of Allah, the two sexes are equals, with the only criteria Allah looking at is one’s piety, just as He mentions in the Quran.
cute2904:
Lets take your word for Reason/Rationality. Whats wrong with Reason then? You mean women’s reason/rationality is weak? men’s reason and rationality are much better than women?
are you willing to reject the findings of scientific psychological research and say that women’s sense of reason and rationality is generally better than men’s? perhaps you should read this: why two women witnesses?, which is a reply to the accusation against islam that it degrades a woman’s status by making a man’s testimony equal to that of two women’s.
cute2904:
But Islam has put women in such poor condition.
coming from a religion like christianity, you’re one to speak…
women in islam vs. women in the judeo-christian tradition; the myth and the reality.
