Women Theologians

  • Thread starter Thread starter TinaG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TinaG

Guest
Are there any women theologians of international stature now working in the Catholic church? If so, who?

I understand that women can’t be priests - I understand your position on that and I tend to agree: if I were Catholic I would have no trouble with it - but it seems that in order to be a theologian, one must first be a priest. And to be a priest one must be male, so women cannot be theologians. That doesn’t sound right. Is it?

Isn’t St. Therese of Avila a doctor of the church? Is she the only woman doctor? Catholics allow women strong roles in the church, but is this an area where there is a glass ceiling? Is she the exception that proves the rule?

I mean no offense. Really. I am just curious and not out to argue or anything. Please forgive my ignorance.

-Tina
 
Isn’t St. Therese of Avila a doctor of the church? Is she the only woman doctor? -Tina
St. Catherine of Siena and St. Therese of Lisieux are also doctors of the Church. Catherine (who lived in the 14th century) was instrumental in bringing the popes back from France to Rome, ending a division in the Church. St. Edith Stein, who lived during the 20th century, was a very well regarded philosopher and thinker.

There are many other great women saints in the Catholic Church, from Mary (the greatest saint of all – man or woman) to, hopefully in the near future, Mother Teresa (probably the most famous Christian woman of the 20th century).

Incidentally, I’m not familiar with any well-known female Protestant theologians, either historically or in modern times. I know there are many female ministers, but as for theologians, I haven’t heard of any, though I’m sure there are some. Not a knock, just an observation.
 
Are there any women theologians of international stature now working in the Catholic church? If so, who?

I understand that women can’t be priests - I understand your position on that and I tend to agree: if I were Catholic I would have no trouble with it - but it seems that in order to be a theologian, one must first be a priest. And to be a priest one must be male, so women cannot be theologians. That doesn’t sound right. Is it?

Isn’t St. Therese of Avila a doctor of the church? Is she the only woman doctor? Catholics allow women strong roles in the church, but is this an area where there is a glass ceiling? Is she the exception that proves the rule?

I mean no offense. Really. I am just curious and not out to argue or anything. Please forgive my ignorance.

-Tina
Alice von Hildebrand

Doctors
St. Catherine of Siena
St. Teresa of Avila
St. Therese of Lisieux
St. Hilary of Poitiers 😛
 
St. Catherine of Siena and St. Therese of Lisieux are also doctors of the Church. Catherine (who lived in the 14th century) was instrumental in bringing the popes back from France to Rome, ending a division in the Church. St. Edith Stein, who lived during the 20th century, was a very well regarded philosopher and thinker.

There are many other great women saints in the Catholic Church, from Mary (the greatest saint of all – man or woman) to, hopefully in the near future, Mother Teresa (probably the most famous Christian woman of the 20th century).

Incidentally, I’m not familiar with any well-known female Protestant theologians, either historically or in modern times. I know there are many female ministers, but as for theologians, I haven’t heard of any, though I’m sure there are some. Not a knock, just an observation.
Thanks!

I didn’t take it as a knock. Among Protestants, serious theology seems to be mostly one of those male preserves. Only a few women come to mind (Nancy Pearcy, for example, and she is not nearly as well known as a John Piper).
 
Yes a woman can be a theologian, and yes there are prominent women theologians in the Catholic Church.

I’m not sure why you equate being a theologian with first being a priest? One may obtain a doctorate in theology, teach theology, write books, etc, without ever being a priest. Both men and women do so. Of course there are many theologians who are priests as well, since obviously many priests pursue advanced degrees in theology.

As for women, Dr. Janet Smith is a wonderful moral theologian. Dr. Alice von Hildebrand is another highly regarded woman that comes to mind. I’m sure there are many others, as I know many women teach in seminaries and Catholic universities, and are on pontifical councils, etc.
 
Are there any women theologians of international stature now working in the Catholic church? If so, who?

I understand that women can’t be priests - I understand your position on that and I tend to agree: if I were Catholic I would have no trouble with it - but it seems that in order to be a theologian, one must first be a priest. And to be a priest one must be male, so women cannot be theologians. That doesn’t sound right. Is it?

Isn’t St. Therese of Avila a doctor of the church? Is she the only woman doctor? Catholics allow women strong roles in the church, but is this an area where there is a glass ceiling? Is she the exception that proves the rule?

I mean no offense. Really. I am just curious and not out to argue or anything. Please forgive my ignorance.

-Tina
I like Dr. Pia de Solenni. She’s a moral theologian on Teresa Tomeo’s Catholic Connection radio program every week.
 
hmmm the women theologians I know I would qualify them as “modernistic”. I prefer to be cautious about modernism.
here’s one of the bible verses which addresses this topic:

For this I was appointed preacher and apostle (I am speaking the truth, I am not lying), teacher of the Gentiles in faith and truth. It is my wish, then, that in every place the men should pray, lifting up holy hands, without anger or argument. Similarly, (too,) women should adorn themselves with proper conduct, with modesty and self-control, not with braided hairstyles and gold ornaments, or pearls, or expensive clothes, but rather, as befits women who profess reverence for God, with good deeds.
A woman must receive instruction silently and under complete control.** I do not permit a woman to teach or to have authority over a man. She must be quiet.For Adam was formed first, then Eve. Further, Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and transgressed. But she will be saved through motherhood, provided women persevere in faith and love and holiness, with self-control.** (1 tim 2:7-15)

here is a link with more thoughts about this: "[Society and culture has a profound effect on all of us. We live our entire lives immersed in our society and culture. We eat, drink, breathe, and sleep our culture. When our culture teaches something incorrect, and teaches it constantly and thoroughly, it is difficult for us to even consider a different idea. When our culture teaches something incorrect, and we stumble across the truth, the truth will seem foreign and awkward to us. The truth will not “feel right,” whenever the truth contradicts the culture in which we are immersed. That is why many Catholics have rejected certain teachings of the Church – because those teachings contradict the teachings of the society and culture around us.

Our society and culture teaches that men and women should have much the same roles in their lives. Modern secular culture treats men and women as if they were meant to be interchangeable parts in society. Men and women are given nearly the same roles in our society today…](http://www.catholicplanet.com/women/roles.htm)"
 
Re: women as teachers

I guess you disagree with Paul’s letter to Timothy, then, where he charges Timothy to remember what his mother and grandmother taught him. Women are the natural teachers in the home, and they have a lot of call to teach in the world. Just because they don’t sit on the seat of authority in the parish church or the cathedral, doesn’t mean they can’t breathe a word about Christ the rest of the time.

I guess you also don’t believe that there were deaconesses in the Church. Most of the modernist stuff about them is made up; but it’s true that they had responsibility for teaching women in areas where men couldn’t go, and for making sure that the Church’s orphans were taught Christianity.

From the earliest times, moreover, it was acknowledged that a woman leading a religious community of women, or even communities of women and communities of men, had a teaching authority somewhat comparable to a bishop, although without anything like the same consecration.

A wonderful example of a woman teacher and theologian in the early Church is St. Macrina the Younger. She was the eldest of a family of Christians, named after her grandmother who had been in the persecutions, and became the abbess of a female religious community on the family estates, ruling both it and a younger brother’s male religious community next door. Her five younger brothers, whom she and her mother taught, included two great theologians and Fathers of the Church: St. Basil the Great and St. Gregory of Nyssa. St. Gregory fully acknowledged his debt to her, writing both the Life of St. Macrina and a presentation of his dialogue with her on her last night on earth, On the Soul and the Resurrection. In both, he calls her “the Teacher” as much as he calls her his sister. Like many abbesses, she is often portrayed in iconography as sitting on a teaching seat – although one inside a house/abbey, not one inside a church – or as holding a scroll, as someone with a message to listen to.

When everybody knows who’s in charge in which spheres where, there’s a lot more room for women to take on authority of certain kinds, and teaching of certain kinds, without being seen as usurping priestly or episcopal teaching authority.
 
Interesting! Thank you all!:tiphat:

But women cannot be deacons, right? Is that doctrine or dogma?

-Tina
 
Interesting! Thank you all!:tiphat:

But women cannot be deacons, right? Is that doctrine or dogma?

-Tina
Doctrine.

The deaconate is an ordained ministry open only to males.
 
Neither. It is canon law.
O-kay…Houston, we have a disagreement. Please cite your sources for these statements, guys, preferably with links (I think we can do that here, but I haven’t tried yet:blush:) to the appropriate documents.

Thank you!

-Tina
 
From Wikipedia (see here):

In 2003, Father Ronald G. Roberson gave a presentation on the diaconate in the Latin Church to annual meeting of the U.S. Oriental Orthodox-Roman Catholic Consultation. He summarized the state of deaconess issue as follows: “The possibility of ordaining women to the diaconate is still an unsettled question in the Catholic Church. Latin rituals for ordaining deaconesses exist from as late as the 10th century, but the precise sacramental nature of these ordinations has not yet been determined authoritatively. There are recent indications that the Holy See intends to continue the exclusion of women from this office.”[33]

The link for [33] is to the USCCB website (see here).
 
From Wikipedia (see here):

In 2003, Father Ronald G. Roberson gave a presentation on the diaconate in the Latin Church to annual meeting of the U.S. Oriental Orthodox-Roman Catholic Consultation. He summarized the state of deaconess issue as follows: “The possibility of ordaining women to the diaconate is still an unsettled question in the Catholic Church. Latin rituals for ordaining deaconesses exist from as late as the 10th century, but the precise sacramental nature of these ordinations has not yet been determined authoritatively. There are recent indications that the Holy See intends to continue the exclusion of women from this office.”[33]

The link for [33] is to the USCCB website (see here).
Thank you!

-Tina
 
Where deaconesses existed, they seem to have existed not as part of the clergy, but as assistants to the deacons. If you think of them as little old “church ladies” and wives of deacons, you will be thinking in the right direction.

The reason we don’t really have them today (except maybe in the East, where they’re only deacons’ wives these days, if I recall correctly) is that we don’t really need them. We don’t baptize naked adults with full immersion, so we don’t need women to assist with safety and modesty during the Sacrament being given. We don’t have women shut up in women’s quarters guarded by hostile pagans who need funds and religious instruction delivered. We don’t expect the deacon to find a church lady to raise every orphan in the parish, or nurse every sick woman back to health.

Now, if we were doing a lot of evangelization in a hostile Muslim society, say, you might find deaconesses very useful. Which is probably why Eastern Rites tend to have that sort of thing, still.

But anyway, I’ve strayed way off topic here. Non-dissenting orthodox female theologians was more the topic…

Have we mentioned St. Hildegarde of Bingen yet?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top