There are two things that I’m reading in your posts They have validity, but you must proceed with caution. One paragraph for each.
Yes, teens need to understand the mass. Let us remember that the most important thing that they need to understand is that the mass is worship of God. Everything else, music, environment, etc is meant to support that message. Let us be careful not to make the music and the environment the message. If we insist that this must be song in Latin or use Gregorian chant, because we have always done it that way, we’re not teaching the mass. We’re teaching Catholic culture. While Catholic culture is good, it does not stand alone. The culture developed around the faith as a mean of expressing the faith. Sometimes, we want to drag young people to faith through culture. But that’s not how the culture came into existence. We must always begin by teaching them faith, then they will appreciate the culture around that faith.
The second thing that we must remember is that tradition is bigger than liturgy. We have a tradition of liturgy, we also have a tradition of diverse spiritualities in the Church: Benedictine, Franciscan, Carmelite, Salesian, and Augustinian. Those are the more common ones. We have a tradition of rich art and music. We have a tradition of scholarship and science. We have a tradition of customs, private devotions such as the rosary, customs for the Catholic family, etc. We have a strong tradition of corporal works of mercy. We have always led the world in responding to the poor and the most vulnerable members of society. We invented the whole notion of peace and justice. We have a long tradition of sacred scripture, which to which we pay very little attention all too often. We have a tradition of prayer that is very Catholic. There are devotional prayers, Liturgy of the Hours, private recitation of the rosary, and many forms of common prayer.
We have to teach the whole culture of Catholicism. The liturgical tradition without the rest is not a good thing. Liturgy lasts an hour, 90 minutes on a solemnity. How do we teach kids to worship? By engaging them in everything that is Catholic. In the parish were I volunteer, I’m not assigned to a parish . . . the kids do use Latin for certain parts of the mass. They love to sing it. But those kids are also very involved in the life of the parish. They are there three or four days a week. They have Benediction on Thursdays with adoration for an hour or two, I forget. They run the parish pantry. They assist in religious education on Tues and Weds. They have mass and the Life Teen meeting on Sundays. They have retreat twice a year. They go to every Pro-Life rally in the state. They go to funeral masses. They have confession every week. They have our brothers who come in from outside of the parish to be with them. They go to Catholic summer camp. They fly to Washington every year for the March for Life. They invite the bishop to celebrate mass for them. Some of them are great artists and they write music for worship. They run retreats for the middle school kids and the first communion kids.
As you can see, these kids are immersed in the Catholic world. The parish pays a person to coordinate all their activities. As a result, we have had two young men who became brothers and one young woman who became a sister. We have not had any become priests yet, but our diocese pushes the brothers and the sisters more. We have a large number of brothers serving here, about one brother to every two priests. However, I do know one or two priests in the diocese who came from the ranks of Life Teen and a lot of young sisters. We have a congregation of sisters with about 50 sisters under age 35.
But I keep saying the same thing, like a broken record. A parish will get what they invest in it. What I’m hearing from your post is that you want to see this very traditional mass and therefore would not like to see Life Teen. What I’m saying is that if you use well, the program will get you where you want to go. Those parishes that molded their youth are finding that the kids themselves are curious.
Maybe they’ll never sing Gregorian chant. That’s OK. Franciscans banned it for 750 years. We’re still the largest religious family in the Church, if you add up all of the branches of the order. Why do we attract so many young men and women? Because we have always presented a very strong faith. That’s what the young need, a spirituality that is strong and moral language that they can use.
Fraternally,
Br. JR, OSF