Would getting bariatric surgery done be committing the sin of vanity?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Holly3278
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

Holly3278

Guest
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
 
Although I personally believe bariatric surgeries to be imprudent for many people (and I obviously don’t presume to know your situation) I think it would definitely NOT be a sin.

First, bariatric surgeries typically have tremendously positive impacts on a person’s health, and someone could well desire such a surgery for these benefits alone. Obviously, wanting to be healthier is not sinful.

Now, regarding vanity… wanting to look attractive, or pretty, or whatever, is NOT vanity in and of itself. There are plenty of Godly reasons for wanting to look “good,” within limits… just as it’s not vain to drive around in a decent, late model car, but is vain to drive around in a Rolls Royce.

Good luck!
 
No. How could something that may save your life be a sin. I had lapband over a year ago and I don’t regret it. It was the best thing and I would do it again. I’ve lost 55 lbs and feel great. I have much much to go…lapband is a slower process than gastric by-pass. I wish you luck in your weight loss. Here’s to a healthier you. 😉
 
I came very close to having bariatric surgery, and I was supposed to be on a strict diet for two weeks in preparation for the procedure, but I was so stricken with the sin of gluttony that I could comply with it for even that long. That was when I prayed for the first time in many years, and suddenly I could stop overeating; I was rid of the sin that had plagued me for so long. I believe I was touched by the Holy Spirit. As the weeks went by, I started feeling that God was telling me surgery was not necessary, that I should put my trust in Him. So I canceled the surgery, and despite being on a diet only slightly less strict than the one I was on while in preparation for surgery, I no longer have any real cravings to overeat, and I am losing weight at a satisfactory pace. I have full confidence that I will eventually reach a healthy weight naturally. Well, perhaps not naturally, but without surgery through the grace of the Holy Spirit.

I should say, though, that I debated with myself whether I should post this message because I don’t want to give the impression that I believe God opposes bariatric surgery. What I’m saying is, put your trust in God without reservations and He will show you the way.
 
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
I just want to encourage you Holly! I struggle with weight myself. In the last 6 months (since September 8 2009, with a two break around Christmas/New Years)…I have lost about 115 pounds. I am 35, single and male. I was about 400 pounds when I started. I lost all of that weight by counting calories (weighing my food), and cutting calories down to 1800 a day. It is rough at first but once you establish a routine of eating it gets easier and easier. I eat lots of vegetables (I’m vegetarian) and fruit, and I never eat fried food at all. But mostly I believe that God’s grace has enabled me to do this. And i was not even praying for grace at the time. So imagine how he can help you if you turn to him from the outset! 👍😃
 
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
Well, considering that obesity drastically shortens your life and makes you sick and unable to fully function, I would not say that it is vanity.
 
For some reason, I did too. :confused:

If such surgery is done for health reasons, no sin. If strictly for vanity, maybe sin. Only you know, Holly, what your motivation is.
I don’t know, vanity is a beautiful woman having plastic surgery to remove some wrinkles from her face.

If someone weighs 300 pounds, wanting to look normal is not vanity, just like someone who has lost their limbs but wants a fake arm to look normal is not vain.
 
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
Well I don’t think so…Gluttony is a sin, but you know if the surgery works you might be able to shed a lot of weight and contribute more time to our Lord… matter of fact you will probably will regardless as you seem to be living for the Lord now and you will likely live longer… just being here an extra day means you can get in a few more prayers or good works…

God Bless… I will Pray for you…Please Pray for me…
 
I don’t know, vanity is a beautiful woman having plastic surgery to remove some wrinkles from her face.

If someone weighs 300 pounds, wanting to look normal is not vanity, just like someone who has lost their limbs but wants a fake arm to look normal is not vain.
Oh, don’t get me wrong, I agree with you. What I mean is that if someone is not significantly i.e. unhealthily overweight or just wants to lose those 10, 20 or so “vanity pounds” that they cannot seem to get off with diet and exercise, that’s questionable. Of course, they’d have a hard time getting a doctor to do such surgery.

But I’d also question what is “normal” looking? The 50 year old mother of 3 that is 20 pounds overweight or the 50 year old mother of 3 that spend hour upon hour in the gym just to be able to pinch less than 1/2"?

To some extent, accepting one’s body type is part of rejecting vanity. That’s not to say that medical or psycological weight gain and retention is healthy and we should accept that, but certainly there is a difference between someone wanting to be healthier and someone who just wants to look great. Therein lies the dividing line.
 
If the procedure will be life saving, then it is all good.

If this is an elective procedure, and you can afford to pay for it without harming others (for example, you still will pay your rent and gas bill…), then it would not be objectively sinful.
 
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
I’m just curious - is it lap-band, or bypass? I ask only because I know lap-band is less dangerous (my mom is considering the options too).

Anyway, no, it’s not a sin. Our heath is very important. God has given us good Doctors to ensure our Health. Feeling good about how one looks isn’t the vanity you’re thinking of - that would be an obsession with our looks. Something that gets in the way of our relationships - especially with God.
 
My country is actually currently debating putting lap band surgery on our public funded surgeries list. Some times people reach a poing of no return for themselves, and theri weight has become so massive that lap bands and other surgeries are really the last resort. In most of these cases diabetes and hypertension are causing serious health issues, not to mention, the damage depression can do to a person if they’ have a low body image.

However, its always about intention, I suppose if you wanted a lap band so you could be a porn star or model, then you’re probably crossing a line.
 
My country is actually currently debating putting lap band surgery on our public funded surgeries list. Some times people reach a poing of no return for themselves, and theri weight has become so massive that lap bands and other surgeries are really the last resort. In most of these cases diabetes and hypertension are causing serious health issues, not to mention, the damage depression can do to a person if they’ have a low body image.

However, its always about intention, I suppose if you wanted a lap band so you could be a porn star or model, then you’re probably crossing a line.
I don’t believe in the “point of no return” myself. I’ve seen stories of people who weighed more than 650 pounds and lost 400 pounds in two years time, simply by calorie restriction, willpower, Grace, and then eventually exercise.

But whether you get the lap band or not, you may require surgery. I’ve lost about 120 pounds this year myself…I and I have 60 more to go, and right now my worry is the remaining loose skin that is going to require surgery to tighten up (after a the age of 20 your skin won’t “snap back” when the weight comes of). So even if you don’t need elective surgery to get the weight off, you might end up needing it just to look normal and avoid some kinds of infections down the road.
 
it’s not vain to drive around in a decent, late model car, but is vain to drive around in a Rolls Royce.
It may be your personal opinion that a person driving around in a Rolls Royce is vain, but that does not make it actually so. I think this was a judgemental remark.

Totally OffTopic, sorry. It just really bothered me, and I don’t even drive an expensive car.
 
I’m just curious - is it lap-band, or bypass? I ask only because I know lap-band is less dangerous (my mom is considering the options too).

Anyway, no, it’s not a sin. Our heath is very important. God has given us good Doctors to ensure our Health. Feeling good about how one looks isn’t the vanity you’re thinking of - that would be an obsession with our looks. Something that gets in the way of our relationships - especially with God.
I am honestly not sure which type of surgery my doctor will choose to do.
 
It may be your personal opinion that a person driving around in a Rolls Royce is vain, but that does not make it actually so. I think this was a judgemental remark.

Totally OffTopic, sorry. It just really bothered me, and I don’t even drive an expensive car.
Someone driving a Rolls Royce would not be vain if he or she were the humble chauffeur of a rich individual. In other circumstances, it is very hard to see it as anything other than vanity.
 
Hi everyone. Within a year or two, I will most likely be getting bariatric surgery done. Well, I am doing this for two reasons. One, because I want to be healthier and two, because I want to look better. So, I ask, would getting bariatric surgery done in my case be committing the sin of vanity?
No for heath and for the “look better” I would ask why you want to look better. Some do it to be praised by others while if your married you could be doing it to help your relationship which would be a good reason to look better. Only God and you know your reasons for this.
 
If the procedure will be life saving, then it is all good.

If this is an elective procedure, and you can afford to pay for it without harming others (for example, you still will pay your rent and gas bill…), then it would not be objectively sinful.
Most health insurance will pay for the lap band or the gastric bypass if your doctor says you need it and you can only qualify if you are 35 or over in your BMI (body mass index). I would recommend that a person seeking bariatric surgery look for a “Bariatric Surgical Center of Excellence”. In other words, you would want someone who specializes in this type of surgery.

I had lapband, my BMI was 50 when I had surgery (lap band) I have lost 55 lbs. since Sept of 2008. My friend has gastric by pass last July of 09 and has lost over 100.

Yes, lapband is safer. It is done lapriscopicly. You have 5 small holes in your belly and one of them will be the “port” where you get your “fill” to tighten the band. You cannot leave the office until you are able to drink a half glass of water easily.

I also know that Medicare will also pay for it. The insurance companies look at it this way, “we pay 15K now or 500K for quad heart bypass”. As for sagging skin with lapband, very minimal. I go to the gym and work out. Because the weight comes off slowly …the sagging skin has a bit of snap left in it. I am 52…someone who is 30 yrs younger will fare better.

You will have a change in your diet. Bread of any kind will be impossible to eat…donuts, anything heavy cake like will “pack” up inside your new pouch and back up your esophagus. Trust me, you will know when you are full and you will stop eating. Forget soda or anything carbonated…rice is also a “packer”. There are things I do miss eating…but I sure don’t miss that 55 lbs. My knees don’t hurt, I can get down on the floor and get up again without 10 men and boy helping me up. I breathe better. My clothes are falling off and loose. It is a good feeling. I am not tired, and winded, and blah.

I will note: some insurance companies will not go with lapband if your BMI is over 53. In that case, if you want it, you will have to go on the Adkins Diet to get the BMI down and they will pay for it. Otherwise they will only approve gastric bypass.

There are many steps you have to go through first. You have to have your primary care doctor sign off on it. You then have to have blood tests, ultrasound of your belly area, a psych visit, a chest xray, obgyn visit, and a test where they stick a tube down your throat (I forgot the name of the test). If you have a hernia and it is “inoperable”, a good bariatric surgeon will not do a lapband, they will suggest gastric bypass.

Lapband is reversible. Gastric bypass is not. Either surgery you will have to take bariatric vitamins for the rest of your life. No big deal they taste like sweet tarts.

Either surgery is a “tool” for use in weight loss. If you don’t follow the guidelines and “stuff” yourself, it will not work. It takes me close to a full hour to eat. Also, you get a card from your doctor to present to restaurants that you had bariatric surgery and need to eat off the “child’s menu”. Alot of restaurants are very understanding and will comply.

You don’t have life a fat life anymore. It is not vanity. It is life saving when all other methods have failed. I still can eat a cheeseburger only I ask for it with no bun. I eat “flat” crust pizza and can only eat one slice.

Holly, if this is what you want to do…go to your primary care doctor and ask him for a referral.👍
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top