Would This Be Communion 3 Times In One Day? - I Think So

  • Thread starter Thread starter Marchmain1987
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Marchmain1987

Guest
I will be received into the Church this Saturday during the Easter Vigil.

:heaven:

My question is:

If I attend the Easter Sunday Mass (9am) at my local parish and receive communion, can I also attend the Extraordinary Form at 1 pm that afternoon and also receive communion?

I do not think I can because the Easter Vigil Mass fulfills Sunday obligation.

Am I wrong?

Help! 🙂
 
I will be received into the Church this Saturday during the Easter Vigil.

:heaven:

My question is:

If I attend the Easter Sunday Mass (9am) at my local parish and receive communion, can I also attend the Extraordinary Form at 1 pm that afternoon and also receive communion?

I do not think I can because the Easter Vigil Mass fulfills Sunday obligation.

Am I wrong?

Help! 🙂
If your Easter Vigil Mass has the distribution of communion prior to midnight on Saturday, then yes you may receive twice on Sunday.

Yes, the Easter Vigil fufills the Sunday obligation. However, that is not the same thing as the canons regarding reception of the Eucharist. That is referring to actual 24 hour days, midnight to midnight.

So, Easter Vigil and two Sunday Masses do not equate to receiving three times in one day.
 
If your Easter Vigil Mass has the distribution of communion prior to midnight on Saturday, then yes you may receive twice on Sunday.

Yes, the Easter Vigil fufills the Sunday obligation. However, that is not the same thing as the canons regarding reception of the Eucharist. That is referring to actual 24 hour days, midnight to midnight.

So, Easter Vigil and two Sunday Masses do not equate to receiving three times in one day.
THANKS

😃

Happy, Happy, Joy, Joy - :yyeess:
I drive two hours for the Extraordinary Form.
I would have hated to attended again (this time in full communion) and not receive Our Lord.
 
THANKS

😃

Happy, Happy, Joy, Joy - :yyeess:
I drive two hours for the Extraordinary Form.
I would have hated to attended again (this time in full communion) and not receive Our Lord.
[SIGN]Welcome Home![/SIGN]

:extrahappy::bowdown2:
 
Welcome HOME!!!

I’ve been Home for four months now and it’s pretty AMAZING!

I can’t wait to see everyone on Saturday night!
 
The rule has to do with the types of liturgies you attend. You shouldn’t receive at consecutive masses on a given Sunday if the masses are all the same. In your case, the Vigil is a special night, Easter morning has different readings and the EF is very different. So you are fine.
 
The rule has to do with the types of liturgies you attend. You shouldn’t receive at consecutive masses on a given Sunday if the masses are all the same. In your case, the Vigil is a special night, Easter morning has different readings and the EF is very different. So you are fine.
No, the “types of liturgies” has nothing to do with it. We can receive twice in one day (24 hour period) as long as the second time is at a Mass. You can go to two Masses that are exactly the same, back to back, and receive Communion at both. The readings and form of the Mass do not matter.
 
IMO, it is a bit much to receive more than once in one day, unless you have a special reason. Like a devotion to daily mass every morning and a wedding in the afternoon.
 
Since this post is up here anyway, I will throw out my question. On Saturday morning I will attend a funeral at 10 am. ( I didn’t think you could have a funeral in the Triduum.) Not a Mass, but Communion is to be distributed. I also plan to attend the Easter Vigil Mass in the evening, at 9pm. Can I receive Communion twice in this situation? I hope someone answers soon!
 
The rule has to do with the types of liturgies you attend. You shouldn’t receive at consecutive masses on a given Sunday if the masses are all the same. In your case, the Vigil is a special night, Easter morning has different readings and the EF is very different. So you are fine.
Anna Claire, I am not sure where you got this idea, but it is not correct.
 
Since this post is up here anyway, I will throw out my question. On Saturday morning I will attend a funeral at 10 am. ( I didn’t think you could have a funeral in the Triduum.) Not a Mass, but Communion is to be distributed. I also plan to attend the Easter Vigil Mass in the evening, at 9pm. Can I receive Communion twice in this situation? I hope someone answers soon!
Yes. The second reception must be at Mass. What you describe seems to be fine.

Can.* 917 A person who has already received the Most Holy Eucharist can receive it a second time on the same day only within the eucharistic celebration in which the person participates, without prejudice to the prescript of ⇒ can. 921, §2.
 
Anna Claire, I am not sure where you got this idea, but it is not correct.
I stand by what I said.
Reception of communion once a day is enough. It’s not suppose to be a personal devotion in which we acquire more grace if we receive more than once. That would be a grave misunderstanding of the Eucharist. Once we participate in one Eucharistic celebration we are given instructions to go out and spread the gospel. We can share in communion again only if we participate in a special circumstance such as a wedding mass,a first communion etc…not for our own personal reasons of devotion.
 
I stand by what I said.
Reception of communion once a day is enough. It’s not suppose to be a personal devotion in which we acquire more grace if we receive more than once. That would be a grave misunderstanding of the Eucharist. Once we participate in one Eucharistic celebration we are given instructions to go out and spread the gospel. We can share in communion again only if we participate in a special circumstance such as a wedding mass,a first communion etc…not for our own personal reasons of devotion.
You are incorrect. You are placing your personal opinion above that of the Church. The Church requires no such thing.
 
You are incorrect. You are placing your personal opinion above that of the Church. The Church requires no such thing.
Holy Communion More Than Once a Day: A person who has already received the Eucharist may receive it (only) once again on the same day only during a Eucharistic celebration in which the person participates. A person in danger of death who has already received the Eucharist once or twice is urged to receive Communion again as Viaticum. Pope John Paul approved this decision, in accord with Canon 917, and ordered it published July 11, 1984.

**Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments

**A MORE EXTENSIVE FACULTY TO RECEIVE COMMUNION TWICE IN ONE DAY

The discipline now in force permits the faithful to receive communion a second time on the same day:
  • on Saturday evening or the evening before a holyday of obligation, when they are fulfilling the obligation to assist at Mass, even if they have received communion that morning;3
  • at the second Mass of Easter Sunday and in one of the day Masses on Christmas, even if they have received communion at the Mass of the Easter Vigil or at the Mass at Midnight on Christmas;4
  • also at the evening Mass on Holy Thursday, even if they have also received communion at the chrism Mass.5
Over and above those listed, there are other situations of the same type that favor a second communion. The reasons for granting a new faculty therefore must here be set out in detail.

Like a provident mother, the Church has established from centuries-old practice and has received into its canon law a norm according to which it is lawful for the faithful to receive communion only once a day. That norm remains unchanged and is not to be disregarded simply for reasons of devotion. Any ill-advised desire to repeat communion must be countered by the truth that the more devoutly a person approaches the holy table the greater the power of that sacrament which feeds, strengthens, and expresses faith, charity, and the rest of the virtues.6 For the faithful are to go forth from the liturgical celebration to do works of charity, religion, and the apostolate “so that what they have received by faith and sacrament in the celebration of the eucharist they will hold to by the way they live.”7

There may however be special circumstances in which the faithful who have already received communion on the same day or in which priests who have celebrated Mass attend some community’s celebration. It will be lawful for these faithful and these priests to receive communion a second time in the following situations:
  1. at ritual Masses in which the sacraments of baptism, confirmation, anointing of the sick, orders, and marriage are administered, as well as at Masses in which there is a first communion;8
  2. at Masses for the consecration of a church or an altar, for a religious profession, for the conferral of a “canonical mission”;
  3. at the Masses for the dead on the occasion of the funeral, news of the death, the final burial, or the first anniversary;
  4. at the principal Mass celebrated in a cathedral or parish church on the solemnity of Corpus Christi and on the day of a pastoral visitation; at a Mass celebrated on the occasion of a major religious superior’s canonical visitation to a particular religious house or chapter;
  5. at the principal Mass at a eucharistic or Marian congress, whether international or national, regional or diocesan;
  6. at the principal Mass of any kind of meeting, pilgrimage, or people’s mission;
7 at the administration of viaticum, when communion may be given to the members of the household and the friends of the sick person who are present.
  1. Over and above the cases already mentioned, the local Ordinary is allowed to grant for a single occasion the faculty to receive communion twice on the same day whenever, because of truly special circumstances. a second reception is warranted on the basis of this Instruction.
 
Since this post is up here anyway, I will throw out my question. On Saturday morning I will attend a funeral at 10 am. ( I didn’t think you could have a funeral in the Triduum.) Not a Mass, but Communion is to be distributed. I also plan to attend the Easter Vigil Mass in the evening, at 9pm. Can I receive Communion twice in this situation? I hope someone answers soon!
Under normal circumstances, yes, that would be fine: you can receive Communion at a non-Mass distribution and then at a Mass, but not at a Mass and then at a non-Mass distribution.

In your case, I hesitate to say that it is completely fine, since on Holy Saturday, “Holy Communion may only be given in the form of Viaticum” (Paschales Solemnitatis no. 75; see also Roman Missal; cf. CIC, Can. 931). The priest, therefore, is wrong to distribute Communion at this funeral in the first place.
 
Under normal circumstances, yes, that would be fine: you can receive Communion at a non-Mass distribution and then at a Mass, but not at a Mass and then at a non-Mass distribution.

In your case, I hesitate to say that it is completely fine, since on Holy Saturday, “Holy Communion may only be given in the form of Viaticum” (Paschales Solemnitatis no. 75; see also Roman Missal; cf. CIC, Can. 931). The priest, therefore, is wrong to distribute Communion at this funeral in the first place.
Thank you all who replied. After this comment, I am thinking I should not be taking Communion. The funeral is in a parish in a neighboring diocese. Our Deacon told me no funerals are allowed during the Triduum, so perhaps this whole thing is off; I am very confused. It is a very sudden death of one of my family members. This whole thing is awful and I just want to do the right thing. At the Easter Vigil I will have the joy of seeing my husband come into the Church, so the day is very much opposite in the two events. I will gladly omit the first Communion if that is the right thing to do and concentrate on the joy later at the Vigil.
 
If your Easter Vigil Mass has the distribution of communion prior to midnight on Saturday, then yes you may receive twice on Sunday.

Yes, the Easter Vigil fufills the Sunday obligation. However, that is not the same thing as the canons regarding reception of the Eucharist. That is referring to actual 24 hour days, midnight to midnight.

So, Easter Vigil and two Sunday Masses do not equate to receiving three times in one day.
👍
 
Thank you all who replied. After this comment, I am thinking I should not be taking Communion. The funeral is in a parish in a neighboring diocese. Our Deacon told me no funerals are allowed during the Triduum, so perhaps this whole thing is off; I am very confused. It is a very sudden death of one of my family members. This whole thing is awful and I just want to do the right thing. At the Easter Vigil I will have the joy of seeing my husband come into the Church, so the day is very much opposite in the two events. I will gladly omit the first Communion if that is the right thing to do and concentrate on the joy later at the Vigil.
Oh, I’m sorry to hear it was somebody close to you. What a terrible time for this to have happened, although perhaps the timing during the holiest part of the year will serve to intensify everyone’s prayers for your relative and so some good will come of it.

As to your situation, I also didn’t say you shouldn’t receive Communion. It shouldn’t be offered, but if it is I think it would be a judgment call on your part as to whether to receive. And while funeral Masses can’t be held on Holy Saturday, I’m not aware of anything (which isn’t to say that nothing exists, however) that prohibits holding a non-Mass funeral service and interment on that day.
 
Oh, I’m sorry to hear it was somebody close to you. What a terrible time for this to have happened, although perhaps the timing during the holiest part of the year will serve to intensify everyone’s prayers for your relative and so some good will come of it.

As to your situation, I also didn’t say you shouldn’t receive Communion. It shouldn’t be offered, but if it is I think it would be a judgment call on your part as to whether to receive. And while funeral Masses can’t be held on Holy Saturday, I’m not aware of anything (which isn’t to say that nothing exists, however) that prohibits holding a non-Mass funeral service and interment on that day.
Thank you. The only thing I found last night while looking online was mentioned by the Diocese of Detroit, where it was stated that Communion was not to be offered during the funeral rite on a Holy Saturday. I did learn that funerals can be done, but never a Mass. I guess when the moment comes, I will try to make a judgement. I appreciated all (name removed by moderator)ut. How wonderful to have this forum to share information on. Thanks to all.
 
Holy Communion More Than Once a Day: A person who has already received the Eucharist may receive it (only) once again on the same day only during a Eucharistic celebration in which the person participates. A person in danger of death who has already received the Eucharist once or twice is urged to receive Communion again as Viaticum. Pope John Paul approved this decision, in accord with Canon 917, and ordered it published July 11, 1984.

**Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments

**A MORE EXTENSIVE FACULTY TO RECEIVE COMMUNION TWICE IN ONE DAY
Wait, you are mixing up two very different documents!

“A More Extensive Faculty…” is part of the January 1973 document “IMMENSAE CARITATIS — On Facilitating Reception Of Communion In Certain Circumstances”. This is the document that first gave permission for EMHCs and extended the occasions under which the laity could receive twice in one day. This was promulgated during the Pontificate of Paul VI, under the 1917 Code of Canon Law which had originally forbid reception of Communion twice in one day.

The 1984 document is a response to a dubium about Canon 917 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law. The 1983 Code places no restrictions on a second reception other than it must be during Mass, or as Viaticum if outside of Mass.

The way the canon is worded is that the faithful may receive “again” and the dubium was to whether that meant they could receive as many times as they wanted as long as it was during Mass or whether ‘again’ had a more limited meaning. The response to the dubium was that they could receive a second time, not an unlimited number of times.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top