would this be immoral?

  • Thread starter Thread starter angell1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

angell1

Guest
my parish wants to do a dinner fundraiser for world youth day. they want to also have a 50/50 but no one in the group seems to want to get a license because it’s too much hassle, including the priest.

I guess this would be a sin since we’re breaking the law?
 
We do this all the time in the military…but we technically can’t gamble while on duty.

We don’t call it a 50/50 or a raffle.

We just call it a charitable donation that includes a “thank-you” for giving.

I’m the one that usually conducts this donation and I don’t think I’ve ever had an instance where anyone has accepted the prize. We all just give it back so 100% goes to the charity.
 
Canada has laws against a simple 50-50?

Crazy.

yeah, you’ll all sinning. :rolleyes:

(that’s sarcasm)
 
It would seem to me that if the person donated the gift to be given randomly to ANYONE and that if you were not selling a chance to win the gift for x dollars per ticket, you may find a way to have the fundraiser, as the gentleman or lady in the military suggests…in other words, one person distributes tickets and another person follows collecting a freewill donation of any sum (or none at all); then, it seems to me, there isn’t strictly speaking a game of chance. It would be more like a family shower game or some sort. I don’t know the laws for Canada for such affairs.

Ultimately, it seems to me the issue might perhaps be running afoul of some requirement of the civil law – which should be clearly avoided – but that does not mean a moral wrong has been committed.

According to the law, one should have a dog license but if one has not yet obtained it, one may be guilty of a civil infraction without thereby committing a moral offense. Those categories and distinctions are very important.
 
yes, we do have laws against it. you’re supposed to obtain a gambling license.
The post above mine is the best.
Are you in charge of this fundraiser?
It seems harmless enough. Maybe get a printout of what constitutes “gambling” in your province.
We can have casino nights here at our parish because no one wins cash. It’s just for chips and the fun of it. We hold one annually for a mission rip to Haiti to benefit CRS activities there.
 
my parish wants to do a dinner fundraiser for world youth day. they want to also have a 50/50 but no one in the group seems to want to get a license because it’s too much hassle, including the priest.

I guess this would be a sin since we’re breaking the law?
Sorry but I have never heard of 50/50. Could you explain what this is please.
 
Sorry but I have never heard of 50/50. Could you explain what this is please.
A 50/50 is a raffle where one person wins half of the pot, and the other half goes to the cause. They are very common fundraisers around here (usually as part of other events, like a parish festival or charity baseball game etc etc.)
 
The post above mine is the best.
Are you in charge of this fundraiser?
It seems harmless enough. Maybe get a printout of what constitutes “gambling” in your province.
We can have casino nights here at our parish because no one wins cash. It’s just for chips and the fun of it. We hold one annually for a mission rip to Haiti to benefit CRS activities there.
that’s the difference, there’s no problem if there’s no money involved. or at least if it’s a donation.

the 50/50 is considered gambling because ther’s winning of money involved.

i’ll try and convince the rest of the group to change it up slightly though, if they don’t want to deal with that
 
that’s the difference, there’s no problem if there’s no money involved. or at least if it’s a donation.

the 50/50 is considered gambling because ther’s winning of money involved.

i’ll try and convince the rest of the group to change it up slightly though, if they don’t want to deal with that
In our part of the world we call it a “donation”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top