Would you consider Pope John Paul II "reckless"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter KaneKatholic
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
K

KaneKatholic

Guest
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
 
Hahaha, seriously dude, keep off the anti-catholic ****.
If you look at it too much you start doubting things, its natural.

Read more on your own faith instead of deliberately putting it at risk.
 
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
What do you mean by “giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire?” What is “pagan attire” and how does one tell? Is a suit and tie less “pagan” than, say, a Japanese kimono or Papua New Guinean traditional clothing? By “pagan” do you actually mean not Western? To continue, no, I do not think Pope John Paul or Pope Benedict are reckless in their actions or spirituality and certainly do not contradict the Catholic faith by meeting with leaders of other faith traditions.
 
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
Our Lord considers each and every person on earth one of his children - not just Catholics. We are called to love people of all faiths and beliefs, not just those who share our belief.

The Popes (both JPII and B16) very much lived/live that example. We do not strive for a divided world - we strive for a united world as far as possible. We strive for a world which shares a desire for peace and mutual respect of each and every person. This means making an effort to get out there and put this goal into practice. Remaining in one’s own cocoon will achieve little.

Mother Theresa was another who made no distinction between people of different beliefs - she welcomed and loved children of ALL faiths equally. That is what living the Catholic faith is all about. We do not dilute our own faith and belief by showing respect and love for others… On the contrary, that is what being Catholic should be all about.

I concur with Tsuwano - what is “pagan attire”? The clothing we wear when we recieve communion is of little importance. It is what is in our hearts and minds that matters to God.

Patrick
 
Yes I think Pope John Paul’s inter-religious and ecumenical activities were reckless. However, I also think Pope John Paul II was a good pope. When I remember his pontificate, I see more good than bad.

Do not visit those websites. The authors misguided and they have an agenda.
 
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
Keep in mind that those who want to bash the Catholic Church will resort to any and all twisting possible to make the Church look bad. They will misrepresent, and tell half truths to get you to accept a different version of what really happened.

Just like those horrid sensationalist newspapers that are on a newstand as you are on the checkout at the food market.
Some people buy and read them, thinking they are true.
 
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
put aside the anti Catholic and Sedvaticantist propaganda. Pope John Paul II was great man who was truly touched by the Holy Spirit.
 
One thing I would like to ask:

How do we know that the book in the photograph was a Quran? It could have been an Arabic translation of the Gospels.

I would hate to think that Pope John Paul II kissed a copy of the Quran, but I think he may have done this to try and build better relations with Muslims around the world. After all, don’t forget that Christians are still killed in Muslim countries. Maybe John Paul kissed the Quran in an attempt to make life easier for Christians in Muslim countries?
 
Dempsey
One thing I would like to ask:
How do we know that the book in the photograph was a Quran? It could have been an Arabic translation of the Gospels.
Because the Cleric who gave him the book said it was the Quran and the Pope’s spokesman confirmed that it was, and that the Pope had kissed it out of respect toward the Cleric.

Pope John Paul II wrote that we should embrace truth’s found in non-Catholic religions and not reject them just because they are not Catholic.

Although we don’t embrace everything, there are truths in the Koran.

Jim
 
The reason why I ask this is because Im always looking at both anti-catholic and sedevacantist claims and they all point to pictures of JPG kissing qurans and standing side by side with people or leaders of other faiths,(ie the Dalai Lama, or muslim leaders or african mystic leaders)
it has even been said that he told african mystics NOT to abandon their faith because it would offend their ancestors…I dont know if this is true but there seems to be a disconnect between the catholic view and the world view of JPG
there are so many pictures of both popes JPG and B16
giving communion to people dressed in pagan attire,
it feels as if Im getting mixed messages and it confuses me greatly any help
No I do not think he was reckless. If anything I think he was a great leader in establishing dialogue with those of other faiths, and it is only through dialogue that we can foster respect and peace and maybe begin to heal some of the fractions within our own Catholic faith to bring others back into the fold. I think he knew exactly what he was doing and challenged people when necessary to see all people of all faiths as we all are children of God. We all deserve dignity and kindness. He kissed the quran out of respect because he very much wanted to go to Iraq.

I too would love to know what you mean by “pagan” clothes. Catholics around the world are going to look much different than you or me.
 
Would St Thomas More have kissed the Quran? Or do you think he would have preferred to get his head cut off?
 
All I know is that Pope John Paul II was a very holy pope, and he was well loved by many.

If, indeed, he did kiss a Koran, than there is something we do not understand as to why he did so. It certainly wasn’t because he was trivializing our faith, in which he was very strong in.

I do not understand why a Catholic would be willing to think the worst about Pope John Paul II.
 
All I know is that Pope John Paul II was a very holy pope, and he was well loved by many.

If, indeed, he did kiss a Koran, than there is something we do not understand as to why he did so. It certainly wasn’t because he was trivializing our faith, in which he was very strong in.

I do not understand why a Catholic would be willing to think the worst about Pope John Paul II.
I do not think the worst of the Pope, but this gesture certainly concerns me. It sent/sends the wrong message about the Muslim faith. Just because he was Pope does not mean he didn’t/couldn’t make mistakes.
 
Although we don’t embrace everything, there are truths in the Koran.
Since the Church teaches that God’s revelation ended with the death of the Apostles, the Koran is not true revelation. Why would/should we embrace anything in the Koran?
 
Since the Church teaches that God’s revelation ended with the death of the Apostles, the Koran is not true revelation. Why would/should we embrace anything in the Koran?
It by no means saying we should embrace the Qu’ran. But we should work on improving our relationships with the Muslims. In the same aspect is would also be wrong to burn the Qu’ran as what that minister awhile back was going to do. St. Francis of Assisi wanted to bring peace between Christians and Muslims and he and Brother Leo set out to talk to the Sultan. They faced excommunication with the Church, getting killed among other things. When they did meet the Sultan, they also became mytrs of the faith. Instead they worked on the relationship between the Islam Community and the Christian Community. During this expedition over time the famous prayer of St. Francis “Give me a channel of thy peace” was formed. Pope John Paul II was a very holy person and I am sure his intent was to establish peace among the Islam community and the Christian community in a similar fashion that St. Francis had done in the early 13th century.
 
I think you all misunderstand what the Pope meant by his action, it was not to accept the koran.
One critic argues that it was a blasphemous act, showing his “hatred” of God and his apostate defection from the true faith. It was none of these things. The Pope is on the record about the differences between Catholics and the followers of Islam. Let us look at the situation. The Pope has longed to go to Iraq in order to walk in the footsteps of Abraham, claimed as a father in faith by Muslims, Jews, and Christians. Pope John Paul II has seen first hand the debth of man’s inhumanity to his brothers and sisters. Our history as a world is written in blood. As illustrated in his many Mea Culpas, he strives for a new understanding between peoples where dialogue, tolerance, and cooperation will replace anathemas, persecution, and rivalry. Abraham is an integral figure of unity in turning things around politically. Looking at the incident in question, the Holy Father received a delegation that included the Shiite Imam of Khadum Mosque, the Sunni President of the council that operates the Iraqi Islamic Bank, and a member of the Iraqi Ministry of Religion. The invitation of a papal visit was renewed. They even went so far as to say that it would be “a grace from heaven”. While Iraq has been guilty of real violations of human rights, this Islamic state has been the most tolerant of Christians than any of its islamic neighbors. Many Catholics hold positions in government, commerce, education, etc. The Chaldean Patriarch of Babylon (Iraq), His Beatitude Raphael I Bidawid, who was a major spokesman for the delegation. He applauded the Pope’s actions and words as a true sign of concern from the Successor of St. Peter. (Christians represent 5% of the 20 million people in Iraq. Catholics of the large Chaldean rite [implementing the Aramaic language] and of the smaller Latin rite represent 80% of all Christians there.) It was said that a papal visit would confirm the faith of Christian believers while showing forth a genuine love for all in this mostly Muslim nation.
The Koran was a gift to him from the delegation. Islamic peoples are not casual in the giving of gifts. It represents the giver. They knew perfectly well that the Pope was a Catholic Christian, but they gave to him that which was regarded as most important in their life, their own holy book. Thus, at the end of the audience, the Pope showed his deep appreciation to this intimate self-donation, by bowing and kissing the Koran as a sign of respect. Such a gesture ran totally against the grain of crusades and condemnations. It did not mean that the Pope accepted all that was in the book, only that his love for the Muslim people, and the Iraqis in particular, was genuine. He makes the first move, not in the capitulation of our faith, but in the recognition that the followers of Jesus and those who cherish Mohammed should not be engaged in name-calling, or worse, killing each other. The Pope appreciated the suffering of the Iraqi people, particularly the women and children. It showed he did not look down upon them but had a genuine respect for them within the brotherhood of man.
Quoted from Fr. Joe.
 
I do not think the worst of the Pope, but this gesture certainly concerns me. It sent/sends the wrong message about the Muslim faith. Just because he was Pope does not mean he didn’t/couldn’t make mistakes.
I think it is very evident from the differing views in this thread that the message the Pope conveyed by kissing a Koran, is open to interpretation. It is what YOU personally make of it. This sounds like a rather inanely logical statement to make, but the point is, we need to be open to the fact that the Pope indeed did have an intention in mind by doing what he did. I am sure he probably knew his action would raise eyebrows amongst certain people (of all faiths).

Knowing what we do about Pope John Paul II, I think we should not see it as a mistake, but should try to think carefully about what impact his actions would have on the Islamic community. To turn things around for a second, if an Islamic leader made efforts to meet with Catholics, made an effort to sit down and talk through important issues, and even go as far as to kiss a Bible, would you not consider all of that an incredibly respectful thing to do and welcome this? Certainly a lot better than refusing to meet with Catholics, or criticising us as Catholics without bothering to enter into dialogue with people of our faith.

Once again, the crux here is this - in no way should the Pope’s actions be seen as compromising or diluting the Catholic faith. Love and respect should extend across ALL boundaries. I have absolutely no doubt that this is what the Pope was exemplifying.
 
To turn things around for a second, if an Islamic leader made efforts to meet with Catholics, made an effort to sit down and talk through important issues, and even go as far as to kiss a Bible, would you not consider all of that an incredibly respectful thing to do and welcome this? Certainly a lot better than refusing to meet with Catholics, or criticising us as Catholics without bothering to enter into dialogue with people of our faith.
Actually, I would not want him to kiss the Bible. Said Islamic leader does not need to kiss our Bible to show a willingness to dialogue with and have respect for Catholics.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top