Would you date a relapsed Catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter SomeCatholicGuy
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SomeCatholicGuy

Guest
Recently I was offered the opportunity of being set up on a date with a relapsed Catholic. I turned it down, but I was wondering if I was wrong in judging someone without even having met that person. What are your thoughts regarding this matter? Thanks in advance!
 
Recently I was offered the opportunity of being set up on a date with a relapsed Catholic. I turned it down, but I was wondering if I was wrong in judging someone without even having met that person. What are your thoughts regarding this matter? Thanks in advance!
I see nothing wrong with meeting them. If there was intention for dating then at some point sooner than later, you will have to bring up that you are a practicing Catholic and all that implies for anyone you would consider getting serious with. If the person doesn’t flee for the hills at hearing that, there is hope.
 
If by a relapsed Catholic, you mean one who fell away from church teachings for a time then returned, then yes I would.

I fit that description. My last relationship was heavily sinful and was not what I should have been pursuing as a Catholic. My new relationship is based on faith. I would hope that just because I fell (and we all do) that does not make me less of a potential partner.

Also, I think once you have fallen, it can (and did for me) make you more resistant to falling again. The last thing I ever want to do again would be to use my girlfriend for purposes other than a loving relationship that leads to god.

So, I think that I would, and I think a fall can actually strengthen you in the future if you react correctly…
 
Do you mean a “lapsed” Catholic? If so, why not. You may bring him back to the faith.
 
You aren’t judging them as a person, you’re just judging them as someone you don’t want to date. You’ve probably made that judgement hundreds of times without ever feeling guilty about it (unless you attempt to date every girl you meet). This person may be just lovely, but why get into a situation when you know you have a big obstacle in your way? It’s not like you know this person and believe she may be the one, but dang it she’s not Catholic. You have no connection to her at all. Better off leaving it that way.
 
You aren’t judging them as a person, you’re just judging them as someone you don’t want to date. You’ve probably made that judgement hundreds of times without ever feeling guilty about it (unless you attempt to date every girl you meet). This person may be just lovely, but why get into a situation when you know you have a big obstacle in your way? It’s not like you know this person and believe she may be the one, but dang it she’s not Catholic. You have no connection to her at all. Better off leaving it that way.
YES. Too much complication, why would you go for that?
 
OHHHHH, just lapsed…

I’m always up for some evangi-dating

just kidding, but seriously…
 
Depends on how lapsed. If it is just a matter of not going to Mass every week and HDO, and she knows she should and needs encouragement, then OK, but I won’t be thinking about rings until she has a “proven track record”. In fact, the last lady I dated was just in this predicament. However, if she disagrees with the Church to such a point that she would be an “occasion of sin”, as the old Baltimore Catechism would say, and/or likes immoral lifestyles, and/or does not care about the Catholic faith at all, then no way; I don’t have the energy to convert a wild pagan.

Additionally, the Bible warns of not being unequally yoked with a non-believer. I’m lonely, but I’m not THAT desparate (yet).
 
No. I want someone fervent in their faith, or I’d rather live out my life with just my dogs. I don’t compromise well. 😃
 
Be their friend. They need one.

Not their boyfriend/girlfriend.

Too many issues. By a certain age, someone needs to have a mature relationship with God before they can have mature relationships with the people around them. Once when I was young and stupid I didn’t know this. I got it backwards. I thought I could help someone’s relationship with God. It was a miserable failure and now my children’s relationships with God are at stake.
 
I would go on a date. It’s just one date – there’s nothing that says that you have to go out again. I would at least find out what their views are now towards the Church and their beliefs. You might make a friend – who can have too many friends – or you might find someone that’s just looking for that push to return. That’s what happened to me except it was the birth of my niece and not a boyfriend.

I would not write off just meeting someone because they’re a lapsed Catholic. If you get to know them and realize that your views are too different, then don’t continue dating them.

Again, it’s just ONE meeting.
 
Recently I was offered the opportunity of being set up on a date with a relapsed Catholic. I turned it down, but I was wondering if I was wrong in judging someone without even having met that person. What are your thoughts regarding this matter? Thanks in advance!
Well as I don’t have any offers lately and the guys I know that are interested aren’t catholic so I wouldn’t date them anyway due to value issues probably not. I’m sick of wasting my time in the dating pool with people who don’t share my values. 🤷
 
I was a lapsed Catholic when I dated and got married. You could be the one that brings them back to the fold. You may want to find out what made them leave.
 
My best friend is a convert, who became Catholic when she married her Catholic husband. Another best friend is a convert, who became Catholic after she married her Catholic husband. Gee, I’m glad the amazing husbands of these 2 amazing women didn’t write them off!!

Oh wait, I remember another one, from my prayer group. She dated her husband once or twice, he told her how important his Catholic faith was to him, she was no religion at all, and he took her to mass. In one mass, she just knew she had to become Catholic.

Catholics bring non-Catholics to the faith all the time!! I am sure it works for lapsed Catholics too…

Whoever said it, I like the expression “evangi-dating!” 🙂 👍
 
I’m still not completely sure what you mean by “lapsed”. Each of us could have a different interpretation, so you may want to ask your source what they mean by lapsed. If God leads you to do so, perhaps it is something to learn from the woman herself? Depending on where she is, my post may not hold any bearing at all, but I’ll add it just the same.

My DH and I could’ve easily considered each other “lapsed” for completely different reasons. For me, it wasn’t enough that he went to mass regularly. He did not have a strong background of spending daily time praying and reading from the Bible, and I’d even heard him say that he often skipped out on his singles Bible study to go drink margarittas (with the other half of the class who was skipping out). I probably would’ve completely rejected him based on this information. At this same time, I was not attending mass regularly. It was for a very personal and private reason (something happened at my local parish), and I had been praying for courage to try another parish - even though it was very scary for me to try a new place on my own.

But as God ordained it, DH and I ended up working at the same place, and we did not even consider each other as potential partners in any way for many months. But after a few months, I suddenly realized one day that I’d never spent so much time around a man who so reflected Jesus Christ day-in and day-out, and in many different situations with every kind of person we dealt with. Of course, there were many other things to consider and learn about each other along the way, and that is what the “dating & praying about it” phase was for.

I suppose God moved in DH’s heart to not hold my attendance record against me, and we actually started attending a new parish together (the place where we were married, and where our first child -expected in April- will be baptized).

After 3 years of marriage, and many more life experiences together, I can still say I am amazed by the ways I see Christ reflected in my husband’s decisions and actions. He has bad days like anyone else, and he expresses his honest feelings. But he is still respectful of others and doesn’t use his emotions as an excuse to behave badly.

Only you can determine whether God is leading you to learn more about this prospective person. Perhaps you will know without ever meeting them, or perhaps you will know by the first date, or the 20th. Be open to His leading even if they seem perfect from Day 1.
 
Recently I was offered the opportunity of being set up on a date with a relapsed Catholic. I turned it down, but I was wondering if I was wrong in judging someone without even having met that person. What are your thoughts regarding this matter? Thanks in advance!
Depends. Many people who have practised have done worse things than those who’ve been away for a time and many of those away are good people with a loss of faith. There’s no need to scratch them off. There’s a need to have a valid sacramental marriage, though.
 
I was a lapsed Catholic when I dated and got married. You could be the one that brings them back to the fold. You may want to find out what made them leave.
Ok well great for you but I feel it’s a mistake getting involved with someone with the idea that they may change. It rarely happens and entering into a relationship with such a idea in my opinion is just a bad idea. It’s my belief that you should take people as they are and not as you want them to be. I know it’s not very probable that I would change very much so why should I expect that of some one else.
 
Ok well great for you but I feel it’s a mistake getting involved with someone with the idea that they may change. It rarely happens and entering into a relationship with such a idea in my opinion is just a bad idea. It’s my belief that you should take people as they are and not as you want them to be. I know it’s not very probable that I would change very much so why should I expect that of some one else.
Sierrah, while I think you have a valid point, I think it’s important to remember that this is a first date. All dating couples grow, and change naturally comes from that and that’s what you base your decision to continue a relationship or call it quits. Just to automatically decline an offer for a first date based on almost no information is a little drastic. It could turn out to be a better relationship than you could have imagined. You don’t know until you get to know someone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top