Would you give up your career for her?

  • Thread starter Thread starter AllSeasons
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A

AllSeasons

Guest
That’s right - for her. I suppose women traditionally have been “expected” for do that for men, when they get married and have children, though nowadays that’s changing. However, this is not the question I’m asking here. The question I’m asking is: If you’re a man and have a successful career, if needed, would you give up that career or take a big step back in that career, to be with the woman you love?
 
How many wives would want a successful man to give up his career? Usually, they are too busy spending his money!:😉
 
How many wives would want a successful man to give up his career? Usually, they are too busy spending his money!:😉
hilarious,

and hilarious this topic is brought up, i would love nothing more in life than to be a stay at home dad, an build a tree fort , an teach kids how to do all kinds of things, plus i rock at cooking, but i am being called at the moment down another path in life, seems marrage was not in the deck for me, * shrugs * …

Tired of working for people an corporations that could careless about the employees as long as their numbers or quotas for the financial year are where they need to be an they make sure they get their big bonus…

i would honestly prefer my own plot of land to farm, out in the middle of no where and be left alone with my own family. Be self sufficient , but as much as it would be great to be married an have kids, dealing with their own gut wrenching problems that would arrise i have no clue how i would handle it, and i don’t know if i could be strong or mature enough to do the morally right thing if anything bad happened to this hypothetical family.Plus think about this, being a stay at home dad, or at home husband, plenty of time to do awesome stuff, bowling, learn how to shoot, i mean the sky is the limit. Working is for the birds and really just burns time off of doing stuff that ya really wana do.

plus there is more things in life that are important than a " career " wilderness skills, gota be able to build a shelter, fight off grizzly bears and zombies, kill spiders, unclog pipes… drive cars all of that is probably way more important than an actual career.
 
Depends on what premises, generally because being faced with an unreasonable demand changes a lot of things, as does the availability of an alternative choice that e.g. brings slightly less benefit at a significantly lower cost. This is what I’m not giving an unconditional yes.
 
How many wives would want a successful man to give up his career? Usually, they are too busy spending his money!:😉
What a pathetic and offensive comment, don’t you think? You know, for a married couple the money is not his, it is theirs.
 
What a pathetic and offensive comment, don’t you think? You know, for a married couple the money is not his, it is theirs.
And often times when the woman earns more its “hers.” Guys share but women don’t. Time Magazine did an article on this and reported that when the man is the breadwinner the spending decisions are split 50/50. When the woman is breadwinner she makes >90% of the decisions.

time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2109140-7,00.html
 
Lots of men have given up advances in their career or changed careers for the sake of their family. This isn’t unusual at all. My grandfather could have been a wealthy man if he was willing to move to Atlanta or New York for his career. He didn’t want to take his children away from their extended family, their school, and their home.
 
…Plus think about this, being a stay at home dad, or at home husband, plenty of time to do awesome stuff, bowling, learn how to shoot, i mean the sky is the limit. Working is for the birds and really just burns time off of doing stuff that ya really wana do.
My mom still remembers how my dad first talked about staying at home with me and my brother (they reversed roles when I was little) and how it was going to be wonderful, he would finally be able to write that novel and have so much free time… yeah, didn’t happen.

👍
 
Maybe. 😃

As in, only if there was a genuinely legitimate reason, or if the career in question was incompatible with a happy marriage.

Why not make this a poll? 🙂
 
…plus there is more things in life that are important than a " career " wilderness skills, gota be able to build a shelter, fight off grizzly bears and zombies, kill spiders, unclog pipes… drive cars all of that is probably way more important than an actual career.
not many things, no, if you take your obligations as a husband and father seriously. a job is what pays for the roof, food, insurance, transportation, school. that is what God promised is our fate in life as men because of our fallen nature: * In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground*. if you attend your duty rather than seek instant gratification playing farmer in the dell, you’ll successfully raise a family and set an example for your kids. then, you can enjoy the toys.

F/
 
Believe it or not a woman can provide for her family too.

I’m a stay at home mom now…but my husband has already signed over his GI bill to me…because he knows that, out of the two of us, I’m the one that would most likely finish my Bachelor’s degree.

If and when I get the chance to finish and find a good job…I’m certain my husband would be more then happy to stay home.
He doesn’t enjoy working too much anyway.

Until this time comes he will bear his cross and work a job he doesn’t like because it provides us with a roof over the head, food on the table, and a solid working class lifestyle.

He’s worked very hard for us and will continue to do so…but secretly he would give it all up to stay at home with the kids.
 
I didn’t give up a career, but I did give up a job I loved, in a geographical area that I loved, not to mention many friends and professional colleagues, and moved 500 miles for her. I was offered a better position in my new locale 2 days after I moved here, so I can’t say I took a step downward, career-wise.
 
not many things, no, if you take your obligations as a husband and father seriously. a job is what pays for the roof, food, insurance, transportation, school. that is what God promised is our fate in life as men because of our fallen nature: * In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground*. if you attend your duty rather than seek instant gratification playing farmer in the dell, you’ll successfully raise a family and set an example for your kids. then, you can enjoy the toys.

F/
nope your wrong, all that matters is having a good time and preparing for the zombie apocalypse, plus ya can live in the woods, with nothing but a brain and a sharp stick and hunt, or buy some tools, and a tent if ya want to be fancy, or buy some really good tools, an build a log cabin an live in the woods on your own, so now money is worthless an when the economy goes kaput for good an zombies are abundant and money is worthless, good luck trying to learn how to survive in the woods at that point in time.
 
More often than not, the husband makes more money in his job/career, and so it would be impractical and even foolhardy for him to give up the job/career for the wife.

I think that in most marriages, the wise thing to do is allow the spouse (husband OR wife), who is bringing home the biggest paycheck to continue to work/follow career, and allow the spouse with the smaller paycheck to “give up” that job/career if there are compelling reasons (e.g., a move, child care, a family illness, a military assignment, a mission field, etc.).

Of course, every case must be considered individually. E.g., a Protestant pastor will be assigned to different churches during his lifetime (depending on the denomination). This means packing up and moving, sometimes on very little notice. A woman who marries a Protestant pastor must recognize this and be willing to do this for her husband; otherwise, she shouldn’t marry him. A woman who has a career that will not allow her to move or give up that career should think very carefully about any decision to marry.

Also, we need to differentiate between a “job” and a “career.” I think many men and women would gladly, joyously, giddily, with bells on their toes, give up a “job.” I know I sure would! Yippee ki yi ay! And I would dance and sing as I ran out the door! (And I don’t even know how to dance, and I can’t run because of my feet!)

But a career–that implies something that someone has aspired to since childhood and has prepared for, studied for, and sacrificed for. Christians might even say that they are “called” to their career, especially if that career is a “service” career like health care or teaching. To “give up a career” is not a decision that is easily made, because a whole new “calling” must trump the old calling.
 
One more thing–in a marriage, each spouse should be willing to give up anything and everything for the other. The vocation is to the marriage, not the career. You can’t say, “I will NOT give this up for you, even if it ends or seriously hurts our marriage” when you are married.

But if a man and a woman haven’t married yet, and the issue of “Who will give up their career?” comes up, then I would say that if they aren’t willing to give up careers for each other, they should seriously consider not marrying, but just remain friends.
 
And often times when the woman earns more its “hers.” Guys share but women don’t. Time Magazine did an article on this and reported that when the man is the breadwinner the spending decisions are split 50/50. When the woman is breadwinner she makes >90% of the decisions.

time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,2109140-7,00.html
UGH, I don’t even want to read that. Being the breadwinner after my husband lost his job last year has been the roughest time of my life… and I’m hardly a control freak. I have no desire to make financial decisions for the family.:o
I didn’t give up a career, but I did give up a job I loved, in a geographical area that I loved, not to mention many friends and professional colleagues, and moved 500 miles for her. I was offered a better position in my new locale 2 days after I moved here, so I can’t say I took a step downward, career-wise.
Honestly, I think this ends up being the most reasonable answer. Many men would “enjoy” working in one area, but often get “stuck” working in another, which may have better income potential, better job security, etc, etc. I would think the sacrifice often comes in “joy” rather than “income” because men tend to want to work hard to provide for the family’s security.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top