Would you marry a non-catholic?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Montie_Claunch
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I can’t imagine marrying a non-Catholic, or even dating one. I find it hard to relate to and indeed trust people who don’t have the same basic principles, beliefs, and world-view. Plus I just love the devotion some young Catholic men have to the Faith :love: It’s very admirable and thrills me to see it.
 
40.png
Breton:
True, the ends do not justify the means. But neither is the end assured by the beginning. Best laid plans and all that…

I married a non-Catholic, she converted, we have two beautiful children that are Catholic. Where would I be if I had found someone else - a Catholic - to marry? Don’t know.

Did I choose her for my wife? Absolutely.

Did God choose her for my wife? Absolutely.
Firstly, this sounds a bit soppy dont you think? (-:

You make it sound like it was providential. Did you think that God had chosen her from when you first started dating? Or was it more of a case of you had known her for ages because of some reason other than just her being your friend (eg, worked together or something)… that would make your marriage being ‘providential’ a bit more believeable, as you would have known her without having a ‘relationship’ (ie, her being your girlfriend) for a long time.

I’ve got no idea how God would ‘choose’ a non-Catholic wife for me, because I’m always careful about not getting too close to any of them (non-Catholic girls). Still, I guess if He can turn water into wine…
 
I guess I’m coming a bit late to this thread but I broke off a relationship with a woman who Ioved very much as was seriously seeing for a number of years precisely because she wasn’t Catholic.

It hit me when she asked me to attend her church and I asked her to attend mine. During the Eucharistic Prayer, she didn’t bother to knee and decided to sit because she “didn’t believe in that stuff”. That’s when I knew that marriage wouldn’t work out.

Recall that Jesus said that anyone who places Mother, Father, Sister, Brother, etc., before me, is not worthy of me. To help us remember this, recall that in the dictionary, ‘Faith’ comes before ‘Family’ and ‘Family’ comes before ‘Friends’.
 
My husband had been raised Episcopal. We married in 1996. He agreed that our children would be raised Catholic. I kept praying that he would decide to become Catholic. In 2002, I was Confirmed (even though I was raised Catholic) and our son received his First Communion. (BTW: The main reason I didn’t want to be confirmed when I was a teenager was because I was told by my CCD teacher that I would be required to marry a Catholic. That’s a heavy statement to tell a 14 year old.) In the fall of that 2002, my husand decided to go to RCIA classes and was Confirmed the following Easter Vigil, then we had our marriaged blessed in June of that year. I have no regrets about the way things have worked out nor the process in getting there.

Maggie
 
I did marry a non-catholic, Carrie and I will celebrate 20 years next June. She joined the church about 5 years after we were married. When we were getting serious, her mother asked her if she was sure she wanted to marry a catholic as we have large families. Carrie is no.6 of 8 kids. I’m 3 of 4. Go figure. 😛
 
40.png
Flopfoot:
Firstly, this sounds a bit soppy dont you think? (-:

You make it sound like it was providential. Did you think that God had chosen her from when you first started dating? Or was it more of a case of you had known her for ages because of some reason other than just her being your friend (eg, worked together or something)… that would make your marriage being ‘providential’ a bit more believeable, as you would have known her without having a ‘relationship’ (ie, her being your girlfriend) for a long time.

I’ve got no idea how God would ‘choose’ a non-Catholic wife for me, because I’m always careful about not getting too close to any of them (non-Catholic girls). Still, I guess if He can turn water into wine…
I don’t have a Crocodile Dundee dictionary so I can’t be real certain what “soppy” means but I get your drift.

As to the combination of forces that brought my non-Catholic wife and I together – free will and providence – you’re welcome to prove otherwise.

Here is word I know will appear in your dictionary: arrogant. Look it up.
 
40.png
aurora77:
I did marry a non-Catholic. When God shoves the right man my direction, who am I to say no? Of course, my husband is completely supportive of my faith and plans to raise our kids Catholic. I don’t know that I would marry a man that was a serious practitioner of another faith, even another Christian denomination.
I can certainly appreciate “When God shoves the right man my direction, who am I to say no?” 👍

I think it is wonderful that there are so many non-Catholics (along with subsequent children) that have been brought to the Church through marriage.

I also think it is admirable and don’t fault anyone that wants to limit their potential marriage-relationships to Catholics though and wish you all happiness.

But let’s not make the false assumption that those of us that married non-Catholics did not properly discern what we were doing; that we just rushed into our marriage with this non-Catholic person without regard to the importance of our faith.

God works for good in all things.
 
40.png
Breton:
I can certainly appreciate “When God shoves the right man my direction, who am I to say no?” 👍

I think it is wonderful that there are so many non-Catholics (along with subsequent children) that have been brought to the Church through marriage.

I also think it is admirable and don’t fault anyone that wants to limit their potential marriage-relationships to Catholics though and wish you all happiness.

But let’s not make the false assumption that those of us that married non-Catholics did not properly discern what we were doing; that we just rushed into our marriage with this non-Catholic person without regard to the importance of our faith.

God works for good in all things.
Breton, I totally agree with you. Especially when you said that God chose your wife for you. Others may think it’s “soppy” but sometimes God just gives us a kick in the right direction. Maybe I’m so oblivious He has to make it really, really obvious for me. :o

I think my experience is colored by the fact that my mom isn’t Catholic. My dad is, and together they made the decision to raise us Catholic; she made sure we went to Mass every week and greatly influenced the way I live my life now.

If someone wants only to marry a fellow Catholic, that’s a great thing; that doesn’t mean it’s the only option available or that it’s the only correct option.
 
40.png
Flopfoot:
You make it sound like it was providential. Did you think that God had chosen her from when you first started dating? Or was it more of a case of you had known her for ages because of some reason other than just her being your friend (eg, worked together or something)… that would make your marriage being ‘providential’ a bit more believeable, as you would have known her without having a ‘relationship’ (ie, her being your girlfriend) for a long time.
I can’t answer for Breton, but I can speak for myself. My husband and I worked together, but had no contact with each other until we got set up. We each knew of the other, but had never spoken, not once, until someone put us together. We had no pre-existing relationship of any kind. Yet, I knew two weeks after our first date that we were going to get married. I mean absolutely, no questions asked that he was “the one.” If you are meant to be married, Flopfoot, I hope it happens this way. It’s amazing. There I was, 24, thinking I’d probably just end up single (not feeling sorry for myself, but I wasn’t dating much) then, BAM! There he was. As someone, I can’t remember who, said “God works in mysterious ways, His wonders to perform.”
 
Montie Claunch:
Would you marry a non-catholic? Why or Why not?
I married a Catholic and she and I divorced 8 1/2 years later, with one child. It has been 7 years and I have dated non-Cahtolics because Catholics are hard to find in Oklahoma.

Currently, my girlfriend is an atheist. She has gone to Mass with me (including this past Sunday) and my 8 1/2 year old son grilled her afterwards why she is not Cahtolic and why she does not worship God. I pray she will convert, but am not optimistic.

I may stay single rather than take a risk with a woman again.
 
I am married to a non-Catholic… if I had been practicing my faith, I probably wouldn’t have married him. To be honest though… who knows what God has in store for him. He’s not baptised so it can get interesting sometimes around here. All three of our children are Catholic as that is a non-negotiable issue. We do follow alot of Catholic tradition in our house so he’s more Catholic than he thinks. I believe he just doesn’t want a “label” that his anti-Catholic family can latch onto and shake unmercifully like a rabid dog (much like they do to me during Christmas and the birth of any baby because I have the baby baptised)

I don’t regret my marriage to him, but I can attest to the fact that I’m very envious of the families that can pray together, go to Mass together, celebrate the sacraments like a family (my husand always feels like the odd man out at the baptisms). I carry the cross of being the spiritual guide in the family and there are days where I really wish he would at least share the burden if not take it. But I will carry it until he can figure out his heart and I will continue to pray for his “conversion.” (I put it in quotes because he’s got nothing to “convert” from… does that make sense?)
 
40.png
Breton:
I don’t have a Crocodile Dundee dictionary so I can’t be real certain what “soppy” means but I get your drift.

As to the combination of forces that brought my non-Catholic wife and I together – free will and providence – you’re welcome to prove otherwise.

Here is word I know will appear in your dictionary: arrogant. Look it up.
Not quite sure what it means, but I get the drift.

Wasn’t trying to be offensive to you btw, sorry you took it that way.

Aurora77, I don’t understand what you are on about (2 weeks after our first date we knew we were going to get married).
Is it possibly me, and not everyone else, who knows nothing about relationships? Maybe it is, I think I’ll stop posting in this thread now. )-:
 
Hmm… can’t seem to find the edit function. I don’t even know why I put the above post in for.

All I know is that there are dozens of threads in Family Life (which is where this one should prolly go too) and in Spirituality and even Apologetics of people who got into a relationship with someone who wasn’t Catholic (they thought it was a good idea at the time) and it brought them no end of problems. Maybe it’s just luck that some of you here have not had any serious problems because of your relationship with a non-Catholic, even though some reckon it was providence and discernment more than luck. I guess you know better than I do. Anyway, what do you care what it was now, you’ve got your spouse and not problems. God Bless. Some people aren’t so fortunate.

But when I’m giving advice to young Catholics I’ll give them the same advice my dad gave me - don’t even date someone who is not Catholic.
 
I would.
Differences in beliefs/religious beliefs don’t bother me much, as long as they’re not sick/twisted (as in sacrificing an animal, etc) or seem completely off-the-wall and fake (though a lot of people would argue that a lot of religions are fake, I read somewhere that Jedi is actually a religion).

A relationship shouldn’t revolve around religion anyway. I mean, you could find your match and he/she could be Taoist or something. 😛
 
40.png
infabilly:
I would.
Differences in beliefs/religious beliefs don’t bother me much, as long as they’re not sick/twisted (as in sacrificing an animal, etc) or seem completely off-the-wall and fake (though a lot of people would argue that a lot of religions are fake, I read somewhere that Jedi is actually a religion).

A relationship shouldn’t revolve around religion anyway. I mean, you could find your match and he/she could be Taoist or something. 😛
Amen.
 
40.png
Flopfoot:
Hmm… can’t seem to find the edit function. I don’t even know why I put the above post in for.

All I know is that there are dozens of threads in Family Life (which is where this one should prolly go too) and in Spirituality and even Apologetics of people who got into a relationship with someone who wasn’t Catholic (they thought it was a good idea at the time) and it brought them no end of problems. Maybe it’s just luck that some of you here have not had any serious problems because of your relationship with a non-Catholic, even though some reckon it was providence and discernment more than luck. I guess you know better than I do. Anyway, what do you care what it was now, you’ve got your spouse and not problems. God Bless. Some people aren’t so fortunate.

But when I’m giving advice to young Catholics I’ll give them the same advice my dad gave me - don’t even date someone who is not Catholic.
You know Flopfoot, I don’t want us to be cross with one another and I sure hope you don’t leave this thread. However, as one who married a non-Catholic, I perceive a certain arrogance in your post; a view that if you marry a non-Catholic, your marriage will end up in divorce or your just plain lucky. Your tone is dismissive of discernment and providence not to mention hard work and prayer as factors in the success of mixed marriages. I think you can answer the original question of this thread and provide justification without tearing down the other side.

For many, Jesus was (still is) unrecognizable as the Messiah. They were expecting a regal and mighty figure, not a common carpenter’s son.

I will advise my children as to the obvious benefits of marrying someone that shares their faith. However, I will temper this by advising them to trust in God and keep their hearts and minds open to the possibility of the unexpected.
 
40.png
Flopfoot:
. even though some reckon it was providence and discernment more than luck.
I think this is where you hit the nail on the head. In marriage, as in any vocation, it’s all about providence and discernment. Luck isn’t an issue. It doesn’t matter who’s getting married, whether they share the same religion or not, marriage is not something to be taken lightly. That’s why I think the marriage prep courses that the Church mandates are such a fabulous idea–they’re designed to red flag any potential problems before the wedding.

I appreciate that you can’t relate to what I say about “knowing” I’d marry my husband. All I ask is that you respect that, and I think you do. Every person has their way of getting through life. Mine’s a lot of prayer and the occasional kick in the pants by God (i.e. knowing what to do next).
 
Okok. I’ll just clarify 1 thing. Wasn’t trying to suggest that those who marry non-Catholics are lucky not to end in divorce (wasn’t being that drastic - I reckon knowing whether someone will be true to you or not is a matter of discernment not luck). But what may be more a case of luck is to not have extra problems relating to differences in religion, eg, disagreements on setting an example to children (or how to bring up children), arguments about religion (the same kind as you would have with a stranger), etc. Most difficulties in marriage, if they can’t be ‘solved’, can be simply put up with - but it just means that you might have additional problems on top of other difficulties of marriage that aren’t related to religion.
 
Everybody had interesting perspectives on this thread, it is really great that God is the divine artist and we are the canvass, painted in various colors and strokes. Where did you fit into the picture? It is more of a continuing family album. Merry Christmas to all.
 
BUMP

I married a non-Catholic. She was a non-practicing Jehovah Witness. She converted to the Catholic faith about a year afterward.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top