Wrong choice of school?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bluecake
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bluecake

Guest
I am concerned that my grandchildren are about to be enrolled in a "Christian"school - by all accounts, a very good school with strict discipline and a high academic standard - which advertises itself as being “non-denominational”.
However, when I read the information on the website, I learned that actually this school was founded by members of the Dutch Reform Church - about whom I know very little.

I worry that my grandchildren will be influenced by teachings based on a strict literal interpretation of the Bible - and furthermore that this will cause discord within the family as I will feel obliged to correct the teachings, if it is necessary to do so.

My grandchildren have all been baptised Catholic, however, apart from seeing that they presented themselves for the proper instruction at the appropriate time for First Communion etc, my daughter says she is simply "too busy"to take them to Mass.
I have tried taking them with me to the Latin Mass I attend, but it is an hours’ drive away and the children fidgeted, were bored and distracted me. I intend to try again when they are a little older and more civilised.

Should I pursue my concerns about this Christian school? - or let well enough alone? I may say that part of the reason for considering this school is that the Catholic Church has NO secondary schools in the area, and to choose one of the Catholic colleges would mean long bus trips and a 10-hour day for the children. The Christian school begins at kindergarten level and goes all the way to school leaving and university entrance.
 
Honestly…I think that if your daughter will allow it, you should take them to Mass yourself…but not necessarily to the Latin Mass since it is so far.

If it is between helping them with their faith formation, or preserving an undistracted Mass experience for yourself, I would choose the sacrifice of helping them with their faith formation. You can always go to a second Mass, undistracted, or an hour in Adoration. It only gets harder as they get older.
 
Be more concerned with your daughter than the school. I know many strong Catholic families whose children attend Christian schools. Bringing children not raised in regular mass attendance to a Latin Mass might be asking a lot of them. As much as it would bother you, find a local Mass that is family friendly. Going to a Mass that is welcoming to them will go a long way. They may even become excited about going and get mom to take them every week.

Like many similar circumstances, if you take yourself (being distracted by them) out of the equation, they will see the true love you have for them. They are very blessed to have you.

Good luck!
 
I attended a non-denominational Christian school in 9th and 10th grade. Here is a snippet of my experience:

This section, and future installments, deals with a book I was exposed to, and used, for much of my teen years and early adulthood. That book is “Bible Doctrines for Today” by Michael C. Bere , edited by Beka Horton, and published by A Beka Book Publishing out of Pensacola, Florida. A Beka Book Publishing is the publishing company of Pensacola Christian College (PCC), a far right Protestant college that was founded by Alvin Horton and his wife Rebekah “Beka” Horton; NO relation to myself. Because the PCC is such an ardent supporter of the King-James-Version-only movement I will mainly be using the KJV for this series as it concerns the book in question. Anything not from the KJV is indicated as such. This particular KJV Bible is the one my dad used in seminary and is at least as old as A.D.1958 according to the first inscription in the front cover; it should not be a problem for any KJV advocates.

The book, tellingly, starts its first point of instruction with a quote from Haile Selassie I, who was the Emperor of Ethiopia and lived 1892-1975. The quote itself is actually not bad:
“Today man sees all his hopes and aspirations crumbling before him. He is perplexed and knows not whither he is drifting. But he must realize that the Bible is his refuge, and the rallying point for all humanity. It is here man will find the solution tof his present difficulties and guidance for his future action, and unless he accepts with clear conscience the Bible and its great message, he cannot hope for salvation. For my part, I glory in the Bible”
Now, the above quote from Emperor Haile Selassie I is, at its core, a great generalized message of hope through salvation via the Bible’s soothing words which are inerrant and inspired. However, when we look at WHO Haile Selassie I was, and remains revered as, we gotta ask ourselves: why is this man the first quote in a point of instruction in a “Christian” book. For those unaware, Haile Selassie I was born with the name Tafari Makonnen. The term “ras”, meaning head of, was assigned to him as a title by his followers and brought forth what we know now as the Rastafari movement/religious cult. Rastafarians believe Haile Selassie is Jesus Christ incarnate and returned. It’s a Christian-esque version of the pan-African/blacks-are-the-true-Jews movement. It’s about as Christian as Mormonism, which is to say not at all. Oddly (not really), Haile has not risen from his grave and remains in its grasp; so much for the Jesus title. Thankfully the quote is above one of the many Gustave Dore prints found throughout the book, and Dore’s artwork is about the only redeeming quality of the book outside of the inarguable Christian truths. The PCC is extremely anti-secular, and for this I commend them to a degree, but why are they quoting the head of a fake religion which has at its head a man who the followers believe is Jesus Christ? Haile Selassie never squashed that idea. This doesn’t jive.

Page 9 contains, in part, the following:
” God dictated the actual words that appeared on those original manuscripts the “graphe“(writings) themselves.”

Excellent, I’m glad we agree but why don’t they subscribe to that in fullness? In expanding that idea they quote a ton of Protestant writers including John Calvin (founder of Calvinist doctrine/anti-Catholic), Benjamin Warfield (Presbyterian/ Calvinist follower/anti-Catholic), Charles Spurgeon (Baptist minister/anti-Catholic), Louis Gaussen (Swiss Protestant/anti-Catholic), John R. Rice (Baptist evangelist/anti-Catholic), Robert Preus (Lutheran/Translator for the NIV/anti-Catholic), and A.J. Gordon (son of a Baptist deacon/Calvinist; Baptist preacher/anti-Catholic). So not a single word was said about the inspiration of the Bible, its inerrancy, or anything else before circa 1520 A.D.? I highly doubt that. Maybe it has to do with the fact that the writer/editor/publisher are just anti-Catholic to such a degree that they refuse to even acknowledge almost two thousand years of traceable Church history, and seek instead to completely divorce Christianity from the Catholic faith, history, and doctrine. Being that the PCC is often associated, or at least linkable, to Bob Jones University I’d say that they probably share the BJU’s view on the Catholic Church which believes the RCC (Roman Catholic Church) is the harlot, beast, or false prophet of Revelation. If the RCC starts telling me I have to take a mark to buy or sell, beheads me (or others) for proclaiming the name of Christ, or if the Pope ever stands up on the Temple Mount and declares himself GOD, I’ll agree. Until then, what on earth do these people hate about the Roman Catholic Church which inspires such hatred for it in their hearts? The audacity to trace its lineage to St. Peter, et al early Christians? The lack of timidity it displays in defending the cause of Christ? The constant efficacy of the symbolism of the Sacraments and sacramentals pointing incessantly to Christ? The fact that their little effort of rebellion has done NOTHING to hurt the RCC and almost 500 years later is still the same church, with the same doctrines, and the same historical claim as the rightful Church which Jesus Christ founded? The only hurt to the RCC has been internal, though often at the influence of outside forces: Marxism, neo-Liberalism, modernism, etc.​

Be weary of what your grandchildren are exposed to. Even as a young Protestant, I was confused more than edified in the faith because of the chaotic theology present in non-Catholic settings.
 
Pt 2

Page 19 ironically contains the following quote:
“If we can trust the Bible for our eternal destiny, we can trust it to be accurate in every area of life and thought.”
OK, so why do they not live up to that then? Why is communion lowered to a level of something done on an inconsistent basis, and without the beauty of what it represents? Why do they accuse Catholics of polytheistic idolatry for asking the intercession of Saints? Was St. John incorrect when he saw the events described in Revelation 5:8? Absolutely not according to Proverbs 30:5, 2 Timothy 3:16, etc. They, being anti-Catholics, often like to throw verses like 1 Timothy 2:5 at the question:
“For there is one God, and there is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus;”
Well and good, and Catholics agree to that verse 100%. What Protestants don’t understand, and I didn’t understand prior to my own research, is that Catholics don’t pray to Saints as if they are God. The entire point is to ask for intercession/prayer to God from that Saint for the sinner, knowing that God hears the prayer too. Furthermore, when I pray and ask a Saint to intercede for something I first start by addressing Jesus and the one thing I stress during that prayer is that the prayer is only to be answered in accordance with the plan and will of God; I end the prayer by addressing God and again stressing that I do not want to go against the will of God; should the thing being prayed for be against the will of God I don’t expect the Saint I’m asking intercession from to go behind God’s back or something, that’s just a stupid idea. Again, the entire point of it all is to focus on God, Christ, and to seek help from those who are in Heaven via the power of the Holy Spirit. It’s basically the same thing as asking another Christian to pray for a certain cause or need. Not a dang bit of difference except the person who is asked to pray for us is IN Heaven and knows the will of God. It’s not saying that we have to go through someone other than Christ to get to God. Any Catholic that thinks that God is too busy or can’t keep up with his PrayerMail.com account is improperly instructed in the faith, and any other Christian that accuses Catholics of this in general is accusing fellow Christians of witchcraft, idolatry, and divination of spirits- all which are expressly forbidden. The actual simplistic beauty of 1 Timothy 2:5 is nothing more than Buddha, mohammed, Martin Luther, or any other slew of people DID NOT DIE ON THE CROSS FOR OUR SINS. That’s it, nothing more, quit reading into it so much. Loraine Boettner, an extremely anti-Catholic American theologian, is quoted in the book on page 12 regarding the inerrancy and inspiration of the Bible. Boettner’s most famous work on the Roman Catholic Church is inappropriately titled “Roman Catholicism”; inappropriately titled because there is nothing Roman Catholic about it.
 
My grandchildren have all been baptised Catholic, however, apart from seeing that they presented themselves for the proper instruction at the appropriate time for First Communion etc, my daughter says she is simply "too busy"to take them to Mass.
I have tried taking them with me to the Latin Mass I attend, but it is an hours’ drive away and the children fidgeted, were bored and distracted me. I intend to try again when they are a little older and more civilised.
I would be very concerned about the school, but more concerned that the children will go to the school with no active formation in the Church to counter the errors they will learn in the school.
It sounds as if they essentially get no formation in their faith at home and to second what was said by Jon, the school being from the Reformed tradition means they will get an incorrect education in many core areas. In fact, they will likely be seen as “in error” and “in need of saving” including the need to be baptised again since they were baptised as children.

If that is the only choice for education then I would suggest you find the most solid local parish that is close to your grandchildren and start taking them to mass and doing what you can yourself to catechize them. Once they are used to going to mass, perhaps you can start taking them to the Latin Mass. If you are in an area where the OF masses are really out there liturgically, maybe you continue to take them to the Latin mass and again, try to just offer up the distractions. There are some excellent books geared for children for the OF mass that are not very expensive and they may help.
Angelus Press has some wonderful ones for children and I found a really nice mass booklet on Lulu that is in color and has the mass responses in large print for young readers. (I am not connected with the author at all, I just found the booklet and it is quite nice) A Traditional Missal for Young Catholics By Peter Kwasniewski ,
If you need additional information to counter specific errors they may hear the Shamless Popery blog is excellent as he pretty much daily refutes many of the errors that he worked through as he converted.
 
Thank you to everyone for such thoughtful replies. You have brought to the fore what I suppose I had been trying to avoid! - namely that perhaps in this case, my attendance at the very distant Latin Mass is self-indulgent, and that I should be making the effort to attend the local parish.
That would be very hard for me! - since yes, it IS liturgically “out there”. However it is a vibrant parish with a strong focus on families and youth groups, and I can see that I need to examine my priorities.
I am very conservative, and to exchange Gregorian chant for amplified music will be almost more than I can bear.

At the same time, I have come to the conclusion that I shall maintain my opposition to the consideration of this Christian school - as the children have not been exposed to any Catholic doctrine in their home, they would be completely at the mercy of peer influence at this place, without having a strong platform - or the maturity, they are very young - to be able to discern and evaluate what is presented to them.
And my daughter is going to be very cross with me if she thinks I am interfering!!!

A dilemma indeed.
 
I wouldn’t consider your attendance at the Latin Mass self-indulgent, but, I would consider maybe taking the grandchildren to a local parish if the drive and their ages precludes full understanding of the Latin, having been barely exposed to it . Baby steps. Once they are older and can appreciate the Latin Mass, perhaps then you could pull them that way.

There is also the option of taking them to the regular parish during the week or attending a different Latin Mass than usual. You don’t have to give up the Latin Mass, but, you certainly might find that working your schedule around is to the benefit of all.

Of course, Grandma’s “everyone is going out for ice cream after mass” day should be a big hit, right!? 😉
 
At the same time, I have come to the conclusion that I shall maintain my opposition to the consideration of this Christian school - as the children have not been exposed to any Catholic doctrine in their home, they would be completely at the mercy of peer influence at this place, without having a strong platform - or the maturity, they are very young - to be able to discern and evaluate what is presented to them.
And my daughter is going to be very cross with me if she thinks I am interfering!!!

A dilemma indeed.
I just saw that you are “down under” so I can definitely understand that distance can be a real issue. Is there any way if you helped with transportation the Catholic school might be a possibility or is it just so far that any transportation would mean a long day? Again, if you have the means to transport and that would make the difference that could be worth the sacrifice.
You might be able to tell from the school’s website if everyone has to go to the religion classes or if there is any exemption. If your daughter won’d be swayed then I think the best you can do is to make certain the children do get to mass and are properly catechised. Perhaps you could be a volunteer (here Catholic schools have no problem with grandparents helping out since many parents work) and that way would see what is being presented and being in a better position to counter it with the teacher and with your grandchild.
 
Don’t let them!!! My mom has sent me to a SDA school (they said that they are “non-denominational.” Ha! My foot!) my whole life and it has screwed my religious views up majorly. I’m still trying to shake everything I’ve learned about the SDA religion and not confuse it with Catholicism. I despise it! Please! If you care about your grandchildren’s spiritual well being, don’t send them to that school.
 
Although we live a world apart, I had faced the same concern when I was choosing a school setting for my children. I actually asked our parish priest. He mentioned that while yes, it was a non-denominational school, it would be o.k. That it was more about the family influence (or lack of) that would make the difference in my children’s faith.

As time goes on, I can see that he was quite right. My children go to the local public school and attend faith formation classes weekly at our parish. More importantly, we attend Mass there on Sundays. That makes the biggest difference in the world.

I was a teacher in Catholic schools for some time. It is still the family that has the strongest influence on a child’s faith.

And yes, ice cream/doughnuts after Mass goes a long, long way…for everybody.

I hope it works out for you and your family in a way that brings everybody peace.
 
Although we live a world apart, I had faced the same concern when I was choosing a school setting for my children. I actually asked our parish priest. He mentioned that while yes, it was a non-denominational school, it would be o.k. That it was more about the family influence (or lack of) that would make the difference in my children’s faith.

As time goes on, I can see that he was quite right. My children go to the local public school and attend faith formation classes weekly at our parish. More importantly, we attend Mass there on Sundays. That makes the biggest difference in the world.

I was a teacher in Catholic schools for some time. It is still the family that has the strongest influence on a child’s faith.

And yes, ice cream/doughnuts after Mass goes a long, long way…for everybody.

I hope it works out for you and your family in a way that brings everybody peace.
Unfortunately for this lovely woman, her daughter is in fact not providing familial support necessary to counter insidious heresy and lackluster theology.

I think until the daughter can be brought into the fold, the grandmother has valid concerns.
 
I did not miss that, friend.

Rather, I was subtly suggesting that she focus on making a Church-going lifestyle her bigger fight. A strategy of showing her daughter’s family what is good and right is more likely to take hold than pointing out their errors.

So, ice cream / family time after Sunday Mass. Kids are happy, mom is happy. Grandmother is happy. (be the change you wish to see in the world idea).

I think fostering family strength is more important than being right. Telling/ blaming the daughter for what is wrong will not get her as far as showing her what it feels like to be united in prayer in her Church community.

Baby steps.
 
Although we live a world apart, I had faced the same concern when I was choosing a school setting for my children. I actually asked our parish priest. He mentioned that while yes, it was a non-denominational school, it would be o.k. That it was more about the family influence (or lack of) that would make the difference in my children’s faith.

As time goes on, I can see that he was quite right. My children go to the local public school and attend faith formation classes weekly at our parish. More importantly, we attend Mass there on Sundays. That makes the biggest difference in the world.

I was a teacher in Catholic schools for some time. It is still the family that has the strongest influence on a child’s faith.

And yes, ice cream/doughnuts after Mass goes a long, long way…for everybody.

I hope it works out for you and your family in a way that brings everybody peace.
I can believe this, because I work with some Sikhs who attended Catholic schools in India from childhood up.
They are very familiar with Christianity and Catholicism, yet remained strong Sikhs. Family and culture play a very important role in passing on and maintaining religious traditions, perhaps the most important role.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top