Wrong to distance self from family?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TigerKitty
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TigerKitty

Guest
So this is a VERY brief synopsis:

My sister has been historically emotionally and physically abusive to me…one time kicking me so hard she broke my leg. My extended family is pretty much oblivious to this since my father always said not to say anything to anyone. My mom died when I was 8 so there’s really not been anyone advocating for me.

My sister married a protestant man who vehemently and vocally hates the Catholic church and pretty much all religion. Although they were married in the Church (sacrament but not in the mass), he forbids raising their kids Catholic (or anything, really). Luckily I met someone (a Catholic man my own age) and we are now marred 10years…despite a rockystart. We attend mass every Sunday and he is a Knight of Columbus.

My father once admonished me for taking a college course on Protestantism, telling me I was Catholic and don’t go getting any ideas. I was engaged to a nondenominational Christian of strong faith who went through RCIA and still attends mass. Sister forced my father to force me to break off engagement because she thought my fiancee was a backward hick. (She married someone from the same high school as my fiancee.)

Anyway…stopped talking to her to protect my daughter from the emotional manipulation and unhealth. My father hates her husband and does all he can to put himself between her husband and their kids…including illicitly baptizing the kids without permission of the parents and building a HUGE playhouse (like all on his own…from design to construction…it cost thousands of dollars and the local permit officer shut him down…it was that big a project…of course he did not pull necessary permits) for her kids in their back yard ( while my daughter is lucky to get an hour of my father’s time every four months.

For 2Christmases in a row, my sister gave NOTHING to my daughter, and she cried for the entire 2hour car ride back home.

Last straw was my sister had a birthday party for my dad and didn’t invite me, and posted pictures all over Facebook of my dad andher kids positively gushing that he was the best grandpa in the whole world…and of course my daughter saw the pictures and knew she was excluded (again).

Fast forward 2years and my daughter received first communion. My father came for the mass and seemed quite proud that he didn’t receive during mass. I think he doesn’t go to church anymore because my sister and her kids don’t go. It’s so messed up. I cannot believe he would give up church just so my sister’s kids wouldn’t feel bad. And during dinner when I was not at the table, he was bragging to my in laws about the stupid clubhouse he made for my sister’s kids and how awesomeit is and how smart my sister’s kids are…and my daughter sat there at the table next to him on her special day , and I don’t know how she didn’t burst into tears.

I’m seriously considering limiting interactions with my father at this point.

I’m interested to hear people’s thoughts on this matter.
 
Wow, you have some real stress to deal with. Yes, I would personally read the book Boundaries as quickly as possible. Pray (of course). And don’t hesitate to find a professional to talk with on catholictherapists dot com because you have a lot on your plate with that crew!
 
You are a grown women who has been married ten years and has a family of her own. I think you should stop worrying about what other people think. You mentioned a few times that you were “forced” to do certain things. Nobody can force you to do the things you mentioned. Those are your adult choices. I would say you should work on giving yourself permssion to live your own life. It doesn’t mean you have to separate yourself from the people in your family unless that is something you want to do. If you lost your mother at 8, I imagine it was as hard on your sister as it was on you. Her misbehavior as a kid may have been her way of acting out. I would try not to hold that against her. On the other hand, if she is still acting out as an adult, then I would put as much distance between you and her as you need to be comfortable.

We are born into our families of origin. That doesn’t mean we have to stay there our whole life. Sometimes the healthy thing is to build some distance in, both physically and emotionally.

I would caution you to be aware of how much of your bad feelings towards your family is justified, and how much of it is just because they are different (not in a bad way) from you. Choosing a different religion doesn’t make them bad. However, from what you described, it sounds like a pretty toxic situation and like you have more than enough reason to maintain distance from them. Protect your child, your husband, and most of all yourself.
 
I’m seriously considering limiting interactions with my father at this point.
I would block all of them from my life.
I’m interested to hear people’s thoughts on this matter.
Why have you waited so long? I’d have done it the day I could legally defend myself from a sister who broke my leg and a father who protected her instead of me when she did it.
 
Last edited:
I’m seriously considering limiting interactions with my father at this point.

I’m interested to hear people’s thoughts on this matter.
With both your father AND your sister, I hope. Seriously, some people are just toxic, and you (and your daughter) don’t need that. I would be “limiting” so much that interactions would be non-existent. When your own father won’t protect you from physical abuse, it’s time to go.

And yes, do read “Boundaries.”
 
You’re not required to put up with an abusive situation. We CO FIL (Hubby still maintains very low contact, but it’s extremely sporadic) due to his financial abuse, body-shaming our impressionable preteen daughter, and trying to destroy our marriage. Yes, he is Hubby’s dad. Yes, we pray for him. But we don’t see him. If we are able to with God’s grace to have more children, they will not be meeting him.
 
Although I believe your father’s thoughtless actions (bragging about sister’s kids and building their playhouse) might be directed more at your BIL (sister’s husband)than at you, who cares. If it feels like abuse and neglect, it will be experienced that way. Since your sister didn’t put up with his interference in her relationship and subsequent marriage, he went passive/aggressive on her husband!
OK, enough psychobabble. I’d say you have every right to limit contact with your father. He’s not behaving in a kind was towards you and your family.
Your sister, OTOH, has, several times, showed open hostility, sometimes outright cruelty. She invited your daughter to her house for Christmas, and no present? Every child should get something on Christmas. Adults, not so important. Unless she, or your BIL, have a tradition of not giving gifts, this was a cruel exclusion. I would, also, not leave your daughter alone with your sister and her family. She learned that she could get away with hitting early in the game. Like marries like, and even her kids may follow example, and tease and bully. Don’t put your daughter in this situation!
Otherwise, start looking more to caring about your own, nuclear family. If your father and sister see you doing this, they may even start to think you’re on to something.
Keep your distance, but don’t stop praying for them. God Bless!
 
Last edited:
I just now looked up your posting history…and, I’m surprised that you haven’t cut these people off, long ago!
And, if BIL still has his gun collection…my recommendations about allowing your daughter to visit his home grow exponentially! Your daughter is a true blessing. Hope all is going well for your family.

Again, God Bless!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top