You do not have joy? Maybe here's the reason

  • Thread starter Thread starter nuntym
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

nuntym

Guest
+JMJ+

For the past couple of weeks I have been following St. Therese of Lisieux’s recommendation to “hide my troubles from Jesus”, then following the counsels of The Cloud of Unknowing, and I noticed a pattern.

You see, both advocate (and The Cloud of Unknowing is more forceful in this recommendation) to approach our Lord by “hiding” our emotions as well as removing our preconceptions of Him. Indeed the anonymous author of The Cloud of Unknowing wrote:

Cultivate self-control of body and soul. Accept the will of our Lord gracefully. Never lunge for it like a hungry dog. Even if you’re starving, don’t be a greedy greyhound. Don’t grab. Let me suggest how you do this. I’m going to advise you to play a sort of game with God, seriously. Pretend you don’t want what you want as much as you want it. When you feel that beast, desire, stirring inside you with tremendous power, restrain it. Act as if you don’t want God to find out how much you long to see Him, know Him, and feel Him. Hide all that.

In an anecdote of St. Therese of Lisieux, this was written:

“Tears for God!” she promptly replied, “that must not be. Far less to Him than to creatures ought you to show a mournful face. Our Divine Master has only our monasteries where He may obtain some solace for His Heart. He comes to us in search of rest—to forget the unceasing complaints of His friends in the world, who, instead of appreciating the value of the Cross, receive it far more often with moans and tears. Would you then be as the mediocre souls? Frankly, this is not disinterested love. . . . It is for us to console our Lord, and not for Him to console us. His Heart is so tender that if you cry He will dry your tears; but thereafter He will go away sad, since you did not suffer Him to repose tranquilly within you. Our Lord loves the glad of heart, the children that greet Him with a smile. When will you learn to hide your troubles from Him, or to tell Him gaily that you are happy to suffer for Him?”

Now the main reason for this approach to God, and the reasoning that I want to thrust in this post, is this, as written again in The Cloud of Unknowing:

[God] sees the yearning you hide more clearly that what you bare, and your desire is fulfilled more quickly. There’s no better way of “showing” Him what you want…

I want you to cast your longing deep in your spirit, far from anything corrupt, which would make it less spiritual and further from God…your soul [then] resembles God more when it is pure in spirit because God is spirit.

So I was following these recommendations, and I was pleasantly surprised by what I found: the more I suppress my feelings while praying, the more that joy bubbles up from deep inside me.

These experiences and the words of The Cloud of Unknowing remind me of these words of our Lord:

[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 7:6[/BIBLEDRB]

How many times have I prayed to the Lord full of anguish, and the anguish just seems to get even worse, doubting as whether God heard my prayer, or worrying that God would answer in the negative or even make it worse for my benefit, or even wondering whether there is a God to hear my prayers! It really does seem that when I show holiness to the dogs and pigs of my emotions, they trample them underneath and then tear me to pieces.

And it does seem also that Jesus dislikes pleas of panic and anguish. Who can fail to remember the account of Jesus calming the storm? While Jesus was sleeping, a fierce storm lashes the boat He and His disciples were riding on, and the disciples wake Him up, saying, “Lord, save us, we are about to perish!” And the Gospel of Mark even said that the disciples woke Him with these words: “Teacher, do you not care if we perish?” Jesus then calms the storm and rebukes His disciples with the words: “Why are you afraid? Have you no faith?” (Mark 4:35-41; Matthew 8:23-27; Luke 8:22-25)

So try this, if you scarcely have joy, or do not even know what joy is: Pray as if you do not want God, hide your desire for Him. Hide your tears; hide even your laughter and smiles. Hide what you hope to gain from Him. Hide what you want from Him. Place them not in your emotions and feelings, but deep inside your heart; let Him dig it out from you. And you will find what the author of The Cloud of Unknowing wrote all those centuries ago:

Perhaps I sound like a child making up a game, but I mean it. I am confident that anyone with the grace to put my advice into practice will eventually experience the joy of God’s playfulness. God will come to you, the way an earthly father plays with his child, kissing and hugging, making everything alright.
 
Thank you so much for posting this insight. It so timely as today is Gaudete Sunday. When I went to Confession yesterday my Pastor mentioned that the Evil One always tries to steal our joy by making us doubt ourselves, focus on the negatives and not really rest in our Lord. It makes so much sense now, especially in view of your post. When I go to Confession to my Vicar, which is pretty often, he counsels me to gain better control over my emotions and not give into them as I tend to be rather sensitive. I just love Therese of Lisieux- so much wisdom and love from her. I haven’t read the Cloud of Unknowing, but I’ve heard that it’s really good. The passages you shared now have me thinking I should read it soon. 😃
 
this is insightful, and well worthy of considering deeply.

However, where did we ever get the idea that emotion is bad in some way. Just like many of our human qualities, emotion can be misused, but it is a God-given part of us. We were born with emotions, and part of learning and maturing is learning how to negotiate the waves and shoals of our emotional life. Yet, emotion/feeling is what makes us human versus automatons.

Just saying.
 
nuntym,

This is a very good post. St. Therese is one of my favorite saints and she is full of wisdom. I have also read the Cloud of Unknowing. I have read those parts which you mention. However, I have trouble knowing how to implement the approach of “concealing my desire” from God. In all likelihood, I misunderstand what it means to do this. I am normally very direct with God in prayer and ask for His guidance for what troubles me. I do not pretend with Him and my spiritual director agreed that I should admit to God what troubles me as he said, “you would only be fooling yourself because God already knows about it.”

I also try to pray as Jesus prayed in the garden, "Father, if you are willing, take this cup away from me; still, not my will but yours be done (Lk 22:42).” In this way, I hope that I please Jesus and console His heart. In truth, I am willing to suffer whatever it is that troubles me for as long as He desires that I suffer.

In the Cloud, the author mentions in several places to go with what the Holy Spirit inspires one to do and that one need not stifle the spirit (see chapter 48, e.g.). As someone who has a tendency to complicate things as I often do, I try to avoid overcomplicating my prayer to God and approach Him in a manner that draws me closer to Him. 1 Pet. 5:7 says, “Cast all your worries upon him because he cares for you.” I try to do this as best I can with complete trust that God will take care of whatever concerns me.

This is a very interesting post and I’d love to hear your thoughts on this. Thanks for posting.

houston1
 
this is insightful, and well worthy of considering deeply.

However, where did we ever get the idea that emotion is bad in some way. Just like many of our human qualities, emotion can be misused, but it is a God-given part of us. We were born with emotions, and part of learning and maturing is learning how to negotiate the waves and shoals of our emotional life. Yet, emotion/feeling is what makes us human versus automatons.

Just saying.
👍

That said, it would be nice to actually have some emotions once in a while. My own emotional spectrum is so narrow that sometimes I wonder if perhaps I have some Vulcan blood 🤷
 
+JMJ+
this is insightful, and well worthy of considering deeply.

However, where did we ever get the idea that emotion is bad in some way. Just like many of our human qualities, emotion can be misused, but it is a God-given part of us. We were born with emotions, and part of learning and maturing is learning how to negotiate the waves and shoals of our emotional life. Yet, emotion/feeling is what makes us human versus automatons.

Just saying.
👍

That said, it would be nice to actually have some emotions once in a while. My own emotional spectrum is so narrow that sometimes I wonder if perhaps I have some Vulcan blood 🤷
Oh no, don’t get me wrong! Emotions, in all their magnificent variety and power, are a wonderful gift from God. Indeed I look with suspicion at those who view any one or more emotions as wrong or bad, like for example that famous saying by Yoda in The Phantom Menace: “Fear leads to anger; anger leads to hate; hate leads to suffering.”

One of my favorite stories is how St. Nicholas (yes, Santa Claus) punched a heretic in the face during an ecumenical council.

During the First Ecumenical Council of Nicea (AD 325), Arius was called upon to defend his position on the inferiority of Christ. Saint Nicholas just couldn’t listen to all of Arius’ nonsense and so he stood up and laid in to Arius with his fist.

The Emperor Constantine and the bishops present at the Council were alarmed by Nicholas’ act of violence against Arius. They immediately stripped Nicholas of his office as a bishop by confiscating the two items that marked out a man as a Christian bishop: Nicholas’ personal copy of the Gospels and his pallium (the vestment worn by all bishops in the East).

…

However, after Nicholas was deposed, the Lord Jesus Christ and the Blessed Virgin Mary visited Nicholas who was being held in a prison cell for his fist-fight with the heretic.

Our Lord Jesus Christ asked Saint Nicholas, “Why are you here?” Nicholas responded, “Because I love you, my Lord and my God.”

Christ then presented Nicholas with his copy of the Gospels. Next, the Blessed Virgin vested Nicholas with his episcopal pallium, thus restoring him to his rank as a bishop.

taylormarshall.com/2009/12/st-nicholas-he-who-punches-heretics-in.html

However, each creature, each thing of creation, must have its place. Can you imagine placing The Blood of Christ in Mass on an ordinary glass? Church Law insists that what must be in contact with the Precious Body and Blood of Christ must be of precious things, like for example the gold plating on the vessels the priest uses at Mass.

And so it is with our emotions, they may be good do good and combat evil, but when we get near the Lord it is best we leave our emotions and preconceptions aside and let Him be as He is, so He can rest on the most pure and most noble part of us, our souls.
 
It’s not so much the emotions, but the ego which feeds off emotions.

Detachment from the things that are not the true self, but the false self, could be used instead.

Jim
 
I don’t understand how one can hide their emotions from God. He is omniscient. He knows what I really feel like. Now I don’t have to whine to Him about things, but neither do I have to pretend everything is OK when it isn’t. I just present myself as I am and rejoice in the fact that He loves me like that. I try to put things in His hands and leave it there. This brings me great peace.

I am not debating–everyone has their own spirituality–but sometimes I just do not understand some of the writings of some of the Saints, although St. Therese is one of my favorites. She is the model of simplicity, to me a great virtue.

But whatever brings one closer to God, and joy and peace, that is the way to go. He will lead.

🙂
 
You can’t hide emotions/false-self, i.e. the ego, from God.

What St Teresa meant was to hide complaining or reacting to the emotions which the ego wants to attach to. These emotions are what the ego feeds on, they are the false self attaching it’s identity to them and building a plan of course for the future.

Don’t misunderstand emotions in the general sense. Emotions are part of the spiritual life, they are part of being human. It’s the disordered emotions which the ego builds the false image of self, which is to be detached from.

Jim
 
+JMJ+
I don’t understand how one can hide their emotions from God. He is omniscient. He knows what I really feel like. Now I don’t have to whine to Him about things, but neither do I have to pretend everything is OK when it isn’t. I just present myself as I am and rejoice in the fact that He loves me like that. I try to put things in His hands and leave it there. This brings me great peace.

I am not debating–everyone has their own spirituality–but sometimes I just do not understand some of the writings of some of the Saints, although St. Therese is one of my favorites. She is the model of simplicity, to me a great virtue.

But whatever brings one closer to God, and joy and peace, that is the way to go. He will lead.

🙂
Actually the author of The Cloud of Unknowing said this:

I am not asking you to hide [your emotions] completely. Only an idiot would ask you to that, because it’s impossible. But I am still saying try your best—do all you can to hide it from God.

And you know what they say about prayer: Prayer is not to change how God works, but to let it change you.
 
+JMJ+
nuntym,

This is a very good post. St. Therese is one of my favorite saints and she is full of wisdom. I have also read the Cloud of Unknowing. I have read those parts which you mention. However, I have trouble knowing how to implement the approach of “concealing my desire” from God. In all likelihood, I misunderstand what it means to do this. I am normally very direct with God in prayer and ask for His guidance for what troubles me. I do not pretend with Him and my spiritual director agreed that I should admit to God what troubles me as he said, “you would only be fooling yourself because God already knows about it.”

I also try to pray as Jesus prayed in the garden, "Father, if you are willing, take this cup away from me; still, not my will but yours be done (Lk 22:42).” In this way, I hope that I please Jesus and console His heart. In truth, I am willing to suffer whatever it is that troubles me for as long as He desires that I suffer.

In the Cloud, the author mentions in several places to go with what the Holy Spirit inspires one to do and that one need not stifle the spirit (see chapter 48, e.g.). As someone who has a tendency to complicate things as I often do, I try to avoid overcomplicating my prayer to God and approach Him in a manner that draws me closer to Him. 1 Pet. 5:7 says, “Cast all your worries upon him because he cares for you.” I try to do this as best I can with complete trust that God will take care of whatever concerns me.

This is a very interesting post and I’d love to hear your thoughts on this. Thanks for posting.

houston1
All I can say is give it some time, and maybe get a better translation. First of all, the first time I read The Cloud of Unknowing I really couldn’t understand much of it, probably because I had read an archaic translation. The free translated version I found online is even worse. I suggest you buy THIS one if you are interested.

But even then it took me a few readings and several months of setting the book aside that I was able to slowly able to understand and integrate it.

Besides, I think there will be people who will not “get” this book simply because they are not called to this kind of spirituality. They may be called to reach the heights of contemplation just using the ordinary but tried-and-tested means of such meditative/vocal prayers as the Rosary and reading Scripture.

BUT, aside from all that, you seem to be in a good road. Completely trust your spiritual director and do what he/she asks of you. Talk to him/her about this post if you want, then follow his/her directions 🙂
 
Keep in mind that during St Terese’s time, and the author of the Cloud of Unknowing, they didn’t have the understanding of human psychology that we do today. What they described as emotions, were merely the food that feeds the ego, the false self.

Archbishop Fulton Sheen gave good teachings on the ego, which I don’t have the specifics on at this time, but he had the resources which St Teresa and the author of the Cloud, did not have the language to explain to our understanding.

Jim
 
No one can hide anything from the all knowing God. I believe the suggestion of “hiding” by some classic authors really means putting things in the back of our mind and concentrating on the Lord – the Beloved. Sincerity is crucial in any relationship if we want the relationship significant. Pretending could never be authentic or fruitful.

We should talk to God with our true feelings. However, we do not have to keep on whining or expressing once we make ourselves transparent before the Lord. We then put whatever mood we have in the back burner and focus on the Lord. That is how our hearts can be joyful. For the Lord Himself is the source of all the joy.

It is not the “hiding” itself that brings us joy but the shift of focus from our own misery to the glorious Lord makes us joyful.
 
No one can hide anything from the all knowing God. I believe the suggestion of “hiding” by some classic authors really means putting things in the back of our mind and concentrating on the Lord – the Beloved. Sincerity is crucial in any relationship if we want the relationship significant. Pretending could never be authentic or fruitful.

We should talk to God with our true feelings. However, we do not have to keep on whining or expressing once we make ourselves transparent before the Lord. We then put whatever mood we have in the back burner and focus on the Lord. That is how our hearts can be joyful. For the Lord Himself is the source of all the joy.

It is not the “hiding” itself that brings us joy but the shift of focus from our own misery to the glorious Lord makes us joyful.
very well said. 🙂
 
No one can hide anything from the all knowing God. I believe the suggestion of “hiding” by some classic authors really means putting things in the back of our mind and concentrating on the Lord – the Beloved. Sincerity is crucial in any relationship if we want the relationship significant. Pretending could never be authentic or fruitful.

We should talk to God with our true feelings. However, we do not have to keep on whining or expressing once we make ourselves transparent before the Lord. We then put whatever mood we have in the back burner and focus on the Lord. That is how our hearts can be joyful. For the Lord Himself is the source of all the joy.

It is not the “hiding” itself that brings us joy but the shift of focus from our own misery to the glorious Lord makes us joyful.
Agreed, as far as I know.

It’s the classic language the authors used, which isn’t hiding normal emotions from God, but letting go of inordinate thoughts and desires which come into mind.

Jim
 
No one can hide anything from the all knowing God. I believe the suggestion of “hiding” by some classic authors really means putting things in the back of our mind and concentrating on the Lord – the Beloved.
However, we do not have to keep on whining or expressing once we make ourselves transparent before the Lord. We then put whatever mood we have in the back burner and focus on the Lord. That is how our hearts can be joyful.
This makes sense to me. I feel like every time my prayer consists of whining, then I don’t really pray well. Bringing a problem to God and then leaving it aside is necessary in order to actually hear God. Otherwise we just engage in a monologue and remain focused on ourselves.
 
You can’t hide emotions/false-self, i.e. the ego, from God.

What St Teresa meant was to hide complaining or reacting to the emotions which the ego wants to attach to. These emotions are what the ego feeds on, they are the false self attaching it’s identity to them and building a plan of course for the future.

Don’t misunderstand emotions in the general sense. Emotions are part of the spiritual life, they are part of being human. It’s the disordered emotions which the ego builds the false image of self, which is to be detached from.

Jim
Jim, I do not understand your equating the false self, ego with emotional feeding. I think of the ego as our “executive function” that is the “I” that decides among events, emotions, feelings and discerns that which leads us toward versus away from God. You seem to be using ego in the sense if a false self, that which is more involved with meeting its own false needs rather than turning outward to other/God. This may just be a semantic difference.
 
Sorry, for two posts in a row, but been busy with Christmas stuff, family, friends. That time of year! 🙂

Would “hiding” in the sense that it is used be similar to “humility”?
 
Jim, I do not understand your equating the false self, ego with emotional feeding. I think of the ego as our “executive function” that is the “I” that decides among events, emotions, feelings and discerns that which leads us toward versus away from God. You seem to be using ego in the sense if a false self, that which is more involved with meeting its own false needs rather than turning outward to other/God. This may just be a semantic difference.
The ego creates the false self in order to present an certain image to others. The ego is defensive and will attack those who offend it. The ego is not the I or the Id, as it was taught in times past, but the defensive mechanism we develop sometime after we reach the age of reason. It is not our true self.

The main development in the spiritual life is detachment from the ego, which drives a falsehood of our own true being.

Jim
 
The ego creates the false self in order to present an certain image to others. The ego is defensive and will attack those who offend it. The ego is not the I or the Id, as it was taught in times past, but the defensive mechanism we develop sometime after we reach the age of reason. It is not our true self.

The main development in the spiritual life is detachment from the ego, which drives a falsehood of our own true being.

Jim
Can you give me a reference for this point of view - psychological or spiritual writer. I do not recognize this at all. With respect, there are lots of points of view that I have not encountered and this is one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top