Youcat

  • Thread starter Thread starter lifeisbeautiful
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you guys for posting your opinions about this book. I was debating on whether to get it, but because my funds are limited, I decided to wait until someone posted about it.

Dan,

Thanks for posting the link that presented the problems with the Youcat.

I think it would be a waste of my time and money both which are precious to me to further pursue this book. Thanks for doing the legwork.

God bless.
 
I hadn’t heard of this until I saw it at a Catholic book store yesterday. I contemplated getting it since I’ve been having a hard time getting my wife & son to read Catholicism for Dummies (I’m trying to strengthen their understanding of our faith and want them to have something more to go on than just what I’m telling them, and personally found CfD to be a great help as I started brushing up/relearning the Church’s teachings after all these years). I’m glad I checked here before blindly buying it, if for no other reasons than the concerns raised about what Youcat says about masturbation, contraception and homosexuality.

My son’s 20 and received some very erroneous instruction at his Catholic high school, which was compounded by even more misguided opinions from his peers. I’ve been talking to him about our faith for a while now and some of what comes out of him astounds me. From what I’ve read here and on the Youcat recall site, this would not only add a lot of confusion to the mix, but also reinforce a lot of the bad teachings and opinions he picked up over the last 5-6 years.

One positive thing is that this helps reinforce my commitment to guide my family in their faith. I may not have all the answers, but I have much better understanding now than I ever did, and if I’m ever unsure about anything, it only takes a few seconds to google the CCC and get just the right answer.
 
Catholic Catechisms that quote Martin Luther (as this one does) should also raise some serious questions.
I like YOUCAT. Of course, it won’t be perfect but it does reference the CCC with every topic. I think it does explain everything pretty well.

I think they quoted Martin Luther to show that even HE needed confession in the Catholic Church.

It says on page 92-93:

“I would be sore afraid, if it were not for secret confession” -Martin Luther.

From my own experience, when the topic of the Catholic Church comes up and I am speaking to someone who is a non-Catholic-Christian they usually mention Martin Luther, and how he wrote the 95 thesies apposing the Catholic Church. Martin Luther was once a Catholic, too. I think that Catholic-Christian youth need to know about the history of the church, and even what some of the church opponents said. It shows youth not to be afraid to know about even non-Christian peoples and what they said regarding truth.

Even Benedict XVI said regarding YOUCAT in his foreword of the book:

“One can, of course criticize some things or even many things in such a work: Everything that man makes is inadequate and can be improved”

Best regards,

TruthSeeker92
 
Good for firewood maybe.😛

The implication is there are separate truths for youth than for adults and there really isn’t.
That is absolutely* not* implied. You will not find such a statement anywhere, or anything like it. There are different approaches for teaching different people. For me as a Catholic, I would be slow to burn anything the Catholic Church puts out, or anything that the Holy Father urges one to read.

EXCERPTS FROM POPE BENEDICT’S FOREWORD
TO YOUCAT:

“So I invite you: Study this Catechism! That is my heartfelt desire. This Catechism was not written to please you. It will not make life easy for you, because it demands of you a new life. It places before you the Gospel message as the ‘pearl of great value’ (Mt 13:46) for which you must give everything. So I beg you: Study this Catechism with passion and perseverance.”

ignatius.com/promotions/youcat/?gclid=CIzI4YHQ6qsCFQPj7QodLkwcTA

To the OP. Heed rather the words of the Holy Father and decide for yourself.
 
I like YOUCAT. …
“I would be sore afraid, if it were not for secret confession” -Martin Luther.
I think there are some here who may forget that Martin Luther was also a Catholic.
Even Benedict XVI said regarding YOUCAT in his foreword of the book:

“One can, of course criticize some things or even many things in such a work: Everything that man makes is inadequate and can be improved”
The Holy Father does not object to the Youcat. Rather than take the word of nay-sayers here, listen to what Pope Benedict says. Get just one copy and decide for yourself if it is suitable for your purposes.
 
We each have one because they were given out at World Youth Day. My teenage children found them very readable and helpful. It is abridged in that it obviously don’t contain all the detail in the complete catechism, but it isn’t watered down or incomplete. I highly recommend it for teens and young adults (and the rest of us who don’t have the attention span to read to complete catechism).
 
The YouCat is not meant to replace the full Catechism or to be the last work anyone reads. It is designed as a stepping stone for young people to reach them where they are and draw them in further. Just as you wouldn’t hand War and Peace to a beginning reader, the church realizes that many young people need a bridge from the material made for children and a document like the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

We also have copies of the 3 volume Baltimore Catechism. While every word of it is true, the examples and illustrations are very old-fashioned and can lead a teen to see religion as old fashioned also. The problems teens face today and not quite the same as those of the 50s. Even just the illustrations can be off-putting. In mine, they show either adults or young children, no teens.

As the preface says, not every tool will be perfect, but the YouCat does fill a need that previous materials were just not doing.
 
Then why is there a lot of criticism about it?
Good question. Most people that I have talked to don’t like it due to rumors they have heard about it. Or they are basing what they say on a couple of web sites that don’t like it. Very few have actually picked up a Youcat and read it.

People here that are against it, can tell you themselves.
 
There was a topic on this somewhere, I believe that the article was talking about how it was incorrect on many things? I believe such as birth control, and homosexuality
Greetings Redratfish,

Yes there was. And it got really heated if I remember aright.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Good question. Most people that I have talked to don’t like it due to rumors they have heard about it. Or they are basing what they say on a couple of web sites that don’t like it. Very few have actually picked up a Youcat and read it.

People here that are against it, can tell you themselves.
Greetigns Maryjk,

Is this online anywhere? They have the other Catechisms online, and I am wondering if it is online. This is why I have not bought the YouCat.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Greetigns Maryjk,

Is this online anywhere? They have the other Catechisms online, and I am wondering if it is online. This is why I have not bought the YouCat.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
I have no idea if it is on line. But you can get if for a Kindle. 👍
 
I have no idea if it is on line. But you can get if for a Kindle. 👍
Greetings Maryjk,

Well in that case, I shall wait until I get my Kindle to read it then. Thank you. That has made my day.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Dear friends,

Amen! I am a young Catholic and I find YOUCAT helpful. I like it, and I feel bad that so many people are speaking against it.

I think that if there is anyone apprehensive about YOUCAT they really should buy a copy, or rent one and read it for themmselves.

As a young Catholic, I like that the YOUCAT quotes a lot of saints, martyrs, Church Fathers, and former Popes such as Bl. John Paul II. The YOUCAT quotes Pope Benedict XVI often as well!!! YOUCAT has definitions of words, translations of Latin, as well as teaching about Church history, sacraments, and tradition.

I also really find it helpful that YOUCAT quotes non-Catholic Christians, and even non-Christians because it shows that deep down, everyone has a religious sense about God. Of course, there is only ONE TRUTH, and ONE CHURCH. The YOUCAT explains that!
As a young person, I want to see God from as many accurate angles as I possibly can.

I think the quote about a Father Confessor vs. a Bartender is trying to show that we all feel the need to confess our sins, but the only true person who can forgive us is Jesus who works through the Priest. Some people (not all) may become drunk and start to let their honesty and guilt show through to a bartender, but a bartender cannot forgive sins. Young people may read this reference and realize that they can be comfortable confessing their sins to Christ through the Priest and they don’t have to become tipsy and confess their faults to a bartender who cannot absolve them.

If someone should decide to purchase YOUCAT, they should study it with the Cathechism of the Catholic Church to touch more fully upon the Churches teaching.

Good luck! I hope you at least try to read this Catechism. If your teens/young adult children seem to like it, then listen to them! Read it with them with the CCC handy at all times. Pray for guidance regarding YOUCAT, and keep an open mind!

God bless! 👍

Sincerely,

TruthSeeker92
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top