Youcat

  • Thread starter Thread starter lifeisbeautiful
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
We have the book and use it. Our teens don’t “read” it, but our family uses it as a reference. There have been a few occasions that we have referenced it and my husband and I have told our children we thought the information was a little “watered down”. We then went on to tell them why we felt that way and what we want them to know.

My recommendation is to read it, BUT make sure you are discussing what is being read so that your family’s values and beliefs can be woven into the information.
 
Dear friends,

Amen! I am a young Catholic and I find YOUCAT helpful. I like it, and I feel bad that so many people are speaking against it.

I think that if there is anyone apprehensive about YOUCAT they really should buy a copy, or rent one and read it for themmselves.

As a young Catholic, I like that the YOUCAT quotes a lot of saints, martyrs, Church Fathers, and former Popes such as Bl. John Paul II. The YOUCAT quotes Pope Benedict XVI often as well!!! YOUCAT has definitions of words, translations of Latin, as well as teaching about Church history, sacraments, and tradition.

I also really find it helpful that YOUCAT quotes non-Catholic Christians, and even non-Christians because it shows that deep down, everyone has a religious sense about God. Of course, there is only ONE TRUTH, and ONE CHURCH. The YOUCAT explains that!
As a young person, I want to see God from as many accurate angles as I possibly can.

I think the quote about a Father Confessor vs. a Bartender is trying to show that we all feel the need to confess our sins, but the only true person who can forgive us is Jesus who works through the Priest. Some people (not all) may become drunk and start to let their honesty and guilt show through to a bartender, but a bartender cannot forgive sins. Young people may read this reference and realize that they can be comfortable confessing their sins to Christ through the Priest and they don’t have to become tipsy and confess their faults to a bartender who cannot absolve them.

If someone should decide to purchase YOUCAT, they should study it with the Cathechism of the Catholic Church to touch more fully upon the Churches teaching.

Good luck! I hope you at least try to read this Catechism. If your teens/young adult children seem to like it, then listen to them! Read it with them with the CCC handy at all times. Pray for guidance regarding YOUCAT, and keep an open mind!

God bless! 👍

Sincerely,

TruthSeeker92
This is excellent advice. Especially the idea of reading it with a teen, or perhaps a group of young adults starting a study based on the YouCat and then delving deeper into the issues they have more questions about.

I do not believe our Holy Father would have recommended the YouCat to the million young people at World Youth Day, if he didn’t feel it was worthy or being read and helpful to their formation.
 
This is excellent advice. Especially the idea of reading it with a teen, or perhaps a group of young adults starting a study based on the YouCat and then delving deeper into the issues they have more questions about.

I do not believe our Holy Father would have recommended the YouCat to the million young people at World Youth Day, if he didn’t feel it was worthy or being read and helpful to their formation.
Greetings Mrs Sally,

And it is because the Holy Father has recommended tghe YouCat I am going to read it and judge it fairly.

I am going to wait until I get my Kindle to read it though. That is amazing, I am going to have a huge library on my little Kindle. Gone are the days of packing a suitcase full of books. 😃

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Yes, we love our kindle too! It is easier to read with than I was expecting, and there are many free or very inexpensive classic titles.
 
Hi all,

I have read through the Youcat in its entirety, and am onboard with many of the stated criticisms and compliments of the book. However, I have yet to read about the presentation of the Lord’s Prayer (or maybe I missed it somewhere).

I posted on another Youcat thread in the past that I was confused about the Lord’s Prayer (p.280) ending with “For thine is the kingdom and the power and the glory forever.” I know this is a Protestant ending and is not how the prayer is taught in CCD or printed anywhere in Catholic materials. It is not this way in the Catechism, the Compendium, prayer cards/books, teaching materials, Catholic bibles, …

Since I have never seen this addressed anywhere, I am still confused as to its inclusion in the Youcat, especially because it is done so seamlessly as to imply it is 100% integral to the prayer.

Could somebody let me know if I am making a mountain out of a molehill for myself, or if this is a legitimate concern? I am not a “pro” (so to speak) at being a good or well versed Catholic. I am trying to get things right for myself so I can share that with my kids.
 
To put it out there, I’m a teen, and I really like the Youcat. It’s brought up some great discussions in our youth group. If anyone was reading it and thought it was lacking on an issue they wanted to learn more about, everything is referenced for further reading in the actual CCC.

The quotes, Bible verses, and the comics I also am a fan of. 🙂
 
Hi all,

I have read through the Youcat in its entirety, and am onboard with many of the stated criticisms and compliments of the book. However, I have yet to read about the presentation of the Lord’s Prayer (or maybe I missed it somewhere).

I posted on another Youcat thread in the past that I was confused about the Lord’s Prayer (p.280) ending with “For thine is the kingdom and the power and the glory forever.” I know this is a Protestant ending and is not how the prayer is taught in CCD or printed anywhere in Catholic materials. It is not this way in the Catechism, the Compendium, prayer cards/books, teaching materials, Catholic bibles, …

Since I have never seen this addressed anywhere, I am still confused as to its inclusion in the Youcat, especially because it is done so seamlessly as to imply it is 100% integral to the prayer.

Could somebody let me know if I am making a mountain out of a molehill for myself, or if this is a legitimate concern? I am not a “pro” (so to speak) at being a good or well versed Catholic. I am trying to get things right for myself so I can share that with my kids.
This is confusing since in their explanation they do not explain it:rolleyes: I also do not like that the Hail Mary is presented differently than the Catechism. It isn’t a big deal they just don’t use the thee and thou but why did they decide to change it?
 
This is confusing since in their explanation they do not explain it:rolleyes: I also do not like that the Hail Mary is presented differently than the Catechism. It isn’t a big deal they just don’t use the thee and thou but why did they decide to change it?
Greetings Adrift,

I guess it is because kids these days do not use thee and thou. I always use the thees and thous. This is not a big deal, it is the intention of the prayer.

As to them changing the Lord’s prayer, I am not sure on that one. I am waiting for someone with more knowledge in this matter to explain why they changed it to the Protestant version.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
Greetings Adrift,

I guess it is because kids these days do not use thee and thou. I always use the thees and thous. This is not a big deal, it is the intention of the prayer.

As to them changing the Lord’s prayer, I am not sure on that one. I am waiting for someone with more knowledge in this matter to explain why they changed it to the Protestant version.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
Many Catholic parishes use the “Protestant” version.
 
This is confusing since in their explanation they do not explain it:rolleyes: I also do not like that the Hail Mary is presented differently than the Catechism. It isn’t a big deal they just don’t use the thee and thou but why did they decide to change it?
They do not us the “thee’s and thou’s” at my sons school either in any of the prayers they teach.
 
Many Catholic parishes use the “Protestant” version.
Greetings Ahimsa,

Just becuase the Protestants are doing something does not mean that we need to change the Lord’s Prayer. That is sad if this is the reason that they changed it.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
 
World Youth Day categorizes “Youth” as 18-35.

We used to have Cardinals younger than that. (perhaps some Popes too)

Why does an adult (a young adult, but still an adult), need to be taught the faith with stick figures?

For the most part people meet the standards set for me, whether they are set high or set low. Treat a 20 year old like he his a child and don’t be surprised when he acts like a child.

As I work through the book, there are bigger issues than the tone and format, but on tone and format alone, I’d respectfully suggest that the book poorly serves the Church. Adults don’t need a “dumbed down” version of Church teaching.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Greetings Adrift,

I guess it is because kids these days do not use thee and thou. I always use the thees and thous. This is not a big deal, it is the intention of the prayer.

As to them changing the Lord’s prayer, I am not sure on that one. I am waiting for someone with more knowledge in this matter to explain why they changed it to the Protestant version.

God Bless.
Anathama Sit
I agree it isn’t a big deal. What makes me wonder is why they didn’t follow the Catechism ? I am just curious not that it matters.
 
World Youth Day categorizes “Youth” as 18-35.

We used to have Cardinals younger than that. (perhaps some Popes too)

Why does an adult (a young adult, but still an adult), need to be taught the faith with stick figures?

For the most part people meet the standards set for me, whether they are set high or set low. Treat a 20 year old like he his a child and don’t be surprised when he acts like a child.

As I work through the book, there are bigger issues than the tone and format, but on tone and format alone, I’d respectfully suggest that the book poorly serves the Church. Adults don’t need a “dumbed down” version of Church teaching.

Pax and God Bless.
That should be “standards set for THEM” of course. :o

Pax
 
Many Catholic parishes use the “Protestant” version.
I have a friend who told me the same thing. After a few questions, I understood that she did not realize that the priest says "Deliver us, Lord, from every evil, and grant us peace in our day. In your mercy keep us free from sin and protect us from all anxiety as we wait in joyful hope for the coming of our Saviour Jesus Christ before the For the kingdom,… etc.
I don’t consider it part of the Our Father when it is said this way.
When you say they use the protestant version, exactly how is that done? Do they than say it before what I just quoted the priest as saying?

I just checked the Catechism 2855 talks about the final doxology. Although in the summation it doesn’t mention it. This only makes me more confused. I know why the doxology was orginally added to Scripture but I do not understand why it is stated in the catechism as it is:confused:
 
I posted my reactions to the Youcat once, but that thread was taken down a while ago, but here I would like to give my reactions to some of the most common criticism I’ve seen on this and the half a dozen other threads on the topic.
  1. It’s watered down!
    I consider myself to be a pretty good reader, but when someone posts full passages from the regular catechism, I skip over most of it because it doesn’t hold my attention. The Youcat gives straight answers in plain language, but it also gives citations so that you could look up the relevant passage in the catechism if you wanted to. You have to understand that not everyone wants a deep, complex explanation.
  2. It doesn’t present certain sins seriously enough.
    One specific example of this is the part about how masturbation is not “demonized.” Yes, it’s a mortal sin, but it’s not the end of the world. The language could be tweaked a little, but the text isn’t horrible the way it is.
  3. It quotes non-Catholics.
    So? Does being non-catholic mean that everything they say must be wrong or anti-Catholic. I’ll give two examples. Some people get all riled up because there are two or three quotes from Martin Luther. What does he say? “That is the difference between animals and man: the latter has a Sunday outfit, too.” It’s a little weird (I can imagine it being very funny to Germans), but there is nothing inherently with the quote. Another example is a quote from Ludwid Feuerbach, who is listed as an atheist philosopher. “When faith in the Mother of God declines, so does faith in the Son of God and in the Father.” That is very true and it highlights how even a non-believer can recognize the importance of Mary to Christian theology.
  4. It has stick figures and doodles in the margins. That means it’s been dumbed down.
    I don’t know why people think picture=dumb. I’m attaching a picture of a medieval prayer book. There are little goofy things happening at the bottom of the page (as was common at the time). Is the book worthless in all spiritual instruction because there are little people running around the margins? No. So why should that be the case with the Youcat. Unlike the drawings in the medieval book, the stick figures are actually relevant to what is being discussed. By the way, I thought they were funny.
http://www.shafe.co.uk/crystal/images/lshafe/dEvreux_Book_of_Hours_1324-1328.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top