Youcat

  • Thread starter Thread starter lifeisbeautiful
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
My (high school) youth group has always made good use of the CCC. When Youcat came out, we discussed it for a few minutes then moved on to a different topic. Overall, nobody really made a big deal of the release of Youcat. Some of my friends in youth group own it, but I think we’re all very accostumed to the depth of the CCC that the Youcat felt a little broad for us. I do think that the Youcat serves a purpose and is an interesting read, but I think that the people in my youth group and I remain attached to the CCC and will continue to use that over the Youcat.
 
I sent an email to ignatius press regarding the Lord’s Prayer in their Youcat but have not heard back. (I’m not surprised.) It would be nice if they at least explained why they changed it.
 
World Youth Day categorizes “Youth” as 18-35.

We used to have Cardinals younger than that. (perhaps some Popes too)

Why does an adult (a young adult, but still an adult), need to be taught the faith with stick figures?

For the most part people meet the standards set for me, whether they are set high or set low. Treat a 20 year old like he his a child and don’t be surprised when he acts like a child.

As I work through the book, there are bigger issues than the tone and format, but on tone and format alone, I’d respectfully suggest that the book poorly serves the Church. Adults don’t need a “dumbed down” version of Church teaching.

Pax and God Bless.
I borrowed a friend’s copy of the Youcat. I am 20 years old and am considering converting. I did see some things, like with the Lord’s prayer that were wrong. I do a lot of research on my own and getting this so called “dumbed down” version of the catechism is appropriate for me since I am in the beginning stages of this whole journey. I am certainly now going to sit down and read the whole catechism as pleasure reading. I want to learn as much about the Catholic church as I can. I love to read, but sometimes something less challenging is good. I don’t want to have to read a passage over and over again to really get what it is saying. If helping someone like me is poorly serving the Church, I would say you are mistaken. It explained some things to me better than anything else has. Sometimes you need to start out with a “dumbed down” version and work your way up.

For instance, the two biggest things I am working through right now is birth control and no ordination of women. I read those sections in the Youcat and had a very basic understanding of why Catholics believe what they believe. Since I had that basic knowledge, I was able to do more in-depth research.

I would say that the Youcat is great for young people new to the Catholic faith. But, one should not solely rely on the Youcat. It is the baby food version of the catechism. You have to graduate to solid foods at the right time. In today’s age of youth with short attention spans, the Youcat will hopefully grab the attention and then provoke young people to do more of their own research.
 
I borrowed a friend’s copy of the Youcat. I am 20 years old and am considering converting. I did see some things, like with the Lord’s prayer that were wrong. I do a lot of research on my own and getting this so called “dumbed down” version of the catechism is appropriate for me since I am in the beginning stages of this whole journey. I am certainly now going to sit down and read the whole catechism as pleasure reading. I want to learn as much about the Catholic church as I can. I love to read, but sometimes something less challenging is good. I don’t want to have to read a passage over and over again to really get what it is saying. If helping someone like me is poorly serving the Church, I would say you are mistaken. It explained some things to me better than anything else has. Sometimes you need to start out with a “dumbed down” version and work your way up.

For instance, the two biggest things I am working through right now is birth control and no ordination of women. I read those sections in the Youcat and had a very basic understanding of why Catholics believe what they believe. Since I had that basic knowledge, I was able to do more in-depth research.

I would say that the Youcat is great for young people new to the Catholic faith. But, one should not solely rely on the Youcat. It is the baby food version of the catechism. You have to graduate to solid foods at the right time. In today’s age of youth with short attention spans, the Youcat will hopefully grab the attention and then provoke young people to do more of their own research.
I am glad that young people like you are considering converting and coming into the Catholic Church. We welcome you! I also agree with you that some do need to have an easy to understand catechism first before taking on the whole big catechism. I love because it because it is so beautiful and a real treasure of our Catholic faith, even though hard to read for some. It is so full of inspiring quotes from saints and scripture verses. I don’t think most people just sit down and read the Catechism from beginning to end. I use it to look up all different topics and teachings when I am unsure about something.

Can you quote what Youcat says on birth control. I am interested in what it says.
 
I borrowed a friend’s copy of the Youcat. I am 20 years old and am considering converting. I did see some things, like with the Lord’s prayer that were wrong. I do a lot of research on my own and getting this so called “dumbed down” version of the catechism is appropriate for me since I am in the beginning stages of this whole journey. I am certainly now going to sit down and read the whole catechism as pleasure reading. I want to learn as much about the Catholic church as I can. I love to read, but sometimes something less challenging is good. I don’t want to have to read a passage over and over again to really get what it is saying. If helping someone like me is poorly serving the Church, I would say you are mistaken. It explained some things to me better than anything else has. Sometimes you need to start out with a “dumbed down” version and work your way up.
The catechism is more of a reference book. Not normally something you would sit down and read, cover to cover.
For instance, the two biggest things I am working through right now is birth control and no ordination of women. I read those sections in the Youcat and had a very basic understanding of why Catholics believe what they believe. Since I had that basic knowledge, I was able to do more in-depth research.
In fact, what I love about the YOUCAT, is that it references the catechism. 👍
I would say that the Youcat is great for young people new to the Catholic faith. But, one should not solely rely on the Youcat. It is the baby food version of the catechism. You have to graduate to solid foods at the right time. In today’s age of youth with short attention spans, the Youcat will hopefully grab the attention and then provoke young people to do more of their own research.
I don’t know that I would describe it as “baby food.” but I do agree no one should rely solely on the YOUCAT. It wasn’t written to be the only source of information.
 
I am glad that young people like you are considering converting and coming into the Catholic Church. We welcome you! I also agree with you that some do need to have an easy to understand catechism first before taking on the whole big catechism. I love because it because it is so beautiful and a real treasure of our Catholic faith, even though hard to read for some. It is so full of inspiring quotes from saints and scripture verses. I don’t think most people just sit down and read the Catechism from beginning to end. I use it to look up all different topics and teachings when I am unsure about something.

Can you quote what Youcat says on birth control. I am interested in what it says.
Someone with better typing skills than I have can try to type it all out. I can say that there are 6 questions directly dealing with children in marriage, NFP and artificial fertilization. One statement from the YOUCAT is,
" the Church rejects all artificial means of contraception - namely, chemical methods (the Pill), mechanical methods (condom, IUD) and surgical methods (sterilization)…"
Suffice to say there are a number of pages on children in marriage. One thing that detractors of the YOUCAT try to do is to quote a small portion of the book, claiming somehow that the YOUCAT is watered down. 🤷 But anyone looking at the actual book would see there is much more than is ever quoted.
 
Someone with better typing skills than I have can try to type it all out. I can say that there are 6 questions directly dealing with children in marriage, NFP and artificial fertilization. One statement from the YOUCAT is,

Suffice to say there are a number of pages on children in marriage. One thing that detractors of the YOUCAT try to do is to quote a small portion of the book, claiming somehow that the YOUCAT is watered down. 🤷 But anyone looking at the actual book would see there is much more than is ever quoted.
The term “artificial means of contraception” does seem to create the question- are there “natural” means of contraception?

As as the YOUCAT being helpful to some people, I have no doubt it is. It will tell you far more about the Catholic faith then most books out there.

Say someone is a buddhist. If they start going to a Lutheran Church and reading the NIV Bible, they will get a much better understanding of God. However, they won’t get the fullness of Truth found in the Catholic Faith.

Something can be much better than a lot of other alternatives, and still have serious problems.

I do agree that many 20 or 30 or 40 somethings are not very well equiped to read substantial books on theology. We must ask ourselves the important question…WHY? Why is the ability to read and comprehend spiritual writing a vanishing art? Why is childhood being continually extended into what once was adulthood? There are many causes, but one of the main ones directly related to catechesis is the modern school system- both public and parochial and how it retards intellectual growth and delays the assumption of adult responsiblities.

An explanation of the gospel tailored to a 7 year old is appropriate for a 7 year old. Unfortunately, what happens in Catholic schools and Religious Education programs all over the place is that the person keeps getting the explanation for the 7 year old regurgitated to them each year. The understanding at a 7 year old level is good for a 7 year old. It is catastrophic for an 18 year old. This is very widespread. This problem leads to attempts like the YOUCAT, which I think was well intentioned but poorly executed.

Pax
 
Here’s a specific example of how the YOUCAT’s “watered down” or “dumbed down” explantion on a topic can be misleading to the reader.

It describes belief that the world was created in 6 24-hour days as “naive” and “crossing a line”. That is the opinion of whoever wrote the passage in the YOUCAT, not the teaching of the Church. It fails to mention what the Church does teach on the topic, which is that belief the world was created in 6 24-hour days, is an orthodox Catholic position.

Pax and God bless.
 
One thing that detractors of the YOUCAT try to do is to quote a small portion of the book, claiming somehow that the YOUCAT is watered down. .
😃 I think you have a point. See?
Here’s a specific example of how the YOUCAT’s “watered down” or “dumbed down” explantion on a topic can be misleading to the reader.

It describes belief that the world was created in 6 24-hour days as “naive” and "crossing a line
 
The catechism is more of a reference book. Not normally something you would sit down and read, cover to cover.
The CCC is a great reference. However, like the Bible, it is still helpful to read it from cover to cover at least once. Otherwise, this reference may spend too much time sitting on the shelf with other reference works. If the Youcat makes that easier, then that is one vital function the Youcat serves. I read the CCC for myself when I joined the Church, then I read the CCC through twice more with each of my children when they joined the Church later. I wish I had something like the Youcat to make that process easier.
 
Here’s a specific example of how the YOUCAT’s “watered down” or “dumbed down” explantion on a topic can be misleading to the reader.

It describes belief that the world was created in 6 24-hour days as “naive” and “crossing a line”. That is the opinion of whoever wrote the passage in the YOUCAT, not the teaching of the Church. It fails to mention what the Church does teach on the topic, which is that belief the world was created in 6 24-hour days, is an orthodox Catholic position.

Pax and God bless.
Looking at the Subject Index, there are 32 references for Creation and plan of Creation. Yet all you quote just a couple of words.

Also, you expect that all of the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church to be in the YOUCAT, as well as all teachings of the Orthodox Church? Really?
 
Looking at the Subject Index, there are 32 references for Creation and plan of Creation. Yet all you quote just a couple of words.

Also, you expect that all of the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church to be in the YOUCAT, as well as all teachings of the Orthodox Church? Really?
None of the other sections correct the misleading impression given by the passage I quoted.

Pax
 
I have read the Youcat and like the format. The book provides a short answer and refers you to the exact paragraphs of the Adult Catechism for additional information. It is not a watered down version of the Adult Catechism. It even includes the revised prayers for Mass. Please read question 192 to understand the changes in the mass.
The book is intended for the google generation which is familiar with a short answer and a link, Not the encyclopedia generation of their parents.
 
your criticism of the You Cat misses the point. the question is not about whether the You Cat is soft on certain issues but whether it accurately reflects the the adult catechism.
 
A close reading of the You Cat indicates that the prayers in the book are not the current prayers but the new revised prayers. I suggest the critics wait until after Advent to determine how many errors there are in the You Cat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top