Your side on masturbation

  • Thread starter Thread starter xSteven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
… Never have they mentioned masturbating. My church has never mentioned it either. That’s when I changed and stopped masturbating.

But I had a lot of questions and I found this forum to ask my questions. I was going to ask my priest but it’s just a little awkward.

I remember reading that it’s terrible to change the word of God to something else. If masturbation ISN’T in the Bible, why do we believe it’s a sin. Isn’t it changing/making a new word of God?
Hello xSteven
Just taking a rain-check with you as you haven’t contributed for a day or so?

Are you cool with the above advice or is there something more you’d like to ask or clarify?
 
The Catholic Church is very clear about the fact that masturbation is sinful. “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of “the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved.”

I personally think that if you are seperating sexual pleasure away from the desire to be united to another person, you are actually perverting the action even more than if you were engaging in fantasies. At least in fantasies you are holding onto the idea that it is about uniting with another person. That’s not saying its moral to do it with fantasies. I’m just saying that you’re further perverting it.
 
I wonder how many people who are posting are married, I also wonder how many followed all these high and moral roads when they were dating and I wonder if the advice would come on so strong if they were single. I am not saying it’s not wrong, just some of the attitude makes me wonder. It’s so easy to tell people to totally abstain when you don’t have to.
 
‘My side’ is complicated.

At its most basic level it is simple. Yes it is a sin.

It is a sin against one’s body (in that it can feed addictive passions and interferes with healthy sexual relations with our spouses) and if the ‘fantasy’ used is directed at someone it can be a sin against them as Jesus Christ explicitly says in the Bible.

Too many people seem to think that sexual desire is a hunger you can and need to feed. The reality, though is that sexual desire is a flame that grows hotter the more fuel you throw in. It may seem to grow quiet for a time after but this is an illusion. Too many people seem to think that sexual ‘deviants’ (such as pedophiles) occur or can occur because people don’t relieve the stress. The reality, though, if I understand it correctly, is that sexual deviants, of all forms, are not undersexed, but oversexed. They often start having sex (often ‘normal’ sex) quite early and have large stores of pornography, etc.

That does not mean that masturbation always leads to or is the major leader to these sins. But we are not called to be merely adequate; we are called to perfection and to avoid all sins and all that leads us to sin.

The Church uses other reasons that can often seem (and sometimes are) quite convoluted and often seems to miss the point. But the Church has much wisdom and those that ignore it ignore it at their own peril. (With those who have greater access to that wisdom at much greater peril.)

Perhaps I should stop at this simplicity. But complications enter when we observe that our society has much graver concerns than masturbation. Too many on this board, in our Church, and in our society treat every sin as if they are the most grievous sins. On one level this is good; as I stated earlier we are not called to mere adequacy, but to perfection. But on another level this is bad; on the way to perfection we have to start (but not end) with the most grievous sins. To treat masturbation the same as adultery, or premarital sex, or remarriage after a divorce is a sin against society.

Finally, I would be amiss, if I did not note that way too many people on this board commit an equally grave sin when they offer to pluck the splinter out of your eye without first asking others to remove the plank from theirs. (Unfortunately, this statement probably applies to me as well.)
 
I wonder how many people who are posting are married, I also wonder how many followed all these high and moral roads when they were dating and I wonder if the advice would come on so strong if they were single. I am not saying it’s not wrong, just some of the attitude makes me wonder. It’s so easy to tell people to totally abstain when you don’t have to.
It can be frustrating, but in the end it doesn’t matter, except to them, why they offer the advice they do. Unfortunately, there are way too many hypocrites (one is too many) who pile loads on others that they make excuses for not carrying themselves. Their unfaithfulness and hypocrisy does not justify our unfaithfulness, though.

Finally, just because you are married does not necessarily mean that you don’t have to ‘abstain’ and it sometime makes the periods of abstention harder.
 
Finally, just because you are married does not necessarily mean that you don’t have to ‘abstain’ and it sometime makes the periods of abstention harder.
Indeed. As a married man who is used to reasonably frequent sex, any periods of abstinence are very hard!

I don’t think anyone can reasonably suggest that abstinence/chastity is easy. I know that it is not and would hope to never come across as judging those who struggle, for I struggle too. Likewise, the Church itself recognises this fact, even in the catechism itself, and I’ve not met or confessed to a priest who doesn’t empathise on this issue.

As with all sins, we do our best and when we fall we come back before God, say sorry, and ask for strength to pick ourselves up again. But that fact that this is a very hard sin to master does not diminish our responsibility to attempt to master it.
 
xSteven,

First off, I feel your pain. I have battled with masturbation for a long time as well. It comes and goes and right now the problem is back. I have used it in very similar ways, sometimes just to get rid of stress. And I’ve found that it only added more problems. I thought that by getting my frustrations, lustful thoughts, and stress out while I was alone, I wasn’t hurting anyone…but in the end it really hurts ME.

Like many others have already said, the church teaches that masturbation is wrong. Period. Why? I believe it is because our church understands that sin starts in the mind. If we continually give into lustful thoughts, we will never get the self-control to resist those same temptations when put in a situation with another person. It’s not a slippery-slope argument, it’s planning ahead.

It is very hard to break the habit. I know this first hand. You can battle it all day long, but our church teaches that it is wrong…so where do you go from here? Just a few tips and verses that have helped me:
~“For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways says the Lord.” - Isaiah 55:8 (His way is different from our instincts…that doesn’t make it incorrect.)
~“Do not conform yourselves to this age but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and pleasing and perfect.” -Romans 12:2 (I could talk about this for hours, but suffice it to say the part about renewing your mind is important. If you’re having a hard time with lustful thoughts, FORCE yourself to think about other things. I turn on Christian music when I go to bed…because let’s face it, that’s the hardest time to resist. I also have a cross I keep by my bed, and sometimes I have to physically hold it to keep my own hands in check. But it works. Being blasted with God guilts me away from those impure thoughts. Finally, I have sticky notes ALL over my room with quotes, verses, etc. Yes, it’s obnoxious, but if I’m going to have a “renewal of my mind” I need to see God everywhere instead of TV shows and posters of attractive bodies. We think what we see, we think what we hear…so look at and listen to better things and it will get easier.)
~ As far as the stress goes, find something else to take it out on. Music, boxing, running if you’re into that (works for me). Do something that will wear you out so you won’t have the energy left.
~Last bit and I promise I’ll shut up…make a plan. Psychologists say it takes about a month to break a habit. So I put a rubber band around my wrist (no on else knows that it even means anything). Whenever I mess up, I change wrists. I will keep it on til I’ve been free for a month…which I’m excited to say is soon. Do what you gotta do. And PRAY. Alone, you will never be strong enough to face any temptation. But with God, you can overcome anything. Pray to Him about it; He loves honesty. God bless!

~Me2nd
 
Good Grief…we continue to justify whatever we desire to do regardless of empirical evidence to the contrary & Holy Mother Church Teaching. "The spirit is willing but the flesh is weak.’ Has been and always will be, but what the hell does the Church know? (-*

When I rob a bank I hope I can generate 100 pages in the forums of folks arguing about the right & wrong of it. Sheesh.
 
What’s your side on it? I personally believe it is not a sin for many reasons.
I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore.

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
 
When I rob a bank I hope I can generate 100 pages in the forums of folks arguing about the right & wrong of it. Sheesh.
What a terrible analogy, LOL!!! Come on, at least come up with something reasonably close. :rolleyes:
 
I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore.

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
It does not mean that you don’t love God. One can be on fire for Jesus and still masturbate, but it does mean that you love yourself more than you love God.

-Tim-
 
**I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore. **

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
Toddlers touch themselves because they don’t know any better. Masturbation is self-directed sexual contact. God meant us to share ourselves with our husband or wife, and receive the benefits of sexual intimacy thereby. NOT to self-stimulate with fantasies and pornography.

Are you seriously saying that since God created us, we are not capable of sin?

:confused::mad:
 
Thank you for that site. That helped me a lot. I read all about it. I still have a few questions.

I understand that masturbation can be for pleasure. It stated that it is not used for love between two. Can’t married couples have sex just for the pleasure also?

Also how do we know this is a sin? Where does it say in the Bible?
With masturbation, you cannot have children.
With pleasure in married couples, even if you do not want, you may have children. I fact, I know of several kids who were born that way.
The Bible does not need to say everything. God gave us our intelligence to take conclusions. Moreover, the interpretation of the Bible does not belong to the individuals but to the Community connected to the Pope.
It is the Protestant that interpret the Bible at will…
 
I agree. Why would a loving God create people exactly the way he wanted them, and then spend the rest of life on earth punishing them for how he created them?? Doesn’t fit with my world view anymore.

Toddlers masturbate. It’s a normal, human thing. We were created as sexual beings. Should you become obsessed with it? No, you shouldn’t become obsessed with anything. Does it mean you don’t love God if you do it? I don’t even know where this idea came from, it’s ludicrous.
Dont question God. It is Him who questions you.
I agree that there is some obsession with masturbation but comes from inside. People do not want to masturbate so they ask for help. OK?
So, would you mind to say if everything that is done with sex nowadays is all right? There is no actions done which are wrong? Do you accept every sex action that you see splattered in the papers?
Or do you set boundaries? If yes, where are the boundaries?
 
It does not mean that you don’t love God. One can be on fire for Jesus and still masturbate, but it does mean that you love yourself more than you love God.

-Tim-
I would not mix the 2 things.
Like the cleptomaniac has desordered impulses to steal, in this situation it is a sexual imbalance more than lack of love for God.
 
xSteven,

First off, I feel your pain. I have battled with masturbation for a long time as well. It comes and goes and right now the problem is back. I have used it in very similar ways, sometimes just to get rid of stress. And I’ve found that it only added more problems. I thought that by getting my frustrations, lustful thoughts, and stress out while I was alone, I wasn’t hurting anyone…but in the end it really hurts ME.

Like many others have already said, the church teaches that masturbation is wrong. Period. Why? I believe it is because our church understands that sin starts in the mind. If we continually give into lustful thoughts, we will never get the self-control to resist those same temptations when put in a situation with another person. It’s not a slippery-slope argument, it’s planning ahead.

It is very hard to break the habit. I know this first hand. You can battle it all day long, but our church teaches that it is wrong…so where do you go from here? Just a few tips and verses that have helped me:
~“For my thoughts are not your thoughts, nor are your ways my ways says the Lord.” - Isaiah 55:8 (His way is different from our instincts…that doesn’t make it incorrect.)
~“Do not conform yourselves to this age but be transformed by the renewal of your mind, that you may discern what is the will of God, what is good and pleasing and perfect.” -Romans 12:2 (I could talk about this for hours, but suffice it to say the part about renewing your mind is important. If you’re having a hard time with lustful thoughts, FORCE yourself to think about other things. I turn on Christian music when I go to bed…because let’s face it, that’s the hardest time to resist. I also have a cross I keep by my bed, and sometimes I have to physically hold it to keep my own hands in check. But it works. Being blasted with God guilts me away from those impure thoughts. Finally, I have sticky notes ALL over my room with quotes, verses, etc. Yes, it’s obnoxious, but if I’m going to have a “renewal of my mind” I need to see God everywhere instead of TV shows and posters of attractive bodies. We think what we see, we think what we hear…so look at and listen to better things and it will get easier.)
~ As far as the stress goes, find something else to take it out on. Music, boxing, running if you’re into that (works for me). Do something that will wear you out so you won’t have the energy left.
~Last bit and I promise I’ll shut up…make a plan. Psychologists say it takes about a month to break a habit. So I put a rubber band around my wrist (no on else knows that it even means anything). Whenever I mess up, I change wrists. I will keep it on til I’ve been free for a month…which I’m excited to say is soon. Do what you gotta do. And PRAY. Alone, you will never be strong enough to face any temptation. But with God, you can overcome anything. Pray to Him about it; He loves honesty. God bless!

~Me2nd
I do not think that you are going the right way.
Take the stress out of your life, lead a balanced life and masturbation is gone.
Let’s not put God in everything. We must act too.
 
Masturbation is a release of tension.
If we lead an unbalanced life or if we do not know how to balance our lives or if our lives are full of stress, we feel unhappy, stressed and need relieve that may come through masturbation or drinking or whatever.
So, everything that makes us lead better with stress is helpful: meditation, meditation and meditation, yoga, jogging, rosary, confession, communion, forgive, forgive and forgive our fellow brothers, trust in God, help others, smile, smile and smile, pray to our Mother, the Mother of God.
 
What about the influence of mental illness? How does it impact whether one is culpable? I read somewhere that the mentally ill are not culpable. They incur the consequences of sin, but they have not necessarily committed a mortal sin. The letter was written by a Catholic Cardinal.
Here’s the link to:** **
Code:
							 								 								 								**God's Image In  								the Mentally Ill Person**
							** 								 								**Cardinal Lozano Barragán's  								Address at World Day of the Sick
penitents.org/mentalillness.htm

. Having known many mentally ill persons, I tend to believe this is likely the case.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top