Your side on masturbation

  • Thread starter Thread starter xSteven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If a friend of yours was an obese comfort-eater, and said he needed chocolate to reduce stress and get chocolate-fantasies out of his head, what would you say to him?
 
Someone up there said Catholics, Protestants, etc are all part of the Christian faith. So if Jesus said the Church is his word, how would that work out if Protestants and Catholics believe differently? Do you understand what I’m trying to say? It’s hard to word.
xSteven,

Christianity is Orthodox, Catholic and we accept Protestants baptized in the Trinitarian formula as Christian…

Those baptized in the Trinitarian formula may be

Anglican
Calvinist
Methodist
Baptist
The Church of What’s happnin now and golly

but for the most part…None have Apostolic succession or as the Catechism says…heirarchal organizations that provide for elements of the fullness of the Faith…and those that are what are called ecclesial communities have the only authority as the Bible interpreted by them…so these here folk believe what they believe the Bible says and they differ thus showing how the Bible alone cannot be what was intended for One Lord, One Faith, One Baptism…
 
i really still dont understand stand. someone said catholics are christians, prorestants are christians. so we are all christians. but protestants and catholics believe differently yet we are christians. No one answrred me yet of how can jesus words be in the church when wdifferent religions of christianity belueve different things. idk how else to word it but you guys arent getting what im saying.
 
Someone up there said Catholics, Protestants, etc are all part of the Christian faith. So if Jesus said the Church is his word, how would that work out if Protestants and Catholics believe differently? Do you understand what I’m trying to say? It’s hard to word.
The Church isn’t the same thing as the Christian faith, obviously, so I don’t know what you’re getting at.
 
hmm. ill try again. like you know how protestant, catholic, etc is all part of christianity faith? Someone states that Jesus said that the Church word is also his word. so for example pritestant and catholics believe different things, yet their both apart of christianity so how would that be possible of Jesus saying that its his word? does that make more sense?🤷
 
hmm. ill try again. like you know how protestant, catholic, etc is all part of christianity faith? Someone states that Jesus said that the Church word is also his word. so for example pritestant and catholics believe different things, yet their both apart of christianity so how would that be possible of Jesus saying that its his word? does that make more sense?🤷
Christ said He would be with “you” (i.e., the apostles) until the end of the age. Thus He would be with the Church. If people choose to leave the Church than Christ is no longer with them, i.e., they are no longer protected from error. That’s why Protestants believe different things, i.e., they abandoned the Church and so embraced error.
 
Protestants are all over the map on moral theology because they have no one to say, “Thus sayeth The Lord.” A Protestant pastor could give a sermon on why he believes masturbation is a sin, but anyone in the congregation could say, “We’ll, that’s his opinion.” The people in the congregation may respect the pastor and his training, but they are free to simply disregard what he says, despite E number of bible verses he uses to support his idea. If they don’t like the pastor’s ideas, THEY are the ones who fire him and find someone they want to listen to.

Seriously, the Bible CLEARLY states that divorce and remarriage are sins of adultery, yet Protestants, by and large, reject this idea. Why should it surprise us that they have drifted away from this morality against masturbation? They have rejected the God-given moral authority: the Catholic Magisterium. Am I proud of that? No. Why would I be happy if my best friend, a Protestant, doesn’t have the surety of moral guidance in living a moral life like I do? Does tht mean I AM more moral? No. It just means that I have access to infallible moral truths that give me assurance of what God expects of me.

CCC:
“It is this Magisterium’s task to preserve God’s people from deviations and defections and to guarantee them the objective possibility of professing the true faith without error… To fulfill this service, Christ endowed the Church’s shepherds with the charism of infallibility in matters of faith and morals.” (Catechism, 890)
 
I’m not referring to the protestants. It was an example. I’m just saying Jesus said his word is also with the Church. But if different branches of Christianity believe different things, that makes no sense?:confused:
 
You’re right, in a sense. Shouldn’t all Christians teach the same things? I guess my point is, Protestantism, by nature, is Rationalism. Each individual Protestant doesn’t accept a belief unless it is filtered through their own reason. Catholics don’t deny reason, but they would say that if the Church says it is true, then I believe it. I can take my time in learning why it is true and understanding the reasoning behind the teaching, but since Christ has given us assurance that the Catholic Church cannot error when she teaches on matters of faith and morals, I can rest easy that this is, in fact, what God expects of me. I can accept,it without having to understand all the details undergirding the conclusions.

Protestants don’t believe in any living authority, so on matters like masturbation, there is no “Protestant teaching”.

30,000 denominations after the Protestant revolt should tell us that there is serious division problems when you reject God’s appointed authority.

I understand that you use Protestants as an example, but all Christians are either Catholic or Protestant. So I use Protestants in the wider sense.
 
What’s your side on it? I personally believe it is not a sin for many reasons.
  1. When we don’t masturbate, we get more lustful thoughts in our heads making us sin more, and think/do/say bad things.
  2. we have wet dreams so we are still spilling the “seed” and wet dreams is still masturbating in our sleep
  3. Some people don’t masturbate for pleasure all the time. It can be used to get rid of stress, and our lustful thoughts. I remember I just coulden’t focus on anything, all i could think of was lusful thoughts and I would tell myself “STOP! This is not what God wants!” I just couldent focus to pray to him, or get these thoughts out of my head. How else would I get them out?
  4. If you shoot someone, the gun isn’t the sinful part. So masturbation is the gun, and lust, addiction are the killing things. I just believe in that.
P.S. I am a Roman Catholic and I am sitll confused on wether masturbation is a sin or not. I do go to church every sunday and pray daily.

Thanks!🙂 Bless you all!
Since I am Catholic, my side is on the side of the Church that I belong to and love and on the side of my Savior. How could I believe any of my faith if my Church was wrong on this?
  1. Woah there buddy, dont use the collective “we” here. That is flat out not true. Very holy celibate saints have been our examples. But what you are describing sounds an awful lot like signs of withdraw from an addiction.
  2. You are not responsible for your subconscious. If you dream about murder you did not commit murder…🤷
    3 “some people” may have mitigating circumstances. That does not change the gravity of the sin but only their level of culpability.
    4??? That is not logical. And I believe in logic…
Since you are a Catholic you need to educate yourself on what the church teaches about grave matter and mortal sin. What three things are needed for a sin to be mortal and what the Church teaches and why. You could start with the Chatechism and end with Theology of the Body or a book about Theology of the Body.
 
Since I am Catholic, my side is on the side of the Church that I belong to and love and on the side of my Savior. How could I believe any of my faith if my Church was wrong on this?
  1. Woah there buddy, dont use the collective “we” here. That is flat out not true. Very holy celibate saints have been our examples. But what you are describing sounds an awful lot like signs of withdraw from an addiction.
  2. You are not responsible for your subconscious. If you dream about murder you did not commit murder…🤷
    3 “some people” may have mitigating circumstances. That does not change the gravity of the sin but only their level of culpability.
    4??? That is not logical. And I believe in logic…
Since you are a Catholic you need to educate yourself on what the church teaches about grave matter and mortal sin. What three things are needed for a sin to be mortal and what the Church teaches and why. You could start with the Chatechism and end with Theology of the Body or a book about Theology of the Body.
So your saying if I sleep walk and kill someone in my sleep it’s not a sin. Exactly what a wet dream is. Your sleeping and ejaculate. Same thing. I still have no clue why it’s a sin for other reasons up there about Jesus saying that his word is in the Church. I respect my faith and I love Jesus. I haven’t masturbated in a very very long time because I can’t figure out whether it’s a sin or not!
 
Your body is the temple of the Holy Spirit. Sin separates us from God. It is written in the Bible that you have to respect your body and otherses too in order to be in the Spirit. You can so easily get into a vicious circle imagining wilder and wilder situations, it can be to a certain extent when your relatives become your subject. The joy of a mature christian man comes from his relationship with Christ. If you are called for marriage you will eventually see that this custom might make you apprciate your wife less after all you have been through with yourself. If you really feel that God is important to you try believingin Him, try trusting Him. He cares more about your stress than you would imagine. This whole thing makes you more important than Him for yourself. I hope I could help.

Edit: You have been doing great so far for looking for Christ’s will. Try readin Chorintians 6 9-20.
 
I’m not referring to the protestants. It was an example. I’m just saying Jesus said his word is also with the Church. But if different branches of Christianity believe different things, that makes no sense?:confused:
Because different branches of Christianity aren’t the Church. The Church is the Church. So of course the Church believes what is true (because God protects them from error) and of course others believe stuff that’s false. Again, what doesn’t make sense about this?
So your saying if I sleep walk and kill someone in my sleep it’s not a sin.
Correct, it isn’t. Sin requires complicity of the will as well as full knowledge of what you’re doing, both faculties of which are impaired in a state of sleep.
 
how arent they the church? When Jesus died all they had was Christianity and later on it broke up into different branches. so when god said The churchs word is my word. he was talking about christianity? yet we are all apart of the christianity faith?
 
how arent they the church? When Jesus died all they had was Christianity and later on it broke up into different branches. so when god said The churchs word is my word. he was talking about christianity?
They are not the Church because they are not in unity with the authority which Christ established, namely the Bishops (most especially the Pope, according to Catholicism), who are the successors of the Apostles.
yet we are all apart of the christianity faith?
In the sense that we all believe Christ is Lord - but in fact, we are divided because some have left the truth to various degrees.
 
I understand that you use Protestants as an example, but all Christians are either Catholic or Protestant. So I use Protestants in the wider sense.
Do you include the Orthodox under “Protestant”?
 
They have much in common with the One True Church, but their theology is basically stagnant because there has not been an ecumenical council since the schism of east and west that they recognize as authoritative. Also, there is no one to say, “Thus sayeth the Lord,” since the bishops are not individually infallible. They are, according to Catholic theology, schismatic but valid Churches. However, they do not have he fullness of truth, so there are errors in their theology and morality.

Examples of errors include: allowing divorce and remarriage, birth control, rejecting the supreme authority of the Pope, papal infallibility, the Filioque.

So, to answer your question, no I wouldn’t include EO as Protestants, but I’d do so with certain reservations. They are still schismatic.
 
They are not the Church because they are not in unity with the authority which Christ established, namely the Bishops (most especially the Pope, according to Catholicism), who are the successors of the Apostles.

In the sense that we all believe Christ is Lord - but in fact, we are divided because some have left the truth to various degrees.
So what Jesus said was inaccurate?
 
So what Jesus said was inaccurate?
Which words of Jesus are you referring to?

I don’t think Jesus ever promised that no believer would ever fall into error, or that there wouldn’t be schisms.

The visible authority Christ has set up, however, has never fallen into definitely teaching error, according to Catholicism.
 
Do you include the Orthodox under “Protestant”?
Miles,

You appear to be nieve in your understanding of Christianity. I suggest you study the Catechism…

Monothiesm is belief in one God. To be Monothiestic is to adhere to Islam, Judaism or Christianity.

Christianity at its commencement was Catholic and that Catholicity is retained by the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church. Sins of men caused a seperation in the west that caused Protestanism.

So Christians are Catholic, Orthodox or Protestant. Protestants are Christian by their Trinitarian Baptism but not necessarily by their profession of Faith, and that profession may include many and varied teachings on Morality.

If you were to search Abortion/Protestant you will see that there are varied opinions that changed over time, an element that allows you to understand that:
  1. There is no such thing as a Protestant Church of any authority
  2. Protestants varying on this issue and others cannot have the fullness of the truth, because the truth cannot change. Either abortion is murder or it is not and there was a time when Protestants of varying sorts accepted Abortion…
The following comes from the USA catechism…study and understand this…if you have questions, ask…🙂
The Catholic Church retains the structures of episcopal leadership and sacramental life that are the gift of Christ to his Church (cf. CCC, nos. 765, 766) and that date back to apostolic times. At the same time, the Catholic Church recognizes that the Holy Spirit uses other churches and ecclesial communities “as means of salvation, whose power derives from the fullness of grace and truth that Christ has entrusted to the Catholic Church” (CCC, no. 819; LG, no. 8). Depending on what and how much of the elements of sanctincation and truth (UR, no. 3) these communities have retained, they have a certain though imperfect com¬munion with the Catholic Church. There are also real differences. In some cases “there are very weighty differences not only of a historical, sociological, psychological and cultural character, but especially in the interpretation of revealed truth” (UR, no. 19). (The word church applies to those bodies of Christians who have a valid episcopal leadership or hierarchy, while the phrase ecclesial communities refers to those bodies of Christians that do not have an apostolic hierarchy.)
I too would like to know what it is you keep speaking of when you refer to Jesus and Church?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top