Your side on masturbation

  • Thread starter Thread starter xSteven
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
XSteve,

The Church has spoken means that the Church has declared…Christ built a Church and that Church is the pillar and foundation of truth…therefore what the Church proclaims is truth…what is Doctrine? Doctrine is meditation and thinking with prayer guiding by the Holy Spirit…The Church thinks, prays and with the guidance of the Holy Spirit declares teachings we call Doctrine.

There are many different forms of Christianity that do not acknowledge what we profess in the creed…
So he’s saying that the Church’s word is also God’s word?
 
So he’s saying that the Church’s word is also God’s word?
xSteve,

Have you read the Catechism?

This is the deposit of Faith, that you should know, and if you have not read it I suggest you get a copy of the Audio USA Catechism for Adults so that the answer to this question will be revealed in your listening…

The deposit of Faith is our Faith and the author of our Faith is God and when the Church speaks on Fatih and Morals it is speaking for God…Ok…👍
 
xSteve,

Have you read the Catechism?

This is the deposit of Faith, that you should know, and if you have not read it I suggest you get a copy of the Audio USA Catechism for Adults so that the answer to this question will be revealed in your listening…

The deposit of Faith is our Faith and the author of our Faith is God and when the Church speaks on Fatih and Morals it is speaking for God…Ok…👍
I have never read it, I’m only 15 :confused:
 
QUOTE=xSteven;10211943]I have never read it, I’m only 15 :confused:

Here’s an online link:
scborromeo.org/ccc/index/m.htm

…2352 By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure. "Both the Magisterium of the Church, in the course of a constant tradition, and the moral sense of the faithful have been in no doubt and have firmly maintained that masturbation is an intrinsically and gravely disordered action."138 “The deliberate use of the sexual faculty, for whatever reason, outside of marriage is essentially contrary to its purpose.” For here sexual pleasure is sought outside of "the sexual relationship which is demanded by the moral order and in which the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love is achieved."139

To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. …

Note there is some consideration, per the last sentence, considering your age, etc…
 
The catechism definition:
By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure

So…if the person doesn’t derive or seek “sexual pleasure” from it, but only does it for a basic relief of physical tension that is bodily painful…then it would not be disordered? I wouldn’t fit the definition, in that case.
" …To form an equitable judgment about the subjects’ moral responsibility and to guide pastoral action, one must take into account the affective immaturity, force of acquired habit, conditions of anxiety or other psychological or social factors that lessen, if not even reduce to a minimum, moral culpability. … "

you and your confessor may interpret this “loophole” as you choose, notwithstanding warranted moral scrutiny from sources not of this world…

this “disclaimer” is the source of much debate…
 
The catechism definition:
By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure

So…if the person doesn’t derive or seek “sexual pleasure” from it,** but only does it for a basic relief of physical tension that is bodily painful**…then it would not be disordered? I wouldn’t fit the definition, in that case.
Daddy ma girl,

And this reason for masturbation you derive from where?
 
What’s your side on it? I personally believe it is not a sin for many reasons.
I found this thread searching for other posts you have made, and have read two other threads asking for help because you are having doubts about the existence of God, and if you are wasting your time trying to pray. Now that I see this thread, the reason for the other two becomes clear.

Any mortal sin separates us from the grace of God infused into us at our baptism. Your sense of separation from God and doubts about your faith are a natural outgrowth of your position on this topic.

God has created us, so He gets to decide how we function best, and the parameters /commandments we need to have a healthy happy life. Whether or not you agree with His commandments is really irrelevant. You don’t get to be the one to make the rules, the Creator does.
  1. When we don’t masturbate, we get more lustful thoughts in our heads making us sin more, and think/do/say bad things.
It may seem this way to you now, but trying to cure a grave evil by committing another grave evil will only eventually bear evil fruit.
Code:
2) we have wet dreams so we are still spilling the "seed" and wet dreams is still masturbating in our sleep
No, wet dreams are NOT masturbating in your sleep. They are a reflection of your unconscious expressing itself. This is not an act of the will, but a natural function of the human nature. Masturbation, on the other hand, is a willful, conscious choice toward self pleasuring.
  1. Some people don’t masturbate for pleasure all the time. It can be used to get rid of stress, and our lustful thoughts. I remember I just coulden’t focus on anything, all i could think of was lusful thoughts and I would tell myself “STOP! This is not what God wants!” I just couldent focus to pray to him, or get these thoughts out of my head. How else would I get them out?
This is a good point, and a good question. Yes, many people use it to cope with stress and lustful thoughts. I would also agree that just telling yourself “STOP” is not a very effective method of managing your hormones and natural fleshly impulses. There are a number of other suggestions that have already been provided for you, so I will suffice to say that you have an innate desire for intimacy that needs to be fulfilled. The healthiest way to fill this is within relationship. It is a good time of life to spend some of your energies in serving others, and giving sacrificially of yourself to the poor and needy. When you are helping the suffering, you will not find much room in your head for lustful thoughts.
  1. If you shoot someone, the gun isn’t the sinful part. So masturbation is the gun, and lust, addiction are the killing things. I just believe in that.
I agree with your point, but you have your attributions wrong. The sexual organs are not a sinful part, in and of themselves. God gave them to you for a specific purpose.

Masturbation is the act of employing the gifts that God gave you in a manner that is lustful and addicting. It results in killing the grace of God in your soul, and you will end up feeling alientated from Him, and unable to connect, feel His presence, or even believe He exists. That is why it is called “mortal” (because it is deadly to the soul).
P.S. I am a Roman Catholic and I am sitll confused on wether masturbation is a sin or not. I do go to church every sunday and pray daily.

Thanks!🙂 Bless you all!
I would recommend that you set aside your own ideas, because humans are so prone to rationaliIng sin. Just accept what the Church teaches about it, and proceed accordingly.
 
I have never read it, I’m only 15 :confused:
It’s ok xSteven. You are getting an early start in your faith formation. When I was 15 I could not even frame the kind of questions you ask! 👍

The advice is good, though, you can read the catechism free online, or download it and listen on mp3.

You have gotten the answers you need right now, though, on these threads, so don’t feel overwhelmed by the task of learning your faith all at once. You have made a very good beginning.
 
The catechism definition:
By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure

So…if the person doesn’t derive or seek “sexual pleasure” from it, but only does it for a basic relief of physical tension that is bodily painful…then it would not be disordered? I wouldn’t fit the definition, in that case.
Let me get this right…

Masturbation for relief of physical tension that is bodily painful?

Are you suggesting that there is no other way to relieve physical tension or pain?

Using the sexual faculty to meet such needs does seem to be quite disordered.

What would Jesus do, if He needed relief from physical tension and body pain?
 
The catechism definition:
By masturbation is to be understood the deliberate stimulation of the genital organs in order to derive sexual pleasure

So…if the person doesn’t derive or seek “sexual pleasure” from it, but only does it for a basic relief of physical tension that is bodily painful…then it would not be disordered? I wouldn’t fit the definition, in that case.
Why is it even disordered? Disordered in what way? I think it’s a false connection between sexual pleasure and reproduction. The two are not connected as far as I’m concerned. For me the primary function of the sex organs is to enjoy sex, and nothing to do with reproduction. And I don’t think you have to be married to enjoy sexual pleasure.
 
OK, I haven’t read all of the responses, I’ll throw that out there first. I just want to ask one question. You said you were a practicing Roman Catholic; it should follow that you submit yourself to the authority of the Magisterium. Why, then, do you not trust their authority in this matter? They say it is always a grave matter; whether or not it is a mortal sin every time is based off of numerous factors, which I’m sure plenty have outlined for you already after 13 pages of results.

Your obligation as a Roman Catholic is to submit yourself to the Church’s teachings whether or not you understand them. It is good to be researching the “why” of this particular teaching, but you have to get the official Church teaching on it, not just any old website out there. Holy Mother Church knows what she is talking about.

Operate under “faith seeking understanding” - you must have faith that the Church is correct in this matter, and continue to obtain that understanding - reasoning behind why it is that way. You’ll be in my prayers!
 
Why is it even disordered? Disordered in what way? I think it’s a false connection between sexual pleasure and reproduction. The two are not connected as far as I’m concerned. For me the primary function of the sex organs is to enjoy sex, and nothing to do with reproduction. And I don’t think you have to be married to enjoy sexual pleasure.
it is disordered because the person masturbating is falling into their temptation of lust, I understand your opinion and I used to have a similar one until I recognized the church’s teaching. masturbation is a result of temptation, one is only doing it to fulfill lusting desires instead.

many say it is harmless but its breaking the charity and bond between you and God - you may laugh and say nonsense but think about it. what to people do when they masturbate they think and entertain lustful fantasies and nurture this thoughts which lead to more fantasies and porn which degrades the people in it, and supports an industry that is notorious for degrading people and I even know people from my high school who went into the porn industry and they proudly have displayed their life of drug usage and watching documentaries on the industry its in no way a kind one.
 
Why, then, do you not trust their authority in this matter?
I suppose it’s because when I could think about these things for myself, what I was being told didn’t make any sense.
Your obligation as a Roman Catholic is to submit yourself to the Church’s teachings whether or not you understand them.
That’s the bit I can’t do anymore.
you must have faith that the Church is correct in this matter, and continue to obtain that understanding - reasoning behind why it is that way.
As far as I can see it’s because sex is described as having two roles to play and I don’t think it does. Sex and reproduction are seperate things to me.
 
many say it is harmless but its breaking the charity and bond between you and God -
I’m one of those that thinks it’s harmless and I also can’t get my head around the idea God is even bothered by any of this when you think about all the other stuff happening in the world. Look I’m not saying I’m right and you’re wrong or the church is wrong because I know the church has a position to take on these things and doesn’t move on them. I’m just saying for me it’s no big deal and I can’t see God being too bothered either.
 
As far as I can see it’s because sex is described as having two roles to play and I don’t think it does. Sex and reproduction are seperate things to me.
The bolded bit is the part I want to address. You state that sex and reproduction are separate things. You make this claim based on–what? Sex has a unitive function, to be sure, but it also has a reproductive one. Physically speaking, that is its purpose for our species. The divorce of sex from reproduction is a product of widely-available contraception, but the idea does not make sense.

I can enjoy eating, but its purpose is to nourish my body. If I try to divorce food from nourishment, instead using it for some other purpose (because I’m bored, to relieve stress, to bond with my friends at various functions), I will end with a wrong idea of eating (and I will probably become obese). I am not stating the food cannot do those things, but I am stating that it is wrong to divorce food from the idea of nourishment.

So it is with sex. It is wrong (and illogical) to divorce it from the idea of reproduction. Doing so warps your idea of what sex is, leaving you open to misconstruction of what is and is not immoral sexually.
 
Why is it even disordered? Disordered in what way? I think it’s a false connection between sexual pleasure and reproduction. The two are not connected as far as I’m concerned. For me the primary function of the sex organs is to enjoy sex, and nothing to do with reproduction. And I don’t think you have to be married to enjoy sexual pleasure.
Then why are they called reproductive organs? Their purpose is fulfilled in man - woman intercourse. They are physically designed for that. To use them contrary to their purpose (outside the man-woman sexual act) is sinful and wrong. It’s going against the will of the Creator who designed it.

I think any objective person not influenced and brainwashed by today’s popular culture will see this, like the way biologists knew the purpose of reproductive organs.

But one aspect that really convinced me why it’s wrong is the way masturbation banalizes sex. Sex is supposed to be a special sign of love between spouses. That’s why “making love” is a euphemism for it. It’s a “body language” of full mutual self-giving. On the other hand, masturbation twists its purpose to serve a selfish pursuit of pleasure. Rather than making sex a sign of love, it makes of sex just another venue to selfishly enjoy pleasure. Since masturbation has usurped this pleasure for one’s self, it is no longer special.

What would you feel if your spouse choose to masturbate more than to make love with you? Would you feel like being treated like a prostitute if your spouse only used you during sex to please himself, like what he does in masturbation?
 
Masturbation is essentially having sex with oneself. We are meant to have one sexual partner and that’s our spouse, not ourselves.

This is why I take issue with theologians who believe that masturbation is allowed to the woman “in the context” of marital intercourse.

Spilling the seed dates back to the belief that the seed contained all that was needed, before more was discovered on how eggs get fertilised and zygotes follow from that. This said, it is still a “half” of what’s needed, so the reasoning isn’t altogether invalid, it’s perhaps not really a central reason, at least in my eyes. From my point of view, the central thing that’s wrong with masturbation is having sex with oneself, which means having sex with a non-spouse (in addition to other things like damaging the proper responses of the body and the ability to form healthy relationships and have normal relations with one’s spouse).
 
You ask the wrong question, so you get all kind of answers.
If you did not ask whether masturbation was a sin and asked whether it is good to have a balanced sexual life instead, maybe the answer would be different.
What are you asking when you ask whether masturbation is a sin? That you go to hell if you die after masturbation? What is the question?

I think that you should drive well for the safety of everybody. But if you park at the wrong place you will not get 25 years in jail for that or death penalty. Do you get?

So, what were you asking when you ask what you asked?
What if a person basically has no or few friends and no sex life. Would this cause the stress that induces masterbation?
 
Just say “NO”. :hey_bud:
I will speak up for the OP here. I have had trouble with this and my priest finally gave me a prayer for purity involving Mary. It is VERY effective. I am afraid of wet dreams as they are a mess and would masterbate to eliminate them. No porn used. Just a quick release and go on. For someone with a purity issue it’s not always easy to just stop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top