"You're becoming comfortable being empty": what exactly does this mean?

  • Thread starter Thread starter bardegaulois
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

bardegaulois

Guest
So a friend told me lately. However, I’m certainly not comfortable, and I’m certainly not empty. Maybe I’m just less talkative about it.

So, if I’m better than ever before, why do I miss the past so much? Why do I look more favourably on that younger version of myself, obnoxiously self-absorbed as he was, as compared to the balding, austere wretch I see when I look in the mirror now? I’ve changed, and I’m still changing every moment, but the change is as imperceptible as the motion of a clock’s minute hand. I don’t know if I quite like what I’ve become, but I don’t think my opinion really matters.

And so then I find myself so willing to diminish my future glories in favour of some ordinary, corrupt human pleasure today. This presumes, of course, that such a thing as the ordinary exists. I don’t believe it does, though; were I not bearing this cross, I’d be bearing another, and it could be that this is the one I was destined to bear. Whether this was due to divine will or my own sins and lapses in judgment, this is the cross I bear. And whether it was for one or the other thing, it’s not mine to know. And I no longer desire to know. I only now desire to do penance for my (and our) low estate.

Yet some sort of Overwill chastens that pleasurable tendency to lead me on into the dark, cold unknown. So perhaps I’m able to set aside those tendencies in favour of… well, what exactly? The Good? The True? The Beautiful? All my preconceptions don’t matter, and I must now admit that I have absolutely no idea what these things are. Nor do I even want to know. This could be interminable, at least as far as this world is concerned. No less a figure than St Paul acknowledged a certain “thorn” that never departed him. God has more faith that I can bear this than I do, apparently.

To have faith in the revealed will of God is one thing; not to would be that most perverse form of pride, despair, pride in one’s fallenness. But to hope beyond that, for anything that might even seem natural in life, is something I can no longer do. I don’t doubt that I’ll get what I need, the “daily bread,” so to speak, but beyond that, it’s as though I feel I need to become more accustomed to the mortifications of a penitent. And, naturally, I would prefer the girl, the better job, the better salary. But God is jealous and intransigent.

After being a dynamo in the classroom all day, I return home in the evening, sit in my easy chair, exchange my shoes for slippers, pour my Scotch, smoke my pipe, and realize that, the workday done, I’m nothing now–I have no state in life. Perhaps I don’t rail against it as much as I used to, but I fail to see how this is quite comfortable. But then, I also fail to see how anything is truly supposed to be comfortable.

I guess a lot of my opinions are clearing out. We spend our youths “finding ourselves,” clichéd as that sounds, then move on to get over ourselves. I feel empty but I’m not comfortable. I long for my spring’s glow again. Even a good meal leaves me feeling like there’s still a pit in my stomach, and I lie awake at night, not quite able to sleep.

Has anyone been here? Or has anyone any wise words regarding this unusual juncture?
 
I hope you find a good creative outlet for your evident flair for writing!

The person’s comment may have been judgemental and rude,
but the comment may be beneficial in that it (along with an inner sense of emptiness) causes you to reflect upon your life and spirituality, providing a possible springboard for human and spiritual growth,
in terms that hopefully include reflection on the beatitudes and the two commandments of love spoken by Jesus,
and not forgetting to give genuine focus to the second of those commands, as some do in their pursuit of loving God, not forgetting also what Jesus also reveals in Matthew 25 verses 31-46
 
Francie, thank you. I’m an English teacher, and I write a little too.

My friend, I must admit, meant this with all the best intentions. For what it’s worth, I think he’s a Buddhist, and to them, emptiness is the height of all virtues.

I guess that this all started earlier this year when I decided, after a very trying personal situation, that I just wasn’t going to try to fill the emptiness of my own accord any longer. What is supposed to make me uncomfortable now will make me uncomfortable now, and as this is part and parcel of human existence, I can’t really lift a finger to do anything about it. Wandering through the desert is something I’ve perhaps unwisely delayed for too long.

You know, I see evidence of happiness, whether among those I meet or in literature, and I ache within. It’s not envy, but something deeper–like there’s been a longing within for a while that I’m seeing partly fulfilled somehow else. And it all just leads to repentance for my past “fullness” that made me incapable now of that, and regret that that has frustrated the divine will. If it’s even that. Add to that the self-debasement based on my reasoning that all these are just much worthier than I am. But I can scarcely bear much company any longer, especially in this season. Joy for some is just grief for others.

So, how to love? Oh, that frustrating word! I must admit that I don’t even know what that means any longer. I’m dropping my preconceptions of it, and, if it’s so vital as the faith avers it to be, trusting that it’s nature will just emerge over time–that which is truly love, not niceness, not mere benevolence, not mere altruism.
 
hmm. If it weren’t for the Scotch and the pipe- I’ll allow you the slippers- 😃 -then I’d say it sounds like the dark night of the soul. Or maybe you are a poet.

In any case- I’ve noticed that when we start to get “comfortable” God tends to allow these deep longings for Him to emerge. Sometimes much- and for a long time, isn’t it true? Like labor pains, there is something good and very new at the end of it.
 
Your composition is almost lyrical. But yes, you do have a state in life: If you’re unmarried, it’s called the single vocation. I spent the earlier part of my adult life as a single Catholic woman, my career (professional dancer with the New York City Ballet) put me in a position where there were few suitable men available.

During the performance season, well, performance pretty much ate up my time and energies. I still found opportunity to volunteer at my parish’s soup kitchen, and opportunity to teach ballet to disadvantaged inner city youth. I was also graced to be asked by a colleague who was converting to Catholicism to be her RCIA sponsor.

During the non-performance season I took classes and finished my degree in performing arts, and when that was done, I volunteered for other “mission style” work. One of the most memorable summers of my life was when I went out West to a reservation and worked with their parish’s health outreach (I’m of native American ancestry myself.)

On the weekends in New York, there was usually some sort of gala or charitable event to which my company sent a few ballerinas. The public was always somewhat excited to meet the dancers, so that consumed some of my socializing time.

Beyond that, there were friends, other people in my apartment building and neighborhood (Chelsea,) and things to do. I also traveled internationally, either as part of the traveling troupe, or recreationally on my own.

When I took some more classes at Fordham, toward the end of my ballet career (to prepare me for a post-stage working life) I met my now-husband on a camping trip to the Adirondacks which was sponsored by the student life committee.

I wouldn’t have called my life empty, regardless of my single (at the time) state. I found that contributing my time, talent, and treasure to Church activities, or other human needs, was a very fulfilling (if sometimes tiring) way to live.
 
I think the kind of “emptiness” that is best, is a spirit of poverty. Basically attaining such a spirit is a key that gets us entrance into the kingdom.

“Blessed are the poor of spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.”

With a spirit of poverty, everything is a gift and nothing is lacking. So to a “kingdom person,” the world is a glorious kingdom, not a trash dump infested with evil humans.

Note that by poor in spirit I don’t mean lacking in things, nor do I mean sadness, depression, or suffering. I think suffering can help a person find a state of spiritual poverty, but I’m afraid more often it doesn’t happen, as evidenced by the number of people who complain about Their Lot In Life.

Alan
 
I have to admit that when I see things about “emptiness” I am reminded of this Gospel passage:
43 "When the unclean spirit has gone out of a man, he passes through waterless places seeking rest, but he finds none. 44 Then he says, ‘I will return to my house from which I came.’ And when he comes he finds it empty, swept, and put in order. 45 Then he goes and brings with him seven other spirits more evil than himself, and they enter and dwell there; and the last state of that man becomes worse than the first… (Mt 12:43-45)
What strikes me in this is the danger of simple “emptiness”. As we purge ourselves of “unclean spirits” they need to be replaced with something “clean” so that when the unclean spirit returns it does NOT find the dwelling empty…
The Holy Spirit is what must replace the unclean (unholy) spirit…Love is the principle essence of that Holy Spirit…

If I understand your OP…It seems that you feel there needs to be more than simply teaching (which in itself is a wonderful vocation) and then coming home to the “pipe and slippers”. The thing to do is probably to use this time for prayer, spiritual reading, some Lectio Divina" type contemplative exercises etc.
Ask God to come nearer, to fill you and to guide you into where He needs you to be.

Peace
James
 
…
The Holy Spirit is what must replace the unclean (unholy) spirit…Love is the principle essence of that Holy Spirit…
…
Peace
James
Your post reminded me of the Prayer to The Holy Spirit
Come, Holy Spirit, replace the tension within me with a holy relaxation.
Replace the turbulence within me with a sacred calm.
Replace the anxiety with me with a quiet confidence.
Replace the fear within me with a strong faith.
Replace the bitterness within me with the sweetness of grace.
Replace the darkness within me with a gentle light.
Replace the coldness with me with a loving warmth.
Replace the night within me with your light.
Straighten my crookedness.
Fill my emptiness.
Blunt the edge of my pride.
Sharpen the edge of my humility.
Light the fire of my love.
Quench the flames of my lust.
Let me see myself as You see me.
That I may see You as You have promised, and be blessed according to Your word: “Blessed are the pure of heart, for they shall see God.”
 
I would see your “you’re becoming comfortable being empty” as a kind of optimistic wish for all of us! I am sorry if it sounds strange or not really what you read into it. I know that many times I feel the same way and it is at that cross road, at that “and now what?” that we realize that we are not all that we think we should be. It is a good feeling (even though it does not feel good), a feeling that really puts us into perspective and shows to us who we really are! “Not much compared to the Creator of all things uh”! It makes us stop and think! Being comfortable being empty is for me a wish from God so that His Spirit can start leading us without " our own self" in the way. this is the way that God shows us that in spite of all our our intentions, vanities, ideas of who we ought be, we should be empty vessels for Him to fill.
just ask Him to show you his love a little more.
lovingtruth.
 
Thanks all for the responses. I’d like to respond to some of these replies:

Odile, I don’t think the issue is my bachelorhood. Granted that beyond the general vocation to holiness and the responsibilities to my worldly profession, I have no responsibilities beyond those I take on to myself (which I’ve stopped doing as it’s just a generally futile effort to fill empty spaces) and those assigned to me from above. But that’s not really the point. A sense of loneliness and emptiness can overtake anyone regardless of their state in life. You seem to indicate that I ought to be more gregarious, as once I was, but upon being in pleasant society, I just ache all the more. Perhaps Soren Kierkegaard said it best: “I have just now come from a party where I was its life and soul; witticisms streamed from my lips, everyone laughed and admired me, but I went away — yes, the dash should be as long as the radius of the earth’s orbit ——————————— and wanted to shoot myself.”

Incidentally (and completely off-topic), I was remembering a little Italian restaurant in Chelsea where I’d dine with friends occasionally, but I can’t remember its name. Unpretentious, dimly lit place. Do you have any idea which restaurant I’m talking about?
 
JRKH, I do empathise with your words about the potential perils of emptiness. It’s something I’d feared for a while, much in the same way that we all naturally fear death. As I think I noted above, I think coming to this state was long something I should have done, but due to my reticence, circumstances had to conspire so. However, I doubt that in the spiritual world, as in the natural world, any true vacuum is possible. Something must invariably fill it sometime (when this process of kenosis is complete, that is), and I think it becomes the call of the intellect to discern those spirits that will, no doubt, emerge.

Pitcharan, thank you for the prayer. It’s very relevant to this, and I will certainly, starting this very evening, add it to my repertoire.

And DaddyGirl, I’m Canadian only by ancestry and by a few memorable months I boarded in Québec City. My spelling is simply a modest revolt against Yankee arrogance. But I am in New England, and, yes, it can get QUITE cold and dark here. That always has its effect every year.
 
Agree with your comment that circumstances have to conspire to bring us to certain points. We can sometimes conceptualize or recognize things intellectually, but until they “smack us up side the head” they tend to remain just constructs.

Glad that our (name removed by moderator)ut has been of help to you.

Peace
James
 
We French used to show them through force of arms; now, safely nestled with in their homeland, we just show the Yankees by doing everything they think they do well (education, literature, culture, etc.) better than they.

But, petty tribal squabbles aside…
 
We French used to show them through force of arms; now, safely nestled with in their homeland, we just show the Yankees by doing everything they think they do well (education, literature, culture, etc.) better than they.

But, petty tribal squabbles aside…
… My spelling is simply a modest revolt against Yankee arrogance. …
Who are Yankees? Do they have difficulty with the letter ‘u’?

I watched this film A Connecticut Yankee at King Arthur’s Court The Yankee wasn’t really arrogant.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top