Youth retreats

  • Thread starter Thread starter coolduude
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

coolduude

Guest
Hi,

The one retreat that I’ve been on was a very bad experience. So I’m just curious. What is a normal (as in average) retreat like? What are the activities? Pros/cons? And what could be considered a ‘bad retreat’? In other words, what are some major no-no’s of youth retreats? What should be reported?

I know there are many questions, but I thank anyone who has the time to answer some (or all) of them 🙂

coolduude
 
Hi,

The one retreat that I’ve been on was a very bad experience. So I’m just curious. What is a normal (as in average) retreat like? What are the activities? Pros/cons? And what could be considered a ‘bad retreat’? In other words, what are some major no-no’s of youth retreats? What should be reported?

I know there are many questions, but I thank anyone who has the time to answer some (or all) of them 🙂

coolduude
So sorry to have to say this, but, if the retreat leader gropes you, then that’s not “normal”.
 
I would say that it isn’t all that good an idea to go on a retreat ‘armed’ with all the possible things that could go wrong in order that you can look for them.

Go with the expectation of having a communal and spiritual experience of God, the openness towards learning new things about your faith. If something seems wrong or odd, raise it at an appropriate time or ask questions afterwards. Assuming or expecting the worst before you even go isn’t a good thing…
 
Hi,

The one retreat that I’ve been on was a very bad experience. So I’m just curious. What is a normal (as in average) retreat like? What are the activities? Pros/cons? And what could be considered a ‘bad retreat’? In other words, what are some major no-no’s of youth retreats? What should be reported?

I know there are many questions, but I thank anyone who has the time to answer some (or all) of them 🙂

coolduude
What a good retreat is depends on the individual in question.

Some people would be happy reflecting or reading for three or four hours at a time; others would enjoy more communal and active things to do.

I for one would be irritated by contrived activities. Daily offices and other natural communal activities are fine; but I wouldn’t like to go on retreat to socialise. On the other side of the coin; many people would prefer being more active.

I don’t think we can say what a normal retreat is; or what a perfect one is. With the exception of the daily offices as a general obligation (it would be rude and absurd to avoid them).

What the activities in a particular retreat are depends upon the individual and the community. Each time I have been on retreat I spent most of the week in my room or the library; barring offices and mealtimes; and each time I have been on a retreat it has been a very good experience.

The only no-no’s of retreat would be the same no-no’s one would get anywhere else. Apart from that it’s down to the person going on retreat.
 
Hi,

The one retreat that I’ve been on was a very bad experience. So I’m just curious. What is a normal (as in average) retreat like? What are the activities? Pros/cons? And what could be considered a ‘bad retreat’? In other words, what are some major no-no’s of youth retreats? What should be reported?

I know there are many questions, but I thank anyone who has the time to answer some (or all) of them 🙂

coolduude
Maybe it would help if you told us what made your retreat a bad experience.

But if we’re talking in general, I would say any activity or conversation that goes against what the Church teaches would be a bad retreat. If the people leading the retreat seem to have a lazy, don’t care attitude would make it a bad retreat.
 
Hi,

The one retreat that I’ve been on was a very bad experience. So I’m just curious. What is a normal (as in average) retreat like? What are the activities? Pros/cons? And what could be considered a ‘bad retreat’? In other words, what are some major no-no’s of youth retreats? What should be reported?

I know there are many questions, but I thank anyone who has the time to answer some (or all) of them 🙂

coolduude
this is sad that this was a bad retreat

i do alot of work with retreats but good retreats I think will include good speakers who inform the kids will keeping them interested in what they are speaking about.

good retreats have small groups (this is where kids can really dive deep)

there are many many things that can make a good retreat

but one thing that I think needs to be put it to make a great retreat depending on the length is adoration or at-least a few minuets in-front of the tabernacle even if you go to the worst retreat ever in your life 10 to 20 minuets in-front of Jesus can change kids lives forever.
 
Thanks for the advice so far. As one person pointed out, groping would most definitely be wrong. Thankfully that didn’t happen on the retreat I was on.

Here’s my recollection of my retreat, taken from another thread when I wrote it there:

It was a Friday to Sunday retreat at a retreat center in the country (farms and stuff ). On Friday we did the usual retreat things- games and ‘small groups’, in which we talked about “who we are” (whatever that means).

Saturday we did the same, except on Saturday night. Saturday night we had a reconcilliation service. Let me explain. The people who ran the retreat center put on a little skit about rejecting Jesus and indulging in the world. I have to admit, it was a good skit and made me well up. After the skit, we all took a rock (a small pebble) and one by one went up to the front of the room and set it in a bowl of sand, while announcing some sin we were letting go from our hearts. It was a quite time and there was no time limit really (but we all had to go up there- no questions asked). After everyone went, they blasted, I mean BLASTED, the song “What I’ve done” by Linkin Park. I guess it fit. After the music, the small group leaders all took up places in the room. My memory of this part fades, but I do remember we each had to go up to our leader, pray with them (just listen while they pray off the top of their head), then they bless us (I think; like I said my memory is fading). Lastly, we went to the chapel, did some meditating thing, then went to bed.

On Sunday, we did a little bit more of small groups, filled out a survey, then went to a Communion Service. The Service was, I thought, extremely disrespectful. For the readings, kids volunteered to dress up and act out the readings. I say dress up and I mean costumes. Costumes made of clothes from a thrift store (not that there’s anything wrong with thrift stores- there isn’t). The costumes included over-sized, baggy clothing and gaudy hats. The skit consisted of running around and no respect for what was actually happening. After the skit we all made a circle, stood, and recieved the Eucharist, not from a priest or deacon, but a lay person who works there- and this Service was not in the chapel. After that we got bussed home.

What are some thoughts on this retreat? As you can probably tell, I didn’t like it at all. Should I report this or let it go? The school does this every year and it is mandatory. The retreat consists of about 25/30 people and there are about 5 or 6 retreats to accomodate the entire class.

How does this compare to other retreats?

And no, there was no Adoration or formal Mass. 😦
 
On Friday we did the usual retreat things- games and ‘small groups’, in which we talked about “who we are” (whatever that means).
this is a good way to start off a retreat you get to know the people in your small group and such so friday night looked like it was good.
Saturday we did the same, except on Saturday night. Saturday night we had a reconcilliation service. Let me explain. The people who ran the retreat center put on a little skit about rejecting Jesus and indulging in the world. I have to admit, it was a good skit and made me well up. After the skit, we all took a rock (a small pebble) and one by one went up to the front of the room and set it in a bowl of sand, while announcing some sin we were letting go from our hearts. It was a quite time and there was no time limit really (but we all had to go up there- no questions asked). After everyone went, they blasted, I mean BLASTED, the song “What I’ve done” by Linkin Park. I guess it fit. After the music, the small group leaders all took up places in the room. My memory of this part fades, but I do remember we each had to go up to our leader, pray with them (just listen while they pray off the top of their head), then they bless us (I think; like I said my memory is fading). Lastly, we went to the chapel, did some meditating thing, then went to bed.
the reconciliation service seems like a good idea (i hope they had a priest becuase without him the service would mean nothing, you just fell good and thats about it)

The pebble idea cool i think its a better idea to do something like that at the beinging of the retreat kinda like this pepple is something that is holding you back from fulling opening yourself to this retreat.

Then linkin park good song and all but should be treated like the pleuage (can’t spell today) in a reconciliation service

but yeah sounds like they could have done things better there.
On Sunday, we did a little bit more of small groups, filled out a survey, then went to a Communion Service. The Service was, I thought, extremely disrespectful. For the readings, kids volunteered to dress up and act out the readings. I say dress up and I mean costumes. Costumes made of clothes from a thrift store (not that there’s anything wrong with thrift stores- there isn’t). The costumes included over-sized, baggy clothing and gaudy hats. The skit consisted of running around and no respect for what was actually happening. After the skit we all made a circle, stood, and recieved the Eucharist, not from a priest or deacon, but a lay person who works there- and this Service was not in the chapel. After that we got bussed home.
this aprt is really sad the skits ok but shouldn’t be used but getting in a circle and not having a decon their or priest 😦

i think you get why it is so bad.

but enough about why your retreat was so bad Ill go ahead knowing what the retreat is based off of tell you of my experince with a retreat simular to yours.

my youth groups fall retreat, friday through sunday.

Friday night just kinda be the night where we get to know people we hear talks play fun games and so on and so forth, we probably have some nice prayer service to end the night and that was about it.

Saturday morning we get up and have breakfast (im alittle cloudy on this part of my memory on this thing its been a couple years)

after breakfast we play a scavenger hunt type game adults would be hidden around the camp kids would run and find them give them their card and who evers card he had last would win his points

then we have lunch don’t remember what we did after maybe more small groups, but then mid afternoon late after noon we have an outdoor foodfight, i wasn’t always the biggest fan of it but it was fun none less.

After that we have some free time many people would go down to the river, but i think adventually can’t remember if it was before or after the food fight but we have the sacrament of confession, i went every year, one year the priest did a walking confession we walk together and I say my confession the other year just the normal confession. There was no church so no confessional we just close off a certin area for confessions.

Then that night we have more talks and maybe a skit but the night would finish off with adoartion probably last 30 min to 45 min 1 hour at the most. This was the highlight of the day ofcourse. there where alot of devout kids in my group many kids recieved gifts, i remember my YM speaking in toungs and actually one kid understood him.

then that night we have a big game of CTF and then we call it a night.

Sunday was mass and maybe a speaker or two and that was it.

hope this helps you understand what a good retreat should look like
 
Thanks for the perspective. I still find some of the things on youth retreats odd and somewhat unorthodox.

Unfortunately, there was no priest at the reconciliation service, hence there was no opportunity for a real Confession. My problem with this is that I think it gives the other kids wrong impressions about what can forgive sin and what can’t. I feel like a lot of the kids there thought of that service as a different type of Confession and left thinking their sins, mortal and venial, were forgiven. If they know the difference though, I guess that would make it better.
 
i agree youth group stuff is very unorthodox and odd at times, the move away from tradition seems to be having the largest impact on the youth

but even if they aren’t very traditional if they still bring you to the foot of the cross and to Jesus your life will still change thats they way its been for me atleast.

but it seems like you are solid in your faith already.
 
It sounds like the retreat just wasn’t something that you liked, and if you get the chance, maybe you can tell your RE director or teacher that you didn’t enjoy it and why.

But it sounds like they were doing the best they can. Due to the shortage of priests, my mom’s parish often has to hold communion services in place of the daily mass and one of the Eucharistic ministers (lay person) must distribute communion.

It sounds like not much as changed in youth retreats since I was a volunteer for our diocese youth ministry. Your retreat seems to follow a typical schedule, skits and all, when its more casual. There are other youth retreats that are more traditional. You didn’t say how old you were, but the more traditional retreats seemed to be geared more for an older crowd. You just sound like you are leaps and bounds ahead of maybe where your classmates are on their faith journey and what took place on your retreat may be just what a few of them needed to jump start their developing a deeper appreciation for their faith.
 
Here’s my recollection of my retreat
I’m unhappy to hear they still do this sort of thing. I hoped it died out with the postconciliar hippie generation. Since it’s mandatory, there’s nothing you can do. Grit your teeth.
 
It doesn’t even sound like a Catholic retreat… was it, or did I miss something?

I’ve been on quite a few retreats in the past couple of years. The most notable of them was Steubenville, but I also had a couple of others. I never really had a “bad” retreat experience. I can see where yours went wrong though. With no priest, there didn’t seem to have any substance to the retreat. I think as my priests and my spiritual fathers, as guidance. A retreat is nothing without a priest there.

At least now you know not to go back… sorry you didn’t enjoy yourself 😦
 
It doesn’t even sound like a Catholic retreat… was it, or did I miss something?

I’ve been on quite a few retreats in the past couple of years. The most notable of them was Steubenville, but I also had a couple of others. I never really had a “bad” retreat experience. I can see where yours went wrong though. With no priest, there didn’t seem to have any substance to the retreat. I think as my priests and my spiritual fathers, as guidance. A retreat is nothing without a priest there.

At least now you know not to go back… sorry you didn’t enjoy yourself 😦
Catholic In Name Only I suppose 🤷

forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=144957&highlight=Plano%2C+Illinois

That 3 year old thread details some of the horrors on the retreat I have the opportunity to attend this year. However, as is mentioned in the thread, the senior retreat is not staff run. So I don’t know what to think. But yes, LaSalle Manor was where my retreat was at 😦
 
Wow. As a member of a Catholic charismatic youth retreat team, I have a lot to say on this subject. Let me start by talking about the way our team does retreats. Locally, we do 10-15 day retreats a year, as well as youth rally’s and a youth conference. We are blessed to have the full support of our Archdiocese, which was not easy to gain, but because our retired Auxiliary Bishop is the liaison between the Charismatic Renewal and the Archdiocese of San Antonio, we have good support from both inside the local Renewal and the rest of the Archdiocese. Sometimes Bishop Flanagan himself comes and gives a talk on the importance of forgiveness on a retreat, and even says Mass for us.

I do not like trendy, emotion-based retreats. I have no problem with emotions, but I believe it should be a manifestation of being touched by God in a new way, not just a good feeling. Just “feelings” never last: conversions to God, (which are often emotional moments) do.

We have two main retreats, one is a one-day Life in the Spirit Seminar, which in our Archdiocese has been given for at least 20 years by youth and young adults, and the other is a purity from drugs and immorality retreat, called Challenged 2 the Core. Our talks are given by youth and young adults, on a basic topic that they are trained for: for example: God’s love, Salvation, Purity of Mind, Purity of Heart, and a short testimony is given. We then break up into small groups, where trained youth and young adults lead discussions on the talks given.

Throughout the day, we have moments of fun, such as icebreakers and quick games, but after these there is a new focus given on the subject matter.

An important part of the retreat is praise and worship. Beginning the day with praise wakes the youth up and is a good start for a good retreat.

Our retreats include times of one-on-one prayer with the youth for conversion and healing, as well as prayers for charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit, (due to brevity, I am not going to debate the merits or demerits of the Charismatic Renewal; a Charismatic retreat group is going to be Charismatic).

My view is that a weekend retreat should always have Mass, if possible. Every retreat possible Confession should be available. Connections should be made through out the day regarding the importance of our Catholic Faith with the youth.

I am not saying our method is perfect, but it is one that I have seen work.

As far as a youth retreat goes - if it does not connect one to the Sacraments, it does not call young people to repent and change their lives, if it does not have a good prayer time, if the youth are bored, the retreat is a failure.

God Bless,
Peter
 
Overall the retreat sounds routine, however I wouldn’t hesitate to talk to your bishop about this “Communion service” if you feel called to. While I’m sure they had no ill intention, it certainly seems to lack reverence in the manor they did it.
 
Wow. As a member of a Catholic charismatic youth retreat team, I have a lot to say on this subject. Let me start by talking about the way our team does retreats. Locally, we do 10-15 day retreats a year, as well as youth rally’s and a youth conference. We are blessed to have the full support of our Archdiocese, which was not easy to gain, but because our retired Auxiliary Bishop is the liaison between the Charismatic Renewal and the Archdiocese of San Antonio, we have good support from both inside the local Renewal and the rest of the Archdiocese. Sometimes Bishop Flanagan himself comes and gives a talk on the importance of forgiveness on a retreat, and even says Mass for us.

I do not like trendy, emotion-based retreats. I have no problem with emotions, but I believe it should be a manifestation of being touched by God in a new way, not just a good feeling. Just “feelings” never last: conversions to God, (which are often emotional moments) do.

We have two main retreats, one is a one-day Life in the Spirit Seminar, which in our Archdiocese has been given for at least 20 years by youth and young adults, and the other is a purity from drugs and immorality retreat, called Challenged 2 the Core. Our talks are given by youth and young adults, on a basic topic that they are trained for: for example: God’s love, Salvation, Purity of Mind, Purity of Heart, and a short testimony is given. We then break up into small groups, where trained youth and young adults lead discussions on the talks given.

Throughout the day, we have moments of fun, such as icebreakers and quick games, but after these there is a new focus given on the subject matter.

**An important part of the retreat is praise and worship. Beginning the day with praise wakes the youth up and is a good start for a good retreat. **

Our retreats include times of one-on-one prayer with the youth for conversion and healing, as well as prayers for charismatic gifts of the Holy Spirit, (due to brevity, I am not going to debate the merits or demerits of the Charismatic Renewal; a Charismatic retreat group is going to be Charismatic).

My view is that a weekend retreat should always have Mass, if possible. Every retreat possible Confession should be available. Connections should be made through out the day regarding the importance of our Catholic Faith with the youth.

I am not saying our method is perfect, but it is one that I have seen work.

As far as a youth retreat goes - if it does not connect one to the Sacraments, it does not call young people to repent and change their lives, if it does not have a good prayer time, if the youth are bored, the retreat is a failure.

God Bless,
Peter
There was about 0 of that on my retreat, unless you count the Communion Service (which was really far out there theology wise). My main beef with youth retreats, such as the one I was on, is the ‘team building activities’. I mean, I saw straight through those. I can understand 1 or 2 icebreaker games which incorporate team building elements, but when we do 4 or 5 games like that it really becomes old. Also, the small groups. In and of itself those are fine, but the subject matter is what’s really important. I would go back on retreat if we talked theology in those groups, but instead we talk about personal issues and other personal things. Retreats should be about God, not about what you do in your personal life. I wish the small group discussions were more intellectual and less unintellectual. :mad:

This thread reminds me of another thing that is somewhat debatable. Is LifeTeen ok for a youth group to get in to? My local parish is starting a chapter of it soon, and my heart sank when I saw the add for it. It seems ultra-unorthodox. Is it ok to participate in, or should I say something about it?
 
Overall the retreat sounds routine, however I wouldn’t hesitate to talk to your bishop about this “Communion service” if you feel called to. While I’m sure they had no ill intention, it certainly seems to lack reverence in the manor they did it.
True, but it was about a year ago now. 😦
 
It doesn’t even sound like a Catholic retreat… was it, or did I miss something?
Unfortunately this sounds like most “Catholic” retreats I’ve been to. When there is “prayer” time, people around you start babbling in “tongues” or “resting in the spirit”, so you can’t even focus.

Not saying all youth retreats are like this, just ones I’ve been to.
 
Unfortunately this sounds like most “Catholic” retreats I’ve been to. When there is “prayer” time, people around you start babbling in “tongues” or “resting in the spirit”, so you can’t even focus.

Not saying all youth retreats are like this, just ones I’ve been to.
Oy vey! Sounds more like a Pentecostal service if that happens.

Though I suppose speaking in tongues is a gift, is it not? But does anyone really know if they’re faking or not? 🤷
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top