Zombie Apocalypse Suicide Question

  • Thread starter Thread starter TheNew52
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
With regard to your post-apocalyptoc world, you seem to have it sorted. But with regard to Catholic morality…

Unfortunately you’re also committing the sin of presumption - itself a serious sin - so your plan is not foolproof.

And you don’t know that you can properly repent in that final moment, since if you are truly sorry for the sin you plan on committing, you won’t commit it in the first place - or to flip that around - if you go ahead and commit it, how can you then be sorry for it? Other than merely being sorry because you are now fearful of hell, but the Church does not consider that sufficient to acheive forgiveness apart from sacramental confession.
Sure, I can repent at that final moment. I’ll have a face-to-face with God, explain the whole situation, and he’ll be cool with it. Who’s to say I can’t? Has anyone ever been there and lived to tell about it?

Honestly–the idea that God will sentence people to eternal damnation because they happened to make a “bad” decision under extreme duress is just as far-fetched as the idea that we’ll be overrun by zombies.

We all share this condition called “being human.”
 
Sure, I can repent at that final moment. I’ll have a face-to-face with God, explain the whole situation, and he’ll be cool with it. Who’s to say I can’t? Has anyone ever been there and lived to tell about it?

Honestly–the idea that God will sentence people to eternal damnation because they happened to make a “bad” decision under extreme duress is just as far-fetched as the idea that we’ll be overrun by zombies.

We all share this condition called “being human.”
😃

I remember watching people jump from the towers on 9/11. I never thought that they were going to hell. I thought how horrible it would be to h ave only two choices, burn or jump. I’m sure God understood those people. And I’m sure people on that day had talks with him before taking that leap.
 
Sure, I can repent at that final moment. I’ll have a face-to-face with God, explain the whole situation, and he’ll be cool with it. Who’s to say I can’t? Has anyone ever been there and lived to tell about it?
This - as pointed out - is the sin of presumption.

How do you know you can repent? You clearly lack contrition for the act before hand - otherwise you would not do it. So how can you be sure you will have contrition later? You are in fact trying to fool God. Not a sensible choice.
Honestly–the idea that God will sentence people to eternal damnation because they happened to make a “bad” decision under extreme duress is just as far-fetched as the idea that we’ll be overrun by zombies.
It is not a “bad” decision.

It is a bad decision. (noting removal of “…”). But still, duress mitigates culpability (as the Church clearly teaches).

While the situation is absurd, the moral principles are clear enough:

a) Suicide is not a legitimate moral choice. Not something to freely choose.

b) If a person committs suicide due to duress or other factors than diminish cuplability, then it is not mortal sin. This is different from what you are doing - which is rationally weighing the options beforehand and choosing (freely) that suicide will be your approach.
 
This - as pointed out - is the sin of presumption.

How do you know you can repent? You clearly lack contrition for the act before hand - otherwise you would not do it. So how can you be sure you will have contrition later? You are in fact trying to fool God. Not a sensible choice.
How do you know I can’t? And how do you know I lack contrition?
a) Suicide is not a legitimate moral choice. Not something to freely choose.

b) If a person committs suicide due to duress or other factors than diminish cuplability, then it is not mortal sin. This is different from what you are doing - which is rationally weighing the options beforehand and choosing (freely) that suicide will be your approach.
In this situation, culpability evaporates to nothing. Maybe I’m not being rational. Maybe I’m panicking and psychotic with fear. The vast, vast, vast majority of people who take their own lives are not thinking rationally when they do it.
 
How do you know I can’t? And how do you know I lack contrition?
You don’t know if you can or can’t - that’s the point - it’s a risky proposition. Risking eternal hell.

And we know right now that you do not have contrition, because you plan to commit the sin in question. You can’t have contrition for something you plan to do. So how does no contrition turn into contrition afterwards? Fear of hell does not equal contrition - that is merely attrition and is consider insufficient for forgiveness outside of sacramental confession.
In this situation, culpability evaporates to nothing. Maybe I’m not being rational. Maybe I’m panicking and psychotic with fear. The vast, vast, vast majority of people who take their own lives are not thinking rationally when they do it.
But right now you are being rational. You are rationally planning to commit grave sin.

And this is all quite different from anticipating that duress will have whatever effect on you. Planning to commit suicide is different from anticipating that you may feel compelled to in such difficult circumstances.

We can say it is understandable that someone would commit suicide in such circumstances, but we cannot say it is the right thing to do.
 
Wow. What an interesting Thread. It is good to have an SF “what if” thread to discuss moral issues that come up. I thought the point of the Zombie Apocalypse a good point.
There is Biblical justification for that.
So I find the answers here curious. Almost everyone agrees that suicide is never justified and that if someone were in this situation then it would still be a sin. However I remember hearing the story of St. Pelagia, who leapt to her death to avoid being raped by roman soldiers. Historically her act of suicide is considered valiant by many in the Church. Does not the same rule apply to this situation as well?
“Suicide is never justified” is absolutely wrong. I must be the only Catholic that has read his Bible. It looks like the Magisterium hasn’t either.

In the case of the Kurdish woman, she is right in what she had done. Or either way is right, get captured, raped and abused or commit suicide. For this is what the Bible says:
**“It is manful that one kills oneself than to fall into the hands of ungodly men.” **
That is at II Mac. 14:42.

Saul committed suicide or commanded his stewart to kill him in order not to be captured. Roman commanders and soldiers did this all the time. It was a practice common throughout the Ancient World. When the Germanic tribes caught Roman prisoners, they would torture them and still slit their throats in worshipping their gods.

The Natural Law says there is an exception to every rule. Suicide is wrong 99% of the time. It is a sin. But in cases in time of war, it may be right to kill oneself in order to escape from ungodly men. The Bible justifies suicide in this case. So the statement that “suicide is NEVER justified” is false. Just like the Church amended its penalties for abortion in the Early Church, the Magisterium needs to reevaluate its teaching on suicide to conform to what the Bible says.

In the Zombie Apocalypse, with 30 zombies charging and one bullet—it is better to off oneself while quoting that verse.

There are exceptions to every rule.
 
Fr. Grondin says that the “full context does not lend itself”.

Yet, I find there are two adjectives used to praise the situation. First, (I use the Septuagint), there is the word “euyeneias”, meaning “well-born” or noble birth. The translator translates that as “manliness”. Manliness is a Virtue. That means it is in line with the dictates of manliness.

Again, the author of the passage says that when that failed, he ran up thru the tower and Manfully threw himself down. Both actions are described as “Manly”. It is a term of praise. Both adjectives describe the situation and both are praiseworthy actions.

The man ends by throwing his intestines out of his bowels, flinging them in the faces of his enemies.

As a former military man, I read that with pride and honor. It was a good deed. I see nothing wrong with it.

At the same time this was going on, in the Maccabean revolt, was the encirclement of Masada by Roman troops. The defenders resisted the advances of the Romans. But when the defenders realized that the next day the Romans would breach the wall, ----THEY ALL COMMITTED SUICIDE. That included families with children.

Today, Israel honors the site. Some Israeli military units take their oaths on the site. It is revered ground in Israel.

So, you have two actions of suicide–both are praised.
 
Well, I could accept your personal analysis of the situation…

Or I could accept the Magesterium of the Church’s constant teaching that suicide is per se wrong.

You seem to think that in 2000 years of Church history no one in the Magesterium has come across the story of the Maccabes. That would be quite a remarkable oversight! No, I’m sure they’ve read it and interpreted it - as is their authority - differently to you.
 
To each his own.

If you look carefully, I catalogue myself as Roman Catholic and Greek Orthodox. I know a lot about both Churches and for many years attended both on Sundays running between one and the other. The Orthodox don’t have a “Magisterium”, and they have never condemned slavery preferring to hold fast to the Deposit of Faith and the Bible. I live in both worlds so my take is more nuanced.
 
There is nothing to say that the Church can’t revise something. It is always revising something.

That situation only pertains to military situations–or zombie situations.
 
I just thought of another wonderful situation in Science Fiction that would the Borg species in the Star Trek series,* The Next Generation *and the Voyager. These things were quite gruesome. If you happened to run across one of their ships, which where the size of small planets, it wasn’t a good thing. They almost always won. What would happen is that they would tractor beam the foreign ship, take out all the living things in it and add them to their ship’s company after being transformed into half-way computers. All the Borg were attached to their ship like robots.

When they came into contact with any other foreign ship, they would release this command:

“We are the Borg. Lower your shields and surrender your ships. We will add your biological and technological distinctiveness to our own. Your culture will adapt to service us. Resistance is futile.”

At this point, I, as a Catholic Captain, would blow up our ship. For some reason the Star Trek people would escape but that was because of literary license. But in the real science fiction, escape would be impossible from the Borg. I would use all measures of escape but when escape became futile, it became time to say one’s Confiteor, Praise God, and blow up the ship.
 
For those interested, here is an article

The Good Soldier’s End: From Suicide to Martyrdom.

It was normal for Senior Roman military officers to commit suicide. The article talks about the only change that the Roman Army did under the influence of Christianity. Roman officers began to let themselves be captured and suffer the consequences. It is nice short article.
 
The ends do not justify the means. Rape is a horrible crime, but suicide is never justified. I may not kill all poor people to end poverty. If someone commits suicide, that does not give us the right to presume that person is in hell. The Catechism states:
Grave psychological disturbances, anguish, or grave fear of hardship, suffering, or torture can diminish the responsibility of the one committing suicide.
2283 We should not despair of the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives. By ways known to him alone, God can provide the opportunity for salutary repentance. The Church prays for persons who have taken their own lives.
This does not mean the CCC is giving permission to commit suicide, but that other factors may reduce the culpability of the action committed.
 
Wow. What an interesting Thread. It is good to have an SF “what if” thread to discuss moral issues that come up. I thought the point of the Zombie Apocalypse a good point.

There is Biblical justification for that.

“Suicide is never justified” is absolutely wrong. I must be the only Catholic that has read his Bible. It looks like the Magisterium hasn’t either.

In the case of the Kurdish woman, she is right in what she had done. Or either way is right, get captured, raped and abused or commit suicide. For this is what the Bible says:

That is at II Mac. 14:42.

Saul committed suicide or commanded his stewart to kill him in order not to be captured. Roman commanders and soldiers did this all the time. It was a practice common throughout the Ancient World. When the Germanic tribes caught Roman prisoners, they would torture them and still slit their throats in worshipping their gods.

The Natural Law says there is an exception to every rule. Suicide is wrong 99% of the time. It is a sin. But in cases in time of war, it may be right to kill oneself in order to escape from ungodly men. The Bible justifies suicide in this case. So the statement that “suicide is NEVER justified” is false. Just like the Church amended its penalties for abortion in the Early Church, the Magisterium needs to reevaluate its teaching on suicide to conform to what the Bible says.

In the Zombie Apocalypse, with 30 zombies charging and one bullet—it is better to off oneself while quoting that verse.

There are exceptions to every rule.
There is nothing that justifies suicide. It is always wrong. Period.
 
At the same time this was going on, in the Maccabean revolt, was the encirclement of Masada by Roman troops. The defenders resisted the advances of the Romans. But when the defenders realized that the next day the Romans would breach the wall, ----THEY ALL COMMITTED SUICIDE. That included families with children.

Today, Israel honors the site. Some Israeli military units take their oaths on the site. It is revered ground in Israel.

So, you have two actions of suicide–both are praised.
According to Josephus the men killed their own families and then drew lots. The man chosen by lots killed the others and when he was the last one left he committed suicide. According to Josephus only one person committed suicide.
 
No. There is nothing courageous about murdering your children then killing yourself!!
 
That is something I have always hated about zombies; everywhere they turn up there is nothing but trouble. I have gotten to the point that I refuse to deal with them at all.
 
Are you suggesting that murdering your children and killing yourself is brave??
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top