P
PrayerShark
Guest
Forgive me if this has already been discussed to death previously, but I could find no recent thread dealing with this topic.
A few weeks ago my wife and I were watching a BBC documentary about 23 week-old babies, which dealt with the dilemma of saving very premature (neo-natal) infants. During the course of the documentary, the program dealt with the question of whether medical intervention was worth the price of what is considered the unnecessary suffering of the parents and child. Just to make it clear, 23 weeks is the shortest gestation at which premature babies are considered viable. In reality though, this is a profoundly optimistic position as only 9 of every 100 babies born at 23 weeks survives; only 1 in 100 reaches adulthood without disability. For the most part, the position of almost every parent faced with the decision is to save the baby; as (quite naturally) the other option to most people is to say yes to killing their child. However, even if your child miraculously does survive, they will most certainly live through life with a severe disability. Such disabled adults are not likely to be supported adequately enough by the government (if at all), which is ironic considering the huge expense it costs to save the child. The program also discussed the additional problem of the media treating these babies that do survive as ‘miracle’ babies, but fail to acknowledge that such babies are not given the further assistance to survive into adulthood.
Discussing this with my wife, we both thought that while under cold logic it would be best to let the underdeveloped child die and prevent its suffering. However, we both admitted that we could never make such a decision when faced with the reality. In the Netherlands, this decision is taken out of the hands of the parents and it is up to the doctor. In fact at 23 weeks old, the default position is to allow the baby to die. The UK and Australia have similar positions of letting the parents decide, and both countries have health systems that are able to ‘absorb’ the costs of saving the baby. I’m not sure what the situation is in the USA, but I imagine that unless you have private health care that covers this sort of thing, you would have to pay for it yourself.
I was therefore going to ask if fellow CAF members what their thoughts are on the issue of saving 23 week-old babies and if they’ve gone through such a harrowing experience. I’m started this thread as it’s been on my mind for weeks now and I would like to get a few opinions on the matter. Furthermore, if there are CAF members on here who have had neo-natal babies, what has been the outcome so far for your child? That is, do they enjoy a quality of life that would be considered normal?
As a further note, I would like to add that people be civil and considerate when posting their responses and not be judgemental. Also, this is not a topic on pro-life and abortion. It is to be a discussion on the issue of 23 week-old babies.
A few weeks ago my wife and I were watching a BBC documentary about 23 week-old babies, which dealt with the dilemma of saving very premature (neo-natal) infants. During the course of the documentary, the program dealt with the question of whether medical intervention was worth the price of what is considered the unnecessary suffering of the parents and child. Just to make it clear, 23 weeks is the shortest gestation at which premature babies are considered viable. In reality though, this is a profoundly optimistic position as only 9 of every 100 babies born at 23 weeks survives; only 1 in 100 reaches adulthood without disability. For the most part, the position of almost every parent faced with the decision is to save the baby; as (quite naturally) the other option to most people is to say yes to killing their child. However, even if your child miraculously does survive, they will most certainly live through life with a severe disability. Such disabled adults are not likely to be supported adequately enough by the government (if at all), which is ironic considering the huge expense it costs to save the child. The program also discussed the additional problem of the media treating these babies that do survive as ‘miracle’ babies, but fail to acknowledge that such babies are not given the further assistance to survive into adulthood.
Discussing this with my wife, we both thought that while under cold logic it would be best to let the underdeveloped child die and prevent its suffering. However, we both admitted that we could never make such a decision when faced with the reality. In the Netherlands, this decision is taken out of the hands of the parents and it is up to the doctor. In fact at 23 weeks old, the default position is to allow the baby to die. The UK and Australia have similar positions of letting the parents decide, and both countries have health systems that are able to ‘absorb’ the costs of saving the baby. I’m not sure what the situation is in the USA, but I imagine that unless you have private health care that covers this sort of thing, you would have to pay for it yourself.
I was therefore going to ask if fellow CAF members what their thoughts are on the issue of saving 23 week-old babies and if they’ve gone through such a harrowing experience. I’m started this thread as it’s been on my mind for weeks now and I would like to get a few opinions on the matter. Furthermore, if there are CAF members on here who have had neo-natal babies, what has been the outcome so far for your child? That is, do they enjoy a quality of life that would be considered normal?
As a further note, I would like to add that people be civil and considerate when posting their responses and not be judgemental. Also, this is not a topic on pro-life and abortion. It is to be a discussion on the issue of 23 week-old babies.