23 Week-Old Babies

  • Thread starter Thread starter PrayerShark
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PrayerShark

Guest
Forgive me if this has already been discussed to death previously, but I could find no recent thread dealing with this topic.

A few weeks ago my wife and I were watching a BBC documentary about 23 week-old babies, which dealt with the dilemma of saving very premature (neo-natal) infants. During the course of the documentary, the program dealt with the question of whether medical intervention was worth the price of what is considered the unnecessary suffering of the parents and child. Just to make it clear, 23 weeks is the shortest gestation at which premature babies are considered viable. In reality though, this is a profoundly optimistic position as only 9 of every 100 babies born at 23 weeks survives; only 1 in 100 reaches adulthood without disability. For the most part, the position of almost every parent faced with the decision is to save the baby; as (quite naturally) the other option to most people is to say yes to killing their child. However, even if your child miraculously does survive, they will most certainly live through life with a severe disability. Such disabled adults are not likely to be supported adequately enough by the government (if at all), which is ironic considering the huge expense it costs to save the child. The program also discussed the additional problem of the media treating these babies that do survive as ‘miracle’ babies, but fail to acknowledge that such babies are not given the further assistance to survive into adulthood.

Discussing this with my wife, we both thought that while under cold logic it would be best to let the underdeveloped child die and prevent its suffering. However, we both admitted that we could never make such a decision when faced with the reality. In the Netherlands, this decision is taken out of the hands of the parents and it is up to the doctor. In fact at 23 weeks old, the default position is to allow the baby to die. The UK and Australia have similar positions of letting the parents decide, and both countries have health systems that are able to ‘absorb’ the costs of saving the baby. I’m not sure what the situation is in the USA, but I imagine that unless you have private health care that covers this sort of thing, you would have to pay for it yourself.

I was therefore going to ask if fellow CAF members what their thoughts are on the issue of saving 23 week-old babies and if they’ve gone through such a harrowing experience. I’m started this thread as it’s been on my mind for weeks now and I would like to get a few opinions on the matter. Furthermore, if there are CAF members on here who have had neo-natal babies, what has been the outcome so far for your child? That is, do they enjoy a quality of life that would be considered normal?

As a further note, I would like to add that people be civil and considerate when posting their responses and not be judgemental. Also, this is not a topic on pro-life and abortion. It is to be a discussion on the issue of 23 week-old babies.
 
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1296361/Twins-prove-baby-survive-23-weeks.html

preemies.about.com/od/preemieagesandstages/ss/PrematureBabiesWeekbyWeek_2.htm

pjsaunders.blogspot.com/2011/08/baby-born-at-23-weeks-who-is-happy-and.html

For us who are Catholics and Christians there is no moral possibility but to give these babies the best chance possible to survive and thrive.

Personally, as I have a sister who with her husband adopted two handicapped children, adopted, not fostered, when they had healthy natural children of their own,
and a brother who with his wife adopted three handicapped children one particularly severe, even though they also had healthy natural children
and these wonderful family members have given these children loving opportunities to develop to the best of their potential,
I do know that the lives of children who happen to be handicapped,
which can occur with very immature infants,
can be happy and fulfilled and a great gift to their families.
These five children in their varying handicaps, are happy people,
so I may have a different view to some!

Regardless, as Christians and as Catholics we can’t let babies die without doing our best to save them
 
I see what you mean about cost - 91 out of the 100 babies cannot be saved, and yet to try and save them will cost a lot of money for the parents. I thank God I live in Australia, so the decision is much easier.

The chance of disability due to prematurity is not something that would make me allow my child to die, nor is the cost. It would be very difficult, potentially life-changing for me and my family, but it’s a risk we take when we marry and begin our families.
 
People die everyday in all countries because although the technology is there to prolong their life, the cost is prohibitive. In many countries babies die because of the lack of clean water. To provide it costs next to nothing per baby. Others die because of the absence of very simple medicines. There is a ‘proximity effect’ in most of these ‘moral’ discussions. Babies dying far away are given little consideration; those dying closer to home are considered worthy of an investment of millions. It seems to me that Catholics are shifting more towards the position that extreme efforts to prolong life should be routine. In my view anything costing a lot with a 9% probability of any sort of success is extreme and should not be offered as an option to parents. As a parent I might go for a 0.0009% chance for my own child, but that would be irrational. We owe it to parents overcome by their instincts (not their morality) to save them from this. By the way I think there are many positive things about having handicapped people in our communities, and I feel they make a valuable contribution. I travel on a bus regularly with a number of adults with an assortment of conditions affecting their cognition, and am always grateful for their cheerfulness, friendliness and joy in life.
 
I guess it’s the exception rather than the rule, PrayerShark, but my siblings show what can be done. The parents of these five children from different backgrounds and families felt unable to keep them, from their very birth, but my siblings, with their spouses, adopted them and provide for them, not only for the present, but for the future. They have put means in place to provide for them from assets especially set up for them so that their natural children will not need to be financially responsible for their support in later years.

One of the three adopted handicapped children has been prepared well enough to earn his living, another, is well-adjusted enough that he can work at a routine though simple job, the remaining children will always need care, two of the remaining will have limited lifetimes, but the plan to provide for them is an actuality…therefore it is possible to give handicapped children good lives and to make private provision for them. A couple of the children would be dead by now but for the vigilance and love for these children. They are extraordinarily loved.

Handicap does not have to equal misery.
“Normal” people can be utterly miserable yet we will not let them die.

When I was at university we were asked who would volunteer to read to a fellow student who had been blind from birth. I became one of her readers.
My sympathy went out the window and I saw her as normal after she said casually one day: “I went to see that play last evening”. “See” she said.
It was then when I realized that she was comfortable in her reality.
And I felt no uneasiness in asking her further questions, like how she knew when she was approaching a building. She spoke of air movement as providing a sense of direction and of nearness to objects.

We don’t need to see handicaps as catastrophic. Sometimes they are someone else’s ‘normal’.
 
Thank you for sharing the examples set by your siblings Trish. They are indeed great selfless examples of Christian charity.

I should probably make it clear that I do not hold any ill-feeling about disabled/handicapped people making a normal life for themselves, as they are entitled to. I would happily accept the burden of raising a handicapped child if God wills it. But I do get upset when the government neglects the disabled with the support they so rightly deserve. If we are willing to spend so much money to save these neo-natal children in the first place, this (and I hate using this word) investment should continue throughout the person’s life. So, as admonsta has already said, it is easier for us in Australia to make the choice to save the baby at 23 weeks (as in the UK and in Europe), but in the US where healthcare is vastly different I think the decision may be incredibly difficult given that there is also a large financial factor involved.
40.png
Hokomai:
It seems to me that Catholics are shifting more towards the position that extreme efforts to prolong life should be routine. In my view anything costing a lot with a 9% probability of any sort of success is extreme and should not be offered as an option to parents. As a parent I might go for a 0.0009% chance for my own child, but that would be irrational. We owe it to parents overcome by their instincts (not their morality) to save them from this.
Do you believe that the Netherlands is right in putting the decision in the hands of doctors instead of the parents? At 24 weeks + the chances of survival increases and disability decreases.
 
I understand the practicalities, but as a Catholic, as a Christian, I can’t agree with the Netherlands decision.

As an aside, we did have someone here on CAF absolutely distraught because the doctors refused to make any attempt to save their child at 23 weeks. They pleaded and begged, but the medical staff refused to relent. I may remember incorrectly but I have the impression that it was in England.
 
Do you believe that the Netherlands is right in putting the decision in the hands of doctors instead of the parents? At 24 weeks + the chances of survival increases and disability decreases.
I think the decision-making should begin with medical people, and if they have doubt about prognosis and investment or the balance of the moral issues involved they should be able to seek quick advice from some sort of legally-empowered higher authority. Possibly parents should have some ability to express a view on their preferred action. But parents have no right to command public resources outside of appropriate rationing. Every public, r donated dollar spent on this is not spent on something else. Ultimately we need public debate and consent about what medical procedures will be supported and what will not. I am conflicted on whether private services should be available to those able to afford them. I accept the private right, but deplore the deprivation of the poor which follows. I would be happy to pay very much higher taxes to provide better health services for the poor, both in my country and abroad.
 
It seems to me that Catholics are shifting more towards the position that extreme efforts to prolong life should be routine.
Actually, the Church’s position is that it is not necessary to do extraordinary things to prolong life. It may be nobel to do so but not required.
In my view anything costing a lot with a 9% probability of any sort of success is extreme and should not be offered as an option to parents.
What do you mean by “not offered”? If the parent asks, “can anything be done to save my child?” would you advocate the doctor lying and saying “no”? Or is it better to have these extraordinary measures available only if requested? That would mean that the children of the uneducated die while the children of those more informed about medical procedures get an option.
As a parent I might go for a 0.0009% chance for my own child, but that would be irrational.
No, it is not irrational to do everything you can to give your child a chance for life. It is programmed into our maternal instincts to protect and save our children.
We owe it to parents overcome by their instincts (not their morality) to save them from this.
Save them from what? Maternal instincts? Informed decision making opportunities? This sounds very much like you think “big brother” knows best what is good for your children. He doesn’t.
 
If you were diagnosed with cancer were given a 9% success rate of treatment, would you seek the treatment and pray you were one of the 9%? I would think yes! Why should it be different for a baby?

The husband of a friend was diagnosed with an aggressive cancer about 2 years ago and was given a very grim prognosis and very short time to live (months). He elected to have surgery and follow a strict treatment plan. He is still going strong!
 
Part of the problem is resources.

Even in America we must be aware that there is not an endless supply of anything, even tougne depressors. They did an NPR bit on this recently. There’s a shortage in potassium or some other compontent of a coctail that’s made for those who cannot eat. Without it people will become malnourished and die. The shortage is becuase it’s a fragile component only so much of it can be made at one time, sometimes they’res more than enough sometimes not.

In this scenero they presented a doctor torn between making sure that a 14yo cancer patient has it or a micro preemie (24weeks) or the 39 yo single father of 3 that was injured on the job. In the end they wound up giving it to the 14yo cancer survivor. The 39yo got sicker for a bit but recovered, the micro preemie did not. Sometimes the hard decisions have to be made. Sometimes it comes down to best case for survival, period. The teen, with the vitiman, had a 100% chance of surviving, without it less than 10%. The man had a 50/50 shot at survival with or without the drug. The baby had a 10% chance of survivial with the drug.

We should do WHAT we can, but doing ALL we can is a different thing. It also depends on the child’s will to live. You can have two identical children, born at the same millisecond of gestation, same hospital same resourses, same stable loving family who have the exact same job. But in the end it’s between God and the child. We forget that when they’re so tiny, as if it’s somehow blaming them. It’s not. A fighter is a fighter, just like children who survivie abortions. There are so many stories of parents and doctors who decided to let the child die in peace, only to have the child not need the oxygen tent, etc. It has to be taken scenerio by scenerio. There is never a right answer…telling parents there is a greater measure…not telling them…to me it needs to be left up to compassionate doctors and informed parents who will choose what’s right for that child. Let them fight and be in pain now to have a future or let them pass on and free them of tubes and monitors.
 
In the US if a hospital has a NICU, the NICU will likely be the most and best funded area in the hopsital.

My DS was born premature in a county hospital, many of his baby room mates were underprivileged. They all received the same care, and their release dates were not pushed up because of their economic status.

Decisions for preemies are made on an hour by hour basis, or a minute by minute basis. They determine how strong baby is and what treatment to do next survival is day by day. My 28 week preemie was never told “yes you will be perfect.” Neither was he told 'this is futile" Even when he was ravaged with sepsis, and the most dangerous form of sepsis no one said, “This is futile”

He could have suffered huge disabilities, but he’s fine. God bless him!
 
For me it’s simple:

All life is precious. Every effort should be made to save someone whose life is in danger, no matter what age they are or if they have or might get a disability. Picking and choosing who lives and dies is a slippery slope.
 
For me it’s simple:

All life is precious. Every effort should be made to save someone whose life is in danger, no matter what age they are or if they have or might get a disability. Picking and choosing who lives and dies is a slippery slope.
Brief but great answer.
Code:
It was my privilege and delight to provide care
for a 24-wk micropremie.  I worked as her nanny
for 10hr/day, 5 days/wk for two+ yrs.  

She is now 6 yrs-old and has no deficits.  She is thriving 
- and is in regular school.  I was hired by her parents 
because I had 3yrs of giving care to newborns/toddlers in 
a skilled nursing unit.  This child lost her twin five weeks 
after they were born.  That twin was the "stronger"infant.  

The twin who died was 1lb 5oz at birth.
The little survivor was 1lb 1oz at birth.

Blessed be God!
 
dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1296361/Twins-prove-baby-survive-23-weeks.html

preemies.about.com/od/preemieagesandstages/ss/PrematureBabiesWeekbyWeek_2.htm

pjsaunders.blogspot.com/2011/08/baby-born-at-23-weeks-who-is-happy-and.html

For us who are Catholics and Christians there is no moral possibility but to give these babies the best chance possible to survive and thrive.

Personally, as I have a sister who with her husband adopted two handicapped children, adopted, not fostered, when they had healthy natural children of their own,
and a brother who with his wife adopted three handicapped children one particularly severe, even though they also had healthy natural children
and these wonderful family members have given these children loving opportunities to develop to the best of their potential,
I do know that the lives of children who happen to be handicapped,
which can occur with very immature infants,
can be happy and fulfilled and a great gift to their families.
These five children in their varying handicaps, are happy people,
so I may have a different view to some!

Regardless, as Christians and as Catholics we can’t let babies die without doing our best to save them
Your siblings are amazing, giving people 🙂 I believe very adamantly in the rights and potential of disabled persons, even those severely affected by their disability. I agree with your entire post… we have a duty to those children, even when born so soon and facing extreme odds, to give them every chance possible. One cannot place a price tag on life.
 
For me it’s simple:

All life is precious. Every effort should be made to save someone whose life is in danger, no matter what age they are or if they have or might get a disability. Picking and choosing who lives and dies is a slippery slope.
Alix, I couldn’t agree more. I need to leave this thread alone while pregnant, it’s making me weepy!
 
“to say yes to killing their child”

???
Allowing nature to take its course is not “killing”.
 
Not when these infants have a chance of survival with proper medical intervention.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top