P
Porknpie
Guest
JR,I understand the point you’re making, but when discussing or trying to present Protestant beliefs, whether it’s on the apostasy of the church or the perpetual virginity of Mary, one has to cite the sources that they find credible, and that they use to support their positions. There’s a chapter devoted to Boettner’s Roman Catholicism in The Essential Catholic Survival Guide. The author of that chapter finds Boettner’s book to have had such great influence, to have been quoted by so many groups and authors, that he entitled that chapter The Anti-Catholic Bible. Say what you will about his scholarship or the truth or falsehood of his conclusions,** you still have to concede that what is found in that book is representative of much of the fundamentalist, Protestant world**.
You are correct in what you say…my point with Boettner…not to beat into the ground but for clarity…is he (other protestants), frequently, does not understand, nor makes an attempt to understand the Catholic faith…and it is available for free, on-line in the Catholic Catechism. Boettner is “horrific” in that he puts in writing multiple errors on church teaching and it’s clear he never checked his facts & assumptions. That’s why he is called “no scholar”. Unfortunately, many people, assume what is put to writing is true. So when Boettner says that the Catholic church teaches “A” …when in fact the church teaches, objectively “B”… there can be no dispute. I think we can both agree, that a “Scholar” or “Learned Person” is held to a higher standard than to put into writing that which is objectively not true & to have as a pattern, mis-statements or mis-representation of another’s view or position. “Scholarly” also assumes a level of research and effort that objectively, Boettner does not have.
On some topics & comments there is genuine theological disagreement on biblical text exegesis & the understanding of tradition.
In either case above, but especially the former, Boettner’s credibility is nil, he is simply factually wrong. And, Karl Keating is a must read…at a minimum, to “set the facts” straight. Happens all the time on CAF… both ways, for Catholic’s and non-Catholics.