Because it makes the pro-life movement look illogical and irrelevant by trying to pass laws that are completely unenforceable and send the message that some lives are more valuable than others. Why should the disabled have more (even useless)protections than the unplanned?
I still have no idea how outlawing selective abortion because of disability would suggest that the lives of disabled people are
more valuable than the lives of healthy people. Instead it would send a message that they are not
less valuable than healthy people. It would send a message that we are not (or do not want to be) a society that puts down its weaklings. Not aborting Down Syndrome babies
just because they have a disability is something even many pro-choice people could presumably get on board with, and while it would not be enforceable in a practical way at least we could make the mother sign something swearing the abortion isn’t being done for this or that reason, and forbid doctors from suggesting abortion to women whose unborn babies have just been diagnosed. Even if it only prevents 1% of abortions due to disability that’s still a lot of people, and that’s not irrational or irrelevant.
And are laws introducing illogical elements into our nation’s policies towards the unborn really a bad thing? If a pregnant woman is murdered and her unborn child dies the murderer is charged with two murders, not one. That makes no sense in this Roe v. Wade era, but that very illogicalness is a good thing. It makes people think about whether the child is a human being, and why killing it one way would be murder while killing it another way would be a right. Or we have outlawed partial-birth abortion, but what difference does pulling the child’s body partway out of its mother before killing it really make, other than making the same act more visible? If we protect the disabled from being killed because of their disability, why do we pretend to ourselves that unborn babies are less than human because they don’t look or can’t think like we do? We should try to introduce more of these kinds of pro-life values into civil law and preserve those already there, both to protect some of the innocent and also precisely
because they set up an illogical legal system that begs the question of why we don’t uniformly recognize the human rights of the unborn.