A Less Risky Down Syndrome Test Is Developed

  • Thread starter Thread starter SamTheNewfie
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

SamTheNewfie

Guest
New tests are coming to market that can detect Down syndrome in a fetus using a sample of the mother’s blood, potentially reducing the need for riskier invasive tests while also stirring ethical concerns.

nytimes.com/2011/10/18/business/sequenom-test-for-down-syndrome-raises-hopes-and-questions.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1

So it appears that this new test can diagnose Down Syndrome earlier and without the miscarriage risk of amnio or CVS. Will this save lives and/or increase the rate of abortions?
 
New tests are coming to market that can detect Down syndrome in a fetus using a sample of the mother’s blood, potentially reducing the need for riskier invasive tests while also stirring ethical concerns.

nytimes.com/2011/10/18/business/sequenom-test-for-down-syndrome-raises-hopes-and-questions.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1

So it appears that this new test can diagnose Down Syndrome earlier and without the miscarriage risk of amnio or CVS. Will this save lives and/or increase the rate of abortions?
My is that it may cause more abortions. Just because a person has Down’s Syndrome does not mean they will not have quality of life, in fact most Down’s Syndrome persons have great lives. Some may have other health concerns but most live to a ripe old age these day. My sister was diagnosed in 1957, she was 6 months old. By that time parents got a diagnosis they already loved their babies.

Tests of any type that detect possible health problems cause more abortions.
 
This could help parents prepare, both emotionally and in practical ways, for a baby with special needs, but yes, it could and probably will lead to more abortions.

I have an uncle with Down Syndrome and he lives a happy and meaningful life, really providing an anchor for his siblings I think especially during the times when first their father and then their mother (my grandparents) passed away.

A thought has just occurred to me, that many countries (not sure about the United States) make it illegal to abort a baby simply because if its sex. Perhaps a good issue for the pro-life movement to take on while Roe v. Wade remains on the books would be to seek to make illegal selective abortions done because of disability.
 
Perhaps a good issue for the pro-life movement to take on while Roe v. Wade remains on the books would be to seek to make illegal selective abortions done because of disability.
How would this be enforced? And doesn’t this send the message that unplanned children aren’t as worthy of protected as the disabled?
 
How would this be enforced? And doesn’t this send the message that unplanned children aren’t as worthy of protected as the disabled?
Does outlawing gender-selective abortion send a message that boys aren’t as worthy of being protected as girls?

As for how it would be enforced, that’s a good point, but just having the law on the books could discourage some parents from having abortions that they would have to pretend were for a different reason, and it would send a message to society that we as a nation do not consider disabled people to be better off dead.
 
Something truly shocking like 90% of people who receive a Down’s diagnosis during pregnancy abort. (Can’t recall the citation, but I’m pretty sure its close). Think about that a second. Maybe the jihadis have a point about the West…

Seems to me that enabling more people to find out sooner is just going to result in more people killing their babies.
 
The test only determines if you have a higher risk of having a Down’s Syndrome baby. If your odds are really high, then they recommend having an amnio performed. Strange that I came across this now as I had the test done this morning. Using an ultrasound, they measure the thickness of the skin at the back of baby’s neck. They combine that with the blood work results to determine your risk.

I am absolutely anti-abortion. The only reason that I agreed to the testing is that I would like to be prepared if my risk is increased. My middle child has had some health issues that have caused some delays, and I would have been able to get him the help he needed sooner if I had been aware of the complications. This is also my first “over-30” pregnancy, so there are a few things that come into play.

So far baby #4 looks healthy!

I do agree, though, that the testing could contribute to more abortions. And moms that go through with the amnio for more in-depth results, also risk miscarriage from that procedure. Technology advances come as a double-edged sword with things like this.
 
The test only determines if you have a higher risk of having a Down’s Syndrome baby.
That’s not true. You’re thinking of the current screening tests. This test can tell with 99% accuracy if the baby has Down sydrome. It has a 1% false positive and .5% false negative rate. It’s similar to an amnio without the risk.
 
Why would it unless it’s only illegal to abort a girl for sex selection?
Because worldwide most sex-selective abortions are against girls, by parents who wanted a son.

The law could be against aborting a child because of its health or disability status. Thus it would be just as illegal to abort a child because he or she is healthy and you wanted a disabled child, though a parent doing this would be about as likely as a Chinese parent aborting a son because they wanted a daughter.
 
That’s not true. You’re thinking of the current screening tests. This test can tell with 99% accuracy if the baby has Down sydrome. It has a 1% false positive and .5% false negative rate. It’s similar to an amnio without the risk.
I apologize - I was, in fact, thinking of the current screening test.
 
Because worldwide most sex-selective abortions are against girls, by parents who wanted a son.
But the law wouldn’t be worldwide. It would be in a country where fertility specialists say there is actually a preference for girls when it comes to gender selection.

Also, how could you prove someone was abortiong for gender or disability?
 
Something truly shocking like 90% of people who receive a Down’s diagnosis during pregnancy abort. (Can’t recall the citation, but I’m pretty sure its close). Think about that a second. Maybe the jihadis have a point about the West…

Seems to me that enabling more people to find out sooner is just going to result in more people killing their babies.
So is India the West now too? Because they have a high rate of abortion due to gender, since that society prefers boys to girls and there is even growing trend of getting gender reassignment surgery for babies for the same reason.

I agree with the rest of your post through.
 
But the law wouldn’t be worldwide. It would be in a country where fertility specialists say there is actually a preference for girls when it comes to gender selection.

Also, how could you prove someone was abortiong for gender or disability?
Don’t forget that the point about gender selection was that some countries have a law against it, including places like China where there is a strong preference for boys, and if there can be a law against it in an otherwise pro-abortion country then why not a law against abortion because of disability here, where that is clearly a big problem?

And sure, people would break the law by pretending disability was not their motive, but surely some lives would be saved, wouldn’t they?

Why does the idea aggravate you so much? I figure as long as Roe v. Wade is still on the books we might as well try to cut away at its edges as much as we can, as we are already doing with parental notification laws, the partial-birth abortion ban, etc. These things don’t solve the problem, but they make access to abortion just a little less easy, and that’s likely to save some lives. Surely that’s worth the effort, while we continue the more difficult struggle to get Roe v. Wade revoked.
 
Why does the idea aggravate you so much?
Because it makes the pro-life movement look illogical and irrelevant by trying to pass laws that are completely unenforceable and send the message that some lives are more valuable than others. Why should the disabled have more (even useless)protections than the unplanned?
 
Because it makes the pro-life movement look illogical and irrelevant by trying to pass laws that are completely unenforceable and send the message that some lives are more valuable than others. Why should the disabled have more (even useless)protections than the unplanned?
I still have no idea how outlawing selective abortion because of disability would suggest that the lives of disabled people are more valuable than the lives of healthy people. Instead it would send a message that they are not less valuable than healthy people. It would send a message that we are not (or do not want to be) a society that puts down its weaklings. Not aborting Down Syndrome babies just because they have a disability is something even many pro-choice people could presumably get on board with, and while it would not be enforceable in a practical way at least we could make the mother sign something swearing the abortion isn’t being done for this or that reason, and forbid doctors from suggesting abortion to women whose unborn babies have just been diagnosed. Even if it only prevents 1% of abortions due to disability that’s still a lot of people, and that’s not irrational or irrelevant.

And are laws introducing illogical elements into our nation’s policies towards the unborn really a bad thing? If a pregnant woman is murdered and her unborn child dies the murderer is charged with two murders, not one. That makes no sense in this Roe v. Wade era, but that very illogicalness is a good thing. It makes people think about whether the child is a human being, and why killing it one way would be murder while killing it another way would be a right. Or we have outlawed partial-birth abortion, but what difference does pulling the child’s body partway out of its mother before killing it really make, other than making the same act more visible? If we protect the disabled from being killed because of their disability, why do we pretend to ourselves that unborn babies are less than human because they don’t look or can’t think like we do? We should try to introduce more of these kinds of pro-life values into civil law and preserve those already there, both to protect some of the innocent and also precisely because they set up an illogical legal system that begs the question of why we don’t uniformly recognize the human rights of the unborn.
 
I still have no idea how outlawing selective abortion because of disability would suggest that the lives of disabled people are more valuable than the lives of healthy people. Instead it would send a message that they are not less valuable than healthy people.

Not aborting Down Syndrome babies just because they have a disability is something even many pro-choice people could presumably get on board with,
It would suggest the lives of disabled people are more valuable because they are receiving protection the unplanned are not, and yes it is something many pro-choice people would get on board with. That speaks to their lack of meaningful logic. If a fetus is merely a “clump of cells” then why does it matter if it’s aborted due to gender or disability?
 
It would suggest the lives of disabled people are more valuable because they are receiving protection the unplanned are not, and yes it is something many pro-choice people would get on board with. That speaks to their lack of meaningful logic. If a fetus is merely a “clump of cells” then why does it matter if it’s aborted due to gender or disability?
I won’t repeat myself about the desirability of exactly that kind of illogic in the law as long as abortion is legal, but it’s there above. Let me point out though that it’s not that the disabled would be protected from abortion, but that a particular motive for abortion (one that even many pro-choicers could agree is abominable) would be outlawed. Again I have a hard time imagining anyone coming to the conclusion that disabled people are actually more valuable than healthy people from a law such as the one I am suggesting.

As a matter of principle, while the weak do not have an inherently higher human dignity than the strong, the dignity of the weak is more vulnerable to being not recognized. That merits special emphasis and protection of their dignity to counteract the tendencies to dehumanize them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top