T
Timothy524
Guest
Good Fella Thank you for your response. It was helpful in many ways. To be continued…
Hi!Of course, Calvinists don’t advocate a license to sin, but they do subscribe to the notion of synthetic justification. More precisely, once a person accepts Jesus as his personal Lord and Saviour, God declares the perfect righteousness of Christ to be his by imputation. The righteousness which Catholics believe must inhere in the believer himself by the grace of sanctification doesn’t justify him before God. Calvinists believe that the righteousness of the believer is too imperfect to meet the divine standard, albeit the power of God’s grace. Christ’s external righteousness must be super-imposed upon the believer’s internal righteousness, so to speak, for him to be declared just by God. Thus, the corollary is that whatever the believer does, viz., repent, is superfluous because it fails to meet the divine standard of perfection. Repentance is nothing more than a sign of being saved. If one has truly accepted Jesus as his Lord and Saviour in faith, he will repent. But, meanwhile, it isn’t his sincere act of contrition in grace that renders him just, but rather his personal faith in Jesus alone that justifies him; since his Lord and Saviour’s righteousness is imputed to him when he repents of his sins by his faith in Christ’s merits. If what Calvinists believe is true, then what Jesus exhorts us to be is non-sequitur: “Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matt 5:48). In Protestant reformed theology, sanctification isn’t the formal cause of justification. Holiness is merely a required condition for having Christ’s alien righteousness imputed to the believer. Sanctity serves to confirm that a person has faith, nothing more. Walking in righteousness as Jesus walked in righteousness merely demonstrates that one is declared to be justified by the imputation of Christ’s absolutely perfect righteousness rather than one has been made acceptably righteous and so is justified while remaining in God’s grace.
***Happy are those whose transgression is forgiven,
whose sin is remitted.
Happy are those to whom the Lord imputes no guilt,
and in whose spirit there is no deceit.
Psalm 32, 1-2 ***
:heaven:
You’re most welcome, Timothy. :tiphat:Good Fella Thank you for your response. It was helpful in many ways.
The best way to learn from Jesus is to look to him and try to be like him: meek and humble of heart. Only then can we have the patience and fortitude to carry our cross. It is the proud of heart who can’t bear carrying the cross and regard it as a personal affront. By being inordinately self-appreciative, they see their trials as having no positive value, since they’re too focused on themselves and on what they feel they don’t deserve. But as Christians, we mustn’t forget that the crosses we bear have redemptive value. By offering our suffering to God as an oblation for our sins, in acknowledgement of our sins, we can make temporal satisfaction to God for them in union with Christ’s eternal satisfaction and thereby remit our debt to God for our past sins, regardless of whether God has already forgiven us. God forgave David his mortal sins of murder and adultery, but He still took David’s child from him because of his sins (2 Sam 12:14). This was to restore an equity of justice between them. David still owed God something in return for having taken something from Him, that being God’s sovereign dignity. Jesus made eternal satisfaction to God for our sins. Although he atoned for them more than sufficiently, the consequences of sin remain: suffering and death. That’s because temporally we are still indebted to God for our offenses against Him and are required to make restitution for the remittance of our debts. The purpose of satisfaction is to repair the offense offered to God and make Him favourable to us again. An act of reparation can be satisfactory to God only if it is painful.Timothy: In your opinion what is the best way to learn from Jesus Good Fella? How do you take his yoke upon you Good Fella?
To continue, Jesus says: Come to me, all you who labor and are burdened, and I will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you and learn from me, for I am meek and humble of heart; and you will find rest for yourselves. For my yoke is easy, and my burden light” (Mt. 11:28-30). Our Lord is citing the Book of Sirach 51, 23-30: ‘Come to me, all you that need instruction, and learn in my school. Why do you admit that you are ignorant and do nothing about it? Here is what I say: It costs nothing to be wise. Put on the yoke, and be willing to learn. The opportunity is always near. See for yourselves! I have not studied very hard, but I have found great contentment. No matter how much it costs you to get Wisdom, it will be well worth it. Be joyfully grateful for the Lord’s mercy, and never be ashamed to praise him. Do your duty at the proper time, and the Lord, at the time he thinks proper, will give you your reward.’ Jesus also says: “If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me” (Matt 26:24). By citing Sirach, Jesus is identifying himself with the eternal wisdom: the Divine Logos of God. Our souls can find rest only by learning how to be like Jesus was in his humanity: humbly obedient to the will of God and perfected in obedience by meekly suffering for the sins that offend our heavenly Father. Jesus produced our eternal reward for us, but if we hope to merit this reward, we must be willing to take up our cross after him. No matter how much it physically and emotionally costs us to follow the road to Calvary in our Lord’s footsteps, our love of God and hope in His promised reward should relieve us of our burdens (Rom 8:18).Timothy: In your opinion what is the best way to learn from Jesus Good Fella? How do you take his yoke upon you Good Fella?
The prodigal son was dead in his sin, but then was born again and reconciled with his father. Adam was once alive before he fell from grace. As his descendants, we are born spiritually dead, and because of our condition, physical death has entered the world. But by being born again through the regenerating waters of our baptism and receiving the Holy Spirit, death no longer has a final hold on us as we await the hope of our resurrection. We read in the Nicene Creed: “He suffered and was buried; and the third day He rose again, according to the Scriptures.” The statement “He rose again” refers to Jesus’ resurrection. Jesus didn’t rise from the dead twice, but in his humanity, he rose from the dead to new life.What do you think about “was dead, but is alive again”? I perceive “again”, to mean he once was alive, before he was dead. What do you think?
God’s discipline is inspired by His love for us (Prov 3:11-12). Without wisdom and understanding, we can easily mistake our hardships in life for God’s merciless wrath and anger crashing down on us because of our sins and failures, including those forgotten venial sins. However, God is a loving and caring Father who desires nothing more than to make us better children of His. As I told Timothy, God discipline’s us to cultivate our souls, overcome our disordered passions, and help us mature spiritually. If God didn’t love us, He would overlook our sins and leave us on the path to complete spiritual ruin and eternal damnation. Jesus himself “learned obedience through what he suffered, and being made perfect (in his humanity) he became the source of eternal salvation to all who obey him” (Heb 5:8-9). We must allow God to perfect us with His grace if we hope to have a share in our Lord’s resurrection. And being made perfect by learning obedience involves being disciplined for all our backslidings.I look forward to your thoughts on Heb12:7-9
Jesus is referring to his baptism of blood. Through this baptism, he will be immersed in suffering and death and will rise again (be resurrected) to a new life (cf. Lk 9:22).“Baptized” meaning water? What are your thoughts on Luke12:50?
Hi!You’re most welcome, Timothy. :tiphat:
The best way to learn from Jesus is to look to him and try to be like him: meek and humble of heart. Only then can we have the patience and fortitude to carry our cross. It is the proud of heart who can’t bear carrying the cross and regard it as a personal affront. By being inordinately self-appreciative, they see their trials as having no positive value, since they’re too focused on themselves and on what they feel they don’t deserve. But as Christians, we mustn’t forget that the crosses we bear have redemptive value. By offering our suffering to God as an oblation for our sins, in acknowledgement of our sins, we can make temporal satisfaction to God for them in union with Christ’s eternal satisfaction and thereby remit our debt to God for our past sins, regardless of whether God has already forgiven us. God forgave David his mortal sins of murder and adultery, but He still took David’s child from him because of his sins (2 Sam 12:14). This was to restore an equity of justice between them. David still owed God something in return for having taken something from Him, that being God’s sovereign dignity. Jesus made eternal satisfaction to God for our sins. Although he atoned for them more than sufficiently, the consequences of sin remain: suffering and death. That’s because temporally we are still indebted to God for our offenses against Him and are required to make restitution for the remittance of our debts. The purpose of satisfaction is to repair the offense offered to God and make Him favourable to us again. An act of reparation can be satisfactory to God only if it is painful.
Commutative justice is that virtue whose object is to render to everyone what belongs to him. When we sin against God, we deny Him what He is supremely entitled to, viz., our love and obedience. So, saying sorry isn’t enough to restore a balance of equity in our relationship with God. This requires that we show our love for Him which we have denied Him. By accepting our sufferings and offering them to God as means of reparation for our offenses against Him, equity is restored, as the pain of loss counters the pleasure of selfish gain. Look at it this way, if you had stopped at a red light and I recklessly came up from behind and dented the back fender of your car, you would expect me to offer to pay for the damages despite having forgiven me by accepting my apology. My having said I’m sorry would be meaningless and hold no merit if I didn’t offer to cover the expenses for the damage. And, so, even though you may have forgiven me of my fault, we couldn’t fully be reconciled, not if I refused to restore an equity of justice between us. This equity could be restored only if I chose to repair the effects of the damage I caused. I would have to restore what rightfully belongs to you - an undamaged car. The offense I caused you would still remain regardless of whether you have forgiven me and accepted my apology. If you should then decide to take me to court and sue for damages, you wouldn’t necessarily be acting out of vengeance and pouring down your wrath upon me because of my offense. You might simply be reclaiming what rightfully belongs to you by my having to pay the cost. If I were truly sorry, I’d be willing to cover the damage to begin with.
So, don’t think that all the hardships you are facing and have to endure are merely punishments inflicted on you by a wrathful God because of your sins. Holier people than us have suffered much more. It isn’t because God hates us for having offended Him. Rather, God loves us as a Father loves his children. And because He loves us as any good father should love his children, He disciplines us so that our relationship can be fully restored. God allowed the Assyrians and Babylonians to conquer and take His chosen people into captivity. He even allowed the Babylonians to destroy His holy Temple in Jerusalem for the sake of his people. Through their trials and hardships, they remembered how much Yahweh had faithfully done for them since their exodus from Egypt and realized how much they needed Him for all their blessings. They saw that all their idolatry and apostasy was vain. Through suffering, the Israelites experienced a change of heart. Once rejuvenated in spirit, and the time of their discipline was over, God liberated them again from slavery.
To be continued…
:harp:
Hi!
…as always, your posts are very enjoyable… they are very comprehensive and intelligible.
Hi! :tiphat: And thank you always for your compliments.All this blushing might lead to a stroke.
uch:
I think that we must consider not so much “pain” but “self-sacrifice” since we can offer to God both our joys and our pains, our happiness and afflictions, and our success and our failures; it is by placing God first, self-sacrifice, that we can in deed exalt Him in all that we do.
Hi!Hi! :tiphat: And thank you always for your compliments.All this blushing might lead to a stroke.
uch:
Agreed. All our personal sacrifices, whether they be of praise or thanksgiving or for sin should be for the glory of God. They all require a humble and contrite heart and a broken spirit in mind of our sins and unworthiness. However, the sacrifices we offer up to God for our sins as acts of reparation for them require pain and personal loss for satisfaction to be made to God, for the object is to restore moral equilibrium in our relationship with Him.
Every sin involves some sort of inordinate pleasure which is indulged in against God’s laws. So, in sin there are pleasure and disobedience. What violates God’s laws is indulging in forbidden pleasures. So, to blot out sin and the debt we’ve incurred, there must be something to counter-balance the sinful pleasures (gluttony-fasting, etc.) and fully compensate God for our offenses. The two essential components of reparation for sin are repentance and penance which requires pain and loss to meet its objective. Pain and suffering have no moral and spiritual value if divorced from repentance. Repentance is incomplete if the debt of sin remains in the balance. This debt can only be remitted by proper acts of penance whose pain and loss counter-balance the sinful pleasure one is heartily sorry for. It is through repentance that suffering gains redemptive value, which consists in willingly accepting the pain and loss for one’s sin. Only then can the penitent be fully reconciled to God before being admitted into Heaven. The poor souls in Purgatory are there to remit all debts of sin which they failed to do by the time they passed from this world. To pay off their debts to God, they must willingly suffer and accept the need for suffering to be worthy of entering Heaven. Yet their purgation of sins includes the joy of having been saved and the consoling prospect of finally being delivered from their torments to be eternally with God.
Penitence is a Christian virtue, whose only reason that it exists is sin. Temperance is a virtue in that it consists in regulating our appetites and desires. If there’s a need for this regulation, it’s only because “sin entered the world through one man”. Because of original sin, man’s will is prone to deviate from the straight path at variance with the law of nature and thereby he indulges in needless and vain pleasures that he has no God-given natural right to. By claiming this right for himself in opposition to the will of God, his indulgence offends God’s sovereignty over the world. To restore equilibrium in our relationship with God an equal swing in the right direction is needed to counter-balance the equal swing in the wrong direction. So, in the Divine moral order, since the disorder of sin consists in partaking of forbidden pleasures and offending God, there must be two exponents that are necessary for the process of restoring this moral equilibrium. The act of sin essentially lies in the offense given to God and the disobedience of the person who commits the act through the wicked consent of the will, so the essential element of reparation should be in the change of heart and in the sorrow for the offense. Certainly, punishment alone may expiate any sinful pleasure, but if the heart is not converted and a person doesn’t accept the punishment willingly in a contrite spirit, the expiation itself would hold no moral significance.
This is how it is for the souls of poor sinners in Hell. They are undergoing their expiatory punishment under constraint. Unlike the poor souls in Purgatory, the eternally damned aren’t willingly accepting their suffering in a true spirit of repentance and love of God. Hell is a place of penal expiation to compensate for the indulgence in sinful pleasures. But unlike Purgatory, it isn’t a place where the compensating punishment is undergone for the sake of making reparation to God for admittance into Heaven.
Hence, if a compensating punishment or disciplinary action of God is accompanied by our interior dispositions of sorrow and a frim desire of amendment and our willing acceptance to be punished in acknowledgement of our sins, we have reparation. And if the reparation is made complete, proportionate to the offense (gluttony-fasting; greed-almsgiving, etc.), we have satisfaction to God for our sins. To merit God’s favour and stand just in His sight by removing the debts of our sins, we must make acts of reparation proportionate to our offenses to restore equilibrium in our relationship with God. And this involves pain and loss. The reparation Jesus made for the sins of mankind required that he suffer and die. Our sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving are distinct in characteristic from our sacrifices for sin.
Surely he took up our pain
and bore our suffering,
yet we etseemed him stricken,
smitten by God, and afflicted.
But he was pierced for our transgressions,
he was crushed for our iniquities;
the punishment that brought us peace was on him,
and by his wounds we are healed.
Isaiah 53, 4-5
:heaven:
Hi!
I concur… and sorry for laying it on thick… I wanted to acknowledge your efforts since virtual vacuum can lead one to think that one is hitting against a wall or running into infinity… so, just remember that some one is always thinking:
Hi! :tiphat:
No need to apologize for contributing a very important reminder. It’s when the going is good that we’re more inclined to forget about God and our dependence on Him because of being too much absorbed in our success and happiness. Even an atheist doesn’t give any thought to God, though negatively, until he’s faced with the problem of suffering and misery.
In ancient Judaism, Mosaic law prescribed three basic sacrifices: burnt offerings of praise, thanksgiving, and for sin. The sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving appear to have nothing to do with offering something at great cost to ourselves or have reparatory value. But in Judaic spirituality, sacrifice was closely intertwined with praise and thanksgiving. These sacrifices were supposed to be offered while being sorrowfully mindful of personal sins and served to make personal restitution for all past offenses against God even when reaping His blessings.
Praise doesn’t normally cost us anything in everyday life, but it sometimes does in the spiritual realm. It took an act of will for the ancient Hebrews to lay aside their pride and humble themselves before God as they placed their burnt offerings on the altar. The prescribed sacrifice of praise was intended to express their belief, that despite all the hardships they might have to endure, God could still be trusted because of His goodness to them and the promises he had made to their fathers. True faith called for praising and honouring God at times when it appeared He had abandoned His people. By offering the sacrifice of praise, the Jews were expressing their faith in God, that despite any stormy weather and His apparent distance, God would never forget them. The burnt offerings were meant to joyfully affirm that the Lord was good and to be trusted; He cared for his people and was their only refuge even in the wake of hardships (Nahum 1:7). This sacrifice was offered more meaningfully and pleasing to God when it was made during times of trouble. It was on these occasions that the faith of God’s chosen people was put to the test and a conversion of heart was called for after a lapse of faith. This burnt offering had reparatory value for the person presenting it, though it wasn’t expiatory like the burnt sin offering was for the entire nation through the mediation of the Levitical priesthood.
The sacrifice of praise wasn’t intended to reward God by lavishing praise on Him for His blessings while life’s circumstances were good. God made it known to His people that honouring Him with their lips while their hearts were far from Him didn’t please Him (Isa 29:13). They could never place God in their debt. It was very easy for the Jews to praise God when all was well and presume they were in His favour simply because they were observing the ceremonial precepts of the law. But the sacrifice that God demanded was one offered in a broken spirit, and a broken and contrite heart (Ps 51:16-17). The burnt offerings should be made in a repentant faith, if these sacrifices of praise were to please God. The same could be said for the sacrifices of thanksgiving which were made in a spirit of gratitude for all the blessings God’s people received from Him. These sacrifices had no merit unless the Jews offered them while being mindful of their sins. They should be offered in a spirit of repentance. This meant that the Jews, when offering the sacrifice of thanksgiving, should be ever mindful of the blessings they didn’t deserve because of their backslidings. Real praise and thanksgiving had to flow from a worshipping heart regardless of what the circumstances might be (Acts 16: 23-25).
When the Jews offered their sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving to God, the proper spirit of the offerings demanded that they never lose their trust in God and faith in His goodness in good times and in bad times. God would not accept these sacrifices unless His people were ever mindful that they could forfeit His blessings at any given time because of their infidelity. The Jews, in their stubbornness of heart, had to painfully learn this when they offered up these sacrifices for decades while in exile. In Assyria and in Babylon, their sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving came from a humble heart that had been purified by fire.
In exile, the Jews could offer up their sacrifices in a humble and contrite heart for their sins. They could truly show their trust in God in the circumstance they found themselves in. When presenting their burnt offerings, they could not only remember all the past blessings God bestowed on them despite their backslidings, but more importantly own to themselves that whatever blessings God chose to take back from them, viz., His protection from their enemies, it was only because of their unfaithfulness to God. In captivity, the Jews had to reaffirm that it was God who would remain faithful in His covenant with them. Any chastisement they might receive would be something they had brought upon themselves. This was the true spirit of the sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving that the Jews acquired while in exile after having learned through suffering. Their sacrifices were what they were intended to be – the highest form of worship the Jews could offer God. By offering these sacrifices in a true spirit during their time of trial, the Jews made reparation for all those sacrifices they made by just paying God lip service while being unmindful of their infidelities. Having disciplined them, God freed His people from slavery and restored them in His favour.
:heaven:
Hi!Hi! :tiphat:
…In ancient Judaism, Mosaic law prescribed three basic sacrifices: burnt offerings of praise, thanksgiving, and for sin. The sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving appear to have nothing to do with offering something at great cost to ourselves or have reparatory value. But in Judaic spirituality, sacrifice was closely intertwined with praise and thanksgiving. These sacrifices were supposed to be offered while being sorrowfully mindful of personal sins and served to make personal restitution for all past offenses against God even when reaping His blessings.
Praise doesn’t normally cost us anything in everyday life, but it sometimes does in the spiritual realm. It took an act of will for the ancient Hebrews to lay aside their pride and humble themselves before God as they placed their burnt offerings on the altar. The prescribed sacrifice of praise was intended to express their belief, that despite all the hardships they might have to endure, God could still be trusted because of His goodness to them and the promises he had made to their fathers. True faith called for praising and honouring God at times when it appeared He had abandoned His people. By offering the sacrifice of praise, the Jews were expressing their faith in God, that despite any stormy weather and His apparent distance, God would never forget them. The burnt offerings were meant to joyfully affirm that the Lord was good and to be trusted; He cared for his people and was their only refuge even in the wake of hardships (Nahum 1:7). This sacrifice was offered more meaningfully and pleasing to God when it was made during times of trouble. It was on these occasions that the faith of God’s chosen people was put to the test and a conversion of heart was called for after a lapse of faith. This burnt offering had reparatory value for the person presenting it, though it wasn’t expiatory like the burnt sin offering was for the entire nation through the mediation of the Levitical priesthood.
The sacrifice of praise wasn’t intended to reward God by lavishing praise on Him for His blessings while life’s circumstances were good. God made it known to His people that honouring Him with their lips while their hearts were far from Him didn’t please Him (Isa 29:13). They could never place God in their debt. It was very easy for the Jews to praise God when all was well and presume they were in His favour simply because they were observing the ceremonial precepts of the law. But the sacrifice that God demanded was one offered in a broken spirit, and a broken and contrite heart (Ps 51:16-17). The burnt offerings should be made in a repentant faith, if these sacrifices of praise were to please God. The same could be said for the sacrifices of thanksgiving which were made in a spirit of gratitude for all the blessings God’s people received from Him. These sacrifices had no merit unless the Jews offered them while being mindful of their sins. They should be offered in a spirit of repentance. This meant that the Jews, when offering the sacrifice of thanksgiving, should be ever mindful of the blessings they didn’t deserve because of their backslidings. Real praise and thanksgiving had to flow from a worshipping heart regardless of what the circumstances might be (Acts 16: 23-25).
When the Jews offered their sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving to God, the proper spirit of the offerings demanded that they never lose their trust in God and faith in His goodness in good times and in bad times. God would not accept these sacrifices unless His people were ever mindful that they could forfeit His blessings at any given time because of their infidelity. The Jews, in their stubbornness of heart, had to painfully learn this when they offered up these sacrifices for decades while in exile. In Assyria and in Babylon, their sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving came from a humble heart that had been purified by fire.
In exile, the Jews could offer up their sacrifices in a humble and contrite heart for their sins. They could truly show their trust in God in the circumstance they found themselves in. When presenting their burnt offerings, they could not only remember all the past blessings God bestowed on them despite their backslidings, but more importantly own to themselves that whatever blessings God chose to take back from them, viz., His protection from their enemies, it was only because of their unfaithfulness to God. In captivity, the Jews had to reaffirm that it was God who would remain faithful in His covenant with them. Any chastisement they might receive would be something they had brought upon themselves. This was the true spirit of the sacrifices of praise and thanksgiving that the Jews acquired while in exile after having learned through suffering. Their sacrifices were what they were intended to be – the highest form of worship the Jews could offer God. By offering these sacrifices in a true spirit during their time of trial, the Jews made reparation for all those sacrifices they made by just paying God lip service while being unmindful of their infidelities. Having disciplined them, God freed His people from slavery and restored them in His favour.
:heaven:
(St. Luke 6:46)46 “Why do you call me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ and do not do what I say?
Well… some would say the relationship has changed due to the Trinity and Jesus being at the right hand of the Father. Some might even suggest a relationship wasn’t possible with God until the cross because Jesus still had to preach to those waiting in prison and moral sins could not be forgiven yet (likely due to lack of communion with God).The relationship has not changed… only the means!
Others would say that the relationship with God isn’t any different, but one’s understanding of who God is has changed.Well… some would say the relationship has changed due to the Trinity and Jesus being at the right hand of the Father.
Others would suggest that a relationship with God did in fact exist by the covenant He had established with His people. Those waiting in prison (purgatory) were forgiven by the foreseen merits of Christ, or else they wouldn’t have been in prison, but in Hell. If those in the limbo of the fathers hadn’t been in communion with God, they wouldn’t be there. The Levitical sacrifices for sin were expiatory, but only made temporal satisfaction to God.Some might even suggest a relationship wasn’t possible with God until the cross because Jesus still had to preach to those waiting in prison and moral sins could not be forgiven yet (likely due to lack of communion with God).
Jesus is the only way to the Father. The activity of the Holy Spirit isn’t confined to the sacraments. Non-Christians can be saved by the baptism of desire or of blood.Some might say Jesus is the only way to the Father. Some might even say that Jesus is only found in the legal sacraments of the catholic church which means to have a relationship with God, they would at least require a legal baptism which was only made possible since Jesus on earth…
Hi!Well… some would say the relationship has changed due to the Trinity and Jesus being at the right hand of the Father. Some might even suggest a relationship wasn’t possible with God until the cross because Jesus still had to preach to those waiting in prison and moral sins could not be forgiven yet (likely due to lack of communion with God).
Some might say Jesus is the only way to the Father. Some might even say that Jesus is only found in the legal sacraments of the catholic church which means to have a relationship with God, they would at least require a legal baptism which was only made possible since Jesus on earth…
If not, then I guess the person can stay unbaptised at emnity with God and angels can take their petitions up to ‘god’ whoever that might be… but regardless, that wouldn’t really be the SAME relationship with God as compared to our current Christian relationship.
(Leviticus 11:45b)therefore be holy, because I am holy.
I was laughing at the use of “darn”, rather than a stronger expletive.Hi!
…I know it may seem phony (copycat-like) but I have had quite similar reactions as I read through your posts… I have even made attempts to share my thoughts but have restarted the replies so as not to confuse/derail the spirit of the exchange… but since you’ve brought it up: …you cracking up?
Sometimes I do tell jokes. If we can’t laugh, what’s the point?…sometimes it hits me quite unexpectedly (I am almost completely ignorant of non-Catholic theologies and understanding) and I surrender to the explosive:
That’s why I have listened to them, written down all the verses they use, and discovered Scripture that refutes them.When you present Calvinist understanding I just cannot help but feel sorry that so much misunderstanding is being taught and accredited to God’s Revelation…
It’s mostly because of the assault “Sovereign Predestined Salvation” does on God’s character. No matter how one tries to dodge the issue, God would be responsible for man’s sins!…at time I can almost feel your fervor to bring the Calvinists to the Fullness of Truth. I believe that the Holy Spirit has awakened this need in you.
I’m honored by your words & prayers! :hug3:I can only pray that He keeps Guiding you in your efforts to share the Word of God!
Brother, I’m fully in agreement with you… this is why we cannot truncate Scriptures and apply selective reasoning from those passages that we want to keep while rejecting/voiding Scriptures when passages do not seem to agree with our construct.
They apply the “CATCH-22” — “If a person is unsaved NOW, then he was never TRULY saved in the FIRST place.” This causes wild interpretations (as I just cited above), stamping clear verses with “NOT REALLY”, and rewriting Scripture (like in Jn10:26 & 28 they add “not-even-yourselves” to “No one can snatch you from His hand”.How deep are those understandings that basically nullify God’s Salvific Plan? How can Calvinism (and others) ignore:
(Rom8:12-14 citation)
That’s exactly the issue! IN that, “living-in-sin” is possible! In 1Cor10:1-13, “don’t crave evil, don’t be immoral, don’t be covetous” – any of those things read as “not really possible” for the saved? The consequence, “therefore let he who thinks he stand take heed lest he fall”!St. Paul is not addressing unbelievers/pagans (as I keep hearing from many); St. Paul is clearly telling the Believers that if they live in sin (the flesh) they will die.
Exactly. There are many places where men are judged according to their deeds (Rom2:6-8, Rev20:13, etc.) — but good deeds never save anyone, and evil deeds never condemn anyone; our DEEDS, expose where our heart WAS. A heart that did good deeds knew Jesus, and a heart that did evil did not. That’s the connection with these verses — as John says in 1:5:10 (echoed in places like Jn3:18-20), some are condemned BECAUSE they HAVE NOT believed the testimony. Their unbelief exposed because of their evil deeds!…and is God the One Who damns them? NO!
Exactly that. And – the KING clothes us with HIS righteousness. Matt22:2-14, Isaiah61:10, etcetera.The very next exhortation tells the Believers that it is they that must (with God’s Grace) mortify (give death–crucify, as with the Cross of Christ) their sinful compulsions and their sinful acts… doing this (submitting their will to God’s Will) they are able to Walk being Lead by the Holy Spirit… responding to God’s Call that we “Be Holy, for I AM HOLY!”
…this is both a statement and a requirement: if man claims to be in the Light he must Walk (Live) in the Light (again John 15:1-10); it is not “some” have been chosen and are therefore righteous… but that all must choose to Live day by day (moment by moment) in the Faith!

Excellent. John7:24-27 — if our self worth is based on JESUS (the Rock!), then we do not need validation from fallible men; we are complete, because He loved us and died for us.Timothy524:![]()
1. We must first own that we aren’t absolutely perfect and that only God is. Thus, we have no reason to be proud and boastful. The root of the problem is that we tend to think too highly of ourselves. We should focus more on how great God is and less on ourselves.It seems like I am on a path of self-destruction and the defeat of my own purpose… What is the best remedy for pride?
Spot on. For those unwilling to look up cited verses:2. We have to revise any false notions that we have. People who suffer from pride normally think they are better than other people and take great lengths to show that they are. So when somebody comes along who they judge to be better than them, they see themselves as failures and may even fall into the dark pit of self-condemnation. The root of the problem is a false sense of self-sufficiency, that all their personal assets are their own creation. But the truth is we have no right to judge ourselves and others in comparison with each other. All our personal assets are gifts from God who alone has the right to distribute them as He pleases. And if all the gifts we have are from God, we mustn’t boast as if they are produced by us (1 Cor 4:7). It’s better for us to focus on how we can put our own gifts to good use while not comparing ours to others (Prov 25:27). To overcome pride, we must learn to stop being self-centered and self-appreciating which can lead to self-degradation, if not the degradation of others.
Yes. And — “resist the devil and he will flee; submit yourselves therefore to God. Draw near to God and He will draw near to you. Humble yourselves in the presence of the Lord, and He will exalt you.” James43. What you’re experiencing could very well be a spiritual attack by the devil, who is adept at confusing truths with lies which results in much mayhem and confusion. The best remedy is prayer and imploring divine help (1 Pet 4:8). I receive much strength and encouragement by reading the Psalms and identifying myself with David. The Psalms are my favourite prayers to God. For me they are a great means to pour out to God all that fills my soul. I feel so much closer to Him when I mediate on them and express myself to God in David’s person.
Excellent! In that, constantly regard Jesus as a real person with whom you have a real fellowship (1Jn1:3). This is the reality of our faith; we do not beat ourselves into righteousness, we draw near to Him!**4. **Resist vain temptations for the sake of self-gratifications, focus on your relationship with God and how to strengthen it, and latch on to His promises.
Humble yourselves under the mighty power of God, and at the right time He will lift you up in honor. - 1 Peter 5,6 ***
Timothy524:![]()
By being still. Instead of talking to myself all the time, I should pause and be quiet to hear what God has to say. When I pray to our heavenly Father, I wish to open up a dialogue with Him. I tell Him all that’s making me anxious, then I stop to listen to what He has to say.How do you see and hear?
!!!Yes. And as Jude says, “But you, beloved, building yourselves up on your most holy faith, praying in the Holy Spirit, keep yourselves in the love of God, waiting anxiously for the mercy of our Lord Jesus Christ to eternal life.”Timothy524:![]()
By being persuaded with the help of the gifts of the Holy Spirit, the gift of knowledge being foremost.How do you co-operate with His grace?
Timothy524:![]()
By acknowledging that only God is absolutely perfect, and that all our personal assets are gifts from God which we have no claim to. Without Him, we are nothing.How do you stay in this place that we are no better than each other?

That’s really it. Jeremiah29:11-13 applies to us too; "I know the plans I have for you, for prosperity and not adversity. Then you will come to Me and pray to Me and I will hear you. You will seek Me and you will find Me, when you search with all your heart; I will be found by you."Timothy524:![]()
Keep in mind that God has different plans for each of us for His good purpose. ‘God works for the good to those who love Him’ (Rom 8:28). Essau was his own undoing for not loving God enough. His desire was more important to him than God. Our selfishness alienates us from God.…give me advice on how to accept God’s role for me and how I can accept his desire for me
Think of God’s punishment as a means of discipline. It serves to cultivate our souls, correct our mistakes, and curb our passions, that we may mature in the most positive and effective way. Consider it a blessing - not a curse! (Heb 12:3-11)
In John15, “every branch that bears fruit He prunes, that it may bear more fruit”. Why were we created? For HIS purpose(s). What is called “fruit”, is that which is useful to Him. Pruning hurts; the dead and wayward branches get cut off. But it increases our usefulness to Him.First of all, God doesn’t want us to punish ourselves. He is our judge. But God does want us to examine our conscience, through which He may speak to us. Any punishment we receive from God, we bring on ourselves.
Hi, James!Which is what I said?
Fruit = words (deeds) that glorify GodIn John15, “every branch that bears fruit He prunes, that it may bear more fruit”. Why were we created? For HIS purpose(s). What is called “fruit”, is that which is useful to Him…
Ask a Calvinist, “Why would they WANT to sneak in and pretend to be saved”? Their doctrine is conflicted!Hi!
…I’ve heard of similar claims (at least once I was engaged with it on this very forum)… “the elect,” those who God has Saved as Jesus has put them in the Hand of God… those “sheep” that will not lose Salvation… when it comes to those of their groups that have left… well ‘they were never true Believers’ or ‘they were not of the elect (for Salvation)…’ somehow they simply sneaked in till they got found out. :bigyikes::bigyikes::bigyikes:
Yes. And “impugns God’s character”, charges Him with causality in sin (doesn’t matter if it’s direct or indirect), denies our responsibility, destroys the motivation to share the Gospel, on and on.I thought that God saw into our inner most being… that we could not deceive God… that God did not judge my appearance… do you see how their construct nullifies God’s Word… and in so doing they pit themselves, perhaps even unknowingly, against God?
You have it right. “Teleios”, complete/finished. IOW, righteous.Of course, Calvinists don’t advocate a license to sin, but they do subscribe to the notion of synthetic justification. More precisely, once a person accepts Jesus as his personal Lord and Saviour, God declares the perfect righteousness of Christ to be his by imputation. The righteousness which Catholics believe must inhere(?) in the believer himself by the grace of sanctification doesn’t justify him before God. Calvinists believe that the righteousness of the believer is too imperfect to meet the divine standard, albeit the power of God’s grace. Christ’s external righteousness must be super-imposed upon the believer’s internal righteousness, so to speak, for him to be declared just by God. Thus, the corollary is that whatever the believer does, viz., repent, is superfluous because it fails to meet the divine standard of perfection. Repentance is nothing more than a sign of being saved. If one has truly accepted Jesus as his Lord and Saviour in faith, he will repent. But, meanwhile, it isn’t his sincere act of contrition in grace that renders him just, but rather his personal faith in Jesus alone that justifies him; since his Lord and Saviour’s righteousness is imputed to him when he repents of his sins by his faith in Christ’s merits. If what Calvinists believe is true, then what Jesus exhorts us to be is non-sequitur: “Be perfect as your heavenly Father is perfect” (Matt 5:48).
In Protestant reformed theology, sanctification isn’t the formal cause of justification. Holiness is merely a required condition for having Christ’s alien righteousness imputed to the believer. Sanctity serves to confirm that a person has faith, nothing more. Walking in righteousness as Jesus walked in righteousness merely demonstrates that one is declared to be justified by the imputation of Christ’s absolutely perfect righteousness rather than one has been made acceptably righteous and so is justified while remaining in God’s grace.
They are charged with guilt, they who continue in sin. Shall we start marking out verses, like 1Cor6:9-11, Eph5:5-6, and Gal5:19-21? And 1Jn3 (I think 5-10) is clear also.***Happy are those whose transgression is forgiven,
whose sin is remitted.
Happy are those to whom the Lord imputes no guilt,
and in whose spirit there is no deceit.
Psalm 32, 1-2 ***