M
Mickey_Jackson
Guest
It has always bothered me on these forums when people claim that the Novus Ordo Mass of Paul VI is somehow heretical or invalid. And no, it’s not just because “the Pope said it’s OK,” it’s because I have yet to see any one of the critics of the NO on these forums back up their complaints with facts. I have heard the phrase “the Novus Ordo contains heresy” too many times to count, but not once have I seen anyone give a good example of a heresy found in the Ordinary Roman Missal. Some of the bad examples I’ve heard are:
I’m sick of platitudes, particularly those that attack Holy Mother Church and her Earthly head, the Pope. Don’t we get enough of that from the Protestant Fundamentalists?
That’s my rant. Sorry about that; I just had lots of pent-up energy after sitting for five hours taking the AP US exam. Carry on!
- “The Missal of Paul VI says the Mass is a meal, not a Sacrifice” - of course if you actually read the Missal you see that the word “meal” is not mentioned once, but Sacrifice is mentioned in every Eucharistic prayer, at least implicitly (the EP that Traditionalists love to hate, EPII, is from the Mass of Hippolytus and is probably the most “traditional” of the four).
- “They took out the Offertory to deny the true theology of the Mass” - actually, they took out most of the references to Sacrifice before the Consecration to emphasize the fact that the Sacrifice occurs at the Consecration and is of the Body and Blood of Christ, not of the bread and wine.
- “Quo Primum was infallible” - St. Pius V, when he promulgated his version of the Breviary, concluded with the same language as Quo Primum, saying that the decree was to be “valid in perpetuity,” that anyone who changed a word of it would incur the wrath of Ss. Peter and Paul, etc.; and yet the first Pope to radically revise the Breviary was not John XXIII, not Paul VI, but that raving Modernist, Pius X!
- My personal favorite: “The Novus Ordo uses the Protestant version of the Our Father” - Hey, if you think it’s heretical to say to the Father that “the Kingdom, the power, and the glory” are His, I’m not even sure you’re a Christian.
I’m sick of platitudes, particularly those that attack Holy Mother Church and her Earthly head, the Pope. Don’t we get enough of that from the Protestant Fundamentalists?
That’s my rant. Sorry about that; I just had lots of pent-up energy after sitting for five hours taking the AP US exam. Carry on!