A traditional catholic defends the Neocatechumenal Way

  • Thread starter Thread starter santodomingo
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
“For those who believe no proof is necessary for those who dont no proof is possible” Anon.
Of course, St. Paul famously wrote that we should test all things. By the way, that line was uttered at the tail end of the movie “Song of Bernadette.”
 
The Statutes themselves are the documentation. The quote that you’re looking for WH is actually quoted in the statutes too. Maybe the Church didn’t verify first, eh? What’s your address? I’ll mail you a copy. Or get a copy yourself off Amazon for $15 or $16.
 
The Statutes themselves are the documentation. The quote that you’re looking for WH is actually quoted in the statutes too. Maybe the Church didn’t verify first, eh? What’s your address? I’ll mail you a copy. Or get a copy yourself off Amazon for $15 or $16.

Nice try Earthen Vessel —but the Statues do not give the proper documentation. So I will ask again —you defend the NCW–provide the evidence to support the words the NCW puts in late Pope’s mouth.
 

Nice try Earthen Vessel —but the Statues do not give the proper documentation. So I will ask again —you defend the NCW–provide the evidence to support the words the NCW puts in late Pope’s mouth.
Like I said, you’re a flat earther. And one that’s full of it to boot. You’ve been beaten and can’t admit it. That’s ok. The Lord loves you anyway, so be of good cheer.
 
Like I said, you’re a flat earther. And one that’s full of it to boot. You’ve been beaten and can’t admit it. That’s ok. The Lord loves you anyway, so be of good cheer.

Dear Earthen Vessel – it has become apparent that you cannot provide the evidence to support the words the NCW has put in our late Pope’s mouth. I suggest that you refrain from picking at straws --and as I mentioned earlier—it does nothing to enhance your credibility.
 
I guess this is what bothers me with the whole movement. Liturgy is the public prayer of the Church. No one yet has answered my “why”. Not to throw out the baby with the bath water, why is is necessary to monkey around with the Mass to evengelize.
Let me bump this because I have never received any reaponse. Why the Mass, or why change the Mass? The real presence of Christ was not enough. We are supposed to walk by faith and not sight, so why the need to change anything? Bible study, evangelism, all this can occur outside the Mass.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top