ABC defends Compass program on same-sex marriage [CNAU]

  • Thread starter Thread starter Catholic_Press
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is why I don’t watch the ABC. I just wish they weren’t taxpayer funded.

It is no surprise that the ABC approves and promotes same-sex relationships. What does surprise me is that only one of the dinner guests opposed same-sex marriage when there were 3 religious figures at the table.
Anglican Bishop The Right Reverend Robert Forsyth, Baptist minister Reverend Nathan Nettleton, Jesuit priest Father Frank Brennan, Professor Dennis Altman, broadcaster Julie McCrossin and dad and gay rights advocate, Geoff Thomas.

The article doesn’t say, but I sure hope it was the Jesuit priest who was the one opposing.

btw, in Australia, the Liberal Party is the conservatives.
 
Sickening. The mainstream media is not so mainstream anymore. It seems that now they are better called the liberal media.
 
The article doesn’t say, but I sure hope it was the Jesuit priest who was the one opposing.
Here is the transcript of the program. It also appears that the video is available for download.
abc.net.au/compass/s3251965.htm

I just briefly skimmed through the transcript, but it appears that the Anglican bishop was forcefully against same-sex marriage, while the Baptist minister was comfortable with same-sex marriage and opposed to banning it. The Jesuit priest was more equivocal, talking about the complexity of the issue and the pitfalls to both sides.
 
Here is the transcript of the program. It also appears that the video is available for download.
abc.net.au/compass/s3251965.htm

I just briefly skimmed through the transcript, but it appears that the Anglican bishop was forcefully against same-sex marriage, while the Baptist minister was comfortable with same-sex marriage and opposed to banning it. The Jesuit priest was more equivocal, talking about the complexity of the issue and the pitfalls to both sides.
If you go to comments on the article, the priest responds and seems to support it. 😦
 
If you go to comments on the article, the priest responds and seems to support it. 😦
Hm… he seems to favor civil unions. Here is his response to one commenter’s charge that he is not Catholic:
As for my Catholicity, I have continued to espouse traditional sacramental marriage within church communities while acknowledging a place for the state recognising same sex civil unions. I have previously said:
“Especially with an ageing society, the state has an interest in recognising and affirming relationships between persons committed to supporting each other, regardless of their sexual orientation. Discrimination against same sex couples should be removed in the public domain.
“In the UK, this has been achieved by legislating for civil unions. Archbishop Vincent Nichols, President of their Catholic Bishops Conference, recently said, ‘We were very nuanced. We did not oppose gay civil partnerships. We recognised that in English law there might be a case for those.’
“I would tell my local member of Parliament that it is time Australia went the same way. And I would hope our bishops would see it that way too, though I concede that the present Pope did not when he was prefect for the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.”
www2b.abc.net.au/tmb/Client/Message.aspx?b=87&m=29133&ps=50&dm=1&pd=3
 
“Especially with an ageing society, the state has an interest in recognising and affirming relationships between persons committed to supporting each other, regardless of their sexual orientation. Discrimination against same sex couples should be removed in the public domain.
One’s sexual orientation is tangential to such relationships. They could just as easily involve three ageing sisters living together and supporting each other as a lesbian couple.
As long as the priest is talking about ‘couples’ involved in taking care of each other in non-marital relationships. whether or not they are sexually involved with each other is a red herring and is of no interest to the state. The state may well be interested in having people take care of each other through some sort of legalized personal contracts, but these are not marriages, and it is not discrimination to not recognize them as such.

As for relationships that are involved in creating and raising and forming the next generation of workers, fighters and tax payers into useful and well-adjusted citizens. the state has an particularly strong interest in supporting those kind of relationships and encouraging that they are given the permanence and stability that marriage especially would give them.
 
Here is the transcript of the program. It also appears that the video is available for download.
abc.net.au/compass/s3251965.htm

I just briefly skimmed through the transcript, but it appears that the Anglican bishop was forcefully against same-sex marriage, while the Baptist minister was comfortable with same-sex marriage and opposed to banning it. The Jesuit priest was more equivocal, talking about the complexity of the issue and the pitfalls to both sides.
That is very disappointing. I would have hoped that all the religious representatives had disapproved, but to find the Catholic equivocal, it is quite saddening. I think we need to redouble our prayers for our priests.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top