Abortions go up in Texas?

  • Thread starter Thread starter jtwp5
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Always question the source. Always check to see if there is an agenda being pushed. Always look at the data carefully. Data at the surface and how it’s portrayed can be misleading. Consider the variables being examined. Are they good ones? How do they related if at all? Always look at how the findings fits into a larger context.
 
Always question the source. Always check to see if there is an agenda being pushed. Always look at the data carefully. Data at the surface and how it’s portrayed can be misleading. Consider the variables being examined. Are they good ones? How do they related if at all? Always look at how the findings fits into a larger context.
Seems the agenda here is pushing birth control. But that’s always been an area of contention among Catholics in preventing unwanted pregnancies.
 
huffingtonpost.com/entry/texas-planned-parenthood-teen-abortion_us_59653229e4b09b587d63018a
Saw this on reddit today and found it deeply disturbing. What’s your opinion on it?
researchers manipulating statistics to push a political agenda

What assumptions did they make to show this one: "rose 3 percent over what it would have been had the clinics remained open. "

The article also says the overall abortion rate dropped 14% between 2014-2016.

Family planning and condoms are still widely available in TX, the money just goes to other providers instead of PP. Slight changes in data collection are usually behind rapid swings.
 
Here’s the paper without the spin from the predominantly left-wing media:
academia.edu/19435560/Family_Planning_Funding_Cuts_and_Teen_Childbearing
I’ve decided it’s better to go to the source.

The study is to be published in the Journal of Health Economics. There’s a point to this because last month, they previewed a study that showed in teen pregnancies dropped slightly in the UK when funding cuts to contraception were made. Where was the media when that study was published? I didn’t find any except for the paywalled Times of London and religious sites. That study’s findings can be found here:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=1053846
By ignoring the latter and covering the former, the media has shaped the landscape that is designed to favour the ideological left. If we want a proper debate we need evidence and arguments from both sides. We’re not getting this. We’re only getting one side. Let’s not forget, many people only read the headlines and we know what that will result in. I didn’t read the Puffington Post propaganda but is there an expert critiquing the study? If so how much space was dedicated? What was said? Am I correct in saying they didn’t offer a critique from another expert so that it seems there’s a consensus in the field of social sciences?

What disappoints me is plenty of people’s default position is to assume academics are always right and never ideological, the media are always right and never ideological. They assume data presented are always correct and infallible and never manipulated or calculated in ways that produce a desired outcome. A sceptical approach they use is always to be applied on Church leaders or even academics sympathising with them but never those in the secular realm who are rabidly hostile to Church leaders.
 
Doubt it.
A debunked and discredited video about PP selling dead baby parts…still used as a talking point in a lot of pro-life circles. Why was it necessary for pro-life legislators to lie about this fake news? So, yes, it does go both ways: wanting abortion to be outlawed is also an “agenda.”
 
I remember a video you describe.
Of course, the claim is a discredit of it, but the evidence says otherwise.
 
huffingtonpost.com/entry/texas-planned-parenthood-teen-abortion_us_59653229e4b09b587d63018a
Saw this on reddit today and found it deeply disturbing. What’s your opinion on it?
This does not surprise me. Mucking around with people’s lives at the level of public policy is essentially doing experiments on humans without their consent. So it’s important to approach any issue using sound social science research rather than ideological assumptions. The old adage that the road to hell is paved with good intentions still applies.

Having said that, there is ample evidence that shows the only way to alter the dynamics of a social problem (abortion, drug abuse, delinquency…) is to take a comprehensive approach. Singling out a single factor while ignoring the rest can actually exacerbate a situation. For example, incarcerating delinquent teenagers may seem like a sound method of deterring crime, but all that does is allow delinquent teens to form relationships with other delinquent teens, which then reinforces their delinquent behavior.

Limiting access to abortion services is only one of several factors that reduce the abortion rate. Others include better education, better access to healthcare (abortion is not healthcare), and despite what Catholics profess, better access to contraception. If all Texas did was limit access to abortion services without increasing access to those other factors, it should not be surprising that the overall increase in unintended pregnancies would overwhelm any benefit to be had from limiting access to abortion.
 
Limits of the study:
Page 12:
I restrict the sample of comparison counties to those most similar on observable characteristics to the counties in Texas with publicly funded clinics.
There are benefits and drawbacks. This procedure could exclude counties doing better or worse than those in Texas.

Page 19:
I utilize state-level data from CDC on the number of abortions by age group and state of residence, which is the only existing source of annual abortion data, to compare the changes in abortion rates in Texas to changes in abortion rates in other states over time. There are several limitations to this approach. Unfortunately, as of now, abortion data are only available up to 2013. Moreover, because centers are not required by law to submit annual abortion data, these data contain several omissions and inconsistencies.
Page 22:
estimates for abortion rates two years after funding cuts may be overstated if changes in Texas abortion legislation prompted an increase right before or right after the law took place. Therefore, efforts to obtain more convincing estimates of the effects of the cuts on teen abortion rates could be an important avenue for future research.
This is one study and claims to be the first in this. There may be more to come in the future so to make this study’s conclusions gospel truth as some ‘pro-science’ political commentators and media are doing is irresponsible and very unscientific.

Figure 6 (page 33)
Teen birth rates in Texas were still falling despite the cuts.
(By the way, there appears to be a typo in the y-axis in Panel A.)

Figure 7 (page 34)
Notice in the graph the increase in the abortion rate was short-lived. The decrease was significant after the increase.
 
Limits of the study:
Page 12:
There are benefits and drawbacks. This procedure could exclude counties doing better or worse than those in Texas.

Page 19:
Page 22:

This is one study and claims to be the first in this. There may be more to come in the future so to make this study’s conclusions gospel truth as some ‘pro-science’ political commentators and media are doing is irresponsible and very unscientific.

Figure 6 (page 33)
Teen birth rates in Texas were still falling despite the cuts.
(By the way, there appears to be a typo in the y-axis in Panel A.)

Figure 7 (page 34)
Notice in the graph the increase in the abortion rate was short-lived. The decrease was significant after the increase.
Kudos to you for reading through that paper! I tried, but the first person narrative style really turned me off. I’ve never read a scientific research paper that used the word “I” so much.

You make all good points. Lets hope some more and better research emerges.
 
Correct me if I’m wrong but TX still spends about the same money on family planning services, it just goes to other NGOs besides Planned Parenthood.

It’s silly how the left pretends PP is the only option for for checkups, condoms, and STD testing. It also greatly complicates or outright invalidates research such as this.
 
Of course there are limits to any study, this being just one, and the most obvious point being it is focused on a very narrow age range, not all abortions. However, there is a principle here that we must not ignore, if we are to be true pro-life as the Catholic Church, not the Republican Party, teaches. Life is about more than just legislating abortion. Being anti-abortion is all well and good, but it is important that we also support those in need, in this case, pregnant teens.

Outlawing might prevent some from getting abortions. Defunding PP might makes some decide to not have an abortion. However, supporting life itself, also might give those pregnant, who cannot see any other option but abortion, the tools they need to choose life instead.
 
Correct me if I’m wrong but TX still spends about the same money on family planning services, it just goes to other NGOs besides Planned Parenthood.

It’s silly how the left pretends PP is the only option for for checkups, condoms, and STD testing. It also greatly complicates or outright invalidates research such as this.
Not the only option but when 49% of births are paid for by Medicaid, and they want to curtail Medicaid expansion, that doesn’t exactly help those who want to bring kids into the world.
 
Not the only option but when 49% of births are paid for by Medicaid, and they want to curtail Medicaid expansion, that doesn’t exactly help those who want to bring kids into the world.
Medicaid expansion is a separate topic.

Though a red herring, you shared an interesting stat. I then discovered “New Mexico led all states with 72 percent of the babies born there in 2015 having their births covered by Medicaid.” Something fundamental is definitely broken if the vast majority of mothers having babies lack the family income provide basic care.
 
Medicaid expansion is a separate topic.
I do not think so. If abortions are rising, even if it is only rising in one demographic, contributing factors to that rise are legitimate topics for those who are opposed to abortion.
 
Medicaid expansion is a separate topic.

Though a red herring, you shared an interesting stat. I then discovered “New Mexico led all states with 72 percent of the babies born there in 2015 having their births covered by Medicaid.” Something fundamental is definitely broken if the vast majority of mothers having babies lack the family income provide basic care.
It could very well be that the mother cannot provide daily care but cost of delivery is an immediate expense, something even families with modest income might have a problem with. Not good to start a family in debt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top