Alabama SC recognizes preborn as children

  • Thread starter Thread starter Luigi_Daniele
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

Luigi_Daniele

Guest
Absolutely…awesome…news! 🙂
Washington D.C., Jan 15, 2013 / 05:02 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- An Alabama Supreme Court decision recognizing the unborn as persons deserving of legal protections could have significant implications in ending abortion in the U.S., say pro-life advocates.
“The Alabama Supreme Court has dealt a massive blow to the constitutional fraud of Roe v. Wade by recognizing that the preborn child is a person,” said Personhood USA legal analyst Gualberto Garcia Jones, J.D., in a statement.
On Jan. 11, the Alabama high court ruled that unborn children are protected by the state’s chemical endangerment law.
catholicnewsagency.com/news/alabama-supreme-court-recognizes-unborn-as-children/
 
I am not sure that the ruling is ground-breaking in any significant way.

Quoting from the article:
The court noted that 40 states and the District of Columbia “permit recovery of damages for the wrongful death of an unborn child when post-viability injuries to that child cause its death before birth.”
The Alabama Supreme Court simply upheld an interpretation which most states in the US already have.
 
I am not sure that the ruling is ground-breaking in any significant way.

Quoting from the article:

The Alabama Supreme Court simply upheld an interpretation which most states in the US already have.
Yes, there have always been laws like if a child-bearing woman is shot and killed, the perpetrator can be tried for two murders, same thing with long standing inheritance rights of a fetus.

But i think this is a little bit deeper.

This is a Catholic News Article and all of us Catholics easily understand the delineation, don’t we??
An Alabama Supreme Court decision recognizing the unborn as persons deserving of legal protections could have significant implications in ending abortion in the U.S., say pro-life advocates.
“The Alabama Supreme Court has dealt a massive blow to the constitutional fraud of Roe v. Wade by recognizing that the preborn child is a person,” said Personhood USA legal analyst Gualberto Garcia Jones, J.D., in a statement
This seems a bit different than saying 40 states afford some protections to the Fetus/Baby depending on the intent of the Mother or other carers involved.
 
This sounds like “Personhood” stuff. What I would expect a detractor of this ruling to say is to say something like “the Federal Government”, some Appeals court, something like this will not agree with this ruling.

As Oklahoma, etc. some states have attempted “Personhood” amendments.
While the Jan. 11 ruling does not directly apply to abortion regulations, pro-life advocates are encouraged by the decision, saying that it could contribute to the growing recognition of the unborn as human persons with legal rights.- linked story
 
Looks like Salon magazine has an article and that they are against this ruling.
Alabama’s Supreme Court says criminal statutes apply to the “unborn,” in an end run on Roe and a win for Personhood
salon.com/2013/01/15/subtracting_pregnant_women/

So I may have spoke prematurely to Dale, all of us would have to be real scholars or at least very knowledgeable on these issues.

But apparently, the pro-life people like the ruling and the pro-choice people don’t.

As to the conclusion of the Salon writer goes, we have crimes in society that people get away with though some are prosecuted and punished.
 
From the article:
The ruling cited a South Carolina case in which a court arrived at a similar ruling, determining that “it would be absurd to recognize the viable fetus as a person for purposes of homicide laws and wrongful death statutes but not for purposes of statutes proscribing child abuse.”
Now we need a court to define what a “viable” fetus is.
 
Now we need a court to define what a “viable” fetus is.
Indeed. 100 years ago, what was viable is very different than now. But did something fundamental to the nature of that unborn child change? Or only our technology? If the latter, then I find it very wrong-headed to pin the definition of personhood to the state of technology.
 
Indeed. 100 years ago, what was viable is very different than now. But did something fundamental to the nature of that unborn child change? Or only our technology? If the latter, then I find it very wrong-headed to pin the definition of personhood to the state of technology.
Thanks for going so succinctly to the heart of the matter. Well said!
 
Indeed. 100 years ago, what was viable is very different than now. But did something fundamental to the nature of that unborn child change? Or only our technology? If the latter, then I find it very wrong-headed to pin the definition of personhood to the state of technology.
This is an excellent point.
 
Indeed. 100 years ago, what was viable is very different than now. But did something fundamental to the nature of that unborn child change? Or only our technology? If the latter, then I find it very wrong-headed to pin the definition of personhood to the state of technology.
Viability has been pushed earlier and earlier as technology has developed. Yes, it does to a degree depend on the baby, but one viable here with specialized care, would not have a chance if delivered in say, a remote sub-Saharan hospital. So yes, it does to an extent depend on technology.
 
I am not sure that the ruling is ground-breaking in any significant way.

Quoting from the article:
The court noted that 40 states and the District of Columbia “permit recovery of damages for the wrongful death of an unborn child when post-viability injuries to that child cause its death before birth.”
So in most states a fetus is worth something, but only after her or she reaches the age of viability.

That’s interesting, because I was just reading a post on Kos and the person made reference to Exodus 21:22-25 regarding the “eye for an eye” law, which applied to pregnant women but not to their babies. Seems like under the Law of Moses, causing a miscarriage was treated pretty much the same as it is today.

22 When men have a fight and hurt a pregnant woman, so that she suffers a miscarriage, but no further injury, the guilty one shall be fined as much as the woman’s husband demands of him, and he shall pay in the presence of the judges.

23 But if injury ensues, you shall give life for life,

24 eye for eye, tooth for tooth, hand for hand, foot for foot,

25 burn for burn, wound for wound, stripe for stripe.

usccb.org/bible/exodus/21
 
Viability has been pushed earlier and earlier as technology has developed. Yes, it does to a degree depend on the baby, but one viable here with specialized care, would not have a chance if delivered in say, a remote sub-Saharan hospital. So yes, it does to an extent depend on technology.
I didn’t say viability depended upon technology. It’s obvious that it does. I said personhood should not depend upon technology. And linking personhood to viability necessarily links it technology.
 
I didn’t say viability depended upon technology. It’s obvious that it does. I said personhood should not depend upon technology. And linking personhood to viability necessarily links it technology.
I misunderstood you then, as you seemed to be linking viability to personhood.
 
I misunderstood you then, as you seemed to be linking viability to personhood.
I’m not, but it seems the courts are.

If the courts want to say viability is the point where protection is afforded, they are making that connection. And if the do make that connection, it is a mistake.
 
States is where the best chances for the pro-life cause lies, Mississippi, Utah, Oklahoma, there are a number of states that would not have abortion. Too bad the Federal Government is involved, this is the slavery issue of our time.
 
This should be common sense from ultrasounds and the fact that when a “fetus” is born premature, it’s a baby that comes out and not a “blob of flesh”. But for those who deny this, there is none as blind as those who refuse to see.
I think the ‘blob of flesh’ argument went out a while ago.

What’s current (to my knowledge) is the argument that an unborn child’s existence should depend on the mother’s choice. Of course, aside from rape, the choice WAS hers to begin with…so that kind of makes the ‘choice argument’ moot.
 
I’m not, but it seems the courts are.

If the courts want to say viability is the point where protection is afforded, they are making that connection. And if the do make that connection, it is a mistake.
I agree. However, I do think that personhood for the fetus has to be defined appropriately for that stage of life, pretty much the same way we apply personhood differently for minors than for adults. I believe that simply because the fetus is in the unique position of sharing another person’s body, so the rights of the two have to be balanced against each other.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top