Am I expected to believe in "ghosts"?

  • Thread starter Thread starter VeritasLuxMea
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
V

VeritasLuxMea

Guest
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”?

Some have implied that, and I find it so thoroughly bizarre and unscientific, completely without evidence of any kind. Not only without evidence, but SO lacking in evidence that there is no basis whatsoever to even entertain the thought.

If that is what is expected of me, I think I’m gonna straight up lose my mind, because that would mean to me that God wants me to reject human reason. At that point, I might as well pick my God and my religion by flipping a coin because up is down and down is up.

I’m serious.
 
We can find comments like this from one Fr. John A. Hardon, SJ, Modern Catholic Dictionary (Garden City, New York: John A. Hardon, ©1980) published by Doubleday and Co., p. 229
“Christianity believes that God may, and sometimes does, permit a departed soul to appear in some visible form to people on earth. Allowing for legend and illusion, there is enough authentic evidence, for example in the lives of the saints, to indicate that such apparitions occur. Their purpose may be to teach or warn, or request some favor of the living” .

However according to 2 Corinthians 11:14, even Satan can masquerade as an angel of light.
The Church urges great caution and any dabbling in spiritualism or the occult is forbidden and sinful…
Catechism of the Catholic Church,

Paragraph 2117
“All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one’s service and have a supernatural power over others - even if this were for the sake of restoring their health - are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. These practices are even more to be condemned when accompanied by the intention of harming someone, or when they have recourse to the intervention of demons. Wearing charms is also reprehensible. Spiritism often implies divination or magical practices; the Church for her part warns the faithful against it. Recourse to so-called traditional cures does not justify either the invocation of evil powers or the exploitation of another’s credulity”
 
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”? …
I’m serious.
I can tell. If you are a Christian of any kind you already believe in a “ghost.” You believe Jesus returned form death and appeared to His followers. Of course, He was raised bodily. Now, the Church teaches Mary was also raised bodily, so I suppose we can accept that by the power of God, Who is all power and only power, they can appear to us from time to time.

But why shouldn’t any Saint or anyone God chooses appear to us? Do you believe God can heal you by making flesh whole that is burned or cut? Can he make the blind see?

Let’s discuss vision. You have never seen any thing. You have had photons enter your eye and stimulate a series of reactions in your nervous system that cause you to acquire information about your environment. If you turn your eyes toward an object, “look” at it, you get more photons and more complete information. But you “see” it inside your brain, not out in three-dimensional space.

So you think God can heal flesh or multiply fish but can’t stimulate a few neurons? People perceive those who have passed, and sometimes angels, as if they were present in Time/Space as if with all or some of their five senses. They perceive that when God chooses and by His action.

I’m not sure what a “ghost” is. I am sure God can grace me with a vision. Or you. (Which, come to think of it, would make for some pretty entertaining posts! :D)

God bless you. And remember: There’s nothing more extraordinary that what happens on the altar at every Mass, every day, in every Catholic church around the world.
 
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”?
You are required to believe that God is capable of altering reality in a way that defies scintifically derived laws about nature. Therefore you also are required to believe that God is capable of allowing “ghosts” to appear or causing events, that make observing humans think a “ghost” is present, as the non-existence of “ghosts” can only be concluded from natural scientific laws and God can ignore them. Any furter requirements depend strongly upon the definition of “ghost”, you seem to have one specific in mind.
Furthermore you are also required to beblieve that the devil is at least in so far able to alter reality as is necessary to communicate with human minds.
Some have implied that, and I find it so thoroughly bizarre and unscientific, completely without evidence of any kind. Not only without evidence, but SO lacking in evidence that there is no basis whatsoever to even entertain the thought.
You have to discern that science is only capable of safely detecting non-intelligent cause and effects. As soon as an intelligent actor is part of the events to be analyzed, science could be unable to see any pattern or even notice that the evevnts actually happen. That is because the intelligent actor might adjust his actions so, that science misses his influence.

E.g. claiming “holding hand on someones head and say some words, will heal him.” is scientifically testable by just subjecting enough ill people to that procedure and data so far suggest such claims are wrong.

E.g. claiming “Blessing someone and praying to God, asking God to heal him, might improve his health if it is within Gods plan.” is non testable. Why the blessing, praying and health change are detecable, we cannot know how this “God” acts and what his plans are. Therefore even if we would subject a lot of ill people to that procedure, the result that no one profitted from the praying does not allow any conclusion, because it might be, that the unknown plans of that “God” were not fitting to healing any of the test persons. Furthermore it might be, that that “God” noticed the test going on and decided he does not want a paper to be published titled “Experimental evidenceregarding the healing power of prayers to God”.
In such case we could only scientifically prove anything, if we had some precautions ensuring that “Gods” actions are not influenced by the way the experiment is conducted,best method probably by hiding from “God” the fact that an experiment is goind on.

And as the “God” in the above can be replaced by any other supposed supernatural entity (e.g. devil, demons, ghosts, zeus, invisible pink unicorns, great spaghetti monster) and the problem would still be the same (with the change that the plans, capabilities for healing, awareness of ongoing experiments, willingness to fool us and actual existence might differ with different entities), you can see that science cannot tell us much about intelligent and supernatural entities interacting with the world, as long as their intelligence is high enough to be aware about scientists trying to nail them down with experiments and they have a decent control over their interaction with the world.
If that is what is expected of me, I think I’m gonna straight up lose my mind, because that would mean to me that God wants me to reject human reason. At that point, I might as well pick my God and my religion by flipping a coin because up is down and down is up.

I’m serious.
That means believe in “ghosts” is only irrational, if the interaction of the “ghost” with the world depends solely on the “mind” of a deceased human (as a human lacks both control and intelligence to always avoid those pesky scientists).

“Ghosts”, whose interactions depend on God or the devil, are not in contradiction with human reason, as God and the devil might limit the “Ghosts” interaction in such way, that science cannot find evidence of "ghosts"and even finds fake evidence against.
(E.g. easy way to produce fake evidence would be, to make a lot of people see ghosts, but stop the appearance as soon as a throughful investigation starts. Then a lot fo people would truthfully claim ghosts for real, but scientifically the conclusion “So many nuts around, seeing things not there.” would look plausible, although it would be untrue.)

Therefore the answer to your question depends a lot of the definition of “ghosts”.
 
There is nothing in Catholicism that says you must believe in ghosts.
You could check the Catechism of the Catholic Church to see if belief in ghosts is a Catholic belief. You could get the Catechism by googling to it online, or it would be easier to go through your own printed copy. There would be nothing in the Catechism saying it is a Catholic belief.
Mary and saints have appeared to Catholics. But ghosts are supposedly those who have died who are wandering about the earth or stuck in one place who have never passed on, or been able to pass on, to heaven or hell. Belief in such ghosts is not part of the Catholic faith.
I am at a loss as to why anyone would say that Catholics must believe in ghosts. Perhaps they think this because of television shows they have watched showing ghosts or through new age literature they have read.
Catholics are free to believe in ghosts, but belief in ghosts is not part of the Catholic faith.
 
“Ghosts” is simply the same as “spirits”. Since we each possess a sprit, we had better believe in them. Spirits come in two forms, which most of us are familiar with, at least in name. Since spirits have no body, they assume a particular appearance when they interact with us. At the resurrection in the Gospel of Matthew (Matthew 28:2-5), the angel’s appearance was “like lightning”. In each case of an angel appearing, the first human response is fear. There is something otherworldly about the appearance that they adopt that does not register in our conscious minds, and which then produces fear. It happened d to Zechariah (Luke 1:11-13), to Mary (Luke 1:30), to the shepherds in Bethlehem at Jesus’ birth (Luke 2:9-10).

However, evil spirits can also adopt physical appearances. The devil appeared as a serpent in Genesis 3. They can “infest” buildings or certain locations. And, yes, they can appear in certain recognizable forms. Here is an interview with an exorcist Priest that I find fascinating. He gives some detail about spirits, as well as about exorcisms specifically. But, note that only man will denigrate Mary - not even demons dare to do such! Amazing.
 
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”?

Some have implied that, and I find it so thoroughly bizarre and unscientific, completely without evidence of any kind. Not only without evidence, but SO lacking in evidence that there is no basis whatsoever to even entertain the thought.

If that is what is expected of me, I think I’m gonna straight up lose my mind, because that would mean to me that God wants me to reject human reason. At that point, I might as well pick my God and my religion by flipping a coin because up is down and down is up.

I’m serious.
I would like to see a “ghost” !!!
 
I think it is important to clarify what the Church would define as a “ghost” or *spirit *versus the common, modern understanding of a “ghost”.

Is is *possible *that a person may be given a vision or be visited by a Saint or Angel? Yes. There are many documented cases of apparitions of the Blessed Virgin, Jesus, or other Saints and Angels and we see examples in the Bible.

Is it *possible *that a person may be visited by Satan or a demon? Yes. We also see examples of this.

A person who receives a vision from God of a Saint or Blessed is receiving a special message for God’s holy purpose for that person.

It is possible for demons to manifest, those are fallen angels. But they are not ghosts.

However, in modern usage, “ghosts” are people who have departed this world who roam the earth and haunt houses and buildings and such. The Church teaches that when we die, we are judged and we go to Heaven, Hell, or Purgatory. We are not left “roaming” the earth, doing “unfinished business” or “haunting” people/things, or “trying to get our wings”. All that is Hollywood, not Church teaching.
 
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”?

.
it is not Catholic teaching that the dead come back and haunt people on earth as ghosts, if that is what you mean. My hunch is this is not your real issue. When you are ready to talk about it, so are we.
 
As a Catholic, am I required to believe in “ghosts”?
According to Church teaching, there are three kinds of spirits: God, angelic, and human. Of the angelic spirits, some rebelled against God and are referred to as devils or demons. This teaching is a doctrine of the faith, and therefore Catholics are required to believe in such spirits.

But your question seems to be asking whether or not Catholics are required to believe in the sort of ghostly phenomena described in such TV shows as Ghost Hunters. Simply put, Catholics are not. The Church has no official teaching concerning whether or not human spirits appear in shadowy forms in the modern world with the ability to generate sounds and move objects. Nevertheless, the Bible describes such an event between Saul and the spirit of Samuel, so I do not think we should dismiss the possibility of such phenomena. But whereas we are required to believe in Sacred Scripture, this does not mean that, by extension, we are required to believe in the things reported by paranormal investigators.

Nevertheless, I think it is worth pointing out that many of the things that are described in such TV shows are not necessary contrary to Catholic teaching. For example, it could be that part of the experience of the souls in Purgatory is to temporarily visit places on earth in spiritual form. God may allow people on earth to witness such visits as a reminder to pray for them. Keep in mind that Catholic doctrine says very little about what specifically happens during the purification process of Purgatory, so there is certainly room for speculation on our end of things.

In light of everything I’ve stated, a Catholic is free to believe in or not believe in what is commonly referred to as ghostly phenomena.
 
Short answer: no, you are not required to.

I’ve had some personal experiences that I can’t explain, but it doesn’t constitute proof that ‘ghosts’ exist. It just means something weird happened and I don’t know what the cause was.
 
just the Holy Ghost 🙂

actually, Greek says pneuma and translations nowaday read ‘Holy Spirit’

DRB and KJV have Ghost.

many new translations read when when Jesus walked on the water:

Matt 14:26 When the disciples saw him walking on the sea they were terrified. “It is a ghost,” they said, and they cried out in fear. (NAB)

ghost here comes from Greek φάντασμά / phantasma which English can transliterate as ‘phantasm’, they saw what they thought was a phantasm of Jesus.
 
I can tell. If you are a Christian of any kind you already believe in a “ghost.” You believe Jesus returned form death and appeared to His followers. Of course, He was raised bodily. Now, the Church teaches Mary was also raised bodily, so I suppose we can accept that by the power of God, Who is all power and only power, they can appear to us from time to time.

But why shouldn’t any Saint or anyone God chooses appear to us? Do you believe God can heal you by making flesh whole that is burned or cut? Can he make the blind see?

Let’s discuss vision. You have never seen any thing. You have had photons enter your eye and stimulate a series of reactions in your nervous system that cause you to acquire information about your environment. If you turn your eyes toward an object, “look” at it, you get more photons and more complete information. But you “see” it inside your brain, not out in three-dimensional space.

So you think God can heal flesh or multiply fish but can’t stimulate a few neurons? People perceive those who have passed, and sometimes angels, as if they were present in Time/Space as if with all or some of their five senses. They perceive that when God chooses and by His action.

I’m not sure what a “ghost” is. I am sure God can grace me with a vision. Or you. (Which, come to think of it, would make for some pretty entertaining posts! :D)

God bless you. And remember: There’s nothing more extraordinary that what happens on the altar at every Mass, every day, in every Catholic church around the world.
You are not sure what a ghost is.
Therefore, with all your faith we still can not find your faith in ghosts.
I think this is ample evidence that the belief in ghosts have no merit at all.
 
There have been ample sightings to indicate that there are things which appear to be ‘ghosts’ that people experience and interact with. From ‘hauntings’ to sightings, we have more than enough evidence to realize that something must be going on.

As to the what we can only make assumptions as to what they actually are, as it’s not ‘repeatable’ in a scientific fashion. That doesn’t make it any less real or plausible. It simply means that we as Catholics have to leave room for the existence of ‘something’ that have been given the label of ‘ghosts.’

Are they souls that have been sent back with messages? Are they demons that are trying to confuse? Are they echoes of other ‘dimensions’? Are they memories leaving an indelible mark in time? We don’t know, and until one of us personally experiences it we cannot equate it as any of the above, neither can we equate them as ‘none of the above.’

The one thing we do not believe in as Catholics is that a soul can be ‘trapped’ in a physical location. Either it has been sent here by the Father, or it’s not a ‘saint’ so to speak, or it’s not a soul at all but some sort of phenomena we haven’t an explanation for.
 
I am not English speaker.
Why do you call Holy Ghost?
I think Ghost is an apparition at night !
Why not Holy spirit?
It seems some people even like Holy Ghost more.
Problems with my english…
In Spanish: Sancto Espiritu, in french Le Saint Esprit but in germany
it is Heiligen Geist, which is closer your your Ghost.
 
I am not English speaker.
Why do you call Holy Ghost?
I think Ghost is an apparition at night !
Why not Holy spirit?
It seems some people even like Holy Ghost more.
Problems with my english…
In Spanish: Sancto Espiritu, in french Le Saint Esprit but in germany
it is Heiligen Geist, which is closer your your Ghost.
I have a German speaking friend that is a member here as well. Perhaps she may help both of us out in trying to address this question.

I admire all of those here who speak multiple languages.
 
Having seen a ghost, and having had a close encounter with an angel (a story I told awhile back on another thread), I have no problem at all believing in disembodied spirits. Besides which, as others here have pointed out, physical science (and I am a scientist) cannot prove or disprove the existence of ghosts.
 
Having seen a ghost, and having had a close encounter with an angel (a story I told awhile back on another thread), I have no problem at all believing in disembodied spirits. Besides which, as others here have pointed out, physical science (and I am a scientist) cannot prove or disprove the existence of ghosts.
The question was, Am I expected to believe in “ghosts”?
I am not sure that your post here really even takes a stab at answering this question from a viewpoint other than your own personal experience with no mention of what the Catholic Church has to say about it at all. I am sorry to call you out on this and am not challenging you on what you believe you experienced. I just think it is right to make sure you make it clear your personal experiences are not to be taken as approved by the Catholic Church.
From the purely scientific view, ghosts do not exist simply because no one can disprove their existance.
If you teach science, I surely hope it is in a faith school, not a public school.
 
From the purely scientific view, ghosts do not exist simply because no one can disprove their existance.
.
This statement is tautological. If their existence could be disproved, then it surely would be.
If you teach science, I surely hope it is in a faith school, not a public school
I don’t believe public school science teachers make a habit of injecting their beliefs in spiritual beings into the science curriculum. Do you think that only agnostics or atheists are qualified to teach in public schools?
 
I have a German speaking friend that is a member here as well. Perhaps she may help both of us out in trying to address this question.

I admire all of those here who speak multiple languages.
In the liturgy of an Episcopalian (in reality Anglo-Catholic) service I attended recently, the term “Holy Ghost” was used wherever the Catholic liturgy uses “Holy Spirit.” This is just the old, pre-Vatican II language, which some of the most traditional Episcopalian/Anglican parishes have apparently maintained. “Ghost” and “spirit” were nearly synonymous terms in the not-so-distant past.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top