Am I wrong for viewing it as a gift?

  • Thread starter Thread starter skigirl1689
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

skigirl1689

Guest
I was born with many health issues and I’ve grown to see them as a gift to show others life is worth it even though my life is tough, and sometimes I am not able to do what others do. I don’t “flaunt” it…I just try to live the best I can with God helping me, always thankful for those who help me.

That’s how I chose to see my life and don’t force it on others or go about telling people that unless it comes up in a discussion of how I cope with my condition. I could be mad at the world, demanding as heck for equality, to be “normal.” I’ll never be seen as “normal” and why waste my time getting people to see me as such, just ain’t happening as people still stare and everything else. I am different, and the world is not going to see me as “normal.”

I learned (no one taught me to do this) as I’ve accepted my condition, and just live my life, people naturally learn to see past it if they take the time to, and learn from it, i.e. dispel misconceptions, simply by knowing me. Do I actively do this? Only when someone asks me a direct question, otherwise people around me tell me they gain inspiration from knowing me…Am I to be offended by this? I chose to see it as part of the reason I did not die when I was basically very close to it when I was born. This stems from my faith and the fact I’ve been told I’ve helped others just by being who I am. I don’t feel pressured to be perfect or even an “example;” it just happens. People who really know me know my faults, the good, the bad, and the ugly.

A friend is thoroughly offended by this and feels like I shouldn’t use my condition to teach people (she has the same condition, and seems very bitter). But I can’t help it, and it has helped others just by me being me.

I feel bad I offended her, but am I wrong for seeing my condition as a gift? Or am I just being naive for thinking there is a reason I struggle with my condition and it really serves no purpose? Her comments really put a doubt in my mind that something good comes out of me having this condition. I know it is probably just temptation, but I would appreciate some guidance.
 
I would definitely say that God brings beauty from ugliness. St. Paul had what he called a “thorn in the flesh”: “Therefore, that I might not become too elated, a thorn in the flesh was given to me, an angel of Satan, to beat me, to keep me from being too elated.” (2 Cor 12:7) This didn’t stop him from glorifying God! He also called it a thorn. If he called it that, you probably can too. 🙂 Allow God to bring good from the bad! Your condition was not from God though, because God intended us to be perfect. Your condition was the result of Original Sin and the particular way it stained you. So let God use it for His own purposes. I know he can bring beauty from destruction as seen in my own life. God bless you!!
 
suffering is a gift only if you put it to good use! i forgot which saint said this, but one of them said never to waste suffering. offer up your sufferings as reparation for your or other people’s sins.
 
I feel bad I offended her, but am I wrong for seeing my condition as a gift? Or am I just being naive for thinking there is a reason I struggle with my condition and it really serves no purpose? Her comments really put a doubt in my mind that something good comes out of me having this condition. I know it is probably just temptation, but I would appreciate some guidance.
Your post is so inspirational and beautiful. You sound like a wonderful person, filled with God’s grace. This is what the world needs so desperately, especially today when ugly ideas about what constitutes a life worth living are spreading like the plague.

We Catholics believe in redemptive suffering. Is this also present in Lutheranism? Is your friend a Christian? It is a beautiful teaching that allows us to see our suffering as something of value. We offer it up, we place it at the cross of Jesus and ask him to use it for some purpose. In this way our suffering doesn’t go to waste but is spiritualised. When a person is spiritually mature, they can even see it as a gift. God is working through you. Don’t apologise to others for your attitude. Pray for your friend and keep being who you are. God bless.
 
To God, the only part of you that matters is your heart, and we can see from your post that it is just fine. You friend, on the other hand, is in need of prayer. If God’s will was that His only begotten Son was to suffer, then how can we expect to avoid suffering? Especially since we are parts of Christ’s Body? To continue on with what Paul teaches us:

Romans 8:16-18
16 For the Spirit himself giveth testimony to our spirit, that we are the sons of God.
17 And if sons, heirs also; heirs indeed of God, and joint heirs with Christ: yet so, if we suffer with him, that we may be also glorified with him.
18 For I reckon that the sufferings of this time are not worthy to be compared with the glory to come, that shall be revealed in us.

Philippians 1:29
29 For unto you it is given for Christ, not only to believe in him, but also to suffer for him.

What we do with our suffering is of paramount importance. We can waste it, or we can offer it, as members of Christ’s Body, to the Father for eternal good - for ourselves, but especially for others. You could offer your suffering for the eternal good of your friend. Her embittered heart may place her soul in jeopardy. Our lives are Christ-like when we suffer - yet they are perfectly Christ-like if we suffer for the sake of His Name.
 
Not at all.

It takes a special strength to see one’s life in that way. Not everybody, including your friend, has it.

ICXC NIKA
 
Not at all.

It takes a special strength to see one’s life in that way. Not everybody, including your friend, has it.

ICXC NIKA
For that matter, very few people even with no “visible” disabilities see their lives as gifts the way the OP describes! 🙂

Alan
 
Be thankful for the gift you have to give as are those that receive it and pray that your friend comes to understand this
 
Whether we will or not, we must suffer. There are some who suffer like the good thief, and others like the bad thief. They both suffered equally. But one knew how to make his sufferings meritorious, he accepted them in the spirit of reparation, and turning towards Jesus crucified, he received from His mouth these beautiful words: "This day thou shalt be with Me in Paradise. " The other, on the contrary, cried out, uttered imprecations and blasphemies, and expired in the most frightful despair. There are two ways of suffering – to suffer with love, and to suffer without love. The saints suffered everything with joy, patience, and perseverance, because they loved. As for us, we suffer with anger, vexation, and weariness, because we do not love. If we loved God, we should love crosses, we should wish for them, we should take pleasure in them. . . . We should be happy to be able to suffer for the love of Him who lovingly suffered for us. Of what do we complain? Alas! the poor infidels, who have not the happiness of knowing God and His infinite loveliness, have the same crosses that we have; but they have not the same consolations. You say it is hard? No, it is easy, it is consoling, it is sweet; it is happiness. Only we must love while we suffer, and suffer while we love.
From St Faustina’s Diary - 343
I thank You, Jesus, You who first drank the cup of bitterness before You gave it to me, in a much milder form. I put my lips to this cup of Your holy will. Let all be done according to Your good pleasure; let that which Your wisdom ordained before the ages be done to me. I want to drink the cup to its last drop, and not seek to know the reason why. In bitterness is my joy, in hopelessness is my trust. In You, O Lord, all is good, all is a gift of Your paternal Heart. I do not prefer consolations, but thank You, O Jesus, for everything! It is my delight to fix my gaze upon You, O mysterious dwelling places, and ther I am at home. I know very well the dwelling place of my Spouse. I feel there is not a single drop of blood in me that does not burn with love for You.
Here’s more of what the saints said about suffering:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=542373
 
I was born with many health issues and I’ve grown to see them as a gift to show others life is worth it even though my life is tough, and sometimes I am not able to do what others do. I don’t “flaunt” it…I just try to live the best I can with God helping me, always thankful for those who help me.

That’s how I chose to see my life and don’t force it on others or go about telling people that unless it comes up in a discussion of how I cope with my condition. I could be mad at the world, demanding as heck for equality, to be “normal.” I’ll never be seen as “normal” and why waste my time getting people to see me as such, just ain’t happening as people still stare and everything else. I am different, and the world is not going to see me as “normal.”

I learned (no one taught me to do this) as I’ve accepted my condition, and just live my life, people naturally learn to see past it if they take the time to, and learn from it, i.e. dispel misconceptions, simply by knowing me. Do I actively do this? Only when someone asks me a direct question, otherwise people around me tell me they gain inspiration from knowing me…Am I to be offended by this? I chose to see it as part of the reason I did not die when I was basically very close to it when I was born. This stems from my faith and the fact I’ve been told I’ve helped others just by being who I am. I don’t feel pressured to be perfect or even an “example;” it just happens. People who really know me know my faults, the good, the bad, and the ugly.

A friend is thoroughly offended by this and feels like I shouldn’t use my condition to teach people (she has the same condition, and seems very bitter). But I can’t help it, and it has helped others just by me being me.

I feel bad I offended her, but am I wrong for seeing my condition as a gift? Or am I just being naive for thinking there is a reason I struggle with my condition and it really serves no purpose? Her comments really put a doubt in my mind that something good comes out of me having this condition. I know it is probably just temptation, but I would appreciate some guidance.
You are NOT wrong. In fact - you are being a wonderful example to everyone - including your “bitter” friend. What a contrast for others to see…You with your acceptance and desire to simply be the best that you can be and her with her anger and resentment.
You keep right on being you…and pray for your friend.

Peace
James
 
Skigirl,
I have read several of your posts and you are always so sweet! The way you view suffering and your life is wonderful and very much in line with the Faith and this very pleasing to God.

My family and I have been greatly blessed with health and education. But I know a familly, working poor, and several relatives who died, sometimes very young, of a genetic problem.

Wow, the beauty of their love for their relatives, the care of the children, and their acceptance of their suffering *puts me to shame. *When they told me about this, I had tears in my eyes, and I do as I write this. To see people like these, and you, who is so young, is very inspirational, and really helps people like me to *strive *for holiness.

A young man who wanted to be a (Protestant) minister told me many many years ago that we are all handicapped, it’s just that for some us, the handicap shows.

I am sorry for your friend who feels bitter. I hope that she will come to feel God’s grace inher heart so her bitterness can dissolve. I’ll keep both of you in my prayers.

And don’t you ever change!!! Just grow!!!
 
APOSTOLIC LETTER
SALVIFICI DOLORIS…

CONCLUSION
  1. This is the meaning of suffering, which is truly supernatural and at the same time human. It is supernatural because it is rooted in the divine mystery of the Redemption of the world, and it is likewise deeply human, because in it the person discovers himself, his own humanity, his own dignity, his own mission.
Suffering is certainly part of the mystery of man. Perhaps suffering is not wrapped up as much as man is by this mystery, which is an especially impenetrable one. The Second Vatican Council expressed this truth that “…only in the mystery of the Incarnate Word does the mystery of man take on light. In fact…, Christ, the final Adam, by the revelation of the mystery of the Father and his love, fully reveals man to himself and makes his supreme calling clear”(100). If these words refer to everything that concerns the mystery of man, then they certainly refer in a very special way to human suffering. Precisely at this point the “revealing of man to himself and making his supreme vocation clear” is particularly indispensable. It also happens as experience proves—that this can be particularly dramatic. But when it is completely accomplished and becomes the light of human life, it is particularly blessed. “Through Christ and in Christ, the riddles of sorrow and death grow meaningful”(101).

I now end the present considerations on suffering in the year in which the Church is living the extraordinary Jubilee linked to the anniversary of the Redemption.

The mystery of the Redemption of the world is in an amazing way rooted in suffering, and this suffering in turn finds in the mystery of the Redemption its supreme and surest point of reference.

We wish to live this Year of the Redemption in special union with all those who suffer. And so there should come together in spirit beneath the Cross on Calvary all suffering people who believe in Christ, and particularly those who suffer because of their faith in him who is the Crucified and Risen One, so that the offering of their sufferings may hasten the fulfilment of the prayer of the Saviour himself that all may be one(102). Let there also gather beneath the Cross all people of good will, for on this Cross is the “Redeemer of man”, the Man of Sorrows, who has taken upon himself the physical and moral sufferings of the people of all times, so that in love they may find the salvific meaning of their sorrow and valid answers to all of their questions.

Together with Mary, Mother of Christ, who stood beneath the Cross(103),we pause beside all the crosses of contemporary man.

We invoke all the Saints, who down the centuries in a special way shared in the suffering of Christ. We ask them to support us.

And we ask all you who suffer to support us. We ask precisely you who are weak to become a source of strength for the Church and humanity. In the terrible battle between the forces of good and evil, revealed to our eyes by our modern world, may your suffering in union with the Cross of Christ be victorious!

To all of you, dearest brothers and sisters, I send my Apostolic Blessing.

Given at Rome, at Saint Peter’s, on the liturgical Memorial of Our Lady of Lourdes, 11 February 1984, in the sixth year of my Pontificate.

JOHN PAUL II
 
Thank you all for your thoughtful replies; they have helped me immensely.
Your post is so inspirational and beautiful. You sound like a wonderful person, filled with God’s grace. This is what the world needs so desperately, especially today when ugly ideas about what constitutes a life worth living are spreading like the plague.

We Catholics believe in redemptive suffering. Is this also present in Lutheranism? Is your friend a Christian? It is a beautiful teaching that allows us to see our suffering as something of value. We offer it up, we place it at the cross of Jesus and ask him to use it for some purpose. In this way our suffering doesn’t go to waste but is spiritualised. When a person is spiritually mature, they can even see it as a gift. God is working through you. Don’t apologise to others for your attitude. Pray for your friend and keep being who you are. God bless.
I am not exactly sure if Lutheranism holds to redemptive suffering, per se, but we do believe we suffer for the sake of Christ, being united to Him through his suffering and death in Baptism. I personally believe in “offering sufferings up” because of being united to Christ.

My friend was raised Catholic but now is, what she describes, as a Messianic Jew. I know she believes in following the Jewish law because Christ did, but at the same time does not hold Scripture was inspired by God, but just man-made. So I really do not fully understand where she is spiritually.

She wants the world to cease to see her differently, but our conditions are visible, and it’s human nature to automatically pick up on this. She’s so angry, it makes me so sad, and I can only pray for her. But she, on the other hand, is critical of my parents because they never explicitly told me I was “disabled.” I am so confused…my parents told me they didn’t want to put a label on me as to not convey limits to me, but to allow me to push myself and learn my own limitations.
Skigirl,
I have read several of your posts and you are always so sweet! The way you view suffering and your life is wonderful and very much in line with the Faith and this very pleasing to God.

My family and I have been greatly blessed with health and education. But I know a familly, working poor, and several relatives who died, sometimes very young, of a genetic problem.

Wow, the beauty of their love for their relatives, the care of the children, and their acceptance of their suffering *puts me to shame. *When they told me about this, I had tears in my eyes, and I do as I write this. To see people like these, and you, who is so young, is very inspirational, and really helps people like me to *strive *for holiness.

A young man who wanted to be a (Protestant) minister told me many many years ago that we are all handicapped, it’s just that for some us, the handicap shows.

I am sorry for your friend who feels bitter. I hope that she will come to feel God’s grace inher heart so her bitterness can dissolve. I’ll keep both of you in my prayers.

And don’t you ever change!!! Just grow!!!
Believe me, most of the time I just feel as flawed as the next sinner…people tell me they can’t imagine how I live with my condition, and I never understand why they say this because I am just living my life that just happens to have a lot more apparent challenges than most people. There are days I thoroughly disdain my condition, when I am in pain or I can’t participate with my peers, and my attitude is less than Christian.

Your story of the family you know of reminds me of one side of my extended family. They grew up with a disabled sister, much more severe than mine, and they are so much more accepting of me than the other side of the family will ever be.

I honestly do not believe I’d be the same person if I didn’t have my condition. I think this concept can be applied to everyone as we all deal with something.

Please pray for my friend…I know she is hurting a lot despite her tough exterior.
 
Allow God to bring good from the bad! Your condition was not from God though, because God intended us to be perfect.
I would be very careful about attributing anything to any power outside of God. Remember that God says in His Holy Scripture,

Isaias 45:7 I form the light, and create darkness, I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord that do all these things.

Now, there is certainly a difference between God’s prescriptive Will and His permissive Will. God commands only good, but he permits evil, and in Isaias, which is Holy Scripture and cannot be broken, He says He creates it. It can be a trap, to keep trying to decide what came from God and what came from a different power. All power belongs to God, and to attribute everything that happens to Him is a sound course. The power of secondary causes serves God, including all power that Satan exercises! Nothing escapes the Will of the Father.

So as Skigirl views her condition as a Gift from God, and thanks Him for it, I believe she is on the right path, and I admire her courage, which is also a Gift from God in her.
 
I would be very careful about attributing anything to any power outside of God. Remember that God says in His Holy Scripture,

Isaias 45:7 I form the light, and create darkness, I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord that do all these things.

Now, there is certainly a difference between God’s prescriptive Will and His permissive Will. God commands only good, but he permits evil, and in Isaias, which is Holy Scripture and cannot be broken, He says He creates it. It can be a trap, to keep trying to decide what came from God and what came from a different power. All power belongs to God, and to attribute everything that happens to Him is a sound course. The power of secondary causes serves God, including all power that Satan exercises! Nothing escapes the Will of the Father.

So as Skigirl views her condition as a Gift from God, and thanks Him for it, I believe she is on the right path, and I admire her courage, which is also a Gift from God in her.
I think what the comment you referred to was trying to say was sickness and death came about through Original Sin, and God permitted it since he gave us free will. However, God did not create evil, as He is the Supreme source of all good.

I think of the time in the Gospel where Christ was asked whose sin caused the blind man’s condition:
Douay-Rheims Bible
1 AND Jesus passing by, saw a man, who was blind from his birth: 2 And his disciples asked him: Rabbi, who hath sinned, this man, or his parents, that he should be born blind? 3 Jesus answered: Neither hath this man sinned, nor his parents; but that the works of God should be made manifest in him.
 
I thank the Lord for the cross that He has blessed me with and remember: “no cross of suffering, no crown of glory.”
 
I would be very careful about attributing anything to any power outside of God. Remember that God says in His Holy Scripture,

Isaias 45:7 I form the light, and create darkness, I make peace, and create evil: I the Lord that do all these things.

Now, there is certainly a difference between God’s prescriptive Will and His permissive Will. God commands only good, but he permits evil, and in Isaias, which is Holy Scripture and cannot be broken, He says He creates it. It can be a trap, to keep trying to decide what came from God and what came from a different power. All power belongs to God, and to attribute everything that happens to Him is a sound course. The power of secondary causes serves God, including all power that Satan exercises! Nothing escapes the Will of the Father.

So as Skigirl views her condition as a Gift from God, and thanks Him for it, I believe she is on the right path, and I admire her courage, which is also a Gift from God in her.
I love that we can discuss things on this forum! Blessed be God! Draco_Cupri, thank you for keeping me accountable! I think I need to explain myself and what I meant exactly!

Just to respond to what you said… If you do some research on that verse, you’ll find that God does not create evil as we would understand that verse to say, because that claim is heresy. He, as you said, allows it’s existence. God uses evil to create an even greater good!

And… you took what I said out of context! I didn’t say that anything came from some sort of different power. I said that God intended us to be perfect, and, as “StFrancis” said, each of us is handicapped. Why? That isn’t God’s fault! I do need to clarify something I said, which, after research, I realized to be wrong! (Humbling 👍) Original sin isn’t the cause of being handicapped, but since sin has entered the world, birth defects, blindness, deafness, etc. are now present in our world. Because of sin(as a whole)'s entrance into the world, we are plagued by physical evils.

In conclusion, skigirl, offer it up to God, view it as a gift instead of a hindrance! Run the race! Keep the faith! (2 Tim 4:7) 😃
 
I honestly do not believe I’d be the same person if I didn’t have my condition. I think this concept can be applied to everyone as we all deal with something.
You are right, we all deal with something. It can be depression, anxiety, insecurity, addictions, etc. Life spares nobody, there is always a cross. I have no physical disabilities but I have problems that make my life difficult. I think that in the end, we are all in the same boat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top