America the Ignorant

  • Thread starter Thread starter Los_Angeles
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
As the Mother of a really good teacher, we can’t blame everything on teachers!
Perhaps not, but as a college instructor I have to wonder why a MAJORITY of my students can’t write a coherent sentence. This is getting worse every year. If we are alarmed about the direction of the country at present, wait until this generation takes charge.
 
I don’t think Americans are particularly more ignorant than people from other countries, but what I do find unnerving is that many Americans seem more willing to believe in one position over another according to political or religious ideology and refuse to investigate issues objectively. The belief that President Obama is a Muslim, for instance, is a position held contrary to fact and seems to be based primarily on political ideology for the purpose of denigrating the President. The belief or disbelief in global warming also seems to be based on ideology and often amounts to little more than a poll on the popularity of Al Gore. Americans are not ignorant, but more and more we are becoming biased in the facts we choose to believe or disbelieve. We are not objective in our approach to knowledge. Such one sided approach to knowledge and the issues of the day can easily lead others to think we are simple minded.
 
Perhaps not, but as a college instructor I have to wonder why a MAJORITY of my students can’t write a coherent sentence. This is getting worse every year. If we are alarmed about the direction of the country at present, wait until this generation takes charge.
I think one reason you are finding students who are incapable of writing a coherent sentence or paragraph is because there are fewer and fewer forums in which such a skill is useful. You can blame computers more than teachers for that. Students of a certain age now “Tweet” instead of write. They communicate with partial sentences or abbreviations or smilies. LOL, for instance. It would be interesting to see a poll of how many of your students last wrote a letter of more than two pages and mailed it in an envelope with a stamp. Still, we should be careful about labeling such students as “ignorant.” True, they may not know how to write a coherent sentence, but they do know how to communicate in different ways. The ways we communicate are changing and modern students are evolving to communicate in these new and more techniological ways. That doesn’t make them ignorant any more than our inability to write with ink and quill makes us ignorant.
 
I don’t think Americans are particularly more ignorant than people from other countries, but what I do find unnerving is that many Americans seem more willing to believe in one position over another according to political or religious ideology and refuse to investigate issues objectively.
Yes, this slide into shallow, extreme partisanship has been ongoing for a couple decades, but really seems to have accelerated in the past few years. Honestly, it makes me worry about the future of the US. It sets the stage for social strife. We’ve had a handful of CAF members drop hints about the use of violence as a solution to their political and cultural concerns. And they weren’t joking either.
 
I think one reason you are finding students who are incapable of writing a coherent sentence or paragraph is because there are fewer and fewer forums in which such a skill is useful. You can blame computers more than teachers for that. Students of a certain age now “Tweet” instead of write. They communicate with partial sentences or abbreviations or smilies. LOL, for instance. It would be interesting to see a poll of how many of your students last wrote a letter of more than two pages and mailed it in an envelope with a stamp. Still, we should be careful about labeling such students as “ignorant.” True, they may not know how to write a coherent sentence, but they do know how to communicate in different ways. The ways we communicate are changing and modern students are evolving to communicate in these new and more techniological ways. That doesn’t make them ignorant any more than our inability to write with ink and quill makes us ignorant.
I couldn’t disagree more. This new form of communication is certainly at the root of the problem (see* What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains*, by Nicholas Carr), and it causes us to think differently. Or, in the case of most youngsters, limits their ability to concentrate for more than a few minutes at a time. Add to that the insipid idea that teachers should follow a pedagogical model designed to babysit these kids and presto - college students that have little or no reading comprehension, and cant write a complete sentence.
 
Tap, I sympathize with your dilemma. Those of us in the work world run into similar problems.

I don’t know the solution to the educational problems in this country. I am the mother of a very good, very devoted 5th grade teacher (that’s not my mother’s pride showing that’s based on assessments of her performance by her employer.) My daughter does everything she can for her students, but teachers need the support of the parents, and according to my daughter all too often the parents are, at best, complacent. Some parents will actively oppose such things as homework assignments for their children, considering schoolwork is something that should be done exclusively at school, disregarding the need to form good study habits. And then there are the severely dysfunctional homes…

From what I can see, there is a significant segment of the population that does not put a priority on eduction, something I find incomprehensible. We are not going to solve this problem without everyone getting on board to do so. We can’t expect the teachers to do it all. As my daughter tells the parents of her students at “back to school” night ~ “I’m your child’s teacher for 9 months, you are their teachers for life.”
 
Well, I think, as a young, single mom-

that the odds are stacked against us. Girls are told that they don’t need a man. Men are told that women should be independent and have their own jobs/money. Which makes us women work even HARDER to PROVE how equal and independent were are. Which is fine until kids come into the picture.

You know how hard it is as a single parent? I wouldnt wish it upon anybody. And the fact of the matter is that, MOST people are middle to lower class, not having CAREERS that pay us six figures. So we work work work, to where we only SEE our kids on weekends, and then on a Wednesday night a teacher wants a parent conference?

I cant get time off, and by the time I get home I’m ready to pass out…

I dont know- I just know there are LOTS of different factors- THE LEAST of which is parents not CARING about their kids. I love my kid. I care about her education, stress it to her, read to her…all that, but there is just NO time … any little bit of time I can SQUEEZE out for myself, I spend with her talking to her, cuddling with her. If I miss a parent teacher meeting its not because I dont CARE about her or her education, its because I know she can read/write/count, does all her homework, generally know how shes doing in the class, and dont have the 30 minutes to sit there with you to reiterate it.

I know, I’m a terrible mom. But its the truth. 🤷
 
. If I miss a parent teacher meeting its not because I dont CARE about her or her education, its because I know she can read/write/count, does all her homework, generally know how shes doing in the class, and dont have the 30 minutes to sit there with you to reiterate it.
THAT being said I also fully admit that some parents may not have close relationships with their children and may NEED these conferences to ‘catch up’. I just wanted to point out that the odds are kind of against family right now, spending time at home, being with family, is not really the focus, I think being set for younger adults, who in turn, become single parents…and have these kinds of headaches. (how to juggle working/kids/appts, etc)
 
I know, I’m a terrible mom. But its the truth. 🤷
You’re not a terrible Mom. You sound like a great Mom who is doing the best she can. Since I was once a single Mom, I can relate to how impacted your schedule is.

There are parents that can’t be bothered doing any of the things you do, don’t stress the importance of educations with their children, and not only do not support what the teachers are trying to achieve, but sometimes actually work against it. Those are the parents we need to find a way to persuade to cooperate. It’s not all about parent-teacher conferences. 🙂
 
The belief that President Obama is a Muslim, for instance, is a position held contrary to fact and seems to be based primarily on political ideology for the purpose of denigrating the President.
Actually, it’s not as contrary to fact as all that.

“As the son of the Muslim father, Senator Obama was born a Muslim under Muslim law as it is universally understood.” This is from the (admittedly op-ed) article in the New York Times (URL below), which is not known for being a conservative paper.

nytimes.com/2008/05/12/opinion/12luttwak.html

According to my personal definition, I don’t think the President is a Muslim, but according to the Muslim definition, apparently he is. Frankly, I could have a lot more respect for him as a Muslim than as a man who listened to Rev. Wright for 20 years.

You don’t have to be ignorant or an idealogue to believe the President is a Muslim. You could just be a believer in Sharia. 😉

-Jen
 
I don’t know the solution to the educational problems in this country. I am the mother of a very good, very devoted 5th grade teacher (that’s not my mother’s pride showing that’s based on assessments of her performance by her employer.) My daughter does everything she can for her students, but teachers need the support of the parents, and according to my daughter all too often the parents are, at best, complacent. Some parents will actively oppose such things as homework assignments for their children, considering schoolwork is something that should be done exclusively at school, disregarding the need to form good study habits. And then there are the severely dysfunctional homes…
This is where I have to add to this. I have teachers in my family and they’re not happy at all with what’s happening right now, and most of the blame does go to the parents and to the school divisions for listening to them.

First is the idea of grades. Parents can’t seem to tolerate anything less than perfection, but unlike in past generations when the blame was rightly (most of the time) placed on the student, now it’s the teachers fault if little Timmy doesn’t get straight A’s. “Experts” who think they know everything say that grades are “harmful” to a kids self-esteem (these same “experts” would freak if they understood anything about how the real world works), so grades are now discouraged.
Late assignment? Teachers are discouraged from setting due dates. How about a do-over? It’s getting to the point where teachers will be forced to give students an infinite amount of do-overs until they’re satisfied, completely ignoring that in the real world if you screw up there’s no such thing as a do-over.

Parents (not all, the ones who believe in “child-centered parenting” mostly) and school boards are tying teachers hands. Education has been hijacked to become an exercise in ego-boosting instead of, well, educating. Are there some bad teachers? Sure, but often times they’re hands have been tied in the name of “we can’t let the children feel like they haven’t reached a goal even if they haven’t”.

This isn’t some conspiracy either. This is what I have heard from teachers themselves. They’re no longer allowed to mark assignments as late. They’re investigated getting rid of marks. And people wonder why kids aren’t getting educated. The answer for anyone who’s got common sense is that kids aren’t getting enough, and yet the direction always seems to move towards less.

The next generation is going to be so ill-equiped to deal with University that they’ll have to lower to standards of degrees to the point where they no longer mean anything (universities need students to pay tuition and fees to stay afloat, and the idea of downsizing is anathema to universities). In my engineering classes, late homework is a 0%. No ifs, ands, or buts, if you don’t get homework in then it’s a zero (the reason is half “you need to get homework in on time” and half logistics. Homework gets dropped off in a box and is checked once a week, checking it everyday and logging who got what in when isn’t practical when you’ve got upwards of 100 students). If students are coming from a school that allows you to get in homework “when you can get to it”, how are they going to be able to handle strict deadlines? Never mind university, how will they be able to handle deadlines in work, when not getting it done may result in you loosing your job?
 
This is where I have to add to this. I have teachers in my family and they’re not happy at all with what’s happening right now, and most of the blame does go to the parents and to the school divisions for listening to them.

First is the idea of grades. Parents can’t seem to tolerate anything less than perfection, but unlike in past generations when the blame was rightly (most of the time) placed on the student, now it’s the teachers fault if little Timmy doesn’t get straight A’s. “Experts” who think they know everything say that grades are “harmful” to a kids self-esteem (these same “experts” would freak if they understood anything about how the real world works), so grades are now discouraged.
Late assignment? Teachers are discouraged from setting due dates. How about a do-over? It’s getting to the point where teachers will be forced to give students an infinite amount of do-overs until they’re satisfied, completely ignoring that in the real world if you screw up there’s no such thing as a do-over.

Parents (not all, the ones who believe in “child-centered parenting” mostly) and school boards are tying teachers hands. Education has been hijacked to become an exercise in ego-boosting instead of, well, educating. Are there some bad teachers? Sure, but often times they’re hands have been tied in the name of “we can’t let the children feel like they haven’t reached a goal even if they haven’t”.

This isn’t some conspiracy either. This is what I have heard from teachers themselves. They’re no longer allowed to mark assignments as late. They’re investigated getting rid of marks. And people wonder why kids aren’t getting educated. The answer for anyone who’s got common sense is that kids aren’t getting enough, and yet the direction always seems to move towards less.

The next generation is going to be so ill-equiped to deal with University that they’ll have to lower to standards of degrees to the point where they no longer mean anything (universities need students to pay tuition and fees to stay afloat, and the idea of downsizing is anathema to universities). In my engineering classes, late homework is a 0%. No ifs, ands, or buts, if you don’t get homework in then it’s a zero (the reason is half “you need to get homework in on time” and half logistics. Homework gets dropped off in a box and is checked once a week, checking it everyday and logging who got what in when isn’t practical when you’ve got upwards of 100 students). If students are coming from a school that allows you to get in homework “when you can get to it”, how are they going to be able to handle strict deadlines? Never mind university, how will they be able to handle deadlines in work, when not getting it done may result in you loosing your job?
I’ve heard of parents like that, and I do feel for the teachers. On the flipside though, we had one of our kids who was failing in 6th grade. She was lying to us about having all of her work done. When we sat down with the teacher, we told her to fail her and have her repeat the 6th grade. That was unacceptable to the teacher and school because of what it would do to her self-esteem.

Personally, we think she would have survived it and learned an important life lesson. She didn’t…it took her D average freshman year and the realization that it now counts toward her efforts to get into college for her to learn that lesson.

Our schools and parents are messed up, and we have a bunch of illiterate young adults because of it.
 
This is where I have to add to this. I have teachers in my family and they’re not happy at all with what’s happening right now, and most of the blame does go to the parents and to the school divisions for listening to them.

First is the idea of grades. Parents can’t seem to tolerate anything less than perfection, but unlike in past generations when the blame was rightly (most of the time) placed on the student, now it’s the teachers fault if little Timmy doesn’t get straight A’s. “Experts” who think they know everything say that grades are “harmful” to a kids self-esteem (these same “experts” would freak if they understood anything about how the real world works), so grades are now discouraged.
Late assignment? Teachers are discouraged from setting due dates. How about a do-over? It’s getting to the point where teachers will be forced to give students an infinite amount of do-overs until they’re satisfied, completely ignoring that in the real world if you screw up there’s no such thing as a do-over.

Parents (not all, the ones who believe in “child-centered parenting” mostly) and school boards are tying teachers hands. Education has been hijacked to become an exercise in ego-boosting instead of, well, educating. Are there some bad teachers? Sure, but often times they’re hands have been tied in the name of “we can’t let the children feel like they haven’t reached a goal even if they haven’t”.

This isn’t some conspiracy either. This is what I have heard from teachers themselves. They’re no longer allowed to mark assignments as late. They’re investigated getting rid of marks. And people wonder why kids aren’t getting educated. The answer for anyone who’s got common sense is that kids aren’t getting enough, and yet the direction always seems to move towards less.

The next generation is going to be so ill-equiped to deal with University that they’ll have to lower to standards of degrees to the point where they no longer mean anything (universities need students to pay tuition and fees to stay afloat, and the idea of downsizing is anathema to universities). In my engineering classes, late homework is a 0%. No ifs, ands, or buts, if you don’t get homework in then it’s a zero (the reason is half “you need to get homework in on time” and half logistics. Homework gets dropped off in a box and is checked once a week, checking it everyday and logging who got what in when isn’t practical when you’ve got upwards of 100 students). If students are coming from a school that allows you to get in homework “when you can get to it”, how are they going to be able to handle strict deadlines? Never mind university, how will they be able to handle deadlines in work, when not getting it done may result in you loosing your job?
We are already there. I have had a parent in my office yelling at me for giving her child a F. The kid could not write a complete sentence, but had somehow made it to his junior year in college. This is an indictment on parents, teachers, and professors in his department. Believe it or not, he was an education major. No wonder we are at the brink of meltdown.
 
Actually, it’s not as contrary to fact as all that.

“As the son of the Muslim father, Senator Obama was born a Muslim under Muslim law as it is universally understood.” This is from the (admittedly op-ed) article in the New York Times (URL below), which is not known for being a conservative paper.

nytimes.com/2008/05/12/opinion/12luttwak.html

According to my personal definition, I don’t think the President is a Muslim, but according to the Muslim definition, apparently he is. Frankly, I could have a lot more respect for him as a Muslim than as a man who listened to Rev. Wright for 20 years.

You don’t have to be ignorant or an idealogue to believe the President is a Muslim. You could just be a believer in Sharia. 😉

-Jen
It’s odd that according to your own definition you do not think the President is a Muslim, but then you quote an op-ed piece from May of 2008 to bolster the insinuation that he is a Muslim. In fact, a careful reading of the article does not claim that Obama is a Muslim but that in many middle eastern nations he would be considered an apostate from the Muslim faith. It is true that the President’s father was born into a Muslim family, but it is on public record that his father was an avowed athiest before he even met the President’s mother and before President Obama was ever born. In addition to this, the President himself has long identified himself as a Christian and continues to do so. He has never practiced the five pillars of Islam which truly marks the believer in that faith and more specifically, he had never made a public declaration that there is no God but Allah and Muhammed is his prophet as is required before one can truly be considered a believer. It is true that one need not be ignorant to claim that President Obama is a Muslim, but you do have to be deceptive and somewhat loose with the actual facts of the matter. In order to truly believe that the President is a Muslim, I think you do have to be ignorant or, if not ignorant, then at least unreasonable and perhaps even fanatical. The only reason to claim that the President is a Muslim, even in the face of his own personal avowel of his faith in Jesus Christ, is to denigrate him in the eyes of a public that is suspicious of the Islamic faith almost to the point of paranoia. I think this is the result of ideology attempting to disguise the truth for political gain.
 
I couldn’t disagree more. This new form of communication is certainly at the root of the problem (see* What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains*, by Nicholas Carr), and it causes us to think differently. Or, in the case of most youngsters, limits their ability to concentrate for more than a few minutes at a time. Add to that the insipid idea that teachers should follow a pedagogical model designed to babysit these kids and presto - college students that have little or no reading comprehension, and cant write a complete sentence.
I’m not sure what you are disagreeing with. You mention that “This new form of communication is certainly at the root of the problem . . . and it causes us to think differently.” This was exactly the point I was making in my own post. As for the rest of your post, it’s not really a response to anything I’ve written.
 
I couldn’t disagree more. This new form of communication is certainly at the root of the problem (see* What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains*, by Nicholas Carr), and it causes us to think differently. Or, in the case of most youngsters, limits their ability to concentrate for more than a few minutes at a time. Add to that the insipid idea that teachers should follow a pedagogical model designed to babysit these kids and presto - college students that have little or no reading comprehension, and cant write a complete sentence.
Carr’s book sounds interesting? Could the new media be contributing to the surge in cases of ADD and ADHD?

Ever hear of Marshall McLuhan?

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_McLuhan

His ideas might be along the same line as Nicholas Carr’s. I watched an interview of him on EWTN. It’s available on Youtube:

youtube.com/watch?v=1uZYR3jmMng
 
I’m not sure what you are disagreeing with. You mention that “This new form of communication is certainly at the root of the problem . . . and it causes us to think differently.” This was exactly the point I was making in my own post. As for the rest of your post, it’s not really a response to anything I’ve written.
You seemed to suggest that these kids will be just fine in the world because they are proficient in the new forms of communication. I say that the new forms of communication have an effect on their brain that will insure the dumbing down of society.
 
Hate to tell you, but ignorance is world wide, not confined to the USA.

And there are reasons why some people believe that Mr. Obama is secretly Muslim (even though he attended a Christian Church for years). He has been openly supportive of Muslim positions, he has openly attacked Christian positions, and he gives little evidence of having any Christian beliefs. He does not attend church at all, and his administration is actively fighting against Christianity in just about every way possible.

Is he Muslim? Who knows? He claims not to be, but he did live in a Muslim country for a number of years, where he attended Muslim schools. The practice of Christianity in Indonesia is actively suppressed, as it was when he lived there.

Frankly, I doubt if he has any religious beliefs, other than for convenience. He has to profess something to get elected to office, and he knew that if he didn’t claim to be a Christian, he had no chance of becoming President. He certainly does not present any evidence at all that he believes in anything higher than himself.
 
I think it’s a trust issue. People just don’t believe what Obama says. On matters of faith, it kind of started when people learned about the church Obama attended for 20 years, and just how extreme Jeremiah Wright was. When Obama said he could’t remember those extreme things his pastor said, people just didn’t believe him.
 
It has to be realized, of course, that the U.S. has a LOT of immigrants, many of whom are not supposed to be here, and many of whom received virtually no education at all. Add to that the fact that some pockets of people really are isolated from everyone else. That can change, and does. At one time, not so awfully many years ago, my part of the U.S. was extremely isolated. It was “legendary” for its ignorance, and was, for that reason, the subject of many cartoons, movies, etc. When I was a little kid, there was no TV or even electricity available at all. Our water source was a creek and our heat was a stone fireplace. That was a widespread condition of many people over a very large area. Now, there are still isolated and very backward pockets, but not many.

My impression of Canada (and you can correct any errors) is that there are most definitely isolated regions and populations, but that virtually the entire population resides within a few fairly densely populated corridors. The isolated regions are vast and have almost no population at all. A peculiarity, I guess, of the U.S. is that certain previously isolated peoples from the rural South moved to large northern cities, but remained just as isolated within their own groups there (if not more so) than they were in the places they left. Not sure what the answer to that is.

But I don’t think I would broadly characterize Americans (yes, yes, I know you’re “Americans” too, in the broad sense. I’m just using the common expression.) as ignorant of the world. It would be true, however, that a great number of Americans really don’t care much what the world thinks of us, and don’t pay it much attention for that reason. You can call that whatever you want, but that should not be taken for ignorance.
Having traveled a bit I would say that it’s not so much ignorance as lack of exposure. I tend to find that the bigger the country, the less likely the population to be aware of much outside its own immediate orbit. Which is why it may surprise you, Ridgerunner that several immigrant subpopulations may actually be more knowledgeable of the outside world than the average American who has not been abroad much. If your country is a dot on the globe, your books, papers, TV etc are much less likely to be all about itself and your people more likely to have travelled far and wide in search of opportunity - hence they gain more exposure to the outside.

When I got my daily news from international sources, I was able to name just about any major country’s head of state simply from hearing their names so often - now I only know the ones who make enough waves to get mentioned in US news broadcasts. That of course is my fault - becoming too introverted.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top