Americans really ARE selfish

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sandwiches1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Sandwiches1

Guest
Is this true?:

dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2273243/Study-finds-Americans-likely-things-good-community.html#axzz2JxinkAow
Americans really ARE selfish: Study finds individuals are only motivated by self-serving acts
Code:
We're all in this together - but not if you're an American.
A new study by psychologists at Stanford University has found that Americans aren’t driven by a sense of community.

And calls to Americans to act interdependently, rather than independently, could even make things worse.

So if you’re trying to get people to do something like recycling, it’s better to stress that it’s good for them individually rather than pointing out the wider benefits.
 
Is this true?:

dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2273243/Study-finds-Americans-likely-things-good-community.html#axzz2JxinkAow
Americans really ARE selfish: Study finds individuals are only motivated by self-serving acts
Code:
We're all in this together - but not if you're an American.
A new study by psychologists at Stanford University has found that Americans aren’t driven by a sense of community.

And calls to Americans to act interdependently, rather than independently, could even make things worse.

So if you’re trying to get people to do something like recycling, it’s better to stress that it’s good for them individually rather than pointing out the wider benefits.
No its incorrect. It would be like saying that all French are like Sarkozy or all Italians are like Berlusconi. There is no doubt truth that SOME Americans are like that but to make a generalization is incorrect and is indicative of a corrupt media that works against the best interests of the people.
 
The participant sample seems to have been taken from the Stanford student population. That’s hardly a representative sample of the U.S population. 🤷
 
As an Australian,
I personally know Americans who are truly generous,
and on this site during the past few years I have encountered encounters many generous Americans…as also I did during my visits to the United States.
Generalizations about any group of persons is usually simplistic,
and studies of a limit group of person are not convincing as a measure of people in general.
As a generalization…I dislike, and am unconvinced, by generalizations!

God bless,
Trishie 🙂
 
Is this true?:

dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2273243/Study-finds-Americans-likely-things-good-community.html#axzz2JxinkAow
Americans really ARE selfish: Study finds individuals are only motivated by self-serving acts
Code:
We're all in this together - but not if you're an American.
A new study by psychologists at Stanford University has found that Americans aren’t driven by a sense of community.

And calls to Americans to act interdependently, rather than independently, could even make things worse.

So if you’re trying to get people to do something like recycling, it’s better to stress that it’s good for them individually rather than pointing out the wider benefits.
Memories are really short. If Americans are as selfish as reported, then why did we enter WW II in Europe and rescue the UK from the Germans. If it wasn’t for our selfishness, the Daily Mail would be printed in German today!
As for thee Stanford University study, since when did Americans ever hold with collectivity? Our country was founded on a basis of rugged individualism… it is the hall mark of our national identity.
 
Nope, I’m 100% selfish

The only reason that I go on these mission trips to Tanzania and mentor inner city kids is because I want the eternal glory of Heaven.

I’ll do anything that will get me there, no matter who have to help to do it.

😃
 
The sample size was small, Sandwiches, and drawn from very limited demographics. Of course, no statistical study can be 100% accurate unless it poles 100 percent of a population.

That being said there is truth in this study. I’ve always said being American is an individual sport.

I got a kick out of one of those posters below though. I had to really chuckle at him (literally). I remember when the U.S. Army was putting out those “Army of One” commercials making it appear it was much more of an individualistic thing.
  1. dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2273243/Study-finds-Americans-likely-things-good-community.html#axzz2JxinkAow
    From the OP article a poster leaving a comment:
johh in the UK , Late for two world wars… you arrogant Brit… those conflicts were just a continuation of your European wars…and we bailed you TWICE… Many uder 35 Americans are way to self absorbed… except for those in the military…
  • Andrew_59, Arlington, United States, 4/2/2013 14:45
  1. nbcnews.com/id/15197720/ns/us_news-military/t/army-strong-replaces-army-one/#.URAnw2chSZQ
Loren Thompson, a defense analyst at the Lexington Institute research group, said the previous slogan seemed to promote the notion that you could join the Army and preserve your individuality.
**
“If you want to be an ‘Army of One’ you probably want to join the Hell’s Angels, not the U.S. Army,”** he said.
The Army adopted the “Army of One” slogan in January 2001 after research showed that young people saw life in the military as dehumanizing. It had replaced the “Be All You Can Be” campaign, which lasted nearly 20 years but which Army officials had soured on at a time of recruiting problems.
Multiple strengths touted
“Army Strong” was developed by McCann Worldgroup, the communications firm the Army hired last December after struggling through a disappointing recruiting year. The overall five-year contract with McCann Worldgroup is valued at $1 billion, with the first two years guaranteed at $200 million annually.
The new slogan, developed in numerous tests with focus groups and interviews with soldiers, is meant to convey the idea that if you join the Army you will gain physical and emotional strength, as well as strength of character and purpose.
Bold my emphasis.

Some areas of America are worse than others. The small town of Tomha, Wisconsin is very community orientated and will help strangers out (at times, like many small towns some don’t like strangers). Entering the North side of Milwaukee is another world. And even people that grow up from the cradle with each other rather bite, claw, and pull down those they came up with to become the undisputed boss and almighty king than rise together. Just the way it is. 🤷

I reality all humans are self motivated. Well most all (some are altruistic). It’s one of the basic views of the science of biology and probably anthropology too.

The U.S. tends to be more individualistic than most if not all of the developed world. But even in the U.S. some team work has to exist or the whole would eventually fail. Be that whole in the military, private sector, or government. Some of the best training in team work in the U.S.–in my opinion–comes through organized team sports.

Hey… even Brazil (a developing nation) has now granted universal health care and it has the most people in the world on cash transfer programs. And that nation has a much smaller GDP than the U.S.
 
How very silly!

Did it occur to them to consider that Americans also have 2.1 children per woman, while in Europe it’s far less? If one wants to support a family, he’s not going to be quite as quick to donate to UNICEF (as these “testers” did) I wouldn’t donate to UNICEF anyway, no matter what. There are a LOT of charities with a greater claim on me than UNICEF. But my children come before those, no matter what.

Did it occur to them as well that the Asian drive for “interdependence” might not extend beyond their own ethnic or even extended family group? There are other ethnic groups that are like that as well…very generous within the extended supportive group, not so much outside it.

And white Americans (the biggest villains in the article) vary. I have spent lots of times collecting outside stores for retarded citizens, and there are big differences among socioeconomic groups. But that doesn’t tell you the story either. The biggest donors for major civic projects are wealthy white people, bar none.
 
They are making a big mistake by conflating the concept of selfishness with being “individually motivated.”

Example from the article:
Currently, if we want to inspire Americans to think and act interdependently, it may work best to actually emphasize their independence to motivate them to do so,’ Hamedani said. ‘Tell them, “Be the change you want to see in the world” instead of “We’re all in this together”.’
“Be the change you want to see in the world”, a Gandhi quotation if I’m not mistaken. That is not selfish in the slightest, it simply emphasizes the power of the individual to act.
 
Is this true?
I get ALL my information about what America is like from the Daily Mail. 🤷

Seriously, though, there is a big difference between selfishness and individualism. A selfish person might say, “I’m only going to do what helps me,” while an individualist might say, “I want to decide for myself what I will do for others and how I will do it.” Now, someone might say something like that to hide selfishness, but they might also say it if what they wanted to do for others was quite significant. In addition, individualism implies a reluctance to accept help from others unless it is truly necessary, which in my mind is frankly to be preferred to the mentality that says, “society owes me x, y, and z.”

But anyway, according to the description of the study, it was not appropriate to measure selfishness, but primarily individualism. And indeed the article makes conclusions that I HIGHLY doubt the researchers made, since I assume they are responsible scientists.

First, it is completely impossible to say what “Americans” are like based wholly on a sampling of college students, especially students all at one college.

Second, as I mentioned before, the study did not test selfishness, or even individualism, but rather the tendency of college students to prefer “doing their own thing” to working collaboratively.

Third, I personally consider Asian-Americans to be Americans, and the results were different there.

So, in order to be even reasonably accurate, the headline should have been:

European-American College Students in Southern California really DO prefer to work on their own rather than collaboratively

Perhaps there just wasn’t room on the page? I’m sure that they weren’t just looking for an excuse to insult Americans. 😃

–Jen
 
They are making a big mistake by conflating the concept of selfishness with being “individually motivated.”
FWIW, Ayn Rand called selfishness a virtue. In fact she wrote a book on it. “The Virtue of Selfishness.”
 
FWIW, Ayn Rand called selfishness a virtue. In fact she wrote a book on it. “The Virtue of Selfishness.”
What is your fascination with Ayn Rand? You seem to bring her name up on a regular basis. Do you sell her books?
 
FWIW, Ayn Rand called selfishness a virtue. In fact she wrote a book on it. “The Virtue of Selfishness.”
Why are we bringing Rand into this?

Nevertheless, I agree with her to an extent, but it’s more complicated than that. As you likely know, by “selfishness”, she did not mean precisely what the average person might mean.

It’s not as if she was talking about having a will to power and crushing those in your way without regard to ethics. That would be more how the average person might understand “selfishness.”
 
I get ALL my information about what America is like from the Daily Mail. 🤷
…First, it is completely impossible to say what “Americans” are like based wholly on a sampling of college students, especially students all at one college.

Second, as I mentioned before, the study did not test selfishness, or even individualism, but rather the tendency of college students to prefer “doing their own thing” to working collaboratively.

Third, I personally consider Asian-Americans to be Americans, and the results were different there.

So, in order to be even reasonably accurate, the headline should have been:

European-American College Students in Southern California really DO prefer to work on their own rather than collaboratively

Perhaps there just wasn’t room on the page? I’m sure that they weren’t just looking for an excuse to insult Americans. 😃

–Jen
Well said. Many younger Americans, while raised in the “ME FIRST” eras (1980’s and beyond) are actually more altruistic and generous than their parents at times. Some, however, are very selfish or self-centered, two different ideas: Selfishness usually afflicts the comfortable and affluent (although a poor person can be selfish, they usually aren’t criticized for it) Those are mostly the Americans that travel, communicate and interact around the globe;
Self-centered, on the other hand, relates to a childish notion of the world that the individual is at the center and all events are to the credit and/or blame of that person. THIS self-centeredness can happen when a child is neglected and unsupervised and I believe that the last decades’ latchkey children (as well as some before them), whose parents are not at home, suffer from this confusion into their adult years.

The American culture is blessed and cursed with affluence, civil and gender rights in the workplace. It has also seen, in recent decades, smaller families and increased consumerism. These things have brought about some interesting changes in how American individuals see themselves and relate to others.

Along with the past growth of our economy and increased opportunities for Americans, have also come ways to perceive oneself outside of the tribe or community. Whether our present economic downturn creates more community and altruism remains to be seen.

Many Americans have “chosen their own spiritual path”; whether that has lead to more or less generosity is another debate but relates to a person seeking a path that is different from their family and neighbor.

Also, the U.S, especially, is a very culturally diverse country; defining an “American” is trickier than defining a “Japanese” or a “Swede” (yes, I know that both of those countries have immigrants as well but not quite to the degree of the U.S.) On what basis do you ask the question of this post?
 
Is this true?:

dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2273243/Study-finds-Americans-likely-things-good-community.html#axzz2JxinkAow
Americans really ARE selfish: Study finds individuals are only motivated by self-serving acts
Code:
We're all in this together - but not if you're an American.
A new study by psychologists at Stanford University has found that Americans aren’t driven by a sense of community.

And calls to Americans to act interdependently, rather than independently, could even make things worse.

So if you’re trying to get people to do something like recycling, it’s better to stress that it’s good for them individually rather than pointing out the wider benefits.
What a silly conclusion from an equally silly and poorly structured survery! You realize students, particularly at an elite school like Stanford are in a COMPETITIVE environment. This is like saying that if everyone on one football team doesn’t help the other team they are being selfish. The students are at a college to learn, to achieve to make themselves better. They are not there to “lift each other up” If that’s the idea maybe they should be at church instead of college.

Further although it’s been ages since I was in college, whenever there were group projects, the smart and ambitious students ended up doing all or most of the work. I even recall my senior Bus Ad final class when NO ONE but me was motiviated. I did the whole thing because I was working toward a Magna Cum Laude and didn’t want some slacker to ruin my chances. Selfish? I don’t know…how about not wanting to be pulled down by the lazy members of the group.

Americans are the most generous, hands on, volunteering, and kind hearted people in the world. Although I will grant that as religion becomes less and less influential and people become “all about me” you’ll probably see less volunteer spirit from the secular ranks.

Lisa
 
Memories are really short. If Americans are as selfish as reported, then why did we enter WW II in Europe and rescue the UK from the Germans. If it wasn’t for our selfishness, the Daily Mail would be printed in German today!
.
And WW I for that matter.
As for thee Stanford University study, since when did Americans ever hold with collectivity? Our country was founded on a basis of rugged individualism… it is the hall mark of our national identity
As for the Stanford University study, who believes anything Stanford University says, anyway? 😃

Jon
 
Here is a related article
Q. Are Americans more or less charitable than citizens of other countries?
A. No developed country approaches American giving. For example, in 1995 (the most recent year for which data are available), Americans gave, per capita, three and a half times as much to causes and charities as the French, seven times as much as the Germans, and 14 times as much as the Italians. Similarly, in 1998, Americans were 15 percent more likely to volunteer their time than the Dutch, 21 percent more likely than the Swiss, and 32 percent more likely than the Germans. These differences are not attributable to demographic characteristics such as education, income, age, sex, or marital status. On the contrary, if we look at two people who are identical in all these ways except that one is European and the other American, the probability is still far lower that the European will volunteer than the American.
american.com/archive/2008/march-april-magazine-contents/a-nation-of-givers
 
I get ALL my information about what America is like from the Daily Mail. 🤷

Seriously, though, there is a big difference between selfishness and individualism. A selfish person might say, “I’m only going to do what helps me,” while an individualist might say, “I want to decide for myself what I will do for others and how I will do it.” Now, someone might say something like that to hide selfishness, but they might also say it if what they wanted to do for others was quite significant. In addition, individualism implies a reluctance to accept help from others unless it is truly necessary, which in my mind is frankly to be preferred to the mentality that says, “society owes me x, y, and z.”
I general people accept what information they believe reinforces their own perceptions of the world.

I posted on the philosophy section of this website about human life and whether it begins at conception. An agnostic suggested science can’t know when human life begins. Most the Supreme Court Justices concluded this in their decision remarks over Roe vs Wade.

But the fact is–one can play mental gymnastics all they want–human development, human life (the type of life, the species of life), with all it’s heritable genes, begins at conception.

I would propose to you there is much evidence in the United States (the West and world in general) that selfishness rules much more of America (the United States) than altruism or benevolence towards ones neighbors. There is a lot of evidence for selfishness in Europe too. Perhaps it comes with material prosperity in a nation. I dunno.

At any rate… if this thread were on the state of the decline of religion, single mothers, divorce, et cetera… I think the tune of many Americans on this board would be different.

Having spent a short time homeless in the United States I know first hand that as the Americans walk by you not looking at you… they are not a particularly selfless people. I think many Americans desire to dismantle public education (mainly to increase the disadvantage of the poor) and there preference working class Americans go bankrupt treating their cancer rather than have universal health care to all is evidence of a great greed, lack of charity, and disdain for their fellow Americans they do not regard as alphas.

There is another attitude: “We are all in it together.”

But that’s not an American virtue until its time for war (and probably helping expand the wealth of corporate America).

Of course… a welfare state with too generous benefits too easily can become problematic too. That can cause an attitude as you said of “the government owes me x, y, z.”

Some aspects of British and French culture have fallen into that from my Americanized perspective. It almost drops my jaw at some of the things they fiercely protest over in those nations. They also seem less afraid of their police.

I do think Asians come from a traditional Eastern culture that places far more importance on family and community. Even black Africans do. And let me tell you they have beef with many aspects of ethnic Black-American culture. They find this culture I’m from violent, mean, disrespectful, and with no respect for family and marriage.

jsonline.com/news/milwaukee/us-violence-is-stunning-for-african-immigrants-seeking-peace-s462evh-161841825.html
Fessahaye Mebrahtu didn’t want to start a family feud, but some things just need to be said.
“We consider African-Americans to be our ‘next of kin,’ but when something like this happens, it makes some of us pull away.”
Mebrahtu is the executive director of the Pan-African Community Association, a group that sponsors programs and services for about 8,000 to 10,000 African immigrants living in the Milwaukee area.
A native of East Africa who has been in Milwaukee since 1995, Mebrahtu was talking specifically about the recent shooting death of Senegalese immigrant Abraham Assana, a beloved 42-year-old husband and father.
Assana was shot and killed during an apparent robbery June 30 outside a local nightclub where African immigrants often gather to share fellowship. What made Assana’s death more tragic for his friends and family was the discovery that the suspects used his credit card later to buy $11 in hot dogs.
Eleven dollars in hot dogs in exchange for the life of a hardworking man who just wanted the American dream.
According to Mebrahtu, Assana’s death rocked the local Pan-African community made up of immigrants from various African nations. The murder was a shock, but the senseless violence wasn’t necessarily a surprise.
Sadly, many African immigrants who have been living in the United States for decades have come to accept a certain level of crime and violence as part of the American experience, too. Mebrahtu recalled at least four homicides of African immigrants in Milwaukee over the past few years. He also was the victim of a robbery at knife point years ago while visiting Washington, D.C.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top