Americans really ARE selfish

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sandwiches1
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
^^Addendum.

I remember a case some years ago when two young men, one with a shotgun, stopped a white woman with her small mixed-race child on the North side of Milwaukee coming out of a fast food chicken place in the “hood.”

They could have just robbed her. But instead they blew her head off with the shotgun in front of her child. All for a bag of chicken.

Worse yet the child has carried that guilt with him/her for ever as he/she (I don’t remember the sex) begged his/her moms to stop at that fast food place for some fried chicken.

Not the only American child in Milwaukee to watch their parent get gunned down to death over senseless nonsense.
 
I general people accept what information they believe reinforces their own perceptions of the world.

Having spent a short time homeless in the United States I know first hand that as the Americans walk by you not looking at you… they are not a particularly selfless people. I Some aspects of British and French culture have fallen into that from my Americanized
Juxtaposing your first and a subsequent sentence. You state people accept what they believe reinforces their own perception of the world…and then prove it with the other sentence I left in the quote.

You presume that Americans walk by homeless people because they are selfish. I can tell you that is not the case for me or for a number of my Catholic friends. We donate to organizations that provide meals and housing for homeless, we volunteer at the shelters and soup kitchens. We are anything but selfish.

Why do I walk by homeless people and not meet their eye? Because they SCARE me. I have been badgered, threatened, accosted, blocked and screamed at by homeless people. I find much better for my own safety to NOT meet their eye, not engage and leave this to a more controlled situation. Our city has a policy of ignoring people camping, blocking sidewalks, urinating and defecating in public. I guess they think it’s more humane but it makes for a very threatening situation to the public who doesn’t know how to deal with some of these folks. There are many who are simply in need but we also have those with untreated mental illnesses, violent tendencies, and drug problems. I can’t tell by looking at someone lying across a sidewalk if he’s ill or going to grab my handbag.

Please consider that there other reasons besides selfishness in someone’s reaction to homeless people.

Lisa
 
I general people accept what information they believe reinforces their own perceptions of the world.
Obviously. 🙂
I would propose to you there is much evidence in the United States (the West and world in general) that selfishness rules much more of America (the United States) than altruism or benevolence towards ones neighbors. There is a lot of evidence for selfishness in Europe too. Perhaps it comes with material prosperity in a nation. I dunno.
There is a lot of evidence for a lot of things that aren’t necessarily true. This may be one of them. But since you quoted my post, I assume you made your comments in response to mine. But they didn’t actually respond to mine. My main point in the post was:

“The quoted survey does not provide evidence that Americans are selfish.”

The point of the part you quoted was:

“Individualism is not the same as selfishness.”

Your response was, “Yes Americans are selfish, because they don’t look at homeless strangers, want to dismantle public education for the purpose of hurting the poor, and don’t like universal healthcare, with an addendum that Americans are selfish because some guy in Milwaukee was a sociopath.”

If I had argued that Americans were not selfish, well, at least your argument would have been responsive to mine. But actually I didn’t. I don’t have enough data on that point. I don’t think you do, either. For one thing, I don’t think I’ve ever met anyone who wanted to dismantle public education. I’m 100% sure that I’ve never met anyone who wanted to do it “to increase the disadvanage of the poor.” Perhaps we just move in different circles.

–Jen
 
Juxtaposing your first and a subsequent sentence. You state people accept what they believe reinforces their own perception of the world…and then prove it with the other sentence I left in the quote.

You presume that Americans walk by homeless people because they are selfish. I can tell you that is not the case for me or for a number of my Catholic friends. We donate to organizations that provide meals and housing for homeless, we volunteer at the shelters and soup kitchens. We are anything but selfish.
Yes, yes… I’m American and I’ve helped feed the homeless too. But that is not what I was talking about.

I had a social science professor that used get annoyed at undergrad students that would always contradict his point with, “But I know X, Y, Z persons…” As he would explain, social science is in the business of making generalizations. Kind of like a mathematical mean average is a balancing point in a weight of numbers. Not to say I’m speaking in any scientific manner or drawing on any scientific data or opinions. I’m just saying I’m speaking in generalizations for a rational purpose: 300 + million people are to many people for me to speak individually about.

My point here is that I’m open to the idea atheists, homosexuals, pedophiles, single mothers, criminals, and even some Satanic worshipers feed the poor, homeless, and otherwise volunteer. (Not to suggest homosexuals, atheists, or single mothers are or should be considered in negative categories like those others)

If in fact the U.S. population is so good, then there really is little for people on this site to complain about with respects to any concept of the “decline” of America.

But just within my life time I’ve witnessed a dramatic decline just in Black-America alone.
Why do I walk by homeless people and not meet their eye? Because they SCARE me. I have been badgered, threatened, accosted, blocked and screamed at by homeless people. I find much better for my own safety to NOT meet their eye, not engage and leave this to a more controlled situation. Our city has a policy of ignoring people camping, blocking sidewalks, urinating and defecating in public. I guess they think it’s more humane but it makes for a very threatening situation to the public who doesn’t know how to deal with some of these folks. There are many who are simply in need but we also have those with untreated mental illnesses, violent tendencies, and drug problems. I can’t tell by looking at someone lying across a sidewalk if he’s ill or going to grab my handbag.
Please consider that there other reasons besides selfishness in someone’s reaction to homeless people.
There are crazy homeless people. Homeless people one should avoid. It also takes thick skin dealing with the homeless for any length of time because many of them are neither nice, good, or grateful people. Many are obnoxious.

Though… I frankly believe there is almost always (perhaps not always as in every case) a very noticeable difference between homeless military veterans (college educated people as well, or former professionals) and those that never served in the military. The latter often has little to no personal discipline.

Not every homeless person is a psycho though or lacks all social skills.

The guy Will Smith played in this movie was from Milwaukee and had a even more hard life (beginning in Milwaukee) than the movie presented (including being sexually abused as a boy, thrown out naked in the cold winter by I think what was his mother’s boyfriend).

He still kept putting one foot in front of the next though. He was/is a Navy vet too if I recall correctly.

youtube.com/watch?v=doLdmYhpNyc

Can’t say I have that same perseverance. Plus, life has been much gentler on me.
 
Yes, yes… I’m American and I’ve helped feed the homeless too. But that is not what I was talking about.

I had a social science professor that used get annoyed at undergrad students that would always contradict his point with, “But I know X, Y, Z persons…” As he would explain, social science is in the business of making generalizations. Kind of like a mathematical mean average is a balancing point in a weight of numbers. Not to say I’m speaking in any scientific manner or drawing on any scientific data or opinions. I’m just saying I’m speaking in generalizations for a rational purpose: 300 + million people are to many people for me to speak individually about.

My point here is that I’m open to the idea atheists, homosexuals, pedophiles, single mothers, criminals, and even some Satanic worshipers feed the poor, homeless, and otherwise volunteer. (Not to suggest homosexuals, atheists, or single mothers are or should be considered in negative categories like those others)

If in fact the U.S. population is so good, then there really is little for people on this site to complain about with respects to any concept of the “decline” of America.

But just within my life time I’ve witnessed a dramatic decline just in Black-America alone.

There are crazy homeless people. Homeless people one should avoid. It also takes thick skin dealing with the homeless for any length of time because many of them are neither nice, good, or grateful people. Many are obnoxious.

Though… I frankly believe there is almost always (perhaps not always as in every case) a very noticeable difference between homeless military veterans (college educated people as well, or former professionals) and those that never served in the military. The latter often has little to no personal discipline.

Not every homeless person is a psycho though or lacks all social skills.

The guy Will Smith played in this movie was from Milwaukee and had a even more hard life (beginning in Milwaukee) than the movie presented (including being sexually abused as a boy, thrown out naked in the cold winter by I think what was his mother’s boyfriend).

He still kept putting one foot in front of the next though. He was/is a Navy vet too if I recall correctly.

youtube.com/watch?v=doLdmYhpNyc

Can’t say I have that same perseverance. Plus, life has been much gentler on me.
I believe (and am not alone) that the “decline” in Black America can be traced to all of the "help’ provided by the government, most notably the federal programs that have now inspired 70% of black babies to be born to single mothers, the lauding of the “baby daddy” or “baby momma” without reference to actually providing for these children. Oh and the extremely high rate of abortion is yet another cultural phenomenon…

To what do you attribute this decline?

Further I think when referencing the “decline” in America, it is not with respect to our standard of living. There have been many surveys and studies that demonstrate the poor in this country would be considered wealthy in most countries, particularly “Third World” countries. People in this country do not starve in the streets or die in hospital parking lots because they are barred from receiving help. However many of us think the country is in decline because of the CULTURE. Look at the “music” that is popular, particularly certain genres with violent and hateful lyrics (if you can understand them which is often difficult). Look at modern “art” which is more likely to be disturbing than aesthetically appealing. Look at the high rate of STDs, lack of intact families, substance abuse, gang violence, low graduation rates, lower standards in schools, attacks on traditional American values. It’s all about the culture IMO.

I realize you were generalizing with respect to the homeless but did you think about my response and perhaps consider that I speak for many who find the homeless more frightening than pitiful? How is one supposed to be able to judge whether the homeless person sprawled across the sidewalk, slumped in a doorway or camping on the waterfront is safe or not? I can’t tell and thus do not engage with them on the street. They SCARE me.

I have no idea what you meant by adding a number of other categories that might well help homeless people. No one said helping the poor was the exclusive provence of Catholics or religious people. However statisticallly speaking, religious people tend to be more charitable in time, talent and treasure than secular people. I was simply pointing out that in my experience, it is not selfishness that makes us avoid interaction with people on the street but fear.

Lisa
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top