America's Baby Bust

  • Thread starter Thread starter Bubba_Switzler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
B

Bubba_Switzler

Guest
Forget the debt ceiling. Forget the fiscal cliff, the sequestration cliff and the entitlement cliff. Those are all just symptoms. What America really faces is a demographic cliff: The root cause of most of our problems is our declining fertility rate.
The fertility rate is the number of children an average woman bears over the course of her life. The replacement rate is 2.1. If the average woman has more children than that, population grows. Fewer, and it contracts. Today, America’s total fertility rate is 1.93, according to the latest figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; it hasn’t been above the replacement rate in a sustained way since the early 1970s.
online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323375204578270053387770718.html
 
Several countries are desperately battling this now. Both Japan and Russia are stridently trying to reverse their declines. The repercussions can be greater than current national debt.
 
Several countries are desperately battling this now. Both Japan and Russia are stridently trying to reverse their declines. The repercussions can be greater than current national debt.
Yes, nothing new really. But like most such articles it jumps straight from the problem to proposed government policies after briefly noting the many ways that government policies have discouraged procreation. I am skeptical of that.

Just in terms of demographics, you would expect to see subcultures that value large families thriving, at least relatively. Catholicism (as well as Morman and Orthodox Jewish), in theory, should be bucking this trend and growing relative to the general population. But to some extent at least, Catholicism has experienced the same trend albeit a little behind.

There is a tendency, that this article reinforces, to think that birth control is something new but that’s not true. There are very similar stories from the Roman empire. Then the pagans noticed that Jews and Christians were having big families.

This article does touch on something I’ve not seen much discussed elsewhere, the distinction between happiness and fulfillment.
 
Yes, nothing new really. But like most such articles it jumps straight from the problem to proposed government policies after briefly noting the many ways that government policies have discouraged procreation. I am skeptical of that.
Yes, I was a bit surprised at that as well. The underlying root of the demographic challenges facing the US, Japan, Russia and other countries has much to do with the standard of living provided by the successful economy.

A long-noted feature is that as the economies of nations around the world develop, their birth rates begin to decline. Partly this is due to the increased status of women and their ability to choose when to have a child. But another part is that children are expensive, and if child labor is economically no longer necessary, then children tend to lower the standard of living for the family. Most couples want children, but the ideal is one boy and one girl (preferably in that order.) Any additional children is a lifestyle choice. Do you want a third child or do you want a bigger home, nicer clothes and a second car?
This article does touch on something I’ve not seen much discussed elsewhere, the distinction between happiness and fulfillment.
I think this distinction may be at the heart of the matter. What are the values of a culture? How is an individual fulfilled in life? How is a couple fulfilled? Is there a difference?

As economies develop, cultures tend to become secular. And if a secular culture places its value on material pleasures, shouldn’t we expect that those things will be the primary goal?
 
I have experience trying to find a baby to adopt in the US. There are a couple million familes each year who fail to find a baby to adopt, because they are all being aborted!

As a Crisis Pregnancy Counselor, I saw a trend which greatly troubled me. **The abortion rate among College students was almost 98%. We are killing off our babies who are the most likely to be intelligent, innovative leaders. ** Another group which is so low functioning, they fail to plan ahead, or keep an appointment, and are the least likely to abort or be good parents…prostitutes, drugies, and the mentally challenged.
 
I have experience trying to find a baby to adopt in the US. There are a couple million familes each year who fail to find a baby to adopt, because they are all being aborted!

As a Crisis Pregnancy Counselor, I saw a trend which greatly troubled me. **The abortion rate among College students was almost 98%. We are killing off our babies who are the most likely to be intelligent, innovative leaders. ** Another group which is so low functioning, they fail to plan ahead, or keep an appointment, and are the least likely to abort or be good parents…prostitutes, drugies, and the mentally challenged.
Not to be cynical, but it doesn’t take too much to get into college these days. They basically take anyone who will sign a paper with a promise to pay for it. If the college students were able to plan ahead and be responsible enough to be good parents, they probably wouldn’t be in a situation where they felt a need to murder their own child in the first place. Furthermore, prostitutes and drug addicts were not genetically predestined to be those things. Their children could just as easily turn out to be wonderful people, especially if given a chance to be adopted and loved by a good family. I think every abortion is equally a tragedy, regardless of the type of person their mother was.
 
Perhaps another fellow Canadian can help me cite this, but McLean’s, a Canadian news magazine, reported a few years ago that France has had some success in addressing its declining birthrate. Parents with three or more children no longer have to pay income tax!!!

Apparently, that move (along with a few other perks) has made a difference.

Not offering an opinion here, just reporting.😃
 
Perhaps another fellow Canadian can help me cite this, but McLean’s, a Canadian news magazine, reported a few years ago that France has had some success in addressing its declining birthrate. Parents with three or more children no longer have to pay income tax!!!

Apparently, that move (along with a few other perks) has made a difference.

Not offering an opinion here, just reporting.😃
I’m for that!
 
We reap what we sow.

…Er… double entendre? Just realized that… :confused:
 
Perhaps another fellow Canadian can help me cite this, but McLean’s, a Canadian news magazine, reported a few years ago that France has had some success in addressing its declining birthrate. Parents with three or more children no longer have to pay income tax!!!

Apparently, that move (along with a few other perks) has made a difference.

Not offering an opinion here, just reporting.😃
The country of Georgia has had some success in increasing its birthrate, too, with a combination of government incentives and a religious incentive – the Patriarch of the Georgian Orthodox Church promised to be the godfather for children who are the third or subsequent child in their family. (He’s gotten 11,000 new godchildren in just a few years…)
lifesitenews.com/news/rising-birth-rate-in-former-soviet-nation-credited-to-orthodox-patriarch
 
Several countries are desperately battling this now. Both Japan and Russia are stridently trying to reverse their declines. The repercussions can be greater than current national debt.
Don’t forget the Koreas as well. Both North and South Korea have been having problems with low birth rates for quite some time now.

The sad part is, the overpopulation alarmists are spreading their errors to the Third World. Do they not realize that their alarmism is borderline racist?
 
Sounds great, I have six kids 🙂
Some years ago, I read that if the child deduction was the same then as it was in Truman’s day, it would be $20,000 per child. So, if that were true today, your deduction would be $120,000.

Unfortunately, income, which may be (here) called “I” is subject to the following formula:

I(from work) + I(from inventments) = C (consumption) - T (transfer payments).

As the government absorbs more and more of “T”, the less “T” one has to transfer to his children for their support. Whether people think of it in exactly this way or not, they act in accordance with it. As the government absorbs more and more of the national income, it reduces births, EXCEPT to the extent it allows people to keep more of their income or subsidizes births. It subsidizes births only to the extent of the various welfare programs, which keep growing, while simultaneously taking away more and more of the resources of those who would support their own children.
 
It subsidizes births only to the extent of the various welfare programs, which keep growing, while simultaneously taking away more and more of the resources of those who would support their own children.
So the people that are least productive produce the most children. Anyone else see the flaw?
 
Why use the word “borderline”?
Good point.
The overpopulation alarmists tend to be racist of the peoples from third-world countries. For instance, they do not want my people to breed.
 
Good point.
The overpopulation alarmists tend to be racist of the peoples from third-world countries. For instance, they do not want my people to breed.
While that seems to be true, it’s also true that some people looking to increase birthrates are doing so because non-white births are “outpacing” white births.
 
So the people that are least productive produce the most children. Anyone else see the flaw?
Only in the short-term. Their produce is human capital, arguably the most important kind of human “productivity”. The investment is in the long term, when we have all these extra grown children who would not otherwise be around, and therefore, would not be able to produce wealth or consume goods/services in the future (and generate government revenue through income and sales taxes).

Those who cry “population collapse” must logically support those who have children, even if it means benefit payments. You can’t have it both ways.
 
So the people that are least productive produce the most children. Anyone else see the flaw?
Only in the short-term. Their produce is human capital, arguably the most important kind of human “productivity”. The investment is in the long term, when we have all these extra grown children who would not otherwise be around, and therefore, would not be able to produce wealth or consume goods/services in the future (and generate government revenue through income and sales taxes).

Those who cry “population collapse” must logically support those who have children, even if it means benefit payments. You can’t have it both ways.
 
Only in the short-term. Their produce is human capital, arguably the most important kind of human “productivity”. The investment is in the long term, when we have all these extra grown children who would not otherwise be around, and therefore, would not be able to produce wealth or consume goods/services in the future (and generate government revenue through income and sales taxes).

Those who cry “population collapse” must logically support those who have children, even if it means benefit payments. You can’t have it both ways.
Why do you assume that the children of takers raised as takers, taught as takers will not grow to be takers?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top