T
TheSufi
Guest
Not really, because the poison would have killed a normal person instantly, which is what happened to his companion who ate the food with him, yet God allowed him to live 7 years in order to fulfill his mission. So poison is what killed him but not until he was able to fulfill his mission, 7 years a later. So basically for 7 years he was living off the life of God. It was one of his miracles.Odd then how Muhammad contradicts himself is this is the case:
*
Sunan abu dawud 4498 Muhammad then said about the pain which he died: “I continued to feel pain from the morsel which I had eaten at Khalbar. This is the time when it has cut off my aorta.”* (or this is the time of my death)
Contrast that with
Sahih muslim 5430: A Jewess came to Allah’s messenger with poisoned mutton and he took of what had been brought to him. When the effects of this poison were felt by him he called for her and asked her about that, whereupon she said:** I had determined to kill you. **Thereupon he said: Allah will never give you the power to do it.
I really don’t like writing rebuttals to these things, because most people who write anti-religious jargon against other religious people be they Christian, Muslim, Hindu, are usually ignorant of the religion they are criticizing. And you are ignorant of Islam.
To be fair, many of arguments that Muslims write against Christians are pretty stupid as well. There are some good one, but most of them are stupid. You people mean well, but your ignorance shows. Look at this contradiction, and look at that contradiction.
I’ll give you an example, Christians love the devil, and the proof of this is that Jesus told his followers to love their enemies. And the devil is an enemy to all. So in essence, Jesus taught his followers to love the devil, **thus Christians are devil lovers. ** So if if you like I can bring up stupid arguments, all day long.
The truth of the matter is this, no true believer of any religion will convert to any other religion based on an argument. People only convert when they are dissatisfied with their religion and were looking for something else to began with.
But God didn’t tell the story the first time. It was told by Christians trying to fill in the blanks of Jesus’s early life and was never accepted as a true story but rather two extremely late stories.
It is just a stupid argument. We consider, the prophet’s of old to be our prophets, so God tell us these stories to teach Muslims of the past prophets so we can learn the important lessons from those stories, without Muslims having the need to read a book that has been tampered with.We have evidence that these stories were written well after Jesus’s death and yet Muslims only accept them because they appear in the Qur’an. This was a blatant error by Muhammad. He didn’t know any better and now the stories appear in the Qur’an you read today.