I am a cradle Catholic and have only seen pieces of an AU Mass, but I feel the same way you do. Also, of course, I would love to see the TM allowed. I don’t hate the NO, either in Latin or in English, and, to tell the truth, I admire its straightforwardness. Still, I miss the TM (our bishop will not allow it, and says he never will) so I am sure he won’t allow the AU either.
If the Holy Father allows The TLM to be “freed” as the rumors say, perhaps your bishop will have no choice. One can only pray. I wonder if the individual bishop has the power to refuse the AU, if an Episcopal priest/parish is ready to convert…
I truly don’t understand that. In our diocese there are Vietnamese Masses that are unique and Hispanic Masses that are mariachi all the way. Why we Anglo Roman Catholics can’t have anything ANGLO or ROMAN is beyond me. (sigh) There is, however, an Anglican parish not far from here that is so high church it calls itself “Anglo Catholic”. They cannot possibly be liking what’s going on in the Episcopal Church right now. So maybe one of these times??? Also, unfortunately, there is an SSPX parish that probably would not have had the number of adherants it has, but for the prohibition of the TLM.
I don’t know where you are geographically, but I pray the parish in question converts and you all get an Anglican Use Mass!
My theory about all this is that since our chancery (like many others) is chock full of '60s and '70s “liberation theology” types; way left on the political scale, who just plain don’t care for western European tradition of any kind, (“Imperialist, capitalist oppressors”, you know.) they love everything “Third World” and hate everything they perceive as “First world”. And, they associate the TLM with the West, which they associate with “First world”.
Excellent point. Never thought of it.
I also think that’s why lots of American Catholic parishes are uniquely the Preservation Halls of 1960s/70s folk music and primitive art. The folks in some chanceries are in a baby boomer time warp, like the guys with gray pony tails and Trotsky glasses one still sees in coffeehouses here and there, and which one suspects of owning bongo drums and the complete works of Karl Marx.
Yep. You’re right. Our church doesn’t even have a Mary and Joseph altar. We have a “Holy Family” group on one side of the altar. I think the idea is that the tabranacle is to be on the other side!

Thankfully, it is in the middle.
The good thing, if I live to see it, is that they’re all getting pretty old, and most younger people, including most young priests and most of what few new nuns there are, are NOT into all that. Ten more years and it’s goodbye forever to the St. Louis Jesuit songs, burlap banners and the whole shebang. (Well, there will be the old photo albums, like those of the 1890s you sometimes see in parish halls, so people can marvel. (“Look at that”, children will say “Is that the PRIEST dressed like a clown? Why did he do that?” Their grandparents will shrug, not wanting to give the embarrassing explanation. ) Our bishop is 76, and I pray Abp Finn of Kansas City has a younger brother, and that he’s next on Abp Burke’s list!
I pray I live to see it as well!