Animal Biotechnology and Guided Evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Camron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This is not compelling evidence of an ancestor.
It is compelling evidence in the case of a paternity test.
In the genetic blueprint, the leg of a mouse and the leg of a human would have similar, and in some cases, the same coding.
Yes, and the question is, “Why do the leg of a mouse and the leg of a human have similar, and in some cases, the same coding?”

Why is that?
There is a pelvis, a thigh and a leg in both. Similarities in the blueprint only show that the instructions to construct these similar shapes will be similar.
Is that what we use paternity tests for, to only show that the instructions to construct these similar shapes will be similar?
When scientists declared something called “junk DNA,” they thought it would reveal the supposed ‘evolutionary’ twists and turns of human evolution. This turned out to not be the case.
Already provided a link for that in the post that you, once again, failed to use the http://forums.catholic-questions.org/images/buttons_cad/quote.gif button for, that button that you consistently fail to use over and over again for some reason …
Junk, Shattered Genes, and a Twist
Two intriguing elements of the human genome came to light as a direct result of this comparative genomics: the different sizes of some related human and mouse regions and the composition of “junk” between the genes. Two pieces of related DNA for mouse and human show more or less the same genes in more or less the same order. But when Stubbs and her team spread out the two sequences and laid them side by side—the first time this has been done on a chromosome-wide scale—they discovered that many human regions are significantly larger and less compact than the mouse regions. So what’s the filler in the human sequence? Scientists refer to it as junk, but not just any junk.
“For instance,” Stubbs says, “there is a particular kind of junk sequence called the Alu sequence. It’s a repetitive DNA sequence that, in the human, has made lots and lots of copies of itself and has infected our DNA to a much greater extent than anything we see in mouse. It’s just one of many DNA junk elements that make copies of themselves and litter the human genome in the millions.”
Repetitive sequences like Alus are essentially DNA parasites. Their duplication generally does not appear to have serious functional consequences, although Alu copies that get inserted into genes have been shown to cause human disease. Stubbs notes that this sort of litter is also seen in mouse DNA. However, the Alu sequence invasion shows up more recently in the evolution of DNA and appears to have occurred more dramatically in the primate than the rodent lineages. Because mouse and human evolution haven’t been separated all that many years, the difference in overall size and amount of junk is remarkable. “This is something we wouldn’t have seen if we hadn’t been able to lay out the pieces of sequence and compare them,” she said. Why junk sequences happen and what they mean remain to be seen.
 
The last sentence is an example of not proving a conjecture. What they insist on calling junk is being sold by an Australian company, so it’s not junk at all. In fact, the last sentence reveals only wishful thinking.

If I want to build an organism, I will reuse certain coded regions for certain similar parts. Or I can use the same coded regions along with certain inhibiting and limiting factors to build a modified version of a different but similar organism.

Paternity test? I take a sample from the mother or father and find a match in the baby’s DNA? What does that have to do with anything? All participants are human. The baby’s DNA came partly from the mother and partly from the father. If I found Baboon DNA in the baby’s DNA, then I’d be worried 🙂

Peace,
Ed
 
Well…apparently you’re either incapable of using (or else simply refuse to use) the quote button to make it clear who you’re addressing when you’re speaking.

Assuming you’re responding to me, here goes…
The last sentence is an example of not proving a conjecture. What they insist on calling junk is being sold by an Australian company, so it’s not junk at all.
What is it being sold for Ed?
In fact, the last sentence reveals only wishful thinking.
Like saying there is no similarity between the DNA of a human and various other animals, and that this similarity doesn’t in the least provide compelling evidence that humans might indeed share a common ancestor with other animals?
If I want to build an organism, I will reuse certain coded regions for certain similar parts.
Yes, and that’s what happens when creatures evolve.

Are you saying that God literally built each animal step by step, borrowing other genes for transgenic transfers like in original example I gave?

Again, the question is, “Why do the leg of a mouse and the leg of a human have similar, and in some cases, the same coding?”

Why is that?
Or I can use the same coded regions along with certain inhibiting and limiting factors to build a modified version of a different but similar organism.
Yes, and that’s what happens when creatures evolve too.

So what exactly is your objection to the theory of evolution?

I really don’t understand what you’re objecting to.
Paternity test? I take a sample from the mother or father and find a match in the baby’s DNA? What does that have to do with anything? All participants are human. The baby’s DNA came partly from the mother and partly from the father. If I found Baboon DNA in the baby’s DNA, then I’d be worried 🙂
You realize that chimps and humans share somewhere around 96% of the same DNA, correct?

You don’t see any analogy between the tests done in a paternity test on a genetic level to determine the likelihood of fatherhood and the tests done on a genetic level between mice and men to determine the likelihood of common ancestry?

Again, is that what we use paternity tests for?

Are paternity tests only for showing that the instructions to construct these similar shapes will be similar?

No. A paternity test is done because it provides compelling evidence of common ancestry (fatherhood).

And if this is so, why is gene comparison not considered compelling evidence of common ancestry (modification with descent) in the case of a genetic testing between mice and men?

Ed, if you reject the theory of evolution on religious grounds I can respect that. I’m not interested in forcing people to believe this.

But please don’t claim that science doesn’t indicate that we share common ancestry with other animals. Science does indeed appear to indicate that we share common ancestry with other animals.
Peace,
Ed
And may the Lord’s peace rest on you as well Ed.
The LORD bless you, and keep you;
The LORD make His face shine on you,
And be gracious to you;
The LORD lift up His countenance on you,
And give you peace.
 
In the end, in my opinion, you were actually starting to deconstruct many of your own beliefs simply because I used the word 'evolution" in my text. This is the danger behind the ID movement in its most succinct form as I see it.
It’s a deceptive practice to use the word “evolution” and actually mean something entirely different by it than how the term is commonly used by mainstream science.

I deconstructed the faith to show how “evolutionism” is not compatible with Catholicism.

You have redefined the term “evolution” to match your personal view on it. As I said, in the end, you’re not talking about “evolution” but rather a form of creationism.

Additionally, to claim that all of nature is actually supernature is to destroy the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology. Of course, you’re “correct” to point out that everything originates in the supernatural power of God, but we use the category of “nature” as a philosophical starting point in order to do “ordinary science” itself.

I’m more than willing to accept that everything in nature is created by God and influenced by God. This refutes “mainstream evolutionary thought” of course (you’ve asserted that). To call whatever idea comes out of that, “evolution”, is to use a misnomer.

I believe the claim of theistic evolution is that God creates, guides, sustains and designs all things in nature (and non-nature), but there is zero evidence that He actually does that.

Again, it’s the refutation of St. Paul’s teaching that I’ve quoted many times.
 
Like saying there is no similarity between the DNA of a human and various other animals, and that this similarity doesn’t in the least provide compelling evidence that humans might indeed share a common ancestor with other animals?
They share a common creator.
Again, the question is, “Why do the leg of a mouse and the leg of a human have similar, and in some cases, the same coding?”
They were created by the same divine being who created all prime matter and all forms and substances ex nihilio.
So what exactly is your objection to the theory of evolution?
Given that you’ve refuted it already and have posited “Theistic Evolution” in its place, that should be easy for you to see.
You realize that chimps and humans share somewhere around 96% of the same DNA, correct?
Do you think that humans are 4% different than chimps?

This is the “ontological leap” that evolutionists do not factor into their calculations.

Mathematically, what is the probability that a chimp will turn into a human being? If “evolution” (which apparently you’ve decided to argue in favor of here again) is scientifically correct and accurate – it should be able to give us some hard numbers by which we can make predictions. Additionally, evolutionists claim that the theory is “not random” – therefore, predictions should be easier.
Ed, if you reject the theory of evolution on religious grounds I can respect that. I’m not interested in forcing people to believe this.
Again, you have rejected the theory of evolution as it is taught in mainstream science (e.g. as taught in every public school in America).
But please don’t claim that science doesn’t indicate that we share common ancestry with other animals. Science does indeed appear to indicate that we share common ancestry with other animals.
Atheistic science indicates many things.
 
It’s a deceptive practice to use the word “evolution”…
No, it’s not a deceptive practice to use the word “evolution” when I actually really mean “descent with modification”. That’s evolution.

The only difference is that I’m saying that this descent with modification is ultimately guided by God for a purpose whereas many atheists will say that this descent with modification is ultimately purposeless in origin, function, and destiny.
…and actually mean something entirely different by it than how the term is commonly used by mainstream science.
When I say evolution I mean evolution. The only difference is I’m talking about guided evolution whereas others are talking about unguided evolution.
I deconstructed the faith to show how “evolutionism” is not compatible with Catholicism.
Yes, and it appears, based on your own observations and criticisms, that there really is no incompatibility issues between evolution and Catholicism.

As Kenneth Miller points out, quoting the 2004 International Theological Commission document …
40.png
Darwin:
"But it is important to note that, according to the Catholic understanding of divine causality, true contingency in the created order is not incompatible with a purposeful divine providence.’
Right there, in plain view, is the essence of compatibility between evolution and Catholic theology. “Contingency in the created order,” the very essence of evolution, is not at all incompatible with the will of God. The official Church document reemphasizes this point by stating that “even the outcome of a truly contingent natural process can nonetheless fall within God’s providential plan for creation.” And evolution, as Stephen Jay Gould emphasized brilliantly in his writings, is truly a contingent natural process.

The concerns of Pope Benedict, as expressed in his earlier writings and in his coronation homily, are not with evolution per se, but with how evolution is to be understood in our modern world. Biological evolution fits neatly into a traditional Catholic understanding of how contingent natural processes can be seen as part of God’s plan, while “evolutionist” philosophies that deny the Divine do not. Three Popes, beginning with Pius XII, have made this abundantly clear.
As Cardinal Schönborn quite properly points out, the Catholic Church is staunchly opposed to any view of life that would exclude the notion of Divine purpose and meaning. In the new century, as he puts it, the Church will “defend human reason by proclaiming that the immanent design evident in nature is real.” In response I would echo the words of the Catechism that scientific studies of “the age and development of the cosmos, the development of life-forms and the appearance of man . . . invite us to even greater admiration for the greatness of the Creator.”

Indeed they do.
 
You have redefined the term “evolution” to match your personal view on it.
I have not redefined the term “evolution” to match my personal view on it. I’m using it the way the last two Popes have used it.
As I said, in the end, you’re not talking about “evolution” but rather a form of creationism.
Yes, I’m talking about Theistic Evolution.
Additionally, to claim that all of nature is actually supernature is to destroy the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology. Of course, you’re “correct” to point out that everything originates in the supernatural power of God, but we use the category of “nature” as a philosophical starting point in order to do “ordinary science” itself.
Which is it?

Am I correct to point out that everything originates in the supernatural power of God or am I not correct to point out that everything originates in the supernatural power of God?

As I said before, the operation of the natural laws alone would not be as miraculous as any other miracle. I’ve already stressed that God builds upon miraculous events overlapping each other. I’ve also noted that He sustains His creation too, sustaining all thing by His powerful word. I’ve been very clear that if God were to withdraw His presence the universe most likely cease to exist too.

In other words, I’m saying that yes we can expect greater miracles that work over and above the previous miracles. This in no way diminishes the original miraculous events, especially since God’s presence is ever present throughout the entire process, sustaining the process on a spiritual level as His Intelligence guides the causality of these miraculous changes over time.

If what you are saying is true, this would mean the original creation event, where God created the Heavens and the Earth, would have been of no greater significance than when God eventually creates the New Heavens and New Earth along with the Second Coming of Christ.

No. This in no way destroys the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology. It greatly enhances the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology by properly reflecting on how our continued existence is actually prolonged within the extension of a grand miracle, the creation of the entire universe from nothing.

Again, we can no longer discern the “miraculous” from the “natural” even though the origin of the universe (and it’s sustained existence) is indeed held together on a **spiritual level ** that we can no longer distinguish from the physical medium that the spiritual level holds together.

The same too applies to all other events too. What we perceive as a miracle now is actually an augmented “specific intervention” by God building upon previous miracles. The problem is that we can no longer, in many cases, actually distinguish the “natural” from the formerly “miraculous”. To us it just appears “natural”

And yes, we can still recognize the miraculous from the natural now, so long as God actually does something that supersedes the former “specific intervention”, such as transforming a staff into a serpent for example.
 
I’m more than willing to accept that everything in nature is created by God and influenced by God. This refutes “mainstream evolutionary thought” of course (you’ve asserted that). To call whatever idea comes out of that, “evolution”, is to use a misnomer.
Then you’d better write a letter to the Pope, because he’s apparently making this same error too. I’m not trying to be facetious Reggie. But you really need to read what they’ve been writing. You’re talking their words out of context.
I believe the claim of theistic evolution is that God creates, guides, sustains and designs all things in nature (and non-nature), but there is zero evidence that He actually does that.
Some adherents to aberrant forms of theistic evolution (part of the condemned list I gave earlier) actually do this.

Condemned List said:
**1) atheistic forms of evolution which either…
a) claim that evolution proves that God didn’t create us or else…

b) claim that there is no God therefore evolution was not the result of God’s will…2) and other incompatible forms of evolution such as…
a) certain process theologies which ridiculously deny that God actually knew what would happen in the future or else…

b) certain evolutionary theories which claim the soul is actually the result of an epiphenomenalism and not directly breathed by God…**

I suppose you can add to this list any claim that nature provides no evidence that God created it.

Again, I can’t make this any clearer.

I’m perfectly happy to believe that theistic evolution allows the framework for God creating, guiding, sustaining and designing all things in nature (and non-nature), and that there is an superabundant amount of evidence that He actually does that too.

It’s doesn’t have to be an either/or proposition. Pope Benedict XVI certainly doesn’t have a problem discussing this concept on both levels at the same time either.
Again, it’s the refutation of St. Paul’s teaching that I’ve quoted many times.
It is not a refutation of St. Paul’s teaching once you’ve properly understood what’s actually being claimed.
 
Hello Camron,

Thank you for your reply. Consider this scenario.

I am head designer for Global Robotics. It is a fact that today, scientists are developing artificial muscles or muscle analogs made of inorganic materials.

Our first successful project was built entirely on computers. It was a robot horse using the biological horse as a building template. Through computer aided design and computer aided manufacturing, we have millions of lines of code telling automated construction systems the exact specifications for artificial bone and muscle. The horse was built and can walk and perform horse-like movements.

Our next project was a robot dog. I brought up the biological dog skeleton and horse skeleton on my computer. I did a bone count. Now, when I modify the code, there will be areas that will remain. The body plan is similar. The scale is different. I will have to replace hooves with feet.

This was followed by a robot cat.

So, I offer this as compelling evidence that coding for similar body plans will be the same or very similar in similar living creatures. You only need to look at the wide variety of dogs, from the Chihuahua to the Great Dane to see widely varying skull construction, but the body plans are very similar.

Peace,
Ed
 
As I said before, the operation of the natural laws alone would not be as miraculous as any other miracle.
I’m sorry, I don’t understand that statement. “The operation of natural laws” – ok, that I understand. “alone” – that I don’t understand. What do you mean “alone”? “would not be as miraculous as any other miracle” – so the natural laws “alone” are “not as” miraculous. They’re “almost” as miraculous? How did you determine how miraculous they are versus “any other miracle”?
I’ve already stressed that God builds upon miraculous events overlapping each other.
Yes, you have. I actually like your theory – I think it’s quite original (at least I haven’t seen it before). But I would be willing to live with the implications of your views whereas I don’t think you are yet. One implication is that the subject of science is “the miraculous”. So, science is studying supernatural activity. I could live with that, but I don’t think there’s any scientific culture anywhere (except perhaps in Islam or Orthdox Judiasm) that has developed that kind of thought.

At that point, to call this “evolutionary theory” seems far fetched to me. But I think you’re free to call your ideas “evolution” since there’s little agreement on what that term means. I don’t see it defined in Catholic teaching, for example.
I’ve been very clear that if God were to withdraw His presence the universe most likely cease to exist too.
Yes, you have been clear about that. What you haven’t been clear enough about is what you mean (and you mentioned this term a few times) by “nature alone”. As I see your view, natural laws never act “alone” – they are always guided.
But as I proposed before, when tests are done in a laboratory, this would be no different than observing “random” effects of things since both are “guided”.
I affirm that God created Hydrogen and Oxygen. They are not products of evolution.
I affirm that God created the combination of those elements - as Water. God created Water, ex nihilo. It is not a product of evolution. It was created.
Water is an amazing substance. It freezes hard, it boils, it evaporates into the clouds and rains down, it fills oceans, rivers and lakes, it sustains life, it floats things and sinks other things, it creates power from waterfalls - and Jesus used it several times, in Baptism, turning water to wine, and showing water flowing from His side.
Water is something amazing, that is not a product of evolution.

But when a man puts a pot of water on a stove and it boils, in philosophical terms, we don’t say that God is directly creating steam in that case. Steam is the natural output of that process. God created water and the laws that govern water and God created the concept of steam. But human beings can “create” steam by boiling water.

The term “create” in strict definition means to make out of nothing. In that case, nature cannot create anything. Certainly, evolution cannot create anything – it cannot generate new genetic material from nothing. It has to build on something else.
In other words, I’m saying that yes we can expect greater miracles that work over and above the previous miracles. This in no way diminishes the original miraculous events, especially since God’s presence is ever present throughout the entire process, sustaining the process on a spiritual level as His Intelligence guides the causality of these miraculous changes over time.
Again, I find this fascinating and attractive. I can’t argue against it because I think you’re offering a very novel and original idea here, and I also wouldn’t expect you to have all the details worked out. But I would offer one question regarding your sources for belief that new miracles are greater than the old ones.
If what you are saying is true, this would mean the original creation event, where God created the Heavens and the Earth, would have been of no greater significance than when God eventually creates the New Heavens and New Earth along with the Second Coming of Christ.
I honestly don’t know how I could judge the greatness of one or the other. Without the original creation event, we wouldn’t have the Second Coming, but the Second Coming is a fulfillment of Christ’s promise, so therefore a greater event. The miracle of the Eucharist is greater than other miracles, but I don’t know how to fully rank them. There might be somewhere in Catholic theology that ranks the greatness of miracles – if so, I give you a lot of credit for developing those ideas in line with Catholic tradition. If not, even still - it’s a fascinating concept. We would have layers of miracles and we only notice the newer ones because either they’re of greater impact or because we’re accustomed to the old miracles.
This in no way destroys the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology. It greatly enhances the ordinary philosophical categories that inform Catholic theology by properly reflecting on how our continued existence is actually prolonged within the extension of a grand miracle, the creation of the entire universe from nothing.
I have to research traditional Catholic theology on this point. For example, St. Thomas Aquinas’ teaching on the theology of Nature explains how “matter” is in a state of “potency”. It is capable of being brought into existence. The direct creation of God through the creation of “form” is what brings matter into existence.
I’m fairly sure that Catholic theology makes a sharp distinction between nature and the supernatural, but I’m not sure where to find that at the moment.
 
I suppose you can add to this list any claim that nature provides no evidence that God created it.

Again, I can’t make this any clearer.
That is very clear. I view the statement “nature provides evidence that God created it” differently than you do, but I don’t want to argue about that. You affirm that nature does provide evidence of God’s creative power, so that is consistent with St. Paul’s teaching as well as the dogmatic statement of Vatican I. Precisely what evidence and how we recognize it are different matters that are not essential to define with precision (at least to stay within the teaching of the Church).
It’s doesn’t have to be an either/or proposition. Pope Benedict XVI certainly doesn’t have a problem discussing this concept on both levels at the same time either.
I could accept that, about Pope Benedict. But I don’t think it’s irreverent or wrong to suggest that the Holy Father may well have some problems trying to reconcile both views.
It is not a refutation of St. Paul’s teaching once you’ve properly understood what’s actually being claimed.
When added to your strong affirmation that nature does reveal the intelligence of God at work, then you’re right that it’s not a refutation of St. Paul’s teaching.
 
Yes, and it appears, based on your own observations and criticisms, that there really is no incompatibility issues between evolution and Catholicism.
You’ve bitterly complained when I did such things (restating my position to get clarification) but I really don’t mind it.

I see you’re saying that “it appears” …

I’m sorry that I gave that impression because I find many imcomppatibility issues between evolution and Catholicism, and I posted several posts from authentic teachers of the Church which proved the same.

In fact, there are so many problems with evolution and Catholicism that you even had to append another condemned idea about evolution to your already-long list.

Your view on evolution simply doesn’t exist anywhere in scientific literature. Certainly, there’s nothing to be found in evolutionists’ textbooks.

You’ve cited Kenneth Miller with approval, but his views do not align with yours.
“Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.” (Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (1st edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1992), pg. 152; emphasis in original)
 
Let’s get back to the beginning and take a stroll through Genesis for a bit…
In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth.
Is there any scientific value behind it?
Yes. It’s actually the basis and origin of science.
Are there any metaphors conveyed here?
Yes, certainly.
Is this considered literal truth?
Indeed it is.
What exactly is God telling us here?
God is telling us much about Himself and what He did.

The Fathers and Doctors of the Church have given us guidance with their commentaries on this passage also.
 
They share a common creator.
Why can’t it mean that they share a common creator and a common ancestor?
They were created by the same divine being who created all prime matter and all forms and substances ex nihilio.
Yes, we both agree that God created everything from nothing. There’s no argument here. And this is indeed the first miracle. It’s what happened from there that gets more difficult to explain.

Do you agree that, if indeed our very universe started from a miracle by being created from nothing, then its origins are most likely inexplicable to science?

If not, why?

If so, then do you agree that, although we perceive the universe around us as being “natural”, our very existence is still indeed constrained and sustained within the continuum of a miracle that is indeed inexplicable to science?

If not, why?
Given that you’ve refuted it already and have posited “Theistic Evolution” in its place, that should be easy for you to see.
You apparently don’t believe that it can happen all by itself, correct?

Fine. But the question is now, “Can evolution happen if God is the One who is guiding it?
Do you think that humans are 4% different than chimps?
Genetically yes. Spiritually no.
This is the “ontological leap” that evolutionists do not factor into their calculations.
Already covered. forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=226260
Mathematically, what is the probability that a chimp will turn into a human being? If “evolution” (which apparently you’ve decided to argue in favor of here again) is scientifically correct and accurate – it should be able to give us some hard numbers by which we can make predictions. Additionally, evolutionists claim that the theory is “not random” – therefore, predictions should be easier.
It’s precisely because we don’t know all the factors involved that I’m reluctant to provide any mathematical numbers. That’s not my field. And I think people on all sides of the argument are wasting their time by attempting to calculate these percentages too. There’s too much bias on all sides to get anything accurate regarding the probability of evolution happening. And, as I said already, we simply don’t know all the factors involved.
Again, you have rejected the theory of evolution as it is taught in mainstream science (e.g. as taught in every public school in America).
But I have not rejected the fact that God can work through contingent processes to accomplish His will, whether angels, saints, or nature, all of which praise God in various way, even if in non-sentient ways.
Atheistic science indicates many things.
I know. I already covered that.
 
Hello Camron,

Thank you for your reply. Consider this scenario.

I am head designer for Global Robotics. It is a fact that today, scientists are developing artificial muscles or muscle analogs made of inorganic materials.

Our first successful project was built entirely on computers. It was a robot horse using the biological horse as a building template. Through computer aided design and computer aided manufacturing, we have millions of lines of code telling automated construction systems the exact specifications for artificial bone and muscle. The horse was built and can walk and perform horse-like movements.

Our next project was a robot dog. I brought up the biological dog skeleton and horse skeleton on my computer. I did a bone count. Now, when I modify the code, there will be areas that will remain. The body plan is similar. The scale is different. I will have to replace hooves with feet.

This was followed by a robot cat.

So, I offer this as compelling evidence that coding for similar body plans will be the same or very similar in similar living creatures. You only need to look at the wide variety of dogs, from the Chihuahua to the Great Dane to see widely varying skull construction, but the body plans are very similar.

Peace,
Ed
I agree with most of what you are saying. But the dog example gets lost at the end.

We know that all dogs are related. Even you agree with this. And, in fact, for domestic dogs anyway, most of the breeds (not all) have been bred within the last 400 years or so, well within recorded history.

So if we know that all these dogs are related, why would we need to bring in a computer model to document all data regarding their form and structure and replicate these dogs when we can naturally breed them (via intelligent selection) without duplicating them via a computer?

In other words, the example you gave, unless I’m misunderstanding you, seems to be saying that, on a genetic level, all animals could be related to each other, albeit modified with descent from the original plans.

That’s almost exactly what evolution says happened.
 
You’ve bitterly complained when I did such things (restating my position to get clarification) but I really don’t mind it.
I did say “appears” because that’s how it “appears” to me, but I could be wrong.

See?
I see you’re saying that “it appears” …
I’m sorry that I gave that impression because I find many imcomppatibility issues between evolution and Catholicism, and I posted several posts from authentic teachers of the Church which proved the same.
Well, unless there are some other problems with evolution that you object to, perhaps we could just finally ask the simple question, “Can evolution happen if God is the One who is guiding it?’
In fact, there are so many problems with evolution and Catholicism that you even had to append another condemned idea about evolution to your already-long list.
Actually, I’ve been saying this from the beginning of the thread.

It started here…
40.png
Camron:
I personally find the atheistic evolutionary arguments against God “designing” the universe to be about as effective as asking why would an all-good God allow the existence of evil. In other words, they don’t work in my opinion.
It continues here…
40.png
Camron:
Therefore, if indeed God’s creation has been designed by God to praise to Him and give Him glory then I see no reason to believe that God could not use contingent processes to bring about all the species on this world that we see today either, all according to His will.
It continues here…
40.png
Camron:
Evolution didn’t happen, in my opinion, because nature is random. Evolution happened, in my opinion, because nature is ordered, just as God intended it to be (and continues to sustain, and sometimes even steps in and directly interacts with on spiritual/physical interactional level).
And it gets more detailed the further we go through the thread.

No, this is not a new addition. I only added it to the list because you keep missing this point and you keep bringing it up as an objection to evolution and I wanted to make this clear that this really is not an issue.

Do you have any other objections?
Your view on evolution simply doesn’t exist anywhere in scientific literature. Certainly, there’s nothing to be found in evolutionists’ textbooks.
Yes, but the Pope shares my view. Actually, the last two Popes share my view. I know that doesn’t automatically make it right concerning scientific questions. But really, why should I take the words of the atheistic scientists over the words of the Popes concerning our human origins? Is this not a matter of both faith and science at the same time?
You’ve cited Kenneth Miller with approval, but his views do not align with yours.
Here’s the quote again…
“Darwin knew that accepting his theory required believing in philosophical materialism, the conviction that matter is the stuff of all existence and that all mental and spiritual phenomena are its by-products. Darwinian evolution was not only purposeless but also heartless–a process in which the rigors of nature ruthlessly eliminate the unfit. Suddenly, humanity was reduced to just one more species in a world that cared nothing for us. The great human mind was no more than a mass of evolving neurons. Worst of all, there was no divine plan to guide us.” (Biology: Discovering Life, by Joseph S. Levine & Kenneth R. Miller (1st edition, D.C. Heath and Co., 1992), pg. 152; emphasis in original)
First of all, that is not Miller’s view. That’s the view that he thinks Darwin was worried would happen once the theory of evolution came out.

This is Miller’s view…
Kenneth Miller:
As Cardinal Schönborn quite properly points out, the Catholic Church is staunchly opposed to any view of life that would exclude the notion of Divine purpose and meaning. In the new century, as he puts it, the Church will “defend human reason by proclaiming that the immanent design evident in nature is real.” In response I would echo the words of the Catechism that scientific studies of “the age and development of the cosmos, the development of life-forms and the appearance of man . . . invite us to even greater admiration for the greatness of the Creator.”
Have you actually read Miller’s book?

I ask because you are seriously misquoting him so totally out of context if you indeed think that he believes in what Darwin feared would happen.

For the record, I do think Kenneth Miller makes some minor errors in my opinion, and a large error by stressing some things more than others. I might talk about this later. But what I quoted from him here I agree with fully. And I think he does an excellent defense of Theistic Evolution for the most part.
 
That is very clear. I view the statement “nature provides evidence that God created it” differently than you do, but I don’t want to argue about that.
It is perhaps important to weigh in on Christoph Cardinal Schönborn’s thoughts regarding Suffering in a World Guided by God…

Note: The download time is slow but it is very much worth reading.
Christoph Cardinal Schönborn:
The reason why the endless debate about “intelligent design” seems to be going in a circle, is that whenever “design” or a “designer” is mentioned nowadays, people spontaneously think of the “divine engineer,” a kind of omnipotent technician who, being necessarily perfect, should produce only absolutely perfect machines. Here is the deepest source of so many misunderstandings, even from the side of the “intelligent design” movement in the U.S.A. God is not a watchmaker, not a builder of machines; He is the creator of natures. The world is not clockwork, not a giant machine, not even a mega-computer; it is, as Jacques Maritain put it, “a republic of natures” (Raison et raisons, Paris, 1947, 62).
I could accept that, about Pope Benedict. But I don’t think it’s irreverent or wrong to suggest that the Holy Father may well have some problems trying to reconcile both views.
I don’t think it’s irreverent or wrong to suggest that all people, including the Pope himself, may well have some problems trying to reconcile the existence of evil with an all good God either. But we don’t simply refuse to acknowledge that God exists in the face of evil. The same is true regarding God as a “designer” too, since God is indeed guiding all things even though there appears to be much waste and destruction and pain involved in the process.

In other words, just as the existence of evil does not prove that God doesn’t exist, the existence of waste does not prove that God is not the designer either. Certainly just as God is good even in the face of evil, God’s intentions for us to fulfill His purpose still stands through as an intelligent project that all can clearly see

I think that many who reject evolution because of these reasons have not properly reflected on the nature of suffering and how God can use even these harsh events to contingently accomplish His will.

I also think that those who reject evolution because of these reasons are also providing fuel for the fire of the atheistic philosophies-- atheistic philosophies which spark up, rekindle and burn most brightly during this kind of denial of God’s influence when faced with these painful events.
When added to your strong affirmation that nature does reveal the intelligence of God at work, then you’re right that it’s not a refutation of St. Paul’s teaching.
I’ll come back to this later.🙂
 
I agree with most of what you are saying. But the dog example gets lost at the end.

We know that all dogs are related. Even you agree with this. And, in fact, for domestic dogs anyway, most of the breeds (not all) have been bred within the last 400 years or so, well within recorded history.

So if we know that all these dogs are related, why would we need to bring in a computer model to document all data regarding their form and structure and replicate these dogs when we can naturally breed them (via intelligent selection) without duplicating them via a computer?

In other words, the example you gave, unless I’m misunderstanding you, seems to be saying that, on a genetic level, all animals could be related to each other, albeit modified with descent from the original plans.

That’s almost exactly what evolution says happened.
All animals were designed by an intelligent agent. They are related in that they live under the same gravity, breathe the same atmosphere and need to be able to eat the food sources available, including plants. Their requirement to drink water is not an accident. The availability of water is not an accident. The availability of edible plants is not an accident. The ability to find food and water without wasting too much energy must exist immediately.

The instructions to build animals with similar body plans will be similar. The body plans need to take into account environmental factors like the composition of the air, the strength of gravity and even the amount of sunlight and UV rays that reach the surface. It is one thing to say longer or thicker fur evolved or arose as an adaptation, but it must be realized that the moment an organism is born, it needs to eat and understand how to interact with its environment, which it is seeing for the first time, immediately.

Peace,
Ed
 
To Alec -
I am tired of the Stealth Atheism.
I’m sorry you’re tired. My atheism isn’t stealthy and I’m afraid you’re just going to have to put up with it.
Magical thinking, anecdotes, old books, old myths, etc., have no value.
Correct. They have no value in determining the truth about the natural world.
Science is only a tool.
Wrong. Science is not only a tool, but the the most efficacious method that mankind has devised to reveal how the natural world works.
Today, it is primarily used to create product and make money.
That’s just silly - you really have no clue about what you are talking about, do you Ed? I don’t think you have ever been anywhere near a science laboratory or ever opened a science journal. Perhaps you could tell us about the products based on and the money made from the following major scientific endeavours:
COBE
WMAP
Boomerang
SDSS
2dFGRS
All the telescopes on this site: astro.nineplanets.org/bigeyes.html
SOFIA
Gravity Probe B
LISA
VIRGO
LHC
Almost everything published on ArXiv
tolweb
Entrez
HPRD
BLAST
It is also being used to promote ideas - Scientific Atheism being the primary one. Ask PZ Myers or Richard Dawkins or Sam Harris.
Well, it is true that an understanding of science and its methods does, statistically, seem to undermine faith-based ideas. So scientists are probably more atheistic than any group, although a significant number of scientists are religious believers.
Your skepticism about what you call magical thinking ignores the work of centuries by committed religious and scientists who were Christian.
The fact that many people have been Christian is not in itself evidence of the truth of Christianity. Replace the word “Christian” in your sentence with “Protestant”, “Muslim”, “Mormon”, “Spiritualist”, “Hindu”, Shintoist", “Buddhist” etc etc and you’ll see what I mean. The faith of many in the past is not a warrant to continue that faith in the future.
…science, as factual information, cuts across all belief systems and ideologies
Indeed it does. Well done Ed, you’re beginning to understand…
As one atheist put it, “facts are not democratic.”
In other words , we cannot change facts by voting on them. Nature’s facts stand on their own, whatever we think.
I wonder if you would want or prefer to live in the Technocracy controlled by men who would not mind bending the data a bit, or just plain lying, in order to gain some temporal advantage for themselves and those they deem worthy.
This is the fallacy called poisoning the well - you suggest that scientists are dishonest. I suggest that scientists, on average, are immensely more honest than creationists, on average.
Especially since World War II, science is a profit making enterprise
Shows how little you know about science. See above.
Ethics are needed.
Indeed they are.
In the Technocracy, the latest expert and his theories will simply be deposed by the next expert and his theories and so on. Or additional data will be falsified to advance a “worthy” agenda. You ignore human nature at your peril.
So your hypothesis is that humans need to believe in a Big Brotherly god, any god, in order to develop reliable ethics? Or do you think that it has to be a particular God - perhaps you think that only Catholic societies are ethical - well there are very few of those today and I don’t regard any of them as beacons of shining morality.
But back to your point about “magical thinking.” What would you do if you encountered God? Convince yourself it was all a hallucination? If you saw an obvious, impossible healing occur?
Such as? Someone regrowing a amputated limb? If I encountered God, I would accept His existence as I accept the existence of everything and everyone else that I encounter. I hold the existence of god to the same standard of proof as I hold the existence of my barber and so far, it’s the barber whose existence I am sure about.
Faith is evidence…
No it’s not. That is obfuscation. Faith is faith - a belief in something in the absence of evidence or in the face of contrary evidence. Faith is not evidence for anything except for the credulity of human beings.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top