Animal Biotechnology and Guided Evolution

  • Thread starter Thread starter Camron
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
To Alec -

The only thing I need to emphasize is that today’s current maxim is that there are no absolutes, however, those who believe this are absolutely sure about it.

If human beings start with a no foundation, foundation, perhaps in some vain hope of some novelty, they will soon find themselves in the quicksand of anarchy – each going in their own chosen direction.

In the last analysis, the pure science will be manipulated for temporal ends. Misguided men will be in charge of guided weapons. Imperfect men who will justify with what they think is lofty argument, the manipulation of other peoples. History bears this out. The veneer of civilized behavior is thin.

It would be best if people humbled themselves, realizing their innate imperfection. God is listening.

Peace,
Ed
 
The instructions to build animals with similar body plans will be similar.
Why?

Can’t God create animals with similar body plans and very different developmental genes?
The body plans need to take into account environmental factors like the composition of the air, the strength of gravity and even the amount of sunlight and UV rays that reach the surface.
Why are the body plans of animals (tetrapods) that live on land (primates - including humans, dogs, cats, cattle, rabbits, lizards, crocodiles, frogs, some birds) etc, etc; under the earth (moles, mole-rats, some lizards); in the sky (bats, birds); underwater (whales, turtles, dolphins) the same even though they live in very different environments? What sensible explanation can there be other than common ancestry. What about animals with different body plans that share the same environment, like sponges, echinoderms, cephalopods, tetrapods (turtles and cetaceans, eg), crustaceans, fish? Your hypothesis that the environment is what dictates the similarity of body plan and coding is hopelessly wrong.

And you can’t even begin to explain the existence of shared ancestral pseudogenes and retrotransposons.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
The only thing I need to emphasize is that today’s current maxim is that there are no absolutes, however, those who believe this are absolutely sure about it.
The one thing I am sure about is that those who are absolutely sure about their faith-based beliefs can’t agree amongst themselves and are willing to kill one another to prove it. However, I am no post-modernist and relativist - some things can be shown to be true and other things cannot.
If human beings start with a no foundation, foundation, perhaps in some vain hope of some novelty, they will soon find themselves in the quicksand of anarchy – each going in their own chosen direction.
So how is it that in today’s secular societies we have fewer and smaller wars, more peace, more agreement about how to organise a decent society than we have ever had. In secular Europe, war is inconceivable after millennia of fighting. In the USA, founded on the basis of freedom of thought and the separation of religion from government, war is similarly inconceivable. The rule of law is most powerful in the least “believing” societies.
The veneer of civilized behavior is thin.
True - we are one step away from falling back into superstition, dogma and authoritarianism.
It would be best if people humbled themselves, realizing their innate imperfection. God is listening.
So you say. But isn’t that begging the question?

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Yes, I would like to hear more about that. What do you mean by “inherent meaning”, where do you find it in life, and what is the meaning that you do find?

I’ll say in advance, that whatever meaning it is – this meaning is measured against the value of your life personally.

Therefore, someone who says “I find the meaning of my life in following the NY Yankees” has measured the value of his life with a team which may cease to exist one day, and even while it does exist, it produces values which are transient and possessing only a very limited meaning.
I will be delighted to do this, but not isolated from the rest of the discussion. There are several points that you appear to have abandoned. Is that because you have conceded them?

By the way, although I will expand on this as part of the broader dialogue, I will note now that you are loading the dice by defining meaning only in terms of eternal considerations. If such eternal considerations do not exist, which is the subject of our discussion, then my point is that life can still have very profound meaning - you have attempted to pre-empt what I have to say by defining meaning is such a way that it necessarily excludes temporal considerations - this is argument by definition and not at all helpful. Of course, you might think that, for you, life only has meaning in the context of eternity - however, I assure you that for me that is not the case - I find my life deeply meaningful and fulfilling without any hope of an afterlife. You cannot define the meaning in my life away. Do you, or do you not want to know about it?

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
In answer to Post # 163 -

Are people who believe the only humans willing to kill each other? In Stalin’s Russia, it was no man no problem. Killing the opposition was thought to ensure the survival of those in power. After Stalin died, more killing, or people were simply airbrushed away in photos. The ‘new man’ was simply the old man dropped into a manmade system. It collapsed. The old churches that were used for storage are being reused for their original purpose. The greatest faith, Catholic faith, is being shown by people in those parts of the world where physical persecution exists, including killing.

You write about science but are fiercely motivated by a manmade idea - God or belief in God is irrational. Pope Benedict has recognized this. The current craze is science and the worship of the mind of man. This too shall pass.

In Catholic school, or at home, I was never taught to harm anyone and my neighbors practiced that example. I learned from them how to live in a community where not everybody believed as I did or were of a certain race. Then anarchy, disguised as ‘freedom,’ appeared. The anarchists took their time and created enough confusion but the Church is in the process of correcting that as well. Make no mistake, I want to treat my neighbor as myself. And self-defense is held to a high standard and set of conditions.

Peace,
Ed
 
In reply to Post #162

I wrote that similar body plans would have similar coding. Of course, in the ocean, there are a number of body plans, however, most of the body plans that it is claimed evolved are still with us today. I think you would know better than the average peson how many species went extinct in the last 10 years, much less the last million or two.

I think it nonsensical to say the common seal is on its way to developing hands because it can walk using its fins.

I fully agree with this article. I ask that you look at the last paragraph in particular:

nytimes.com/2005/07/07/opinion/07schonborn.html

Cardinal Schoenborn is warning about the ideology infecting science. About things that science cannot demonstrate. Scientist PZ Myers is the latest cheerleader for atheism. It is clear that scientists have been recruited to use science to reject God.

Peace,
Ed
 
II find my life deeply meaningful and fulfilling without any hope of an afterlife. You cannot define the meaning in my life away.
As I said, people can find meaning in anything – sports, shopping at Walmart, collecting comic books, watching soap operas …

It’s not the meaning of these lives that is important, but the meaning of their death.
Do you, or do you not want to know about it?
I think you explained it quite well, thanks. You find meaning in transient values. That meaning dies with you – and after that, I don’t think it’s disrespectful to say that it is truly meaningless for you or anyone else forever.
 
Fine. But the question is now, “Can evolution happen if God is the One who is guiding it?
Evolution is a process which caused by random mutations and natural selection (along with random environmental effects).

A theory that proposes that God is guiding natural development is therefore not evolution.
 
I said:

“Again, you have rejected the theory of evolution as it is taught in mainstream science (e.g. as taught in every public school in America).”

You replied:
But I have not rejected the fact that God can work through contingent processes to accomplish His will, whether angels, saints, or nature, all of which praise God in various way, even if in non-sentient ways.
Cameron, you’re arguing about a concept that is not called “evolution” in our schools and universities or in our science labs anywhere.

To continue to claim that you’re defending “evolution” makes it very difficult to discuss this matter.

If God is developing nature through His Divine powers, then that process is not “evolution”. It is another process. Call it “creation” or “divine guidance” or some other term – but “evolution” has a commonly accepted meaning and what you’ve presented does not fit that meaning.
 
Are people who believe the only humans willing to kill each other?
Broadly speaking, it is those who hold an absolute belief in something, whether it is a god, or a political theory, in the absence of reason or evidence who appear to be most ready and able to kill one another for those beliefs. I am not aware of any humanist or scientist who has set about killing those who think different from him/her or who hold rival hypotheses.
In Stalin’s Russia, it was no man no problem. Killing the opposition was thought to ensure the survival of those in power. After Stalin died, more killing, or people were simply airbrushed away in photos
A perfect example of a society based on absolute beliefs unsupported by evidence. Amongst those to suffer were evolutionary biologists who were killed or sent to Siberia for opposing the official Lysenkoist ‘biology’ which rejected neo-Darwinism and which was responsible for huge famines and untold suffering. It is unshakeable belief held in the absence of or contrary to evidence that seems to be the problem.
The greatest faith, Catholic faith, is being shown by people in those parts of the world where physical persecution exists, including killing.
Like Rwanda? Like Northern Ireland? Like West Africa? Like the barrios of Latin America? Like in the Balkans? And what is your reason for calling the Catholic faith, the greatest - to an outsider, how does it differ from any other?
In Catholic school, or at home, I was never taught to harm anyone and my neighbors practiced that example. I learned from them how to live in a community where not everybody believed as I did or were of a certain race.
Neither was I, but I humbly suggest that that was nothing to do with our Catholicism, but the liberal society in which we were raised, based on the tolerance of one for another that is rooted in the Enlightenment ideals that form the basis of the political and social systems in Europe and North America.
Then anarchy, disguised as ‘freedom,’ appeared. The anarchists took their time and created enough confusion but the Church is in the process of correcting that as well.
What on earth are you talking about? Do you mean anarchism? Not a very powerful force in society, is it? Or do you mean free-thinking?
Make no mistake, I want to treat my neighbor as myself.
Good for you.
And self-defense is held to a high standard and set of conditions.
Eh?

Alec
http:/www.evolutionpages.com
 
40.png
hecd2:
II find my life deeply meaningful and fulfilling without any hope of an afterlife. You cannot define the meaning in my life away.
As I said, people can find meaning in anything – sports, shopping at Walmart, collecting comic books, watching soap operas …

It’s not the meaning of these lives that is important, but the meaning of their death.
Your determination to trivialise what I haven’t yet said is noted. Of course you find no meaning in caring for your family, loving your partner, working for a better society, in art, music, opera, theatre, literature, science (I know that one for sure) - but just in your hope of an afterlife.
Do you, or do you not want to know about it?
I think you explained it quite well, thanks. You find meaning in transient values. That meaning dies with you – and after that, I don’t think it’s disrespectful to say that it is truly meaningless for you or anyone else forever.

Well you obviously don’t want to know about it - but you also seem to have no concept of a legacy.

Be that as it may, your point was that without an afterlife then life is meaningless. Well it isn’t unless you use circular and self-referential definitions. In any case your point is moot - your desire for an afterlife, in order to give your life meaning, does not, in itself, mean that such an afterlife exists. One needs to look for evidence elsewhere.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
I have studied the history of technology. I suggest you pick up a copy of Secret Science - Federal Control of American Science and Technology, by Herbert Foerstel. The Technocracy will not be worth living in.

When I wrote anarchy, I am referring to the planned anarchist activities beginning in 1968 to undermine Church teaching, specifically Humanae Vitae. To promote The Pill (which would be harder to sell if Catholics listened to the Pope). To legalize the killing of babies in 1973. To the proliferation of images of prostitution in Adult Bookstores in the 1970s. To the proliferation of images of prostitution on cable in the 1980s. To the laying of the groundwork for destabilizing the family through a radical group called NOW which spread fear and suspicion among women, followed by the marketing of No-Fault Divorce in the 1980s. To the proliferation of profanity, partial nudity and shock jocks on network TV and radio in the 1990s. To the introduction of the internet as the world’s biggest purveyor of prostitution and bad example.

As Catholics, we are called to be holy. To love our neighbor and our enemies.

Peace,
Ed
 
I am not aware of any humanist or scientist who has set about killing those who think different from him/her or who hold rival hypotheses.
Sam Harris is one of those pop atheists/humanists doin the rounds with his evangelization:-

**“The link between belief and behavior raises the stakes considerably. Some propositions are so dangerous that it may be ethical to kill people for believing them. This may seem an extraordinary claim, but it merely enunciates an ordinary fact about the world in which we live” **(The End of Faith, p. 52).

.
 
Of course you find no meaning in caring for your family, loving your partner, working for a better society, in art, music, opera, theatre, literature, science (I know that one for sure) - but just in your hope of an afterlife.
I should not have cut your response short, sorry. For one thing, I would be interested in hearing how you find meaning in art and music. I think there’s enough atheistic literature for you to content yourself with that alone, but I’d think it would be very difficult to avoid the religiosity of the greatest English literature, for example. To dismiss all of the religious sentiments in literature as the product of deluded minds is to really limit the “meaning” one can find in that field.
Well you obviously don’t want to know about it - but you also seem to have no concept of a legacy.
I do understand a legacy. But I know that even very good scientists are ignored a short time after their death. Others end up being ridiculed for their false ideas. You won’t have any control over your legacy, as I see it. Additionally, a legacy cannot provide you with meaning today, since you don’t know if you’ll have one or if you’ll be praised or hated after you die.
In any case your point is moot - your desire for an afterlife, in order to give your life meaning, does not, in itself, mean that such an afterlife exists. One needs to look for evidence elsewhere.
The desire I have for an afterlife is one that has been commonly shared in humanity since the beginning of recorded history. It is found in the most remote parts of the planet. Several human beings have spoken about direct experiences with the afterlife. This is evidence.
 
When I wrote anarchy, I am referring to the planned anarchist activities beginning in 1968 to undermine Church teaching, specifically Humanae Vitae. To promote The Pill (which would be harder to sell if Catholics listened to the Pope). To legalize the killing of babies in 1973. To the proliferation of images of prostitution in Adult Bookstores in the 1970s. To the proliferation of images of prostitution on cable in the 1980s. To the laying of the groundwork for destabilizing the family through a radical group called NOW which spread fear and suspicion among women, followed by the marketing of No-Fault Divorce in the 1980s. To the proliferation of profanity, partial nudity and shock jocks on network TV and radio in the 1990s. To the introduction of the internet as the world’s biggest purveyor of prostitution and bad example.
Gosh, you are a real live conspiracy theorist, aren’t you? Although, I’ve never heard anarchism blamed for these things before. Are you sure you mean anarchism? Do you really think anarchists are responsible for and planned the internet? Bizarre. Mind you, it doesn’t seem to stop you using it.

By the way, *some *of the things you list here are good, for society and for individuals, in my opinion, so I am hardly likely to be shocked by those ones.

Alec
evolutionpages.com
 
Everything I wrote can be documented. So-called Feminist Icon, Gloria Steinem, is still advancing the plans of the radicals. Finally, I actually lived through the last 40 years. I observed the changes in the people.

I can factually state that a turn away from the transcendant has led to selfishness, decadence and a perversion of human relationships, especially those between men and women. The temporal and fleeting physical pleasures are all that remain, but largely devoid of meaning. As a professional writer, I have watched the arts gutted by the perverted, the bizarre and the obscene. The marketing of the dark in all things: books, films, even comic books. These meditations on the twisted are not good for the human mind. Darkness in, meditation, and darkness out. On television, the average character template is of the profoundly dysfunctional. I find no value in meditating on that or the dark, or the perverse or death. You can pick up the first season of Dexter, that lovable serial killer, at Best Buy.

There is a culture that has embraced the darkness and death. But all death has to offer you is death, both spiritual and psychological, especially when it is the star of the show like Dexter.

Peace,
Ed
 
I said:

reggieM said:
“Again, you have rejected the theory of evolution as it is taught in mainstream science (e.g. as taught in every public school in America).”
You replied:
40.png
Camron:
But I have not rejected the fact that God can work through contingent processes to accomplish His will, whether angels, saints, or nature, all of which praise God in various way, even if in non-sentient ways.
Cameron, you’re arguing about a concept that is not called “evolution” in our schools and universities or in our science labs anywhere.

I’m talking about theistic evolution.

And, actually, I think it’s possible that you’re using some incorrect definitions for evolution.,
Unfortunately the common definitions of evolution outside of the scientific community are different. For example, in the Oxford Concise Science Dictionary we find the following definition:
“evolution: The gradual process by which the present diversity of plant and animal life arose from the earliest and most primitive organisms, which is believed to have been continuing for the past 3000 million years.”
This is inexcusable for a dictionary of science. Not only does this definition exclude prokaryotes, protozoa, and fungi, but it specifically includes a term “gradual process” which should not be part of the definition.

More importantly the definition seems to refer more to the history of evolution than to evolution itself. Using this definition it is possible to debate whether evolution is still occurring, but the definition provides no easy way of distinguishing evolution from other processes.

For example, is the increase in height among Caucasians over the past several hundred years an example of evolution?

Are the color changes in the peppered moth population examples of evolution?

This is not a scientific definition.

Standard dictionaries are even worse.
“evolution: …the doctrine according to which higher forms of life have gradually arisen out of lower…” - Chambers
“evolution: …the development of a species, organism, or organ from its original or primitive state to its present or specialized state; phylogeny or ontogeny” - Webster’s
These definitions are simply wrong.

Unfortunately it is common for non-scientists to enter into a discussion about evolution with such a definition in mind. This often leads to fruitless debate since the experts are thinking about evolution from a different perspective.

When someone claims that they don’t believe in evolution they cannot be referring to an acceptable scientific definition of evolution because that would be denying something which is easy to demonstrate.

It would be like saying that they don’t believe in gravity…
 
To continue to claim that you’re defending “evolution” makes it very difficult to discuss this matter.
No it does not.
One of the most respected evolutionary biologists has defined biological evolution as follows:
"In the broadest sense, evolution is merely change, and so is all-pervasive; galaxies, languages, and political systems all evolve. Biological evolution … is change in the properties of populations of organisms that transcend the lifetime of a single individual.
The ontogeny* of an individual is not considered evolution; individual organisms do not evolve.
The changes in populations that are considered evolutionary are those that are inheritable via the genetic material from one generation to the next.
Biological evolution may be slight or substantial; it embraces everything from slight changes in the proportion of different alleles within a population (such as those determining blood types) to the successive alterations that led from the earliest protoorganism to snails, bees, giraffes, and dandelions."
  • Douglas J. Futuyma in Evolutionary Biology, Sinauer Associates 1986
Note* Ontogeny: development of an individual from the moment the egg is fertilized up till adulthood.
It is important to note that biological evolution refers to populations and not to individuals and that the changes must be passed on to the next generation. In practice this means that,
Evolution is a process that results in heritable changes in a population spread over many generations.
This is a good working scientific definition of evolution; one that can be used to distinguish between evolution and similar changes that are not evolution. Another common short definition of evolution can be found in many textbooks:
“In fact, evolution can be precisely defined as any change in the frequency of alleles within a gene pool from one generation to the next.”
  • Helena Curtis and N. Sue Barnes, Biology, 5th ed. 1989 Worth Publishers, p.974
One can quibble about the accuracy of such a definition (and we have often quibbled on these newsgroups) but it also conveys the essence of what evolution really is.

When biologists say that they have observed evolution, they mean that they have detected a change in the frequency of genes in a population. (Often the genetic change is inferred from phenotypic changes that are heritable.)

When biologists say that humans and chimps have evolved from a common ancestor they mean that there have been successive heritable changes in the two separated populations since they became isolated.

Theistic Evolutionary Questions:

Can God create changes in populations that are inheritable via the genetic material from one generation to the next?

Can God create everything from slight changes in the proportion of different alleles within a population (such as those determining blood types) to the successive alterations that led from the earliest protoorganism to snails, bees, giraffes, and dandelions?

Can God create a process that results in heritable changes in a population spread over many generations?

Can God create any change in the frequency of alleles within a gene pool from one generation to the next?

Can God create successive heritable changes in two separated populations that become isolated so much so that humans and chimps can be found to have evolved from a common ancestor?
If God is developing nature through His Divine powers, then that process is not “evolution”. It is another process. Call it “creation” or “divine guidance” or some other term – but “evolution” has a commonly accepted meaning and what you’ve presented does not fit that meaning.
I’m sorry but I’m not allowing you to hedge the definitions in order to force the conclusion, at least not when it comes to what’s possible for God to do. With God all things are possible Reggie.

In short, it certainly reads like evolution to me. In fact, if God can do any of those things that I asked in the evolutionary questions listed above, then I’m definitely talking about God creating species via descents with modifications from common ancestors.

That’s what theistic evolution is about.
 
Everything I wrote can be documented. So-called Feminist Icon, Gloria Steinem, is still advancing the plans of the radicals. Finally, I actually lived through the last 40 years. I observed the changes in the people.

I can factually state that a turn away from the transcendent has led to selfishness, decadence and a perversion of human relationships, especially those between men and women. The temporal and fleeting physical pleasures are all that remain, but largely devoid of meaning. As a professional writer, I have watched the arts gutted by the perverted, the bizarre and the obscene. The marketing of the dark in all things: books, films, even comic books. These meditations on the twisted are not good for the human mind. Darkness in, meditation, and darkness out. On television, the average character template is of the profoundly dysfunctional. I find no value in meditating on that or the dark, or the perverse or death. You can pick up the first season of Dexter, that lovable serial killer, at Best Buy.

There is a culture that has embraced the darkness and death. But all death has to offer you is death, both spiritual and psychological, especially when it is the star of the show like Dexter.

Peace,
Ed
I don’t think this is part of a grand conspiracy. It’s way too much out in the open to be called a secret anything. But I otherwise agree with everything you’ve said here Ed. 😦

What does this have to do with evolution?
 
In short, it certainly reads like evolution to me. In fact, if God can do any of those things that I asked in the evolutionary questions listed above, then I’m definitely talking about God creating species via descents with modifications from common ancestors.

That’s what theistic evolution is about.
Again, if God is “creating species” as you state here, then it’s not evolution as that term is commonly understood.

There is evidence that God created species directly, as in the following:

Oldest Gecko Fossil Ever Found, Entombed In Amber

http://www.sciencedaily.com/images/2008/09/080902163920-large.jpg

ScienceDaily (Sep. 3, 2008) — Scientists from Oregon State University and the Natural History Museum in London have announced the discovery of the oldest known fossil of a gecko, with body parts that are forever preserved in life-like form after 100 million years of being entombed in amber.

Due to the remarkable preservative power of being embalmed in amber, the tiny foot of this ancient lizard still shows the tiny “lamellae,” or sticky toe hairs, that to this day give modern geckos their unusual ability to cling to surfaces or run across a ceiling. Research programs around the world have tried to mimic this bizarre adhesive capability, with limited success.

From what I’ve gathered …

This find nearly doubles the reported age of the oldest known fossil gecko. Gecko setae are irreducibly complex as an aggregated structure. There is no rationale for setae to accumulate on the feet of ancestral geckos, because there is no identifiable functionality unless the assembly is a fully formed. Merely having setae is not enough either, as is clear from the difficulties of producing biomimetic products.

In support of the irreducible complexity argument, it is significant that these toe pads are fully formed in the very oldest specimen known to us. We do not see any transitional structures. This creates an enormous problem for theories of gradual transformation, which must defend a step-by-step route for climbing Mount Improbable. Geckos appear fully formed, and it is the Darwinists that are found contending with the data in order to preserve their theory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top