Annotated Hitler's Mein Kampf to be published

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
G

gilliam

Guest
The Institute of Contemporary History (IfZ) in Munich says it will print up to 4,000 copies with some 3,500 notes.

IfZ director Andreas Wirsching says the text with expert comments will “shatter the myth” surrounding the book.

But the move has been criticised by Jewish groups, who argue that Nazi works should never be republished.

Mein Kampf (My Struggle) was originally printed in 1925 - eight years before Hitler came to power.

After Nazi Germany was defeated in 1945, the Allied forces handed the copyright to the book to the state of Bavaria.

The local authorities have refused to allow the book to be reprinted to prevent incitement of hatred.

Under German law copyright lasts for 70 years, and so publishers will be able to have free access to the original text from January.

However, German officials have said they will limit public access to the text amid fears that this could stir neo-Nazi sentiment.

bbc.com/news/world-europe-34980701

I think it has been banned in the EU since WWII. It has been available in translation at least in the US, Canada, New Zealand, South Africa and Japan.
 
Kind of like ISIS publishing a book called My Jihad. Doesn’t seem like a good idea to me.
 
Not a good idea at all, cant believe this is even being considered…who are these publishers? lol

Satan is definitely a sneaky one, if this happens!
 
What “myth” will the annotated version shatter? What is the agenda of the Institute of Contemporary History?

ETA: This [link](Institute of Contemporary History) is to an article written earlier this year.
(…) Mein Kampf – which translates as “My Struggle” – would, over the next two decades, be bought or given to over 12 million Germans.
The book is indeed a struggle. It runs to some 700 pages, and is more a notoriously obnoxious and rambling mixture of Hitler’s obsessions, rather than some sort of definitive blueprint for the Third Reich. (…)
(My bold)
The problem with banning things such as Mein Kampf and other symbols of Nazism, is that you create a fetishistic mystique for them, and therefore engender a legitimacy in the immature minds of those disposed to extremism. There must be something in it, so the thinking goes, if the authorities want to ban it.
Herein lies the ultimate irony. When the Allies banned the book, they banned a book that nobody had read. Had the Germans really read and taken on board the absurdity of Mein Kampf in the Twenties and early Thirties, then it is conceivable that they would never have allowed its author to grasp power.
:hmmm:
 
I think it has been banned in the EU since WWII.
I was a little skeptical of this, since even the earliest form of the EU dates only to 1957 or so. A quick check of various Amazon sites reveals it is currently available in Spain, Italy, and the UK at a minimum.
 
I think it has been banned in the EU since WWII. It has been available in translation at least in the US, Canada, New Zealand, South Africa and Japan.
I’m not aware that the EU has any authority to ban books.
 
At the very least lessons can be learned from it.
History is history.
Seeing how the propoganda played out may educate some.
 
At the very least lessons can be learned from it.
History is history.
Seeing how the propoganda played out may educate some.
I read it when I was young and I learned quite a bit from it. It really does belong in a ‘time and place’ but the idea that in any crowd there may well be people with such festering streams of thought about those they consider ‘other’ is something to consider from time to time.
 
I personally don’t believe in banning books. Isn’t it better to know what your enemy/opponent believes?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top