Anyone end a romance because of a vocation?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ancilla_Domini
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I’m not convinced that you ever entirely do get over it. In time you will begin to think about the person less and less. At some point you will most likely not desire to be in a relationship with that person anymore. But, there will always be memories. And sometimes the memories will just be painful. I have been thinking lately that maybe that is just the way it is supposed to be.

James
I’d tend to agree. Sometimes the memories get eradicated up to close to null, but there’s always something. Certainly in case of prolonged relationships it can’t really just go away - well, depends which one. I remember a long-distance relationship of nine months that hasn’t left many memories. Mostly because there’s nothing good to look back at, although I’d be doing that person a disservice if I said it was all bad, I guess. At any rate, I’m happy with it being away from my mind. And while it didn’t involve a religious vocation on either part, it involved a good religious reason to discontinue that relationship. At least one.

A while after that, I had a relationship which is much more difficult to forget - if that will ever happen. She had been among my best friends for at least two years before over a year of a relationship. During that time she was both best friend (one of) and a girlfriend - though we were looking at more and “girlfriend” didn’t cover it. She didn’t know whether she would ever change her lack of current wish to have children. She didn’t want an obligation to that effect. She wouldn’t want to raise her children Catholic, “the way you * see it,” she had issues with my not wanting to party in Lent, was scared of the way she was “catholicising”… there must have been much mishandling on my part. Perhaps she didn’t want to continue down the way once she realised it. She said there would always be more and more requirements to meet. I struggled with thoughts and decided I could never have marital relations in the presence of potentially abortifacient birth control, nor could I enter into a potentially invalid marriage on the grounds of exclusion of progeny. She knew this, she said she wouldn’t change (and part, or major part, of the reason she didn’t want children was the fact we would argue about their upbringing -re pills, premarital sex, having to go to Confession and fast on fast days and other things), she brought it up with me and broke up with me a couple of days later (2nd Feb, Friday… tell me it’s an accident). It was all sad, I ended up feeling tons of pain, going to church every day and not always just once, unable to work on my Master’s thesis for months, wishing to focus on religious matters but suffering a huge trial in that regard. I actually still love the girl and I know she loves me, no matter what she says - unless I didn’t actually know her and I love a projection of imagination. At any rate, after the break-up, I had everything I did wrong with regard to her thrown back at me and my feelings for her seemed to mature, even as I had no current need to talk to her despite daily opportunity. At times I think she was egoistic and her views were making it impossible to have a normal Christian marriage, but I know that’s not the truth of her. I don’t know why the relationship happened (when we were starting it, it was her coming to me a couple of days after much praying on my part and leaving it up to God, already after she initially rejected me)… I don’t know why it ended (apart from the fact it couldn’t really continue). In the beginning, I would say a daily rosary for her and I would feel at peace, although suffering much - and it felt as if something really were going on on her end, which I couldn’t understand. And then I stopped saying the rosary for her every day (though I’d still pray for her every day and sometimes a rosary too), lost any need to talk to her, but remained with my feelings. I don’t know where it’s all going. Part of me wants to leave women alone for a long time, part of me wants to hope for a get-back-together, no part of me wants to talk to her (in the sense of initiating a conversation). I felt silly praying the rosary and trusting. I felt as if I were giving up on something when I hung the rosary at an altar where more such rosaries hung. Now I just don’t know. Part of me wants to resume the daily rosary for her, I guess. I just don’t know why part of me thinks it’s not the end of the story. I feel perfectly ready to move on and yet this.

Well, sorry for the long rant, but this my experience with having to give up on someone for reasons relating to vocation - if not the same as what you’re facing, there are at least many similarities.*
 
In the beginning, I would say a daily rosary for her and I would feel at peace, although suffering much - and it felt as if something really were going on on her end, which I couldn’t understand. And then I stopped saying the rosary for her every day (though I’d still pray for her every day and sometimes a rosary too), lost any need to talk to her, but remained with my feelings. I don’t know where it’s all going. Part of me wants to leave women alone for a long time, part of me wants to hope for a get-back-together, no part of me wants to talk to her (in the sense of initiating a conversation). I felt silly praying the rosary and trusting. I felt as if I were giving up on something when I hung the rosary at an altar where more such rosaries hung. Now I just don’t know. Part of me wants to resume the daily rosary for her, I guess. I just don’t know why part of me thinks it’s not the end of the story. I feel perfectly ready to move on and yet this.
I think you have the right idea in praying for her.

I once heard a priest say “It’s hard to hate someone you are praying for”. And I have found that to be very true on a number of occasions.

James
 
JBoscoII: I still pray with my breviary. For the first month after the breakup, though, I would miss Lauds or Vespers or a whole day of the Divine Office. I’ve only been able to get back to it with the help of God. As for Adoration, it’s a little difficult here as well, seeing how I have to walk to church on weekdays (this year I’m a full-time resident volunteer with the Franciscans, and we only have a few company cars) and the weather is really cold and dreary. (Temperatures were in the negative zone last week!) But let’s try our best to visit our God. He’s the only one who can heal our broken states…

chevalier: Thanks for sharing your story too! Even though you think there’s no vocation involved there, I still see a lot of similarities. You know, a lot of these romantic struggles is because we’re all striving for the vocation to holiness and we’re trying to do that in an increasingly secular world… But yes, I definitely can empathize with you. For me, there’s too much looking back. People tell me not to, but it’s rough because I’m praying for him so much. I’m working hard at not looking back while praying for God’s will in my former boyfriend’s life without getting sad about it… For now, I’ve also decided to put romantic relationships on hold to concentrate more on my relationship with God. I take it that if God wants me back with my former boyfriend, wants me with someone else, or wants me as His bride and His bride only, then he’ll show me as time progresses. But it’s gotten harder to remember that he does have a plan. I even stopped talking to some of my patrons, notably St. Joseph and St. Therese. I don’t know why… Maybe I’m afraid that they didn’t really help me even when I was asking them to. But that’s a dumb thought… Of course they’re helping. Perhaps I’m just afraid of rekindling some false hope or something. 😛
 
I think you have the right idea in praying for her.

I once heard a priest say “It’s hard to hate someone you are praying for”. And I have found that to be very true on a number of occasions.

James
Hmm… Well, it’s never bad to pray for someone, is it? However, I think I wanted to move on and a daily rosary for a former girlfriend wasn’t letting me go - as if I were praying for her return or as if a special bond remained. A special bond could be problematic in case of no such return and especially in case of finding someone else and starting a new relationship. Personally, I wouldn’t have anything against my hypothetical new girlfriend (erm, I don’t like this word in the context of serious adults, but eh…) praying a lot for an ex (note I still pray for her daily, just not that much and not with rosary reflections related to what I’m asking for her), but I don’t know if it doesn’t create some form of spiritual bond (if only one-sided) which could be an obstacle to full commitment in a future marriage.
 
chevalier: Thanks for sharing your story too! Even though you think there’s no vocation involved there, I still see a lot of similarities. You know, a lot of these romantic struggles is because we’re all striving for the vocation to holiness …] Perhaps I’m just afraid of rekindling some false hope or something. 😛
Yes, the vocation to holiness was what I thought about while writing the post, but didn’t actually name it. I know we’re allowed to engage in marital relations if the other spouse uses contraception but we don’t, but if the substance is the same they use in abortifacients and there’s still some chance the drug could kill a conceived foetus, I think I would just freak out and wouldn’t be able to go on. There wouldn’t be much joy in it. Some kind of opposition or even the stress of living in such a close union with someone holding anticlerical views in some regards, I think that could be harmful to one’s vocation to holiness. Perhaps it could be a great test and occasion to show example and convert the other person, lead him or her to light (salvation being at the end of the way), perhaps. At any rate, it’s over now and I don’t predict any going back. It wasn’t my decision, I’ve never heard all the reasons and I couldn’t start a new relationship with her even if she wanted it, unless she changed some views, which is unlikely - and aside from vocation to holiness, one just can’t enter into potentially invalid marriages and canon 1066 says marriages of doubtful validity are not to be celebrated. So… you know where I stand. Actually, I’ll be meeting a friend soon - a pretty and smart Catholic girl, same field of study as mine (law), last time I remember she practiced fasts and knew how to behave in Church and knew the moral teachings, but who knows after several years. Perhaps something will come out of that. At some point I actually thought it was the girl for me, who knows… Intending to find out more before entering into any relationship, though. Something in me is telling me that maybe I should wait longer and wait for someone who’ll strike me a lightning bolt (or otherwise be completely obvious)… and it’s not like I wouldn’t make a fine cardinal if things were to go that way. 😃
 
Yes, the vocation to holiness was what I thought about while writing the post, but didn’t actually name it. I know we’re allowed to engage in marital relations if the other spouse uses contraception but we don’t, but if the substance is the same they use in abortifacients and there’s still some chance the drug could kill a conceived foetus, I think I would just freak out and wouldn’t be able to go on. There wouldn’t be much joy in it. Some kind of opposition or even the stress of living in such a close union with someone holding anticlerical views in some regards, I think that could be harmful to one’s vocation to holiness. Perhaps it could be a great test and occasion to show example and convert the other person, lead him or her to light (salvation being at the end of the way), perhaps. At any rate, it’s over now and I don’t predict any going back. It wasn’t my decision, I’ve never heard all the reasons and I couldn’t start a new relationship with her even if she wanted it, unless she changed some views, which is unlikely - and aside from vocation to holiness, one just can’t enter into potentially invalid marriages and canon 1066 says marriages of doubtful validity are not to be celebrated. So… you know where I stand. Actually, I’ll be meeting a friend soon - a pretty and smart Catholic girl, same field of study as mine (law), last time I remember she practiced fasts and knew how to behave in Church and knew the moral teachings, but who knows after several years. Perhaps something will come out of that. At some point I actually thought it was the girl for me, who knows… Intending to find out more before entering into any relationship, though. Something in me is telling me that maybe I should wait longer and wait for someone who’ll strike me a lightning bolt (or otherwise be completely obvious)… and it’s not like I wouldn’t make a fine cardinal if things were to go that way. 😃
I know what you mean! I won’t date anyone who isn’t Catholic. I don’t think it’s wrong for Catholics to date people of other faiths, but I know that I’d have a hard time discerning marriage with someone that I don’t share the same faith with, especially since I hope to raise my children as Catholics.

But good luck with this girl you’ll be seeing! I’ll remember you in my rosary. 😃
 
How do you get over breakups in general, then? And how do I stop giving myself hopes that there’s a chance that my former flame and I may get back together?
I really sympathize with you here. :hug1:

Time and distance are essential in getting over a breakup. To start with, you need to be physically as far as possible from your ex. Out of sight, out of mind.

Fulton Sheen said that we can’t actively remove thoughts and hang-ups like this from our minds…we can only crowd them out, by replacing them with something else.

An example ------> I drifted away from the Church during the 5+ years I was involved in my doomed relationship. I was emotionally numb, drained and just devastated in so many ways when we finally had to break up for good. We’re talking years here. It wasn’t until I came back to the Church that I was able to move on.

Actually, it was more like I suddenly realized that I had moved on, despite myself. I went to confession (first time in 5 yrs.), started attending mass regularly, praying my rosary, etc. For the first time I wasn’t focusing on my pain and how to deal with it…and then one day I realized that it was gone, by the grace of God. The memories are still there, but the pain and hopes attatched to them are gone.

Even if in your case you don’t need to re-commit to the faith, I think the hopes you have for reconciliaton will fade when your mind, heart and will (may not happen in that order) are focused elsewhere…Just let that happen naturally, because you really can’t force yourself to stop wanting something that you miss so much.
 
But good luck with this girl you’ll be seeing! I’ll remember you in my rosary. 😃
Thank you. 🙂 Turns out when I was praying for assistance in this matter, a message arrived saying, “MyName, I was just boarding the plane when you phoned. I’m in [City] now. Unfortunately, the time passed so fast for me [OtherCity] that I haven’t managed to finish the paper, therefore I need to resign your kind invitation. I thank you cordially once again and greet you from [Country].” I prayed in my favourite church on my way back from work, I knew it would be tough, then the nerves in most of my face went off (happens sometimes after a jaw surgery when I drink too much coffee or something, prevents expressions, pain etc), and then I checked the time on my phone after leaving church and there was the message, the date suggesting it arrived when I was praying. I wonder what’s the implication.

What about you? Any news?
 
Mmm… No news really. I had made these computer wallpapers on Photoshop and decided to send them over to my former boyfriend as a baptism anniversary present. He wrote back thanking me and said only a few things since he knows that I can’t handle speaking to him yet:
  1. That he’s praying for both of us will accept God’s will, and
  2. That our lives become easier - BOTH of our lives.
… Which leads me to scratch my head. I wonder what is making his life difficult. If anything, it sounded as if HE was having the time of his life after the breakup. He got involved in many ministries after we split, and so I thought he was doing well.

Of course, it’s probably the discernment that’s hard. But part of me wishes that it’s also difficult because he misses me and wonders if this is what God is really calling him to…

Still, I’m trying to move on. No use worrying about "what if"s at this point.

Please pray for me; it’s becoming so difficult to pray sometimes! And I will be praying for all of you too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top