Archbishop links priestly celibacy and Catholic sex abuse scandals

  • Thread starter Thread starter Usbek_de_Perse
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
*Well…a secular employer having discovered that one of its employees was molesting kids? Would be fired…and reported to the police. *
Yes, if the allegation was substantiated and if the police were not already aware of it. In a more likely scenario, the person would be suspended pending the outcome of the criminal procedings. You can also get in trouble for assuming guilt based on allegations, at least in the U.S.As a rule, internal discipline is handled after the criminal allegation has be substaniated or dismissed.
 
I think we should behead all of the bishops up to the Pope and start over.
 
It might have just been a typo, but it’s actually a little less than 2%.
Nope,
When you think correctly you need to remember that the Catholic Church consists of the Latin and the many Eastern Rite Churches. 90% of the Eastern rite priest are actually married prior to being ordained.
 
Nope,
When you think correctly you need to remember that the Catholic Church consists of the Latin and the many Eastern Rite Churches. 90% of the Eastern rite priest are actually married prior to being ordained.
Since the whole conversation is about Roman Catholic priests, I mistakenly read your post as Roman Catholic. However, even Orthodox bishops are not allowed to be married.
 
Since the whole conversation is about Roman Catholic priests, I mistakenly read your post as Roman Catholic. However, even Orthodox bishops are not allowed to be married.
Some would argue that the eastern rite priests are also “Roman”. I loathe the term Roman Catholic Church since its origins comes from the Anglican church during and/or after separating.
 
However, even Orthodox bishops are not allowed to be married.
That is the rule today, but this is an innovation since it was not always so. For example, the first Pope of the Catholic Church. St. Peter was married as were more than thirty other Popes of the Catholic Church.
 
Some would argue that the eastern rite priests are also “Roman”. I loathe the term Roman Catholic Church since its origins comes from the Anglican church during and/or after separating.
Then what should we call the western side of the church?
 
That is the rule today, but this is an innovation since it was not always so. For example, the first Pope of the Catholic Church. St. Peter was married as were more than thirty other Popes of the Catholic Church.
name them
 
name them
Please see the article:
39 Popes were married by Father John Shuster.
johnshuster.com/thirtynine_popes.htm
He refers to the book Kelly, J. N. D. Oxford Dictionary of Popes. New York, Oxford Press. 1986.
I don’t know who they all were, however, I read that the following Popes were married:
St. Peter, Apostle
St. Siricius
St. Felix III (II)
St. Hormisdas
St. Silverius
St. Agatho
Hadrian II
Pope John XVII
Boniface IX
Clement IV
Felix V
 
This is a really interesting article, I’ve only posted a taste of it here (below) - frvanhove.wordpress.com/2009/10/01/the-biblical-foundation-of-priestly-celibacy-by-ignace-de-la-potterie-httpwww-vatican-varoman_curiacongregationscclergydocumentsrc_con_cclergy_doc_01011993_bfoun_en-html/

About a 1/4 of the way down, there is a section entitled “The stipulation unius uxoris vir: an argument in ancient tradition for the apostolic origin of celibacy/continence”

Scholars generally agree that the obligation of celibacy, or at least of continence, became canon law from the fourth century onwards. Here certain incontrovertible texts are quoted repeatedly: three pontifical decretals around AD 385 (Decreta and Cum in unum of Pope Siricius and Dominus inter of Siricius or Damasus) and a canon of the Council of Carthage of AD 390.11

However, it is important to observe that the legislators of the fourth and fifth centuries affirmed that this canonical enactment was based on an apostolic tradition. The Council of Carthage, for instance, said that it was fitting that those who were at the service of the divine sacraments be perfectly continent (continentes esse in omnibus): «so that what the apostles taught and antiquity itself maintained, we too may observe».12 The decree on the obligation of continence was then passed unanimously: «It is pleasing to all that bishop, priest and deacon, the guardians of purity, abstain from marital relations with their wives (ab uxori bus se abstineant) so that the perfect purity may be safeguarded of those who serve the altar.»
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top